News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by chewmieser on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:55PM (#38845431)
Are you for free speech or against it? Where is the line drawn?

These are hard questions to answer, especially in the manner they were "asked." And it's probably not exclusively up to Gay to decide & answer them.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by telotortium on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:16PM (#38845733)
Are you for free speech? Is Gay? We all know Harvard would attempt to discipline students for opinions they perceive as "racist" or "transphobic".
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by insickness on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:38PM (#38846004)
Is that true, though? I know colleges bar speakers that espouse disagreeable views but do they prevent students from espousing disagreeable opinions?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by elp on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:13PM (#38846524)
>Is that true, though? ... do they prevent students from espousing disagreeable opinions?

In Harvard's case yes. They have an appalling record of trying to suppress views they don't like for students, speakers, and staff. https://www.thefire.org/news/harvard-gets-worst-score-ever-f...

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by someuser2345 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:26PM (#38845849)
If someone at Harvard was publicly advocating for killing black people, I have no doubt that they would be immediately expelled. So freedom of speech doesn't apply here.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:52PM (#38848835)
Even saying "All Lives Matter" was effectively fatal to several academic careers even though it's a positive affirmation.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:09PM (#38849004)
The context is important. “All Lives Matter” sprung up as a reaction to “Black Lives Matter”. It was hardly ever said outside of the context of Black Lives Matter, and if it was, it was probably referring to something unrelated, such as animal rights.

The only reason people say “All Lives Matter” as a response to “Black Lives Matter” is to void or nullify the latter statement, and as such a very obvious dog whistle for something which is hate speech.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:36PM (#38849185)
That's not correct: many people who said All Lives Matter meant it in good faith and not to nullify BLM. Claiming otherwise is .... not a realistic assessment of their intent. And in fact, in saying so,m you're basically trying to shut down discussion by calling people racist.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:18PM (#38849513)
If “All Lives Matter” is used outside of the context of BLM, then it is harmless. If it is used inside the context of BLM it is a racist dog whistle.

That said, I stand by what I said that most of the time it is being used in the latter case. Wikipedia has an article about the latter case, not the former. Searching the term in any search engine will have you scroll very far down before you see it outside the context of BLM.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:24PM (#38849923)
Perhaps that's because so many people who wanted to say "All Lives Matter" were terrified of saying it because... well, a small number of people used it abusively?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gruez on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:47PM (#38849288)
Suppose everything that you said is true. What does this mean for arguably "dog whistle" terms like "from the river to the sea"?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:13PM (#38849468)
From the River to the Sea is usually said in the context of Palestinian liberation, Israeli occupation or zionism, so applying the same logic it seems to affirm Palestinian liberation and decolonization or deny or nullify zionism. Doesn’t really sound like a dog whistle in that context.

Wikipedia seems to agree with my assessment:

> All Lives Matter is a slogan that was created as a negative response to the Black Lives Matter movement. It is a conservative rejection of the acknowledgement of police brutality and ethnic violence that is the purpose of the Black Lives Matter movement.

> "From the river to the sea" (Arabic: من النهر إلى البحر, romanized: min an-nahr ʾilā l-baḥr; Palestinian Arabic: من المية للمية, romanized: min il-ṃayye la-l-ṃayye, lit. 'from the water to the water') is a political slogan that refers geographically to the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, an area described as Palestine, which today includes Israel and the Israeli-occupied Palestinian territories, including the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip.

> Palestinian progressives use the phrase to call for a united democracy over the whole territory while others say "it's a call for peace and equality after ... decades-long, open-ended Israeli military rule over millions of Palestinians."

