News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by upsuper on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:13AM (#38770408)
Every time I saw this kind of discussions, my first question is, what happens when sun is not shining? Like in the night or when it's very cloudy?

In many places in Australia, we have so many solar panels installed that's enough to power everything in the day time, but when the sun sets, coal still has to be burnt regardless.

I'm quite skeptical to grid-scale battery projects. Every such project has a total capacity of like 2hrs, making them only useful at some short peak time in the day, rather than overnight or over a cloudy rainy week. The only power storage that makes a difference to me is pumped hydro like our Snowy 2.0. But it's constrained by its location, and it's taking a decade to build.

I'm not sure what's the way forward. Maybe more wind farms can complement solar, but I guess that probably means we should really be deploying more wind farms rather than solar at this point.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by thecopy on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:37AM (#38770545)
Dont let perfect be the enemy of good.

This HN thread might interest you [1] "A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage"

From one of the comments:

>That's what is different about this new study. It uses real time supply/demand figures instead of annualized averages. It meets 98.8% of demand with renewables and fills in with fossil power the rest of the time.

1 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32580844

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by upsuper on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:18AM (#38771147)
I was not saying we have to be all on renewable perfectly. We are too far from even reaching a reasonable level. Power generation at night is dominated by coal plants.

The linked article is interesting, and it kinda confirms what I was wondering that it is probably wind farms that we need way more, not solar.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by karmakaze on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:21AM (#38771961)
The top comment there:

> "in Australia" is an important qualification here. Australia has a very high ratio of available solar and wind energy to population.

"Don't let perfect be the enemy of good." doesn't mean not to think it through. Show me the math.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:29AM (#38770499)
Whole renewable energy industry is dead end without usable grid scale storage.

Like inventing a car without brakes.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by defrost on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:51AM (#38770630)
Things take time.

Currently there's more than 100 concentrated solar thermal plants, generating 7GWh of power, deployed around the world with a another 30 under construction right now in China and a third generation plant being designed here in Australia while the second gen is currently being built and tested after the success of first gen pilot.

https://theconversation.com/batteries-wont-cut-it-we-need-so...

It's happening, it just hasn't yet arrived at scale.

In parallel we're also seeing the rise of solar -> green hydrogen | ammonia | methanol for use in heavy primary industry (mining and transport) which is a decent chunk of fossil fuel use to be displaced.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cbmuser on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:52AM (#38770638)
»It's happening, it just hasn't yet arrived at scale.«

Making it at scale is a MAJOR challenge.

Germany alone consumes up to 1.6 billion kWh on a single day. That's the capacity of 16 million Tesla-S batteries with 100 kWh.

Solving the storage problem is simply infeasible and is never going to happen in the foreseeable future!

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by plastic3169 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:21AM (#38771173)
Germany has 50 million cars. Are you saying that after those have been turned eletric their batteries alone would be enough to cover the countrys battery needs?
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:09AM (#38771864)
Usually people buy cars to drive them around, not to use them as batteries for poorly designed grids.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by defrost on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:52PM (#38777389)
Ergo the rise of concentrated solar thermal plants (CSPS) and using excess peak solar to produce hydrogen, ammonia, methonal, etc for off peak (night time) demand.

Batteries aren't the only way in which energy can be offset by 10 hours to meet lower night time demand.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by Kon5ole on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:23AM (#38770801)
Renewables still help without storage. Every TWh of electricity produced from wind and solar is a TWh that was not produced by burning coal. If you reduce the coal consumption in the existing coal power plants by 50% it's as beneficial as closing half the number of plants.

That said sure, we need to build storage, and I think the first and most important step is to remove the political obstacles currently in place to prevent people and companies from generating and storing their own electricity.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cinntaile on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:32AM (#38770511)
Assuming there is no solution to when the sun is not shining you still managed to reduce the usage of coal, no?
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:40AM (#38770569)
No, because you can't switch off the coal power plant on spot, it takes around a week.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cinntaile on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:23AM (#38770805)
You can (and this is being done in practice) regulate the power output instead of turning it off completely and then turning it on again, doing it your way would be extremely detrimental to the power plant's life due to thermal stress. It's also the case that different coal plants have different capabilities so when you claim it takes a around week to turn off a plant, you should provide some more information about the plant (type) you're talking about.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:05AM (#38771081)
You can disconnect output, yet you need to still burn coal anyway, unless you want to damage the coal power plant.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cinntaile on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:54AM (#38771360)
I'm not talking about disconnecting output, I'm talking about reducing it. You don't burn as much coal, which was my original statement.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:08AM (#38771851)
But idle = power plant still running on 80% so you are still using 80% of coal input to just keep it running on empty.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cinntaile on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:40AM (#38772128)
Coal plants for load following end up around 20-40%, nowhere near your 80% number. They have to, because the energy grid demands that they're capable of doing this because it's just not economical to run them at 80% when there is such variability.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cbmuser on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:55AM (#38770654)
You actually can and we're doing that in Germany. The plants remain on stand-by.

