I'm very impressed and glad that HN has discussed Gaza situation has been discussed with seriousness, respect, and a lack of flamewars. Let's not allow the poison to creep in now.
Check out this Reddit thread about a Bangladeshi American dating a Jewish guy, asking what to do about Bangladeshis who support Hitler: https://www.reddit.com/r/bangladesh/comments/17eqywa/how_can...
And check out the first response:
> I just say Hitler is indirectly responsible for the creation of Israel. If he didn't try to kill them all then Jewish people wouldn't have cared that much about founding an independent Israel. This might force them to think a bit differently and change their view about him.
Sure, it’s just one anecdote. But it’s hard to convey to someone who doesn’t have a Muslim family how pervasive anti-semitism is. My favorite aunt, who is the sweetest person, will randomly lower her voice and blame things on “the Jews” (she pronounces it like “juice”). And I’m from a liberal, upper class family where all the women went to college.
Never got that one. Nothing like the flag of a breakaway state founded to preserve chattel slavery as a symbol of… anti-authoritarianism?
Their narrative glossed over slavery, and focused on the other aspects of the conflict: the industrialized north, with its big banks and big corporations, versus the agrarian south. Do you remember the scene in Hamilton where they negotiate about where to put the capital? And the Hamilton says something along the lines of “let the south have the capital, we’ll have the bank where the real power will be.” It’s not hard to make the south look like the good guys if you ignore the Confederate elites’ actual reasons for the war.
I grew up partly in the South of the civil rights era and went to one de-facto segregated school. (Dad was military, stationed in various places.) I was a kid, but I paid attention to the news, and my impression was that racism was the clear, undeniable subtext to the "being a rebel" part: Many Southerners — notably, most of those who held political- and economic power — resented federal "interference" with "Southern ways," namely the violent oppression of blacks to keep them as an impoverished, powerless, underclass workforce.
(In 2020 I read a tweet thread from an anonymous Army officer, recapping the history of post-Civil War Reconstruction and the Union's de facto surrender in 1877; the quote that stuck with me was, "Sherman should've mowed the deep south like a lawn, making multiple passes")
Name one Arab-majority country where Jews live openly as equal citizens. The suggestion that “freeing Palestine from the river to the sea” would just mean a secular multi-ethnic state where Jews life peacefully among an Arab majority is willful blindness.
The logic of your argument implies that binationalism - a single state, belonging equally to both the Jewish and Palestinian nations - is an inherently genocidal position, and hence that proponents of binationalism are guilty of genocidal incitement.
However, there are Jewish Israeli intellectuals who promote binationalism - for example, the journalist Gideon Levy, and the academic Amnon Raz-Krakotzkin. By the logic of your argument, these Jewish intellectuals are guilty of inciting the genocide of their own people - which I think is a rather preposterous claim. Their critics argue that their plans, if ever actually implemented, would inevitably result in genocide in practice - they insist those critics are wrong. But, I don't think it really matters who is right. They don't intend genocide as a consequence of their proposals, so their proposals are not genocidal, whoever is right about what they'd lead to if put into practice. And nobody can really know the answer to that question, unless some day we actually try it.
But, if a binational one-state solution is not inherently genocidal - what makes a mononational one-state solution fundamentally different? In both cases, the claim of genocide is founded on what critics claim will be the practical results of the policy, not what the policy's proponents claim to expect as the outcome.
Some particular versions of a mononational one-state solution are genocidal, as are some proposed strategies to achieve one. But I'm not convinced the idea in itself (either in its Israeli or Palestinian version) necessarily is.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1517_Hebron_attacks
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_Ottoman...
There were periods of peace, but they were also second class citizens and occasionally the victims of massacres.
My point was merely not to romanticise the past.
House to house, Arab mobs went, bursting into every room looking for hiding Jews. Religious books and scrolls were burned or torn to shreds. The defenseless Jews were variously beheaded, castrated, their breasts and fingers sliced off, and in some cases their eyes plucked from their sockets. Infant or adult, man or woman—it mattered not.
