News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by arp242 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @12:52AM (#38838577)
For a lot of things the problem is essentially a problem of scale. Those "ancient human tribes" who did so much better were tribes of 100-200 people, and it's actually not that hard to "do the right thing" with a relatively small group of people.

Blaming it on the two-party system is such a short-sighted US-centric point of view. There are plenty of countries with other types of democracies, and they have roughly similar problems. Details differ and some things are better (and others worse!) but overall: it's not that different.

I don't know about all the individual topics that are mentioned. I'm not an expert of blood cancer and I'm guessing the author isn't either, but ... maybe it's not that simple? The "Preclinical proof-of-concept study" from August 2023 doesn't really sound like "we've solved it, end of story" to me.

"We could fix everything, we just don't" seems far too simplistic. "Everything" encompasses quite a lot, and "I looked at this for a few hours/days and I figured it all out" is classic mistake that people make. Almost everything is conceptually simple. Actually doing it tends to be harder because all those details you didn't account in the high-level overview often do matter.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by marcus_holmes on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:33AM (#38839110)
I've lived in a few places around the world. By far the best-run one was the Isle of Man, which (when I lived there) had a population of around 30K. It has an independent parliament (Tynwald, the oldest continuous parliament in the world), and it makes its own laws.

The government has very little graft. Politicians seemed to genuinely work for the benefit of their constituents [0]. I always attributed this to the fact that they lived in the communities they served, and the people they socialised with were affected by the decisions they made.

The UK has the problem that the politicians are insulated from the people they ostensibly serve. Especially the Tories. They have displayed contempt and arrogance beyond belief.

This is all, as you say, a problem of scale.

[0] One illustration of this is the Manx implementation of social security vs the UK. When the Manx government set up national insurance contributions, they paid them into a separate fund (https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/departments/the-trea...) which is under control of the treasury. The UK just poured the national insurance contributions into the general taxation pool.

The Manx fund (and by extension their health service) is rolling in money. The UK NHS is broke. The Manx system is proof that there were more than enough contributions to the NHS to keep it adequately funded. But the UK politicians spent the contributions on other things, because they could.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by timeon on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:04AM (#38839633)
> that they lived in the communities they served

It is not just this. There are many small municipalities around the world where mayor/local council does not act like this. Most of things come down to voters. Their culture and breadth of views.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by prox on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:47AM (#38839528)
Thomas Paine in Common Sense also describes that is preferable to have constituents from the places and with work in the community they live in. Congress only has 2 years for this reason as well, to be a reflection of the community they live in.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by consp on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:06AM (#38839649)
> the UK politicians spent the contributions on other things

I'm pretty sure this is by design and the end result is as well.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by jampekka on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:27AM (#38839765)
Isle of Man does have the benefit that its economy is based on international tax evasion, money laundering, online gambling etc sleazy stuff that essentially siphon off money from places where the actual labor is conducted.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by _heimdall on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:48AM (#38841092)
How do you distinguish this from, say, the US which runs a trade deficit of around $1 trillion?

Is your problem with Isle of Man the specific industries or businesses that drive revenue there, or the siphoning off of money/labor from other places?

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by jampekka on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:50AM (#38841554)
US does the siphoning with quite a different method, mostly by enforcing the petrodollar using the huge military. It could probably use this money a lot better if wellbeing of the citizens is the benchmark.

Sleazeball havens like Isle of Man (and many others) by the merit of creating international legal loopholes.

West in general siphons off money/labor from other places.

Not a fan of these, but this wasn't really the point. The point was that Isle of Man has the advantage of not having to do much work of their own to keep the economy rolling so it's not necessarily comparable.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by marcus_holmes on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:51PM (#38849317)
They literally just charge a flat tax rate and no corporation tax. It's not really a legal loophole.

There are hoops they make people jump through - if you're a company wanting to relocate then you must have one Manx director. If you're a person then you must actually live there.

The Manx used to make their money from smuggling. This is cleaner.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by ProllyInfamous on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:59AM (#38839984)
"But beware, this country comes with a curse!"

[That's bad].

"But it comes with a FREE FROGURT!"

[That's good].

"But the frogurt is ALSO CURSED!"

[That's bad].

"But it comes with a FREE TOPPING!"

[That's good].

"The country has a long history of sociopathic ideation on its socioeconomic participation within a larger global economy, typically as a parasite to vice."

[...].

"That's bad."

[*] A bad take on Simpson's [did it, first!]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i73-lpVV-Jo

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by MrPatan on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:32AM (#38839791)
Is the secret in the running of it? The policies?

Or is there a source of funds in the Isle of Man that is not applicable to the rest of the world? Like, if it was applied to the rest of the world the funds would stop going to the Isle of Man?

Is there also something not present in the Isle of Man that elsewhere is a sink for money? Something you would have to stop incentivising in other places if you want to have them "rolling in money", but that many people can't bring themselves to do?

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by marcus_holmes on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:54PM (#38849339)
The main thing is that when you impose a tax on people in order to achieve a goal, that income is not then put into the general taxation pool for politicians to spend as they wish, but kept in a separate fund that can only be used to fund the thing it was levied for. If we had more of that we'd have less problems like the NHS.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pvdoom on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:09AM (#38839673)
A better way to put it is, we could fix everything, we just don't, because it is not profitable and not in the interest of the people that have the money to invest in stuff.

I do think there is definitely an element of things being harder than they seem, but it's just an element. The vast majority is the for profit nature of our system, that does not reward making things better.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by roenxi on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:16AM (#38839698)
AI is also likely to make a huge difference to coordination problems. We can imagine a future in a short while ... maybe a decade or few? ... where we as random citizens can ask an AI we trust to go through the last 30 years of parliamentary records, profile an individual politician's voting record and interpret it according to my personal worldview.