However, you always need conventional power plants on the grid as otherwise you won't be able to do load-following.

Most 100%-renewable-energy plans suffer from a deficit of knowledge how large electricity grids actually work.

There is a reason why there is no 100%-renewable-energy grid anywhere in the world which does not heavily rely on hydro power or geothermal power.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:11AM (#38771116)
But you are still burning coal, because you need to keep them hot, otherwise they will get damaged.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:40AM (#38770562)
400+ GW of installed solar in 2023 seems hardly a dead end...
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:41AM (#38770577)
That's installed. How much energy does it produce during night? 0W
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:48AM (#38770612)
Assuming a balanced installation across the world, that number is more like 200 GW. But whatever.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by sokoloff on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:08AM (#38770727)
The energy produced in a day from a solar panel is closer to 4-5 hours of its peak rating, not 12 as your statement suggests.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cbmuser on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:56AM (#38770665)
Yes, because electricity consumers in the US profit at night when solar cells in Asia are generating electricity. /s
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:06AM (#38770716)
That wasn't the question so, was it?
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by brucethemoose2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:36AM (#38770538)
I have been told that the big problem is actually transmission and load scaling.

Energy storage is a big part of that, but really boring, non headline grabbing things like better/more transmission lines and slightly more sane usage patterns make up the low hanging fruit.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by TheLoafOfBread on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:40AM (#38770563)
Solar/wind power plant + storage at the same place and consider it as one unit. Then you have a powerplant which can supply electricity on demand (as gas, coal, nuclear can) and you don't need to worry about rebuilding whole grid.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by brucethemoose2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:43AM (#38770588)
But ultimately you still need to move the electricity.

I know in Texas, we are largely making more wind/solar power than we can even transmit. There are projects to address this, but they are slow.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cbmuser on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:59AM (#38770676)
You still have the unresolved problem that wind and solar do not produce on-demand.

Any other market would have dropped a production machine already that does not produce on-demand.

It's like having a worker that only works when they feel working and be it 3 AM in the morning. No company boss would accept such a behavior in the long term.

For wind and solar, it's just widely accepted and rather than accepting that you can't build an electricity grid on top of unreliable generation, people try to come up with all kind of weird solutions to force a solution based on solar and wind.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:18AM (#38770777)
And seem to fail to understand that industrial electricity demand is flexible nowadays. And has been for almost a decade now.

So to put it in your words, yes, companies are absolutely accepting that kind of behaviour from their electricity suppliers. Companies are even benefiting greatly from it.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by troupo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:21AM (#38780096)
They are not as flexible as stopping all production when there's a quiet night and wind+solar produce 0 electricity.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:51AM (#38780227)
Hard to say absolutely, because some actually are, e.g. producing graphite as the rest heat can keep the process going for quite a while. And, more importantly, because we do not have 100% renewable grids yet.

Hydro does provide power without wind or sun so, as does bio gas, geothermal, pumped hydro.

Nowadays, base load is nowhere near as important anymore so as it was decades ago, industry quitely adapted without any body noticing, unless they wanted to know.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by troupo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @04:37AM (#38780451)
> because some actually are, e.g. producing graphite

How much graphite are we producing compared to, well, almost literally everything else?

> Hydro does provide power without wind or sun so, as does bio gas, geothermal, pumped hydro.

Hydro, geothermal and pumped hydro have the downsides of: you can't build them everywhere. "Bio gas" is a euphemism for, well, burning hydrocarbons (though burning gas is cleaner than burning coal)

> Nowadays, base load is nowhere near as important anymore so as it was decades ago,

This is a patently false statement. If anything, base load is much more important now than decades ago because almost everything we have and depend on requires electricity 24/7.

> industry quitely adapted without any body noticing, unless they wanted to know.

Well, if your only example of such industry is "graphite production", then it sure has. I sampled a few countries here: https://app.electricitymaps.com (note: the time is European, so you have the reversed numbers for "the other side of the world")

                     02:00     14:00
    Germany         43.7 GW   61.9 GW
    France          58.6 GW   59.2 GW
    UK              25.3 GW   31.4 GW
    Central Brazil  47.4 GW   48.2 GW
    
    US
    PMJ Interconn   94.2 GW   88.0 GW
    SW Power Pool   33.6 GW   34.6 GW
    California      21.9 GW   16.2 GW
Oh, look. You need significant baseload everywhere.
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @05:27AM (#38780693)
No power plant can be built anywhere you want, can it? Point being, and I never said we do not need baseload, baseload needs are much, much lower so than they used to be. Graphite production is just one of those really energy hungry industries that found a way to be flixible regarding demand, despite using, in my example, WW1 era production plants. Now imagine what can be done with modern production technology. Other industries I have first hand knowledge of: chemical plants and paper manufacturing. When you do production planning, when you consume electricity is an important constraint. And this flexibility is being rolled out to othet sites and industries, day after day, all the time.

