Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns
by gnicholas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:27PM
(#38846722)
> I don't agree that applies in this case
You don't think the doctrine applies, or you don't think it is satisfied?
I think the bigger issue here is that Harvard does not guarantee First Amendment levels of free speech protection. They caution students about all sorts of protected speech, so what the First Amendment does or doesn't protect isn't really relevant.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns
by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:25PM
(#38846694)
It does apply. Westboro has already argued the “true threat” position and won.
https://news.yahoo.com/supreme-court-hurtful-speech-westboro...
Clearly, the justices and I have a difference of opinion about what a direct threat looks like (in the case of Westboro).
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns
by dpkonofa on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:37PM
(#38846841)
Yes but, as someone else pointed out, Harvard is a private school that takes federal funding. The Supreme Court’s decision wouldn’t affect them either way.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns
by gnicholas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:05PM
(#38849409)
> in terms of Westboro, they very clearly advocate actual direct violence.
They did? When I learned about them in law school, we only covered their protesting at military funerals, which did not involve advocating violence. What did they do that advocated direct violence?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns
by dekhn on Thursday January 04, 2024 @03:16PM
(#38871697)
Sorry, I was working on the assumption that "Death to gays" was considered a direct call to violence, but it does not seem to be.
(All of this was a misunderstanding caused by me misparsing a statement above suggesting Westboro was protesting at Harvard)
I broke my cardinal rule- never get involved in an internet discussion of free speech. Also, and this is purely opinion- I think the Supreme Court made an error in their ruling.