That seems like it'd be a significant change to the game. At the moment, figuring out what someone's record is is still too hard even with sites that are trying to help. I can go to http://politicsthatwork.com/ and see a politician scored 12.8% on "Humane Immigration Policy" which tells me nothing [0]. My views are complex enough that no mass-produced title is going to break things down in a way I'm satisfied with.

But AI will allow that sort of summary where I can describe what sort of features a record should have, with examples of particular bills. I can think of other similar uses too; this'll be a wild era. One person can get through a lot of text all of a sudden. Maybe even fast enough to use it while arguing politics in real time.

[0] Does the dude hate migrants? Love migrants but prefers a welfare-heavy society and wants to try and make it sustainable? Loves migrants but the opposition is playing silly games with bill names? Loves high-skilled migrants? Are the bills being voted only tangentially related to migrants, or strategically entangled with migrant issues? Politics is best understood in context.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by jmnicolas on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:45AM (#38839174)
The ancient tribes did better because when they didn't, people died of starvation. Pretty big incentive here.

Nobody died from the UEFI custom image vulnerability.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Aunche on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:34AM (#38838833)
He doesn't even give an example of "ancient human tribes," but modern day nomads whose traditions have also developed over thousands of years. If ancient human tribes were so great at avoiding tragedy of the commons, I would be eating a mammoth steak right now.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by coldtea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:11AM (#38839001)
The author explained very well what they meant (optimizing for lower risk vs profit) and this has little to do with preserving mammoths. That would be a very peripheral concern (if it was one at all).
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Aunche on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:54AM (#38839564)
Mammoths were an easy protein source for ancient people that were hunted into extinction. This is optimizing for short term profit.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by me_me_me on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:23AM (#38840485)
It was any kind of fauna that was hunted into extinction when humans moved in.

And its still happening to this day.

I was staying in a tribe village in Thailand, a full day trek into jungle. They had a dirt road connecting them to the rest of thailand but were surrounded by jungle. I was sharing few drinks with people i traveled and locals, and there was small commotion. When asking about it, locals explained that someone saw monkey out in the jungle and people were discussing who should shoot it.

They explained that there is no animals in over 5km around the village as its hunted for the meat the moment its spotted. Basically a deadzone for anything that has enough meat to be worth a shotgun shell.

Its clear as day that everyone in the village would benefit from cooperation but they dont. Humans on average are not rational. And we are barely more advanced than the ancient people. We have better tech, and a bit more empathy. But the wiring is still the same.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Fluorescence on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:33AM (#38840965)
I believe it was mainly climate change and loss of habitat during glacial retreat that caused Mammoth and other mega-fauna to die out. Human hunting was likely a minor contributor and nothing like the industrial slaughter of bison.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by more_corn on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @11:46AM (#38843672)
Not true. Megafauna died out across the world in hundreds of different habitats when humans arrived and hunted them to extinction.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Aunche on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @12:47PM (#38844502)
There is still plenty of tundra in Canada and Siberia where mammoths could still live today. Megafauna survived several cycles of climate change. They went extinct during the cycle when humans arrived.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by grotorea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:49AM (#38841098)
I am far from an expert but I think optimizing for profit/productivity and relying on a combination of insurance, trade and savings to reduce risk is one of the big productivity boosts in the last few hundreds years.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pvdoom on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:11AM (#38839686)
The whole tragedy of the commons was literally made up by a very reactionary dude to justify fucking people over and justify enclosure and privatisation. Historically people have actually had rather complicated and at the same time very effective ways of sustainably managing the commons. It also happens that privatisation is the thing that makes the tragedy of the commons happen.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by RandomLensman on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:24AM (#38839749)
Historically, quite a few people ruined themselves.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by concordDance on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:16AM (#38839701)
> Historically people have actually had rather complicated and at the same time very effective ways of sustainably managing the commons.

Ones that scale to more than a million people?

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pvdoom on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:06AM (#38854180)
Yup.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by inglor_cz on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:49AM (#38840292)
Historically, people also cut down most of the forests in the Mediterranean for firewood and shipbuilding without even attempting to balance the process, causing major problems for their descendants. Most of this activity predated modern capitalism by millennia.

Historically and currently, people polluted common waters and air with all sorts of agricultural and industrial runoff. Heck, someone around me has been feeding their home fireplace with plastic right now and fifty other families have to smell the acrid smoke.

Historically and currently, people overfished oceanic stocks to total depletion in certain seas.

Historically and currently, people dumped their refuse somewhere behind their village or city, creating rotting heaps of trash.

I don't see anything made up about the tragedy of the commons.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pvdoom on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:06AM (#38854170)
And a lot of those things you list are not tragedy of the commons as stated, but a consequences of the very thing that Hardin was defending - the enclosure of the commons and privatisation. Because privatisation and capitalism both encourage competition, and unsustainable behaviour towards common resources. This is why we see agricultural and industrial runoffs, oceanic stock depletion etc. Historical communities tend to have tools and practices that prevent all of that stuff from happening, practices that have been put aside with colonialism, enclosure and markets ...
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by nvm0n2 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:34AM (#38840549)
That seems to be ahistorical revisionism. The common land in mediaeval England was literally called "waste" as in a "wasteland". It seems that some ideological academics are now trying to rewrite this history. Wikipedia has been edited into a state of internal inconsistency where it says [2]:

> Millions of acres were "common land", but this did not mean public land open to everybody, a popular fallacy ... Certainly their rights were strong, because the lord was not entitled to build on his own land, or fence off any part of it

So this land wasn't fenced off in any way and the putative "owner" couldn't build anything on it, yet this article argues it also wasn't "open to everybody", despite literally being called "common land" that is the root of the word "commoners".