Even the Hamas charter is pretty explicit about what it means (where the context is obvious):

> Hamas rejects any alternative to the full and complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea [...] along the lines of the 4th of June 1967

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Lives_Matter

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_the_river_to_the_sea

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:23PM (#38849540)
This is one of those cases where wikipedia is not a useful reference.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by haberman on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:07PM (#38849818)
It sounds like you are saying that it is cancellation-worthy to be aligned with an American conservative position, but normal and acceptable political expression to be aligned with Hamas. Is that your position?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gruez on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:10PM (#38849842)
>> All Lives Matter is a slogan that was created as a negative response to the Black Lives Matter movement. It is a conservative rejection of the acknowledgement of police brutality and ethnic violence that is the purpose of the Black Lives Matter movement.

>> "From the river to the sea" (Arabic: من النهر إلى البحر, romanized: min an-nahr ʾilā l-baḥr; Palestinian Arabic: من المية للمية, romanized: min il-ṃayye la-l-ṃayye, lit. 'from the water to the water') is a political slogan that refers geographically to the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, an area described as Palestine, which today includes Israel and the Israeli-occupied Palestinian territories, including the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip.

I can think of opposite interpretations of both examples. For instance, "all lives matter" is to be taken literally to be an inclusive declaration of equal treatment under the law, or "from the river to the sea" calls for ejection of jews from region. How do you arbitrate between them, without relying on an authority like wikipedia?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:33PM (#38849984)
By listening to the context in which they are said. The Wikipedia quotes were simply to reaffirm the context in which both phrases are most likely to be used in. “All lives matter” is most likely to be used as a reaction to the Black Lives Matter movement. While “From the river to the sea” is most likely to be used in the context of Palestinian Liberation (sorry I’m repeating my self).
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SauciestGNU on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:35PM (#38850397)
"From the river to the sea" has nothing to do with expulsion and everything to do with an end to militarily-enforced apartheid. It's highly disingenuous to continue to affirm that this slogan is genocidal when it simply isn't. Astonishingly bad faith when the people saying it are telling you exactly what they mean by it, and it's not mass expulsion or genocide, but equal treatment under the law and a respect for human rights.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:36PM (#38907631)
The Arabic original of the slogan is, "min el-mayeh lil-mayeh, Falastin Arabiyeh" or in English "from the water to the water, an Arab Palestine". It's a clearly nationalistic slogan that goes well beyond equal treatment under law or human rights.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SauciestGNU on Monday January 08, 2024 @01:56PM (#38916427)
Sure, but that's not what's being said. If that were the dominant use of the phrase that would be one thing, but the dominant use (and the one that's got everybody upset) is "from the river to the sea Palestine will be free".
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Monday January 08, 2024 @04:50PM (#38918692)
Are we to believe that the English and Arabic speakers at these demonstrations mean two completely different things, simply by virtue of the English speakers using a nonliteral translation?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SauciestGNU on Monday January 08, 2024 @05:03PM (#38918852)
Yes, a phrase that's used in English that has a different literal meaning than a slogan in another language with a similar phrasing but different meaning is literally not the same thing. I doubt the majority of English speakers are even familiar with the original Arabic, but it's also irrelevant because it's not what it being repeated. If people meant that they would say that.

They mean something different, so they say something different, and keep refuting loudly and repeatedly the baseless accusations of antisemitism lobbed at them by those who want to silence their message by policing the language used to communicate it.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:21PM (#38945005)
>I doubt the majority of English speakers are even familiar with the original Arabic, but it's also irrelevant because it's not what it being repeated.

Yes it is. Lots of people in the current wave of demonstrations have been using the Arabic version.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SauciestGNU on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:39PM (#38958686)
Have they? That's not something I've encountered anywhere. I'm willing to entertain the possibility, but can you back that up with any evidence?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Saturday January 13, 2024 @09:42PM (#38986915)
Let me find you the video clip I saw of demonstrators in Toronto.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:06PM (#39070423)
I haven't managed to find the video of Toronto, but here's one of New York: https://twitter.com/ShaiDavidai/status/1748449960368996486
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Sunday January 21, 2024 @12:01AM (#39075737)
In the time it took you to find this one demonstration with honestly not that many participant, all of whom young students, cited from inside a twitter thread full of bad faith arguments, we’ve had Benjamin Netanyahu himself use this phrase to mean total Israel control (which at best means colonization or apartheid, or worst genocide against arabs).

