News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by assimpleaspossi on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:20AM (#38769839)
I think the real problem is there are too many people.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by nine_k on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:56AM (#38770051)
No, not this, to my mind.

When the world was much smaller, the same problems persisted. The Great Famine of 1845 in Ireland happened not just because crops failed in Ireland. England had enough crops, and the world was ready to sell more, but the British government kept Irish ports closed for imports of foods, and English Protestant farmers were not very keen to sell to Irish Catholics (fun: both considered themselves Christians). Estimated world population at the time was about 1 billion.

Man-made famines are a really common thing all along the human history; just consider the medieval sieges of cities, and routine deliberate destruction of enemy crops. This was happening when the world had merely 300-400M people.

It's not too many people. It's too little wisdom, and too much cruelty, per person.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by briansm on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:24AM (#38770185)
Then again, if you believe that it's not 'too many people' and you also concede that population will continue growing as it has for the last 650+ years and the planet obviously isn't growing then surely you must also concede that at some point it has to become 'too many people', the only question is when.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by ajuc on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @08:22AM (#38771543)
According to our best estimates we're already past the "peak children". World population growth has been slowing down for decades at this point, it will become negative in second half of this century.

World hunger is not caused by too many people, it's entirely caused by our priorities. World produces more food than it needs and that production grows faster than the population.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by nine_k on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:10AM (#38770394)
Population growth slows down literally everywhere, and in most countries it's below replacement level.

We are living through the peak Earth population right now; it will likely be degreasing in 50 years.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by antisthenes on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @11:17AM (#38773042)
Population growth slowing down is literally collective agreement on "there are too many people".
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by dotnet00 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @12:08PM (#38773559)
No, population growth slowing down has nothing to do with a collective agreement on their being too many people.

It's simply that people in developed countries don't want to deal with the trouble of raising more than 1 or 2 kids because raising kids is difficult and expensive. You need 2 kids to replace the 2 adults, but then you add in other mortality factors and it drops below replacement.

Most of those people aren't agreeing that there are too many people, hell in cases like Japan, even their governments want them to have more children, they're just focusing on what strikes a balance for their comfort.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by vidarh on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:36AM (#38770541)
The population is demonstrably not continuing to grow at the same rates - all but sub-Saharan Africa is at below replacement fertility (and sub-Saharan Africa is also dropping fast), and much of the world today only experiences population growth due to immigration. With China likely now having slipped into decline net of migration, and India having dropped below fertility replacement rates and so only a couple of decades away from population decline, we're 50-100 years away from global population decline without drastic steps.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by p-e-w on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:26AM (#38769871)
The elephant in the room that any discussion about social issues will bend over backwards to avoid mentioning.

Climate change, ecocide, many if not most international conflicts, the housing crisis, fossil fuel consumption, and countless other issues are simply proportional to the number of humans on the planet.

Yet directly addressing that fundamental problem is almost always the very last thing proposed, or even talked about.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by wbazant on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:50AM (#38770020)
Sure, these conflicts are caused by people, but 'there' s just too many of us' isn't a suppressed thought, just a bad one that we have since moved on from. Overpopulation was a trendy idea in the 70s that inspired many ugly policies, like sterilisation of ethnic minorities.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by zemvpferreira on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:19AM (#38770155)
Because the base of our moral system is a right to human life.

Strangely I see more people volunteer the lives of others than their own to fix the planet. Never much initiative there.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by p-e-w on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:39AM (#38770255)
Birth control is not "volunteering the lives of others". What utter nonsense.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by zztop44 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:55AM (#38770046)
“Directly addressing that fundamental problem”… what did you have in mind?
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by p-e-w on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:41AM (#38770264)
Umm... promoting family planning instead of stigmatizing it? It's not exactly rocket science.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by flir on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:44AM (#38770282)
Raise living standards, decrease child mortality and wait two generations.

It worked for the first world.

(This is, as I understand it, a very basic summary of Bill Gates' approach).

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by vidarh on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:39AM (#38770558)
It's working everywhere. India dropped below replacement fertility a couple of years ago. The only part of the world left with above replacement growth is sub-Saharan Africa, and even the very highest, like Niger, has seen substantial drops in fertility rates.

If anything we're a few decades away from a rising panic about increasing them again.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by yvely on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:46AM (#38769988)
This is a common sentiment, but I have yet to hear any reasonable proposal for solutions. It certainly is talked about a lot in my experience.

It is so easy to complain about overpopulation. But how would you solve it?

1 child policy? Didn't work out great in China. Some can have children, others can't? Doesn't exactly seem right. Culling? Yeah, no-one wants genocide.

It's a very complex problem and people are very fast to complain about it, without thinking much about what actually to do.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by nine_k on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:13AM (#38770412)
It worked so well in China that they have a birth rate well below replacement level 20 or so years after the one-child policy was repealed.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by vidarh on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:42AM (#38770584)
The cause and effect is not so clear. China's wealth has also risen substantially, and with it comes fertility decline. E.g. India reached below replacement fertility a couple of years ago without it.

I think it's likely the one child policy contributed a bit, but a substantial part of the decline is clearly also due to economic development.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by astrange on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:38AM (#38770551)
It's a completely fake problem invented in the 70s by the book "The Population Bomb", and if it was true the things in that book would already have happened.