It also says:

> the commoners' right to graze the lord's land with their animals was restricted by law - precisely in order to prevent overgrazing

... but the citation for this is very curious. It's a book [1] with an abstract that says:

The report of the Royal Commission on Common Lands (of which both authors were members) revealed not only the chaotic state of the laws relating to the commons but also the lack of information regarding their nature, distribution and extent. Some commons being shamefully misused, while some very large tracts are lying idle and serving no useful purpose either economically or for public enjoyment.

... which sounds exactly like the well known tragedy of the commons that supposedly doesn't exist.

Checking the history of the Wikipedia talk page (which is nearly empty) reveals what you might expect: someone engaged in a massive edit war to totally rewrite this page along ideological lines, claiming the classic understanding taught to British schoolchildren was "neomalthusian rubbish", whatever that means. They appear to have simply ground down their opposition, then the whole discussion was deleted by a bot. Nice. Wikipedia has become such a dumpster fire in recent years, it's so sad.

[1] https://www.amazon.co.uk/Common-England-Collins-Naturalist-L...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Fluorescence on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:32AM (#38841426)
I can't understand what issue you are having. Common land was managed in different ways in different places (chaotic) with local laws granting rights that often restricted scale of access to prevent over-use.

I'm not sure what your point is about waste is because The Lord's Waste was a specific legal designation separate from the more emotive devastated/unusable/excess we might be familiar with.

The assumption that Common Land was unmanaged and owned by all is false but that doesn't mean it was always well managed. Be in no doubt that Enclosure was a horrifying theft of rights from the citizenry and in no way a solution to a Tragedy of the Commons.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by nvm0n2 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:30AM (#38841946)
> The assumption that Common Land was unmanaged and owned by all is false

How? The source wiki now cites for that claim contradicts it. It says lords owned/managed it but not really - they weren't able to control access or put anything on it (manage it), and none of the commoners were able to manage it either because none of them owned it. How do you think "scale of access" was restricted without basics like fences? Cows don't care about laws.

The point of the tragedy of the commons is that without private property rights, resources get wasted and misused. The common land in mediaeval England is described in the book abstract as having that exact problem - it's either overgrazed and destroyed, or abandoned entirely. The solution was Enclosure, i.e. restoring ownership and building fences around the common areas, which is exactly the solution you'd need to utilize land effectively and prevent overgrazing.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by panick21_ on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:17PM (#38844896)
Both broad generalizations are wrong. Yes historically many societies have put in place various solutions to the tragity of the commons. But its also wrong that this was always the case and that all these solutions were great.

> It also happens that privatisation is the thing that makes the tragedy of the commons happen.

That is just fundamentally false. Privatization is one potential solution for a Tragedy of the commons. And of course privatization can be done in a fair or an unfair way. Just like every other potential solution.

I would suggest Elinor Ostrom work on the topic.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pvdoom on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:03AM (#38854129)
> I would suggest Elinor Ostrom work on the topic.

Isn't her fundamental restatement of the tragedy of the commons that if the people decide to cooperate, then it doesn't happen? Which is a pretty thorough refutation to the original tragedy of the commons, as we see it in the Econ 101 meme. Problem is that privatisation (together with markets, cause the two always go hand in hand) introduces incentives to compete and to exploit, which achieves ... well a tragedy of the commons. And the second problem is that historically, privatisation has pretty much always been done in an unfair way.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by panick21_ on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:28PM (#38860180)
Here work shows of course that the simplistic Econ101 Trategy of the Commons is wrong. And that of course was known long before. Just as in any other field just reading 101 isn't sufficient. This is an old problem in economics and much has been written about.

What her work actually shows is that the determining factor isn't so much if something is private or government or something else but rather about various other factor, like communication, monitoring and enforcement.

> Problem is that privatisation (together with markets, cause the two always go hand in hand) introduces incentives to compete and to exploit

There are tons of resources under private management and private operates are very well capable of understanding that if they simply use up the resource they will hurt their future earnings potential.

In the old school case of common land being zoned off, those lands became private. Those private operators used that land far more efficiently and the result a massive increase in the British population. And guess what, 100s of years later and that land is very often still farmed to this day. They understand that the land has capacity that needs to be restored in various way.

Now one can make the argument if the privatization happened in a fair way. Meaning did all the people who had access to common land get an fair share. That however is a different question.

With farm land this works because based on Ostroms work its pretty easy to monitor, and enforce. Secretly going to another farmers land and planting or harvesting isn't all that viable. In case of fishery rights this get much more complex. Before the invention of barbed wire such simply mechanism didn't work for cattle for example and thus other mechanism were used. However once barbed wire was invented cattle farmers moved to full privatization. See 'The Not So Wild, Wild West: Property Rights on the Frontier' if you are interest in various stories like that.

We can take various other examples. Common forest could suffer tragedy of the commons. But private logging operations have long understood that they need to split up land to have forest at different stages so that they can continually harvest wood for a long time.

Privatization (as in splitting up the resources into various parts) can align the intensives correctly, the damage the resource takes impact your own utility and thus aligns intensives correctly.

So it totally correct to say that splitting up a resource and managing it independent is a potential solution. But I think Ostrom work indicates that we need to look deeper and beyond a one size fits all solution to resource management.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pvdoom on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @04:01AM (#39011089)
> But private logging operations have long understood that they need to split up land to have forest at different stages so that they can continually harvest wood for a long time.