The difference here is that those are all pretty young students, and have no control over any policy, while Netanyahu is the Prime minister of a country at trial for Genocide.

And while this variation of the phrase is definitely nationalistic, in the context of Palestine being colonized by a non-arab population it is probably more in line with “Colonizers go home” as opposed “No Jews allowed”, after all there are Jewish Arabs too.

And finally these very same protesters were sprayed with skunk water at the very same demonstration[1]. That really shows how the powerdynamic actually aligns and who is actually at risk.

[1]: https://twitter.com/ColumbiaSJP/status/1748729253770698944

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Sunday January 21, 2024 @12:32AM (#39075882)
> Palestine being colonized by a non-arab population

Colonized? Jews are the indigenous people of the region. Arabs are the colonizers.

> there are Jewish Arabs too.

Not any who identify as Jewish Arabs, no: https://k-larevue.com/en/arab-jews-another-arab-denial/, https://www.jimena.org/who-is-an-arab-jew/

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:42PM (#39120205)
The Arabian (or more accurately the Umayyad) colonization of Palestine was in the 7th century, since then we’ve had, among others, crusader, Ottoman, and British colonizations. Throughout all these colonization periods Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived together in peace (with notable exceptions) and spoke Arabic. It is only in the 1920s when we have a mass migration of white European Yiddish speaking Jewish people under the British colonial period. These Yiddish speaking people changed their language to Hebrew, annexed the area in 1948 and converted the indigenous Arabic speaking Jews to Hebrew speaking Jews. How is this not colonization?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:53PM (#39137606)
>Throughout all these colonization periods Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived together in peace (with notable exceptions) and spoke Arabic.

Absolute bloody rubbish: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_under_Musl.... Jews never lived as equal citizens under Islamic rule until the 1860s with the Tanzimat period. The Tanzimat period then gave us the First Aliyah from Yemen in the 1880s, which, despite being a migration of Ottoman subjects within Ottoman territory, provoked anti-Jewish backlash because it threatened Arab-Islamic domination over the land.

>It is only in the 1920s when we have a mass migration of white European Yiddish speaking Jewish people

Again, rubbish. The Institute for Palestine Studies notes openly (https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/165370) that reactionary backlash against Jewish immigration following Ottoman law, but exercising individual rights as citizens to challenge Arab-Muslim dominance, already crystallized before World War I:

> [T]he intensity of the post-1908 reaction can only be explained by the cumulative effect of a series of land purchases from absentee landlords involving the expulsions of fellahin and the ensuing clashes.

Immigration under a shared legal code, even mass immigration, even of people with a different skin-tone or a different mother tongue, is not colonialism! The backlash was not against a "colonization" that wouldn't arrive for another decade or more (and when it arrived was by the British, not by Jews), but at Jews being allowed to own property and farm it themselves.

>converted the indigenous Arabic speaking Jews to Hebrew speaking Jews

Immigration is not colonization, and indigeneity is not a mere absence of immigration history. Likewise, the Ottoman Jewish community was reviving Hebrew before the Ashkenazi Zionists like Eliezer Ben-Yehudah showed up: there was a Hebrew language newspaper in Istanbul first.

Besides which, why should Jews in the region not choose what language they want to speak? Because it accords with a political project you view as originated by Jews "somewhere else", and thus constitutes a "betrayal" of the region? Who are you and the Arabs to tell Mizrahi Jews how to do politics?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by tptacek on Thursday January 25, 2024 @11:31PM (#39138976)
This is a 23-day-old flagged story. I get why you wrote all of this! I'd have bristled at that comment too. But it's a shame to be investing energy on a thread that nobody is reading (I am a weirdo and I do not count!).
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:31PM (#39179197)
I didn't know it was flagged! And I certainly wasn't the one who flagged the above comment I was replying to.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Monday January 08, 2024 @05:54PM (#38919559)
I think you might be a little dishonest here.

