News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by pridkett on Friday December 22, 2023 @09:47PM (#38741181)
They’re air freighting the goods but doing so in bulk, so it ends up being far less than what the customs fees would be. If they were shipping them in bulk to a US warehouse without a designated customer, they’d have to pay customs. But rather, they arrive at a repackager which manages to skirt these regulations - at the expense of the taxpayer and competition who follow the rules.

In other words, they’ve found a loophole to avoid customs on goods with otherwise high tariffs, pocketing some of the money for themselves and using the rest of the savings (and arguably difficult to return lower quality merchandise, we are talking about fast fashion) to undercut competition. I’d think that SV would worship this type of “disruption”.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by mattas on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:12PM (#38741285)
Right. They even print the UPS/FedEx/USPS label in the distribution center in China. They throw the individual boxes in a Gaylord and inject the Gaylords into the domestic distribution network at the destination air terminal.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by gruez on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:14PM (#38741297)
>Gaylord

I was going to flag this but did a double take: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/gaylord#Noun_2

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by nerdponx on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:36PM (#38741398)
It's also a name.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by stn8188 on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:23PM (#38741612)
As well as a ventilation equipment manufacturer in Oregon [0]. You can imagine how it was driving by every day on the middle school bus. (About as well as Bonar Plastics, which the bus also passed every day).

[0] https://www.gaylordventilation.com/

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by asimovfan on Saturday December 23, 2023 @04:23AM (#38742832)
Its also a playground equipment company! Thought it was very funny when i was eight.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by sudosysgen on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:08PM (#38741548)
As well as a city in Michigan and Minnesota, which doesn't seem to have a connection to the corporation.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by Doctor_Fegg on Saturday December 23, 2023 @04:34AM (#38742887)
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by wannacboatmovie on Saturday December 23, 2023 @03:19AM (#38742566)
> I was going to flag this

Please consider easing up on the itchy trigger finger. Even without knowing the meaning, there is no way any word used in the context above could ever be construed as offensive.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by Kerb_ on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:28AM (#38771217)
So you're why we're renaming the equipment at my job! ;)
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by gruez on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:13PM (#38741294)
>at the expense of the taxpayer and competition

Would taxpayer dollars be better spent collecting $5 worth of duties from a shipment? Or would the customer (who are taxpayers) be better served by having to pay CBP fees for their $20 shipment from china? Would both the customer and the manufacturer (ie. "competition") be better served if the goods had to go through an intermediary in the US to reach the customer?

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by polygamous_bat on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:08PM (#38741547)
> Or would the customer (who are taxpayers) be better served by having to pay CBP fees for their $20 shipment from china?

Sorry, this libertarian logic falls short because there are taxpayers who are not customers of bottom-of-the-barrel Chinese doodads, and thus are being hurt by this laxness. Why should I subsidize someone else’s “seen on social media” gadget addiction?

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by bobsmooth on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:16PM (#38741586)
Why should I have to pay more so overpriced brands don't have to compete as hard?
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by human_person on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:59PM (#38741744)
I think it’s also about keeping the wealth/supporting the relevant skills in your own community. Saving a dollar here and there helps an individual a little but the community gets damaged in the long run. And the individual suffers in the long run too.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by DiogenesKynikos on Saturday December 23, 2023 @06:44AM (#38743508)
Whether the community is hurt in the long run is a complicated economic question involving many factors.

Specialization is one of the most important motors of economic development. Not every community can or should try to produce everything.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by stefan_ on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:48PM (#38741709)
It’s not about paying more, it’s about paying the same. The local brand can not avoid the duties on products less than $X, just like you are charged sales tax at the supermarket on a $5 purchase.

Thankfully computers exist now so it is really not onerous at all to charge the correct duties and massive fees if you want to make the customs people do work (this is basically now the EU approach, and AliExpress had no problem adjusting).

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by charcircuit on Saturday December 23, 2023 @12:32AM (#38741893)
Some products are too niche to be sold locally. If no local brands exist for a product I have to buy it from someone oversees and import it myself. Even if it is sold locally it may be overly marked up compared to buying it from the original seller because there is no local competition to keep the price in check.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by stefan_ on Saturday December 23, 2023 @01:18AM (#38742093)
Okay, and what part of that means normal duties should not be paid on that specialty product?