Private logging operations have started taking a more sustainable view only after a lot of pressure from conservationist groups. And even today, private logging operations are destroying incredibly important forests. Private logging is a good example of why privatisation is so extremely bad about the commons and the environment.

> communication, monitoring and enforcement. > Which is a roundabout way of saying government. Privatised, for profit ownership encourages unsustainable exploitation, without much regard for the longer term consequences. Again - forestry is a good example, and so are fisheries. Likewise:

> Privatization (as in splitting up the resources into various parts) can align the intensives correctly, the damage the resource takes impact your own utility and thus aligns intensives correctly.

Again is a roundabout way of saying government. And instead of adding for-profit middle-men here, we can just skip that part and just govern the resources. Then you don't need to deal with a fiddly system of incentives, that will most likely be made weaker by lobbyists representing private interests.

> Now one can make the argument if the privatization happened in a fair way. Meaning did all the people who had access to common land get a fair share. That however is a different question.

Intimately connected to the topic however, since historically, privatisation has always been used in order to enrich the already wealthy. So it is important, because this is the cause for privatisation, and therefore there will be a lot of propaganda and justification on why it needs to happen - which is what we see historically as well.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by oh_sigh on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:01AM (#38838960)
Maybe losing mammoths wasn't actually a tragedy.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by rocketbop on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:57AM (#38839230)
It was for the mammoths.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by bawolff on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:07AM (#38839291)
And for the people who liked to eat mammoths

More to the point, the word "tragedy" in context isn't saying that the end result is neccesarily a tragedy for the people involved. The "tragedy" is our (alleged) inability to have nice shared stable resources, not any specific outcome of any specific resource being exhausted.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by oh_sigh on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @11:02AM (#38843013)
Sure - my point was that maybe mammoths weren't viewed as nice shared stable resources, but rather like cruel giants that might destroy your settlement, crops, and family randomly for fun. Sort of like how how elephants are viewed by rural farmer folk in many parts of Africa.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by lloeki on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:30AM (#38839781)
> Blaming it on the two-party system is such a short-sighted US-centric point of view. There are plenty of countries with other types of democracies, and they have roughly similar problems

There are also plenty of countries with very close to somewhat different systems. Let's take France, where there are > 2 party - more like a dozen, of various sizes and shapes -, and where the president is a direct elect from the crowd.

Sounds far removed from the Lib vs Dem indirect US presidential election? Well, every single time when there's a new contender that does not alight with the typical left vs right mentality they're going to be derided as weasely opinion cherry-pickers with an agenda of selecting voters; "that one can't make up their mind, therefore they're shady: pick a side already!" unanimously shouts the crowd.

Some think it gets further emphasised by the two-round election system: vote for any candidate (who may or may not be tied to a specific party, but hey, guess show you get any reasonable amount of campaign funding), then vote for one of the top two of the previous round (the latter is basically intentional post-WWII design that assumes >50% of the population is sensible enough to kick out an extremist should they get enough of a share on the first round so that the neighbour's history doesn't repeat itself).

I'd argue that it would be essentially the same without it: there's only one winner, and for the winner to carry any weight through their term they need to have some backing in Senate and Parliament, which also gets us into "pass" vs "no pass" law- and decision-making, and so, deep down, a "us vs them"[0][1] situation.

It's not a two party system, yet ultimately it seems like "yes" vs "no" voting always crystallises things into one as an artifact.

[0]: https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/___97

[1]: https://pbfcomics.com/comics/skub/

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by nvm0n2 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:40AM (#38840584)
That's not to do with the voting system. It's because political disagreement is almost always ideological disagreement, which is one dimensional. See Sowell's analysis in his book "Conflict of visions" for an explanation of why.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by coldtea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:17AM (#38839033)
>For a lot of things the problem is essentially a problem of scale. Those "ancient human tribes" who did so much better were tribes of 100-200 people, and it's actually not that hard to "do the right thing" with a relatively small group of people.

And yet other societies in the present do the right things in a lot of areas even with comparable groups of people.

Not to mention today we have tools like the fast text, voice, and even video communications, the internet, roads, distributed power structures, an educational system, etc. to combat scale issues.

>Blaming it on the two-party system is such a short-sighted US-centric point of view. There are plenty of countries with other types of democracies, and they have roughly similar problems. Details differ and some things are better (and others worse!) but overall: it's not that different.

Is it really a wash? Or rather most things are better in other western countries with big economies?

>"We could fix everything, we just don't" seems far too simplistic. "Everything" encompasses quite a lot

Which doesn't really matter, as it's a figure of speach. It means "most things" or even "a hell of alot of things".

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by concordDance on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:20AM (#38839721)
> Or rather most things are better in other western countries with big economies?

Not sure which other countries you're thinking of, but each of then have their own issues. E.g. the UK has insane house prices and its rail is awful (I live here).

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by jhbadger on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:06AM (#38840774)
Yes, compared to many places in Europe (and even parts of Asia), UK's rail system is pretty bad. But it is still a practical way to get from city to city in the UK. In the US, except for the Washington-NYC-Boston corridor (and maybe the San Diego-Los Angeles route) it isn't really anymore. You can technically take a train from NYC to Chicago, but it will take you longer than the same train trip took 100 years ago! And insane house prices are very much a problem in the US as well.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by concordDance on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:33AM (#38840966)
I wouldn't call it very practical. Unless you want to go to London you're better off driving from a time, cost and reliability perspective. It's bizarre to me that it's much cheaper to fly to Edinburgh or Nice than to take trains...