> Islam had been at war with the Jewish people since its defining inception in 627 when Mohammad exterminated the Jews of Mecca and launched the Islamic conquest that swept north and subsumed Syria-Palestina. For centuries, Jews and Christians in Arab lands were allowed to exist as dhimmis, second-class citizens with limited religious rights. These restrictions were enforced by the Turks who, until World War I, ruled the geographically undetermined region known as Palestine, which included Jerusalem.
Seems quite pre-“colonialization”, assuming we count the establishment of the current state Israel in the 20th century as the startng point for that.
I know it hard to feel calm when things like are happening, and everyone wants to blame someone else, but there’s a whole lot of shared responsibility in what’s happening right now.
I care about what’s happening to folk in Palestine a lot, but I also care about the Jews in Israel and what happens to them.
Those are not mutually exclusive things…
This is laughably false.
The fact that the PLO was trying to achieve a secular democratic state or that they envisioned Jews to live in said state?
I’d love to laugh as well, so it would be helpful if you can be more precise.
Full chant is:
من الميه للميه – فلسطين عربيه
(Min al-mayya lil-mayya, Filasteen Arrabiya)
"From the Water to the Water, Palestine is Arab."
> You can’t travel to my “moderate Muslim” country with an Israeli passport. Guess why that is?
Perhaps for exactly the same reason Russian passport holders aren't welcome in a lot of places?
don’t think just the fact someone believes they are liberating something makes it right, as in their eyes the russians in the current war are liberating ukraine
If not those who use the phase - and have been using it in exactly the same way for decades - can decide what it means, then who can? Should we apply the same argument to "pro choice" and agreee that that it is a call for premediated murder of infants because that is what the "pro life" crowd thinks?
People often say this but I see no contradiction between the American Civil War being about slavery and it being about states' rights. It was about the states' rights to own slaves!
That aside, the idea that "all historians agree" is absurd.
Should we take your opinion seriously instead? Unfortunately you do not share it.
You’ve repeatedly been asked “What Israel should do in your opinion in current situation and what outcome you expect once it does it?” and you repeatedly have failed to produce any answer to that question even in simplified form.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38582722
> The chant is a call for liberation.
Let’s try again : How this “liberation” would look like ? And what outcome you expect to see once it’s done ?
The oppression faced under occupation by people in the West Bank and in Gaza for over 70 years now reminds us of how situations like Apartheid in South Africa formally continued until 1994.
To dismiss as simple “Jew hate” is really not the correct context; very disappointing to see these broad generalizations dismiss the fundamental needs for human life.
And the antipathy in the rest of the Muslim world is mostly about hating Jews. In Bangladesh, where I’m from, people aren’t marching for justice for the Rohingya being genocided by Myanmar—even though Rohingya are closely related to Bangladeshis. But there are huge protests in the streets for Palestinians. What is the explanation for why people would be so much more concerned about a “human rights” issue involving a far away, distantly related people, in comparison to the amount of concern for the human rights issue happening to a closely related people next door? Because it’s not really about “human rights,” it’s about a Muslim solidarity against Jews.
The issue with Rohingya people is also an issue that people take solidarity with and partake in aid of.
I see your comment as dismissing the desire to establish justice in Palestine as if it is only about fighting Jews for being Jewish. Many people also protested the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, which now in the US we recognize as being based on wrong premises. Apartheid was supported by many people but now it is regarded as a dark time in history.
If you wish to be on the side of ignoring the need for justice, know that you won’t be the first to do so. But it does not make it the correct thing to do.
Very few things about this situation are simple.
The phrase has its origins in Arab nationalism. It was coined in 1960 by the PLO to refer to the goal of an Arab state that occupies the entirety of what was Mandatory Palestine. If you ignore the subtext of “what happens to the Jews in that situation” I suppose you can make a case for it.
It’s like the confederate flag. In the 20th century there was an effort to rehabilitate it (as in the Dukes of Hazzard) as a symbol of anti-authoritarianism. And that’s the only connotation lots of people have of it. But it has a pretty unpleasant historical context.
At the very least it’s a dog whistle to the large fraction of the Muslim world that hates Jews: https://www.adl.org/resources/blog/adls-global-100-survey-wh.... Americans who use this phrase should really travel to the Muslim world to understand the antisemitism that’s just in the air. You can’t travel to my “moderate Muslim” country with an Israeli passport. Guess why that is?