Have you ever heard Arabic speakers at a demonstration chant “فلسطين عربية” or “فلسطين إسلامية”?

What you did was open my own wikipedia source, scroll down to the Variations section and found this old variation there.

However if you open the original source[1] which claimed this historic use of the slogan, it specifically states that some people remember it being this way during the first intifada (1987-1993). This same source also says:

> It is true that a state of Palestine would entail the end of Israel as a Jewish ethnic-national state. But as many Palestinian and Israeli intellectuals (and others) have noted: replacing Israel with a Palestinian state need not result in genocide or the ethnic cleansing of Jews.

This article also raises an important point:

> If one of our goals is to move Jewish American audiences, we need to recognize that the Israeli state and its allies have found it easy to weaponize this particular slogan in order to incite fear among Jews.

I recommend you read this article, it is quite brilliant.

1: https://mondoweiss.net/2023/11/on-the-history-meaning-and-po...

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:19PM (#38944984)
>Have you ever heard Arabic speakers at a demonstration chant “فلسطين عربية” or “فلسطين إسلامية”?

Yes, during the current wave of violence and demonstrations.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:43PM (#38946799)
I did some online searching and yours is the only claim I’ve found that this variation is used in the current era of demonstrations. The article I just cited seems pretty sure that this old variation has gone out of fashion in favor of the current one:

> Friends and activists I have asked remember this phrase being used during the Oslo era, when it was adapted and developed as part of a critique of and complaint against a Palestinian leadership from Tunis that surrendered claims over historic Palestine. At some point, the phrase became the rhyming couplet that it is today: “Min al-nahr ila al-bahr / Filastin satatharrar” (“from the river to the sea / Palestine will be free”). It is this version—with its focus on freedom—that has circulated within English-language solidarity culture from at least the 1990s.

> For instance, some variants promote an Arab nationalist frame (“Palestine is Arab”), and others propose an Islamist frame (“Palestine is Islamic”). In contrast, the current version [emphasis mine] (“Palestine will be free”) expresses an open-ended but emphatic aspiration for liberation—this has allowed it to resonate with other freedom struggles.

Now I did find material for the Arab nationalist variation, including a rather catchy protest song (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ldX9UEVJo0g). I don’t speak arabic so it is possible that the older variation is still used and discussed on the arabic speaking web, however I’m not finding it at all on the English speaking web, I can only find it being discussed in the historical context.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by bsaul on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:44PM (#38846105)
I have no idea what the rules are in american universities, but all the recent stories i've read regarding eg gender pronouns, and how people should behave on campus in general made me think free speech is quite a remote consideration.

If i'm wrong however and people really are allowed to say absolutely anything they want, then it would have been a very simple statement to make "we are free speech absolutists, we believe people shouldn't be punished for what they say, no matter how offensive it is, only for what they do". In which case i would have been 100% supporting her.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SauciestGNU on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:31PM (#38850363)
So her answer was complicated in testimony because the pro-Israel side has been trying to frame the words "Free Palestine" and "from the river to the sea" as a call for genocide against Jewish people. Maybe for some people that's what those slogans mean, but for many others those slogans mean a one (secular) state solution with equal civil rights for Jewish Israelis and no military occupations or apartheid. To others it means the establishment of a Palestinian state around the 1967 borders.

The problem is the pro-Israeli right was out to "scalp" Gay (Christopher Rufo said exactly that). Her testimony was bad, but largely because she was not being asked questions in good faith.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by tptacek on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:52PM (#38850516)
Nothing Chris Rufo says matters. He'd claim responsibility for Sam Altman's ouster from OpenAI if it somehow suited the grandiose public profile he's attempted to craft for himself. Certainly no matter who was serving as president of Harvard, and no matter what they'd said, Rufo would love nothing more than to associate himself and his "movement" with their failure.

It's nobody's fault but Rufo's opponents if an Ivy League university administrator somehow becomes a cause celebre and a major 'L' for the left. He's a gigantic troll and there is no reason to empower him.