However, the West's strategy of writing moral panic books like this and then not actually reading them did allow us to defeat China (who read the book, actually did it and now has a demographic crisis) so that's something.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by giantg2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:25AM (#38770813)
The solution is talked about and is reasonable - creating western-like living environments in the remaining high fertility rate areas. Higher standard of living and more individual freedom leads to fertility rates near or even below replacement rate.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by astrange on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:41AM (#38770574)
> Climate change, ecocide, many if not most international conflicts, the housing crisis, fossil fuel consumption, and countless other issues are simply proportional to the number of humans on the planet.

Totally false, CO2 emissions coming from the US have fallen as the population has risen. No, that's not because of offshoring.

These things are caused by economic structure and government policy (independent of population) and technology efficiency (which gets better with more people, not worse). Examples being whether or not you're allowed to build apartments or beef is subsidized.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by p-e-w on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:20AM (#38770792)
> Totally false, CO2 emissions coming from the US have fallen as the population has risen.

That doesn't change the fact that all else being equal, half as many people emit half the amount of CO2.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by astrange on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:59AM (#38771042)
All else is not equal and can't be.

You're going to kill half the country and keep average household size, age, income structure and ability to build nuclear power plants the same?

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by ajuc on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @08:35AM (#38771622)
Poplation growth is slowing down everywhere, in the developed world (which uses the most energy and resources) it's been negative for some time.

Currently there's about 8 billion people, and estimates predict it will stop at 10 billion people and start to derease in the second half of this century.

So you're calling a temporary increase by 25% "elephant in the room", meanwhile the difference between resource consumption in USA (14 metric tons of CO2 per person per year) and the world average (4 metric tons of CO2 per person per year) is over 300%.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by Roark66 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:22AM (#38770461)
No, the real problem is there isn't enough people. If one Einstein is born per 1bln people, imagine what kind of progress in culture efficiency, technology, and ideas in general we would make as a species if there was 1T people (tera as in trilion).
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by Earw0rm on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:28AM (#38770832)
None. At our current efficiency levels, 1T of us would destroy our home planet's ability to support ourselves in a week.

If we want to go multiplanetary and support populations of that kind of size, we have to get much better at optimising our footprint. Which probably requires ethical/philosophical innovation as well as hard science/technology. What we have now is too wasteful and inefficient to scale up in that way, indeed so much so that it risks poisoning itself before it's able to develop those capabilities.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by giantg2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:18AM (#38770779)
This statement ignores a ton of other factors, and provides a particularly poor example. What did Einstein do to alleviate hunger? Most of his contributions remain theoretical or applied to things that don't directly help the population (or haven't paid off yet).

Even if you have someone who is intelligent, will their contributions actually make life better for people? Or will their ideas become commercially corrupted and be used for greed (Edison commercialization vs Tesla gifting)? Will they complicate our lives or provide harm along with some benefit (social media, TV, etc)? At such a small rate of the population (using your 1/1 billion), would a truly good idea gain traction? Maybe the idea to eliminate or restrict meat is theoretically a good one. But are you going to convince all the people to support it? Then how much impact will it actually have?

There is no magic solution nor hyper intelligent person that will save us.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by fragmede on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:48AM (#38771326)
GPS has helped a whole helluva lot of people!
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by giantg2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @10:04AM (#38772312)
But has it helped with living conditions like food and shelter? Sure it's made life easier, even for stuff like tractor positioning for field planting. But I don't see it having a real impact on those sorts of issues. I guess it has made many munitions more accurate and reduced collateral damage.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @11:20AM (#38773074)
Getting vital supplies to remote areas is no small thing.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by giantg2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @11:57AM (#38773460)
And how does GPS make that possible when things like maps have worked in the past? It just makes it easier.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by nine_k on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:04PM (#38776590)
Not just easier, but faster.

Have you tried moving through a desert or a steppe in the dead of night, far from human infrastructure? It's damn dark, the land is literally darker than the star-strewn sky. Headlights give you only so much light, for the next 100-150m of the road maximum. Unless it's a really nice, well-maintained road, with reflector posts, etc (and usually it's not), it's really easy to lose your way if you drive a tad too fast. You either crawl, or choose to camp and wait until the morning light.

With a GPS map, you can proceed much more confidently. And a few hours may play a serious role in disaster relief.

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by giantg2 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:36PM (#38777271)
I'd say cars or helicopters are what makes it faster. Even in land vehicles you can use time/speed/direction navigation.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @10:13PM (#38778699)
A GPS can guide you to a pinpoint in a featureless landscape where there is nothing to follow on a map.
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by giantg2 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:30AM (#38781350)
So too can the stars, or proper time/speed/direction navigation.

I'm not saying GPS isn't useful. I'm saying it hasn't had a life changing impact for the masses that allows for a larger population (eg it's not providing more food, shelter, etc).

Re:What are farm animals thinking? by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday December 28, 2023 @02:14PM (#38797305)
You need to medevac a hiker in a remote valley now and your plan is to wait until nightfall and have someone try to navigate by sextant?
Re:What are farm animals thinking? by lupusreal on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:41AM (#38770573)
You're presuming that Einsteins are born and destined to greatness regardless of their environmental conditions. What if Einsteins require particularly social/environmental conditions to reach their full potential and furthermore, what if those particular conditions cannot arise when people are packed together like sardines in a can?