So no, baseload needs are not as important as they used to be. Something people fail to accept, it seems... And those base load needs can be met, among other things, larger grids covering a bigger area. Also something tgat has been found as completely feasible in multiple studies. Feel free to ignore all of that so, I don't want to harm your strongly hold opinion.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by troupo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @05:50AM (#38780800)
> , baseload needs are much, much lower so than they used to be.

No, they aren't. You said, and I quote, "base load is nowhere near as important anymore so as it was decades ago".

Decades ago we didn't have everything requiring electricity 24/7. These days even your stove continuously drives power from the grid. And where "decades ago" your production stopped or slowed down because workers would go home, now you have 24/7 automated production and logistics chains.

Moreover, a lot of industries have shifted to production at night precisely because of the "civilian" electricity requirements during the day.

And energy consumption has only been growing https://www.iea.org/reports/electricity-information-overview...

> Now imagine what can be done with modern production technology.

I don't deal in fantasies.

> So no, baseload needs are not as important as they used to be.

Again, this is patently and provably false.

> Something people fail to accept, it seems...

Some people pretend that their fantasies are fact and that their baseless statements have to be taken at face value.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @06:34AM (#38781024)
You know what we had decades ago that required electricity 24/7? Steel mills, heavy industry, trains, 3-shift operated production sites and domestic appliances. You know what we have today requiring 24/7 electricity? The same list... Unless you think modern industry came into being with the internet...
Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by troupo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @06:54AM (#38781132)
Funny how it's both "the same things" and "we don't need the same baseload anymore".

Meanwhile electricity consumption has grown almost 5-fold since 1980 https://www.statista.com/statistics/280704/world-power-consu... and ~7.5-fold since the 1950s: https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:06AM (#38781190)
Yes, electricity consomption increased. As did industrial output and GDP, across the world. Not sure where the surprise is in that.

And I never said we don't need baseload anymore, I said, and that is confirmed by grid operators, studies and first habd knowldge, that demand, and there only big consumers matter, is getting more and more flexible. Hence, baseload is less important today than it was before.

Know why industrial consumers do that? Money, they are paid for that flexibility: either by getting free electricity or getting paid (negative prices) at certain periods. Or by getting paid to not consume electricity in certain periods, same way peaker plants are paid to generate electrivity in these periods to maintain grid balance. The large cobsumers do this, as I said, since at least a decade (first time I was directly involved with it, so propably longer), and they do this on production equipment and processes almost a century old.

We do need baseload, because while solar and wind are predictable, they depend on the weather to produce, and might not produce enough sometimes (almost a guarantee, your claim of zero is local so, large grids mitigate that).

Not sure what's so hard to understand about any of that...

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by troupo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:41AM (#38781408)
> And I never said we don't need baseload anymore, I said, and that is confirmed by grid operators, studies

So far we only have your word for it

> and first habd knowldge

And this is your word. That's it.

The rest I really don't care about because I'm just as capable of writing plausible-sounding walls of text without a single link to a study or a statistic. I try not to do that.

> that demand, and there only big consumers matter

Ah yes. Only big consumers. We've increased our electricity requirements 5-fold, but that doesn't matter. The "big consumers" will halt their production when there isn't enough electricity.

> We do need baseload, because while solar and wind are unpredictable, they depend on the weather to produce, and might not produce enough sometimes

I'd say often

> almost a guarantee, your claim of zero is local so, large grids mitigate that

The grid can mitigate it if there's a stable baseload generation available. A month ago there was a day when all of Europe's wind and solar combined was producing something like 10% of installed capacity. Saved by copious amounts of coal burning (and also by nuclear and some hydro).

So, riddle me this: when there isn't enough renewable energy, do "big consumers" halt their production, or the electricity consumption remains the same? And what does this tell you about "we don't require as much baseload anymore", given that our electricity requirements have grown 500% in the past 40 years?

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @08:00AM (#38781521)
Let me riddle you this then:

If there isn't enough solar and wind (hydro and other green / renewable electricity sources are perfectly base load capable), yes, large consumers reduce their consumption for that period. So, in percentage and not absolute values (no surprise you don't get that difference, you don't get neither the electricity has to he consumed when produced and production / consumption lives on a time scale...), we need less base load generation then previously. Heck, even Germany, among other countries, had days with > 80% renewable electricity on the grid, so we know it is technically absolutely possible.