There's no reason to concede the culture war framing in the comment you responded to. We have in fact extraordinarily clear evidence that Gay engaged repeatedly in (perhaps minor, perhaps major) instances of plagiarism. Nobody has a divine mandate to serve as Harvard president; no cause depends on a particular person holding that role; no great injustice can be done by someone losing it who has, for whatever reason, become a liability to the institution. Claudine Gay will be fine. Someone else will be Harvard president.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SauciestGNU on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @11:01PM (#38850573)
I agree with your framing here almost entirely, but I think it's a mistake to write off Rufo entirely. It may be in this case it's a self-serving post hoc analysis of events on his part. Maybe even probably that. But he's managed to start moral panics before (he was championing CRT and "parental rights" as wedge issues long before they were in vogue). Not worth listening to, but imo worth monitoring.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by bsaul on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:25AM (#38852178)
"trying to feame the words free palestine" : i understand that was the goal, however the question in itself was super unambiguous.

If she wanted to be vague or super careful it should gave been on the following questions, not on that one. The least one can say is that she's not very smart.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by throwaway-blaze on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:11PM (#38845657)
Only someone as credentialed as a Harvard president would think this is a hard question to answer. You can be for free speech and not deliver a word-salad answer that basically sounded like "maybe" to most of the people listening.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:25PM (#38845842)
It is a hard question to answer because the school has a policy of allowing and supporting free speech. The question isn’t black and white. If you support free speech, you have to support objectionable speech that you disagree with, unless it moves from being speech to being targeted or actionable. That was the whole crux of her answer and why it was a completely dishonest question. Harvard allows the Westboro Church to say “God hates f*s” and “death to queers” despite many not liking it because it’s free speech until someone takes action on that.

It’s even more ludicrous considering that the people attempting to push the question dishonestly are the same ones who like to cry about free speech on Twitter, a private platform, while saying free speech should be curbed if it’s objectionable in this case at a university that takes public funding.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by haberman on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:11PM (#38847217)
> It is a hard question to answer because the school has a policy of allowing and supporting free speech. The question isn’t black and white. If you support free speech, you have to support objectionable speech that you disagree with, unless it moves from being speech to being targeted or actionable.

This is a great philosophy. I only wish Harvard had thought to embrace it prior to last October, instead of coming in dead last on FIRE's free speech index: https://www.thefire.org/news/harvard-gets-worst-score-ever-f...

I hope that this experience will lead Harvard to actually commit to a free speech culture across the board. But I am admittedly pessimistic that any kind of consistent application of these principles will result.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:24PM (#38847905)
FIRE's free speech index is hardly definitive. It asks students about how they feel, not about actual, verifiable support from the school. The survey uses questions like "Would you be opposed to a speaker with x view coming to campus to speak" and then base the results on how the students responded, not based on whether or not the school actually restricted students' speech. Additionally, disinvitations are measured as well despite not being examples of student speech being censored.

Harvard clearly scored poorly but it seems like they only scored poorly because the students aren't ok with viewpoints that are non-inclusive or borderline hate speech. It has nothing to do with the school's policies or positions on free speech and what is or isn't allowed.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by haberman on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:55PM (#38848206)
The survey does not ask "Would you be opposed...?" It asks:

> Student groups often invite speakers to campus to express their views on a range of topics. Regardless of your own views on the topic, should your school ALLOW or NOT ALLOW a speaker on campus who promotes the following idea?

Someone who truly supports free speech would say "ALLOW" even if they themselves personally disagree with the speech. Students at Harvard apparently do not.

Additionally, the survey asks students whether they support suppressing speech via deplatforming or violence, and whether they believe that the administration would defend the rights of speakers when controversy arises.

The questions can be found on page 76 of this PDF: https://www.thefire.org/sites/default/files/2023/09/CFSR%202...

> Additionally, disinvitations are measured as well despite not being examples of student speech being censored.

