I wouldn't trust either, industry is moving to Airbus because of their failures.
"Provision for the new exits – which boost the exit limit capacity from 189 to 215 passengers – “will be structurally installed as standard in all -900s, and will allow operators to decide if the door should be activated or deactivated”, says 737 chief project engineer Mike Delaney."
Makes it sound like they're always installed, and airlines can opt to activate them or not...
[1] Simulated full pressurization, often many of them
[2] And yeah. Spirit's got problems. But those problems wouldn't be problems if Boeing didn't sell off BCA's Wichita fuse fab to investment bankers back in 2005 as "Spirit". It's a pretty good name, since it's what some religions think is left behind after you're dead.
Maybe if Boeing, you know, lobby to lower these safety restrictions then those pesky quality control checks will reduce and somehow everything will just work out just fine [1].
Seriously though, as a brand new, fresh off the production line 737 this kind of event should be so rare as to be nearly impossible.
[1] - https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein...
I am open to the possibility that an industry might be over-regulated and also expect that the people who would be most likely to try and correct that imbalance would be the companies in the industry. Therefore, it seems perfectly reasonable to me that a company should be able to lobby the government in it's own interests. The issue of de-regulation creating safety hazards lies completely with the government officials who take their advice (and probably money) without regard to the effects that might happen.
When a mobster bribes a cop, the person that's commiting the (much) greater offense is the cop.
a) you’re okay with companies (effectively) acting like mobsters, in their own pecuniary interest
b) you expect every (individual, human) government official to act morally and correctly in every instance, despite the pressure and temptation placed upon them
c) you see no problem with this setup, and see no need to alter this situation
Wow.
I didn't say that. I said I'm okay with them lobbying for their interests and that am open to the idea that some industries might be over-regulated and that the companies in that industry are in the best position to know that.
> you expect every (individual, human) government official to act morally and correctly in every instance, despite the pressure and temptation placed upon them
Yes.
> you see no problem with this setup, and see no need to alter this situation
Again, I didn't say that. I used that as an analogy. Analogies aren't perfect. I'm sorry if I wasn't clear but I expect you know exactly what I was getting at and chose to misinterpret me so you can dunk on the strawman.
My overall point being, if you're upset with deregulation, you should direct your ire at the regulators who took the word of lobbyists at face value instead of doing their jobs.
I guess the root of where we seem to disagree is the extent to which it's reasonable for companies to lobby, and the extent to which we believe it's reasonable to expect government employees to be the last bastion of reason and good conduct, despite everything that might be brought to bear against them.
Part of the case with Boeing and the 737 Max is actually more extreme than this, and also really interesting, as Boeing's financial interest is set clearly and diametrically against the interests of the public who might fly on their planes. Here's a precis (as I understand it): following the two earlier actual crashes of the Max (each killing hundreds of people) the FAA requested changes to those planes, to make them safer. Boeing lobbied against these changes, successfully, resulting in Congress effectively overruling the FAA, via a provision in the recent spending bill. [0]
How does this make sense, in any rational world?
How many of the Congress people who voted for this are going to be re-elected?
It's congresses authority at the end of the day and it's our responsibility to hold them accountable.
1) Congresspeople's voting can often be related to local selfish incentives - they support local industries because that's what their voters care about, irrespective of the bigger picture. There are myriad examples of this - Joe Manchin being in the pocket of the coal industry is an obvious one. In this particular case, Boeing claimed that the safety work requested by the FAA would place the 737 Max program itself (and therefore the jobs that depend on it) at risk. You could see this as democracy at work... but it's really democracy tainted by the influence of money and lobbying.
2) The 'adjustment' to the FAA's safety work was placed inside a much bigger bill, therefore obfuscating responsibility and even awareness.
3) In a highly-partisan, two-party system, it would have to be a highly emotionally-charged topic to push voters into voting tactically against their previous choice. Roe vs. Wade might be big enough for some people, but I doubt that something as small as this would do so.
--
That aside, the idea that the current system is protected by the ability of voters to 'hold their representative to account' every two or so years is surely crazy:
a) such accountability (if it ever happens) has up to a two-year lag - far from acceptable given the current example related to aircraft safety (which should be noted and reversed as a matter of urgency)
b) even if such accountability transpired, is it realistic to expect that a newly-elected replacement Congressperson could reverse the previous wrong? Highly unlikely.
We need to reel in capitalism in a big way. Our priorities are showing and they’re embarrassing.
If by capitalism you mean 'profitable' then Boeing was more so before they started making shitty products.
The reality is companies and all organisation, for many reason change over time.
Ah yes, the aerospace and airline industries are just really overrun with free market ideals.
As opposed to agents motivated by conformity and an eye towards bureaucratic values?
Humans are self interested. This is common across systems. What differs is how we orient those interests in concert or competition, and when that dial is turned.
So where are the profits? Boeing hasn't made money since 2018 and I suspect their revenue per employee is very low.
They are "too big to fail", part of the ministry of defense, and a large make-work program.
> they consolidate into monopolies
Indeed there are about 3 aerospace companies setup to server the US government. It regulates everything from how paperwork is stored, to what tests candidate employees must pass, and which parts they can order.
In the commercial sector all of their customer's requirements come from the government.
> Airlines are less regulated today
In what ways?
Once they bought them out and became a monopoly that was deemed ‘not a monopoly’ they had room to relax and replaced engineers with finance people.
This is what happens when finance people make aircraft.
They is very much competing in lots of different competition for lots things.
Of course they take all subsidies they get, but that does not distinguish that from many other big companies not founded on government initiative.
It’s 2 months old, so poor maintenance, wear and tear, etc are not even minor factors.
This is just a poorly made plane with awful quality control.
And that’s even before we get into some of the design issues, both the shortcuts they’ve taken and ones that are more fundamental.