The ratio of hourly wage to meter of housing is from 2x to 10x worse in the UK than the USS.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:30AM (#38839433)
I’m not gonna argue that it’s precisely a wash, but I’m not aware of any country without political factions who strongly oppose each other and think the country would be much better if everyone else would just get on board. What can sometimes be true is that multiparty systems make the hardness of problems more legible; if you have 5 different parties with 5 different perspectives on how the education system ought to work, it’s a lot less tempting to think that one perspective is unambiguously correct and it’s only The System that’s stopping us from following it.

The author mentions, for example, that we know “providing free college to everyone would be a good idea”. But we don’t know this, and there are many other rich countries that don’t do it; in some, college is entirely unavailable to people who don’t enroll in the appropriate high school track.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by coldtea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:48AM (#38839535)
>The author mentions, for example, that we know “providing free college to everyone would be a good idea”. But we don’t know this, and there are many other rich countries that don’t do it; in some, college is entirely unavailable to people who don’t enroll in the appropriate high school track.

We can change this however to "we know that massively cheeper or free college to anyone in the appropriate high school track is better" and it becomes true.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by xboxnolifes on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:59AM (#38839596)
Not necessarily. It's still possible there are confounding factors that led to it's success, unknown to all implementers and observers. Maybe there are other pre-requisites to the success of the implemented education system.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by coldtea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:29AM (#38840524)
We still know not having millions of people in debt out of university, and not giving millions of others the possibility to even go into university without big spending, is not good - confounding factors or not.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by concordDance on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:23AM (#38839743)
How do we know that a university degree isn't primarily a signalling mechanism? That would make universal university incredibly wasteful of people's most energetic years.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by coldtea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:32AM (#38840535)
Because people don't just learn to be doctors, physistics, biologists, structural and civic engineers, chemists, and countless of other professions on their own (not in any significant nunber after the 18th century at least), they learn it in university, with a structured curriculum, theoritical tuition, supervision, labs, and so on.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by concordDance on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:29AM (#38840936)
The vast majority of people with degrees will not use that degree in their job. I certainly didn't and looking at my fellow physics or maths grads the same is true of almost all of them.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by coldtea on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @11:00AM (#38842966)
Not sure what part one wont use. The degree as in "the printed paper"?

Because I guarantee that the "vast majority of people with degrees" in the professions I described and many more, will use the knowledge acquired during their degree in their jobs.

I'm not sure what physics or maths grad doesn't use the math he was taught/practiced/and picked up during his tutoring for the degree.

The implication is that they learn those things before going to university? Or that they learn them in grad school? (as if studying for graduate school is not also university, and as if the prior knowledge acquired during their BSc and such wasn't necessary to understand what they encountered in grad school -- and to have a basic understanding of their field).

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by concordDance on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @11:14AM (#38843225)
> Because I guarantee that the "vast majority of people with degrees" in the professions I described and many more, will use the knowledge acquired during their degree in their jobs.

I agree with this, but think the jobs that use degrees are a small minority. Maybe 20%?

> I'm not sure what physics or maths grad doesn't use the math he was taught/practiced/and picked up during his tutoring for the degree.

I'm a software engineer atm and while I have done some gnarly stuff with directed graphs, I don't think I've used any of my uni maths in my career. A friend of mine went to be an actuary, same thing, A-level maths was used but nothing beyond that. Catastrophe modeller? Same. Civil servant? Same. Hedge fund analyst? Same.

Very very few jobs actually require graduate level maths.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by RandomLensman on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:21AM (#38839734)
Ancient tribes failed all the time - not sure they did much better on a lot of measures.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by abroadwin on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:07AM (#38838653)
100-200, you say? Sounds familiar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by throwup238 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:33AM (#38838820)
Well yeah, Dunbar was an anthropologist studying social structures of tribes and primates…
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by hackerlight on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:03AM (#38838637)
Problem is that incentives, especially financial incentives, have so much control over our democracy. Why don't we fix the housing crisis? Because homeowners will vote out politicians who reduce their house value. Same answer for why we don't fix global warming, farming subsidies, carried interest loophole.

For everything wrong like this, there's a small but determined group of people who will defend the status quo, versus a much larger majority who actually do want to fix things but this majority has a political will that is diluted and disorganized and can't be concentrated into political leverage. So in practice the smaller group has the power.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by vasco on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:42AM (#38838871)
Things don't change abruptly so society can protect itself from lunatics.

Whatever examples you can come up with for "why don't we solve this faster we have the solution", can be counter argumented with the fact that your solution can turn out to be strictly worse and have unintended side effects. Many times in history we thought we had solutions for things and then we didn't. If society, or "the system" is too easy to change, then anyone can take power and mess it up for everyone else equally as fast.

A slow changing system is preferable if you want to self protect against it, even if some avoidable misery is sometimes around due to this lag it's way better than someone blasting through everything because they know better.

This seems like classic immature "but why don't we change everything and do a revolution" which does not take into account the negatives of that or that the revolution will go like someone else wants to, not you - and these things only work if "you can control everything" which is basically why communism has not worked. A battle of competing incentives seems way better than some guy deciding he knows better about everything and if he can only "coordinate everyone" he can "solve everything". That's called a dictatorship, which comunist states tend to.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by pmontra on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:50AM (#38839545)
I wonder if that's because of communism or because in any country with one party in power for too many years there is a drift to authoritarianism first and eventually to dictatorship. There are examples even in Europe and around it right now.