A second ago you said that free speech covers the Westboro Baptist Church coming on campus. Now it only applies to students? If someone is being disinvited, presumably someone invited them to begin with, whether students or faculty.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:14PM (#38848431)
How is that in any way materially different from my point? The survey still isn't about what actions any of the schools have taken or whether the schools' policies allow for free speech. That makes it completely irrelevant in a discussion about whether the President of the school was committed to free speech. The survey asks students their opinions. FIRE actually has a separate tracker for disinvitations and, based on population sizes and breakdowns by political lean, conservatives request more disinvitations than should be expected for the population of students that consider themselves conservatives.

>A second ago you said that

Yes... and I also said that, as someone else pointed out also, it was irrelevant to a private university that is allowed to remove anyone from campus that it wants. Allowing Westboro to stay on campus shows that their policies on free speech extend to objectionable speech regardless of what ideology is stating it. That's not the same thing as students choosing not to invite or hear views from people whose views are readily available on the internet nor is it the same thing as student opinions overriding the actual actions of schools.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gruez on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:03PM (#38849393)
>The survey still isn't about what actions any of the schools have taken or whether the schools' policies allow for free speech. That makes it completely irrelevant in a discussion about whether the President of the school was committed to free speech. The survey asks students their opinions.

In cases like this though, perception is probably closer to reality than actual activity. For instance, I think it's pretty fair to say that society is pretty against robberies. If you did a survey asking how comfortable people are with robbing people[1], I think most people would answer "Very uncomfortable". However, if you look at FBI crime statistics[2], you see that majority of robberies don't result in arrests. If we were applying your logic, we'd conclude that clearly society/the police don't have a policy of catching robbers.

[1] For the purposes of this argument, we can further presume we're robbing a Bad Person (eg. anti-abortion protesters if you're a liberal) to get past any ethical considerations

[2] https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-...

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:11PM (#38849843)
>If we were applying your logic, we'd conclude that clearly society/the police don't have a policy of catching robbers.

No we wouldn't. My logic is that we'd have stats regarding how many crimes were documented, whether they were solved or not. And, as you've shown, we do.

No police department will have a 100% closure rate but that doesn't mean at all what you're claiming should be the conclusion based on that fact. The conclusion would be to look at how many cases of free speech issues were reported and what was done as a result. Transparency is what's needed, not misleading and inappropriately applied surveys.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by haberman on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:46PM (#38850061)
If there is a climate where people expect that exercise of free speech will result in retaliation, then people will self-censor before there can even be an incident to report. This phenomenon is known as a Chilling Effect.

This is why people's beliefs about whether speech is properly protected or not are relevant. If people don't believe that free speech is protected, speech can effectively be curtailed even with few actual incidents.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:55AM (#38856355)
The complaint is that liberals are reporting conservative viewpoints they disagree with. If the school was doing that, why would the liberals be self-censoring? You’re not making any sense.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:39PM (#38846025)
I think "death to queers" doesn't fall under freedom of speech because it seems to directly call for violence- speech doesn't need to lead to actions to be considered uncovered by free speech rules.

The other example you gave is free speech, because it's not a call to violence.

(I am applying my own interpretation of free speech laws, as well as the general understanding of legitimate free speech in the US; please assume I have a reasonable level of education on this).

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:48PM (#38846163)
It’s already been ruled that “death to queers” is allowed as long as it doesn’t target individuals or amount to a “true threat” which exactly what Gay’s point was during the hearing. The speech itself is protected unless it’s targeted (which “from the river to the sea” or whatever it is and the word “intifada” likely wouldn’t be) and actionable which it definitely isn’t. It would need to be proven that the people making the speech had the intent of directly or indirectly harming the people they had targeted.