Seriously people, we have computers now. Every SaaS in Europe needs to pay correct VAT on every subscription sold based on the customer origin, it is not at all unreasonable to have online sellers pay duties for products shipped to US.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by charcircuit on Saturday December 23, 2023 @03:00AM (#38742492)
I'm already paying through the nose for foriegn stuff. I don't want even more fees to be tacked on.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by polygamous_bat on Saturday December 23, 2023 @08:15AM (#38744032)
So you would like taxpayers to provide a subsidy for your fidget spinner from China? I would much rather that dollar go to healthcare or higher education.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by charcircuit on Saturday December 23, 2023 @01:03PM (#38746407)
Yes, I would prefer to have my hobbies be subsidized.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by nirvdrum on Saturday December 23, 2023 @12:49AM (#38741965)
I’m convinced this is a big part of Amazon’s rise to prominence. While they often had competitive pricing, they also had a built-in discount by not collecting sales tax that brick and mortar stores with nexus could not avoid. And they fought hard against any changes to the status quo as it pertains to sales tax (at least until it became advantageous to do otherwise).

I’m fairly certain Amazon knew these consumers weren’t paying use tax instead. Local stores took a beating by having to play by rules that Amazon didn’t.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday December 23, 2023 @04:08AM (#38742760)
Mail order without nexus didn't charge tax either. The Internet didn't invent the the interstate commerce loophole.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by nirvdrum on Saturday December 23, 2023 @10:45AM (#38745041)
It didn’t, it just made it way easier to order from. And Amazon carried more inventory than most mail order catalogs. Subsidizing shipping helped a lot as well.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by Scoundreller on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:55AM (#38742471)
Heavily discounted shipping (media mail) also supported Amazon's initial rise. Funny how cheap shipping is coming full circle.

By starting with books (and then CDs/DVDs), Jeff picked a good target: inventory that doesn't depreciate too fast, subsidized shipping, not needing to collect sales taxes up-front, high costs at b&m level, high value per weight/volume, popularity of carrying large inventory (books aren't too fungible)

Much better than pets.com selling cat and dog food.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by creer on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:44PM (#38756153)
Why should the rest of us subsidize your tax addiction? This reasoning goes both ways. And I'm not even arguing whether some tax is useful or not - in most cases buying from a foreign vendor means a far far higher overall tax rate - simply arguing whether to favor a path with more expensive middlemen or not.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by hrdwdmrbl on Saturday December 23, 2023 @12:02AM (#38741757)
Amazon does need the competition though
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by sudosysgen on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:43PM (#38741432)
I doubt that CBP spending 30+ minutes of bureaucracy and agent time to inspect, calculate the true value of, invoice and bill 100$ worth of items for 10$ worth of tariffs would be a net profit.
Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by mattas on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:52PM (#38741465)
Anecdotally (there's probably the actual figure out there somewhere), less than 1% of all imported goods are flagged for a customs inspection. Duty is calculated and paid electronically by a licensed customs broker prior to the goods entering the country.

Type 86 filings are still necessary for di minimis shipments, so there isn't a material bureaucracy savings.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by sudosysgen on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:06PM (#38741535)
Yes, I agree. However, anecdotally again, I've never bought anything past the de minimis threshold from China that was actually labelled properly at the correct price - the likelihood of it getting flagged is low enough that it's worth just eating the loss in that case.

Given that, since it doesn't even make economic to inspect the packages even if you already knew they were mislabelled or misvalued, it's not clear to me that the taxpayer loses by increasing the de minimis threshold at least to a number where it would make sense. I'm thinking of the bureaucracy that the government incurs when they do decide to inspect and fine/confiscate, not the bureaucracy in the happy path, which as you've seen is very streamlined.

Re:Shein Forces Amazon to Lower Seller Fees by creer on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:49PM (#38756206)
Which is fine reasoning but rarely enters into the law or regulation. A lot of inspection power has to do with other "concerns" such as mislabelling (per se), trademark protection, counterfeits, forbidden items (for example radio bands), etc etc. "Economic sense" is long lost by then.