Of course communism as ideology cannot allow competing not communist parties. That would be heresy and the first years after the revolution in Russia 100 years ago show how it goes. Not communist parties are unthinkable by definition so yes, an ideological communist country sets the stage for dictatorship. A communist party in charge for only a few years in a democratic country, not much more than anything else.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by hutzlibu on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:30AM (#38839782)
"Of course communism as ideology cannot allow competing not communist parties."

Only when we are talking about marxist communism. Anarcho communism is (in theory) fine with alternatives by design.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by imtringued on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:34AM (#38840968)
The problem with communism isn't the revolution, that part has worked incredibly well. It's the fact that the communists don't know what they actually want. I've seen them argue against almost every concrete concept or idea that is falsifiable, but has a decent track record of improving people's lives, because it compromises their all or nothing ideology. Xi Jingping said something like "How about we let the ideology slide and try something that works for now" and no, China did not adopt capitalism, they adopted a heavily state controlled market economy with politicians having direct influence over almost every major business with the ability to fire CEOs. If anything, this proves that the western style "anti-statism" ideology that blames all economic problems on government intervention is, like communism, complete bullcrap. Yet you naively hear from people how China has adopted Capitalism, when in reality they broke literally every single rule in both the capitalist and communist books.

It's like the author of this blogpost says. It's hopeless, because we already have the solutions, not because the problems are hard.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by bawolff on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:15AM (#38839343)
> Why don't we fix the housing crisis? Because homeowners will vote out politicians who reduce their house value.

I mean, i don't think this is a good example. Well im sure the homeowner class wanting to protect their investment does play a part, its not like there are obvious solutions to the problem just waiting to be implemented (or at least not ones that stand up to scrutiny)

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by from-nibly on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:46AM (#38842123)
Because homeowners CAN vote out politicians who reduce their house value.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by ChatGTP on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:07AM (#38838656)
In my opinion, we always overlook what the natural environment has done for us, almost everything else under our control is a disaster in one way or another or requires very significant effort to keep operating. Anti-biotics overuse, holes in the ozone layer, top soil degredation, climate change, nuclear accidents, microplastics, broken arrows etc.

We're lucky we live in an environment that mostly provides us with the basics to survive. We hope that powerful tech like AI will give us the power to put us in control of our destiny.I think we need to be careful what we wish for because I don't think we actually know what we want.

We can't go backwards now anyway, so best of luck to us.

Cool article though, we seem too like to waddle around in our own shit.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by xwolfi on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:48AM (#38838900)
I agree, it sounds like people saying "our generation can't live as well as our grandparents", typing it from their mind blowing portable computer on the toilets of an airplane, going to vacations abroad.

Problems are only solved when they're solved, if we didn't fix a problem, either it wasn't a problem or we couldn't fix it just yet: it's not that some people are so mean they prefer the problem to persist because they gain something rather than fixing it to maximize problem solving numbers.

If you can't incentivize society to cure cancer, then THAT is the problem that is impossible to fix just yet, and that person should maybe focus on this ?

Look at cancer. I'm a regular smoker, I'll probably die a lonely death, of cancer, in pain, abandoned by everyone in my life who told me for years I should stop. Why don't I stop ? I can cure my own cancer but I don't, why ? The problem is way deeper, way more complex, than just some rich people abusing me for their profit I feel: I give way more money smoking to the government than I do any cigarette industrial, yet nobody seems to have found a way to cure my cancer, myself included, when we all know it will happen most likely.

Maybe we just can't yet find a way to rewire my brain to never need cigarettes anymore, and the problem is deeper than capitalist profit-seeking ? And if it wasn't a cigarette addiction I had, it would be another one, because what I need somehow is a dangerous vice and that is not an easy thing to make me not want ?

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by imtringued on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:39AM (#38841018)
If you care about nicotine and your health, you can just vape. A pure nicotine addiction is way more benign than burnt tobacco, because you aren't breathing in the byproducts of burnt tobacco and additives. Those additives aren't there for nothing, they make the product more addictive than the nicotine alone.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by fifticon on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:28AM (#38840160)
I don't think he was blaming it on the two-party system. He was just explaining how the two-party system is one of those obviously broken mechanisms that effectively blocks against replacing it with one of the better alternatives. The general category of issues he highlights, should be well known to people who have lived in and observed our real world and society for a while. It is possible to produce USB-C cables that are robust and last - I know as I own some. But I also own and buy some that LOOK 'robust' but are fragile and stop working within a few months. The vendors make most money by optimizing for LOOKING robust (which is what I am 'demanding'), but in reality making a fragile product, so I anyway have to buy more. For medicine, he is also obviously right - tons of resources are poured into developing 'money-making' medicines for 'money-making' diseases, by commercial companies. And comparatively little money is expended solving diseases which are harmful but not candidates for making money. As an example, investors prefer chronic diseases where you need periodic medicine, and aren't attracted to 'single-use cure' medicines. He is really just pointing to, that a lot of the worlds problems aren't needing an inventor to solve them technically, they are needing politicians and a political movement to drive the will to solve and change them. I recommend reading Machievelli's 'The Prince', for people who suffer from naivety.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by me_me_me on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:09AM (#38840401)
> He was just explaining how the two-party system is one of those obviously broken mechanisms that effectively blocks against replacing it with one of the better alternatives

I think this is self evident. How the hell US is heading to next Biden vs Trump. Again? How can anyone claim its that those are the best possible choices - or good choices? Trump is a fraud clearly claiming he is one and biden is barely capable to string two sentences together.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:46AM (#38840648)
> biden is barely capable to string two sentences together.