All this discussion does is prove that there’s nuance to the question and that it’s not black and white which is exactly why I believe it was a dishonest question to begin with.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:56PM (#38846291)
> speech itself is protected unless it’s targeted

It's First Amendment protected. Universities have a long track record of having policies more restrictive than that.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:00PM (#38846355)
Yes and that’s a direct quote from Gay during the hearing - “Gay, in her testimony, said such speech can be a violation of the school’s policies “depending on the context” if it is “targeted at an individual.””
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:02PM (#38846391)
Which is mincemeat of an answer. Plenty of hate speech is banned on university campuses even when not targeted at an indi vidual.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:14PM (#38846537)
That’s irrelevant unless you have examples of this being the case at Harvard.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:27PM (#38846718)
Harvard is notorious in its modern history of censorship [1].

[1] https://www.thefire.org/news/harvard-gets-worst-score-ever-f...

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:31PM (#38846783)
None of those things are examples of students being censored. Disinvitation and protesting are themselves protected activities. This doesn’t say what you’re claiming it says.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:03PM (#38846401)
Can you point to the ruling? It looks like Google searches don't uncover any useful writing about a specific legal ruling allowing direct calls to violence against a group, but as usual, I am always best convinced by specific links to articles referencing case decisions.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:24PM (#38846665)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threatening_the_president_of_t...

It needs to something that a reasonable person who directly heard the speech would interpret as a “true threat” to a person or group. In the case above, the defendant made a claim that he was going to “set his sights on LBJ” if he was drafted and they “ever gave [him] a rifle”. He threatened to shoot a President of the US and his speech was found to be protected because of the qualification mentioned above. Two prior courts found him guilty and the Supreme Court reversed the decisions.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gnicholas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:13PM (#38846528)
Look up the true threats doctrine. There won't be any specific case law on the phrase you mentioned. Here's one summary of the doctrine:

> The U.S. Supreme Court defined true threats in Virginia v. Black (2003) as “statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals.” According to the Supreme Court, true threats include when a speaker directs a threat to a person or group of persons with the intent of placing the victim in fear of bodily harm or death. [1]

https://uwm.edu/free-speech-rights-responsibilities/faqs/wha...

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:23PM (#38846658)
I don't agree that applies in this case- in terms of Westboro, they very clearly advocate actual direct violence. In the case of the protesters at Harvard their intent is much less clear - I suspect even the people calling for intifada aren't attempts to elicit immediate violence.

I broke my cardinal rule- never get involved in an internet discussion of free speech. Also, and this is purely opinion- I think the Supreme Court made an error in their ruling.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gnicholas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:27PM (#38846722)
> I don't agree that applies in this case

You don't think the doctrine applies, or you don't think it is satisfied?

I think the bigger issue here is that Harvard does not guarantee First Amendment levels of free speech protection. They caution students about all sorts of protected speech, so what the First Amendment does or doesn't protect isn't really relevant.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:25PM (#38846694)
It does apply. Westboro has already argued the “true threat” position and won.

https://news.yahoo.com/supreme-court-hurtful-speech-westboro...

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:31PM (#38846779)
Clearly, the justices and I have a difference of opinion about what a direct threat looks like (in the case of Westboro).
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:37PM (#38846841)
Yes but, as someone else pointed out, Harvard is a private school that takes federal funding. The Supreme Court’s decision wouldn’t affect them either way.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gnicholas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:05PM (#38849409)
> in terms of Westboro, they very clearly advocate actual direct violence.

They did? When I learned about them in law school, we only covered their protesting at military funerals, which did not involve advocating violence. What did they do that advocated direct violence?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dekhn on Thursday January 04, 2024 @03:16PM (#38871697)
Sorry, I was working on the assumption that "Death to gays" was considered a direct call to violence, but it does not seem to be.