Coal is bad, agree. Nuclear is a great stop gap until everything is ready, grid, capacity, industry and the like, to function with a renewable epectricity grid. Building new NPPs is a dead end so: too expensive, takes too much time and gets nowhere near the additional capacity we need, since most new NPPs replace old ones the net nuclear capacity gain is negligible.

The grid can mitigate if somwhere on the grid sufficient electricity is produced, base load, nuclear, renewables or somethibg else doesn't matter. Throw in demand flexibility and you are almostv here already. Storage is lacking, but even that is built out, e.g. most new residential PV has some storage component.

And since you insist: Yes, big consumers absolutely do stop production if needed and financially interesting. Know what? They even schedule production accordingly in close alignmwnt with electricity markets and grid operators. Hard to believe, I know.

Edit: I know big consumers do stop or scale down production, because my wife does so in production planning every week. And I scheduled production runs the same way during my time in production planning in the chemical industry. Oh, and one of the green belt projects I coached looked for ways to optimize production runs to enable more and more short notice shut downs for limited periods. The last one happened over ten years ago.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by troupo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @08:50AM (#38781880)
> If there isn't enough solar and wind (hydro and other green / renewable electricity sources are perfectly base load capable), yes, large consumers reduce their consumption for that period

Proof beyond "I said so"?

> So, in percentage and not absolute values (no surprise you don't get that difference, you don't get neither the electricity has to he consumed when produced and production / consumption lives on a time scale...), we need less base load generation then previously

So, again, empty words with ad hominem attacks.

"Oh we still produce shitloads of electricity not because we need to, but because you're stupid enough to understand we don't need to produce it".

Strangely enough, instead of "not needing as much baseload" everyone is busy running coal plants to sustain that baseload they don't need or something.

> Edit: I know big consumers do stop or scale down production, because my wife does so

Ah yes, it must be true then. I'll ask my wife, she knows something, too.

---

Anyway. I'm not interested in this discussion any further. Because nothing trumps "you're too stupid to understand" and "my wife said so".

Adieu.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by hef19898 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @08:54AM (#38781907)
>> Adieu

Yeah, couldn't agree more. Hard to discuss with someone who refuses to take other view points into account if they don't fit the narrative, regardless how well founded those other view points are.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cbmuser on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:50AM (#38770623)
» Every time I saw this kind of discussions, my first question is, what happens when sun is not shining? Like in the night or when it's very cloudy?«

We're burning coal or gas. At least that's what happening in Germany which had to reactive 19 coal-fired power plants with a total capacity of 7.3 GW after shutting down 8.4 GW of nuclear capacity.

See: https://www.smard.de/home/rueckkehr-von-kohlekraftwerken-an-...

Don't be like Germany, support nuclear!

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by izacus on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:39AM (#38770559)
> Every time I saw this kind of discussions, my first question is, what happens when sun is not shining? Like in the night or when it's very cloudy?

What's been happening now in Europe - the electricity prices go negative during the day and in the evenings the gas plants are turned on and start burning fossil fuels again to make up for the demand.

Luckily in some places it's supplanted by wind (when available - e.g. Germany), but a lot of EU countries just burn gas in those examples.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by Kon5ole on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:12AM (#38770749)
The basic idea is to produce enough power when the sun shines to last when it doesn't shine, by using some kind of energy storage. Batteries are one option.

How long batteries last is controlled entirely by how long you want them to last. A 2 hour installation is made to last 2 hours, if you attach it to half as many consumers it will last 4 hours, if you double the size as well it will last 8 hours. Some modern EV's can power a single home for several days.

Another interesting option is to synthesize gas. Australia could for example power Sydney from solar+batteries+synthesized gas by the end of this decade if they wanted to, construction could start tomorrow.

It seems that worldwide, the main obstacle really is "Wanting to". Everybody says they want to but there are so many economic structures closely tied to the status quo that actual change is quite slow.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by data_maan on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:49AM (#38770616)
Just imagine what would happen if lawmakers decided that it would be illegal for end consumers to use fossil fuels in the night if you have fossil fuels during the day... :D:D

After an initial "WTF I have to go to sleep now, because there's no electricity?!", people would get crazy innovative and find new solutions, and -to some extent- adapt.

Unfortunately law makers are not keen on making people suffer a little now, in order to avoid a whole more of suffering later, once climate change effects hit irreversibly and tangibly.

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by cbmuser on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:51AM (#38770631)
»After an initial "WTF I have to go to sleep now, because there's no electricity?!", people would get crazy innovative and find new solutions, and -to some extent- adapt.«

You cannot enforce innovations. That's not how it works, really!

Re:All I want for Christmas is 1TW of solar deployed annually by mstipetic on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:23AM (#38770466)
Well read up on it then instead of constantly asking basic questions. Do you think nobody ever thought of that?