A speech impediment is not necessarily an impediment to governance ability. Please, criticise him for the things he's actually done wrong (being a politician, I'm sure those are many), not for a life-long disability.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by me_me_me on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:24AM (#38841359)
Speach impediment? He is old. He keeps forgetting things around him, looses his thought mid sentence. Was caught with cue card written for a 'child'[0], his 'handler' on many occasions whisk him away when he starts rambling [1].

I don't know how people are unable to acknowledge basic fact you can see for yourself.

Would you like to be in a car driven by Biden? Or a company run by trump?

> Please, criticise him for the things he's actually done wrong

Thats the thing. I don't believe biden is making any decisions, the show is run by whatever people around him (i presume leadership of dem party).

It is the similar story with trump. Plenty of evidence, testimonies and leaks from his office. Him complaining that the reports are too long and should include his name in it and point how given matter relates to him. He was also caught multiple times when his aderol was running off.

Difference is to manipulate trump you had to flatter him and appeal to his vanity or outright make him money (corruption).

I am not left or right. I am just stating what everyone is able to observe. The system is not run by people you pick. The choice is between two puppets and whoever can control them (some more some less directly).

The idea of big government used to be that presidents and parties are not able to enact changes as quickly due to bureaucracy and resistance of governmental agencies and institutions.

But now the presidents are not even interested (trump) or capable of that (biden).

Its suppose to be democracy not a cardboard cutout with democracy painted on it.

[0] https://www.businessinsider.com/biden-flashes-extremely-simp... [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zg25440ledA

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by tmaly on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:04PM (#38844714)
Curious to hear how you would solve these issues.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:27PM (#38847370)
> Speech impediment? [list of things that are not speech impediments]

When I'm concentrating hard on a tricky problem, I often forget my surroundings. I've been known to get distracted mid-sentence, and I would love if somebody would discreetly interrupt me when I go off on unnecessary extended tangents. I write myself cue cards one might give a child because I learned how to write cue cards while I was a child, and it's a pretty good system that works for me – but, because my vision is good, I can write them small enough to palm discreetly. I would not want to be in a car driven by me.

None of these things render me unfit for governance, organising, leading people, or understanding laws. In fact, I dabble in all of these things and, where I'm practised, I'm not half-bad. (Not exceptional, mind, but mostly competent.) I can even give speeches that appear memorised, given a month to write and a week to rehearse.

I am not yet old, so nobody calls me senile. But if such attitudes are what I have to look forward to, even if I myself do not change at all, I think we should improve society somewhat.

> > Please, criticise him for the things he's actually done wrong

> Thats the thing. […]

Thanks! This looks like it's about politics, not ableist ageism. (No comment on the validity of your criticism.)

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by ydnaclementine on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @12:02PM (#38843886)
Probably not a new take, but it would make an extremely interesting election night if Trump were to run as an independent. Could potentially see states turn yellow This election year in general is going to be insane to watch
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by OkayPhysicist on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:58PM (#38848230)
It would almost certainly result in a massive spoiler effect, handing the Democrats a landslide victory, unless the Republicans managed to completely and utterly drop the ball in putting forward a candidate that could beat Trump in at least a few states. That latter scenario would mark the death knell of the Republican party as an institution, leaving a power vacuum that Trump-aligned fascists would fill with an even further right party.

First-past-the-post voting makes the 2 party system inevitable.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by OkayPhysicist on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:52PM (#38848170)
The key issue in US politics is that the Democrats have achieved a monopoly on reasonable governance. The right has completely abandoned moderation in favor of active malice. That means it doesn't matter who the Democrats put up for election. A fucking golden retriever would get my vote, because the GOP is committed to overt evil.

That's not to say the Democrats are saints, or even not also evil. Most of them are in it to line their own pockets. But at least they're doing that without actively trying to make things worse. So they're approximately adequate.

Voting third party introduces massive risk that the mustache-twirling, overtly fascist sympathizing party takes power, which isn't acceptable to most reasonable people. Which is why we need to get rid of first-past-the-post voting, but unfortunately those same parties that are currently entrenched in power are the only ones with the power to make that reform.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by nvm0n2 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:06AM (#38840374)
The US two party system isn't that obviously broken. Americans like to say it's broken, but they often aren't that familiar with the alternatives.

You could have FPTP but with more than two parties, like the UK does. The downside of this is that the reason there are more than two major parties in the UK is that the parties are much more closed off to outside influence, and due to the presence of a major independence movement (something banned by the Constitution). In the USA it's considered entirely normal and possible for complete outsiders to run in party primaries, take over that party and then become President. This cannot happen in the UK because none of the parties have open primaries. Small movements towards more internal party democracy by Labour have been rolled back in recent years, because they allowed in non-centrist types like Corbyn who were popular with the base but not with the electorate. Still, it could be implemented in the USA. "All" you need to do is end the system of party primaries and voting for President, to allow party insiders to select their own leadership. And if you want a big independence party then change the Constitution to allow cessation.

You could have PR, like most of Europe does. Then you'd have lots of parties. The downside of this is that it guarantees that politicians can never actually do any of the things they campaigned on doing, with the result that politicians tend not to take policy development seriously. Parties end up standing for extremely vague positions even during election campaign periods, knowing that there's no point in having specific ideas as they'll all be mashed up in coalition negotiations anyway. Because the system is in some sense inherently unstable you have a lot of government collapses, and the promised benefits of representing everyone's views better doesn't happen in reality. Instead what happens is that every party just ends up being at a different point on the 1D ideological spectrum, and all the left and "center" parties form coalitions against the right wing party to deny them any representation at all, even if it means the government becomes deadlocked and can't do anything.