(All of this was a misunderstanding caused by me misparsing a statement above suggesting Westboro was protesting at Harvard)

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by someuser2345 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:54PM (#38846267)
What do you mean "Harvard allows the Westboro Church"? Harvard has no power over the church.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:57PM (#38846308)
Westboro Baptist is allowed to protest at Harvard graduations based on the university’s policies. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2010/12/2/harvard-protest...
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by someuser2345 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:39PM (#38846880)
Based on that article, it doesn't sound like Harvard is allowing them, it sounds like they have no power to stop them, since they're protesting near Harvard.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:51PM (#38847014)
They are allowed on campus. Harvard is a private school and can ask anyone to leave the campus for any reason.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dudul on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:34PM (#38845955)
> It’s even more ludicrous considering that the people attempting to push the question dishonestly are the same ones who like to cry about free speech on Twitter

How do you know they are the same people?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:53PM (#38846246)
Because Elise Stefanik, the Congresswoman in question, cosponsored the “Protecting Free Speech” Act and the “Restoring Academic Freedom on Campus” Act which are supposedly meant to “prevent colleges and universities from stifling the free expression of diverse viewpoints”. As usual, it’s only to prevent stifling the viewpoints they agree with.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:08PM (#38847759)
> the school has a policy of allowing and supporting free speech.

No they don't!

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:26PM (#38847926)
They literally have a policy that allows students to say things that are considered objectionable and, unless you have examples where they've violated that (disinvitations are not censorship of student speech as the invites are external), you'll need to do better than just "No they don't!".
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by iteratethis on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:35PM (#38848015)
It doesn't have such policy. It's the lowest ranking university with a free speech score of 0. ZERO.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:15PM (#38848443)
It does. FIRE asks students how they feel about free speech. It has nothing to do with what actions schools have actually taken and what their policies are.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by gnicholas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:31PM (#38845913)
The issue is that elite universities have not actually been protectors of free speech/academic freedom in recent years, so it becomes difficult for them to make legalistic claims about how calls for genocide are not technically against their policies.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by The5thElephant on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:07PM (#38845607)
Yes but it was an obvious trap and self-inflicted wound. Is giving the technically correct answer alone actually better considering the resulting consequences? Would have been smarter to give both the desired answer (calling for genocide is bad) AND follow it with the technical answer to make it clear she understood both what the schools rules are as well as what was happening in that hearing and why.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by EA-3167 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:35PM (#38845977)
Free speech in what sense? Freedom from government sanction (outside of the realm of things like incitement, defamation, breaking classification, etc) or freedom from any accountability and consequences? The former I support entirely, the latter is simply not a real thing and never has been. People who frame their desire to be free from a public reaction to what they say as "free speech" make me suspect their motives in making those claims.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:05PM (#38847725)
These are not hard questions to answer. To the standard of bullying and harassment that private universities are legally permitted to regulate in their Student Code of Conduct, calling for genocide is in fact bullying and harassment. To the standard of constituting a crime for which an offender can be arrested and tried in court, calling for genocide is not a crime.

Public universities are, as institutions of the state, required to scrupulously uphold the First Amendment, and have an entire toolkit of time-tested ways to do that without making campus life unlivable for whomever the undergrads go on a moral crusade against this semester. I went to a public school that encountered some of the same controversial issues Harvard, Penn, and MIT flubbed, and did a lot freakin' better by standing for the letter of the law in distinguishing between private speech and student conduct in the course of campus activities (eg: in a classroom).

You wanna call for genocide in a campus newspaper editorial? As a hypothetical, it's free speech if the newspaper agrees to print your piece. You wanna mob someone's dorm room or community center calling them a genocidaire (much closer to what Harvard and MIT students are actually doing!), without letting them go in and out of their own space undisturbed? That's harassment insofar as you prevent any specific individual from going about their normal life, including its public component as a student (of a university) or employee (of a firm).

You don't get to walk into a random office building downtown and force the security desk to take you upstairs to the 15th floor so you can hold placards and yell slogans at desk-jockeys working for Web Marketing Firm #23. You don't get to barge into a classroom where course lectures are being given to do that either.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by SilasX on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @08:52AM (#38854030)
The problem was that the tolerance of "kill all Jews" didn't arise from a principled defense of freedom of speech in general. Harvard clamps down on a lot of speech, but then hand-wrings and carefully looks for "context" when the particular group attacked is Jews. That's not even-handed, or a case of biting the bullet in hard cases of free speech.