don’t think just the fact someone believes they are liberating something makes it right, as in their eyes the russians in the current war are liberating ukraine
If not those who use the phase - and have been using it in exactly the same way for decades - can decide what it means, then who can? Should we apply the same argument to "pro choice" and agreee that that it is a call for premediated murder of infants because that is what the "pro life" crowd thinks?
People often say this but I see no contradiction between the American Civil War being about slavery and it being about states' rights. It was about the states' rights to own slaves!
That aside, the idea that "all historians agree" is absurd.
Should we take your opinion seriously instead? Unfortunately you do not share it.
You’ve repeatedly been asked “What Israel should do in your opinion in current situation and what outcome you expect once it does it?” and you repeatedly have failed to produce any answer to that question even in simplified form.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38582722
> The chant is a call for liberation.
Let’s try again : How this “liberation” would look like ? And what outcome you expect to see once it’s done ?
> You can’t travel to my “moderate Muslim” country with an Israeli passport. Guess why that is?
Perhaps for exactly the same reason Russian passport holders aren't welcome in a lot of places?