Overall the US system isn't perfect, but it's also not the great weakness Americans like to claim it is. The two parties are sufficiently loose and broad tents that they shift with the political winds easily, and it means Americans are able to go in an "fix" the parties if they drift too far from what is actually wanted. A big part of the meltdown over Trump is that the party insiders were reminded of this against their will. A big part of the meltdown over Sanders vs Clinton was that Americans actually like this aspect of the system and the left felt it was being denied to them.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by panick21_ on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:13PM (#38844844)
> The downside of this is that it guarantees that politicians can never actually do any of the things they campaigned on doing

That's a bold and total wrong claim.

> with the result that politicians tend not to take policy development seriously.

Ah that's why Europe is such a shithole and the US is an enlightened kingdom.

> Parties end up standing for extremely vague positions even during election campaign periods

That is just wrong. Parties often commit to specific things.

> Because the system is in some sense inherently unstable you have a lot of government collapses

That's why Angela Merkel was only in her position for 2 years.

> and the promised benefits of representing everyone's views better doesn't happen in reality.

Ill taking anyway, thanks very much.

> Instead what happens is that every party just ends up being at a different point on the 1D ideological spectrum

Again, that's just false. The represented views are way broader then what you get in other systems. Sure you don't have anarchist parties and Nazis but that's because those are minority views.

> left and "center" parties form coalitions against the right wing party to deny them any representation at all, even if it means the government becomes deadlocked and can't do anything.

That's a very, very broad generalization. And even if its the case, its not necessarily wrong. If 25% are far right wing and 75% are strongly against that far right wing, then that should be reflected in the government.

> Overall the US system isn't perfect, but it's also not the great weakness Americans like to claim it is. The two parties are sufficiently loose and broad tents that they shift with the political winds easily

Having 2 parties is the outcome of an election process that is fundamentally broken and sometimes its a legally enforced duopoly. To claim that isn't fundamentally broken in terms of translating broad popular views into government is simply wrong. The European system are also broken in various ways but they are far better.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by nvm0n2 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:35PM (#38846824)
> Ah that's why Europe is such a shithole and the US is an enlightened kingdom.

The USA is both richer and more democratic than Europe. You will need to accept this fact before mocking the Americans.

Europe is a place where most countries are partly run by Brussels, which is a totalitarian system. Consider the energy that Americans put into their Presidential elections vs the entirely secret and inexplicable process that led to von der Leyen being able to legislatively control Europe. People may not like Biden or Trump but they can at least explain the process through which they became President, and it is at least theoretically democratic. Nobody outside of Germany even knew who vDL was before she suddenly turned up as the most powerful woman in Europe.

> That is just wrong. Parties often commit to specific things.

Which nobody takes seriously because the best that can be hoped for is for the party to enter coalition, at which point everything is up for negotiation and they are guaranteed to have to discard many of their commitments.

>> Because the system is in some sense inherently unstable you have a lot of government collapses

> That's why Angela Merkel was only in her position for 2 years.

Merkel is an excellent example of the problem: after a deadlocked PR election she presided over an entirely mandateless caretaker government that lasted half a year, because German politicians couldn't form a workable coalition. In theory she was meant to do nothing during this time and simply preserve the status quo, but that is impossible to constitutionally enforce and in fact she continued to rule exactly as before, including signing Germany up for new foreign policy commitments.

The USA simply never has the problem of the previous president continuing to rule after losing support in an election. It is a problem largely unique to PR (the UK went through a coalition setup in 2010 but it only lasted 5 days).

> even if its the case, its not necessarily wrong.

The primary point of PR is to try and ensure the views of minorities are represented. If you disagree with that goal, you may as well just support the much simpler and more stable FPTP system.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by panick21_ on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:30PM (#38847397)
I don't really want to get into a big argument. Government organization is a gigantic field with lots of questions and we would have to go into more detail. Both systems have lots and lots of issue. I don't like the EU and have no interest in defending it either.

> The USA is both richer and more democratic than Europe. You will need to accept this fact before mocking the Americans.

Politics and government organization has something to do with that, but not everything. If the US had the current government style after WW2 then they would be equally or more successful then they are.

If its more democratic is questionable on lots of fronts, specially comparing with individual countries and not the EU specifically.

And frankly GDP is one thing, I rather live in most places in Europe either way. And I much rather live in the richer parts of Europe then in the US and I much, much rather live in poor part of the Europe then the poor parts the US.

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Ragnarork on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:07AM (#38840387)
I get the frustration of the author, but to me this article reeks of the "Cocktail Party Ideas"[0] syndrom.

[0] https://danluu.com/cocktail-ideas/

Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by imtringued on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @07:11AM (#38840803)
It doesn't reek of that for me. The other extreme is to insist on genetic engineering to increase IQ so that we have more "geniuses" with "novel" ideas, when in reality those ideas have been known for a long time and just needed to be put into practice.
Re:We Could Fix Everything, We Just Don't by Kim_Bruning on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @08:34AM (#38841443)
That's basically it. The biggest problem in human society in all era's (including the 21st century) is scaling up.

Once you get past Dunbar's number, whatever your system is, it'll start to run into challenges. Be it a company, an organization, or an entire country.

Objectives become diluted, misbehavior becomes possible, and steerability goes out the window.

Keeping a large group of people focused, well behaved, and capable of change is a huge challenge in any century, and is as ever highly underrated.

When doing research it seems like there's a lot of magical thinking in the field. Finding focussed sources tends to be tricky. Getting people to adopt even the most straightforward of practices even trickier. :-P