There might potentially be a problem if ETFs owned the entire market, but owning half the market cap still allows for market pricing of the other half. I don't see that you are pointing out a problem?
The market put a price on NKLA, and you are simply claiming that you know better than the market (to hell with the wisdom of crowds); such beliefs are generally unfounded. One example does not tell a convincing story, do you have a portfolio of disbelief that you have tracked the performance of?
Still, my point was that passive EFTs create a constant bid on company shares, disregarding any fundamentals. The speculative mania of 2021 artificially inflated the market cap of many SPACs like NKLA - speculators have all the rights to do this, but passive ETFs will blindly follow and increase their allocation based on market cap (the effect goes both ways, as price goes down allocation decreases). Who has been buying NKLA shares? Vanguard, for one: look at fund flows since 2021, mostly positive https://etfdb.com/etf/VTI/#fund-flows most of those inflows result in purchases of NKLA shares.
[1] https://www.acheroninsights.com/blog/wbdvi4uarbd3hdssx3f5kaf...
What money is flowing into this? Why is "Direxion Moonshot Innovators ETF" owned by anyone?
For moments like this, I suspect this fund will liquidate its position? But I'm sure the market for NKLA shares is not that hot...
[1] https://www.etf.com/stock/NKLA [2] https://www.direxion.com/product/moonshot-innovators-etf
> I hope you are able to provide more details on the machinations of these funds.
there are no machinations, it's mechanical, it's betting on expected value while diversifying risk/standard deviation.
Daily rebalancing is mechanical, and the criteria is coarse- but a decision was made and analysis is done.
Or do you think they yolo’d that criteria out in a vacuum?
It just isn’t micromanaging type analysis. Rather a ‘we think this chunk is worthwhile’ type analysis.
There are many different types of strategies that you’re talking about - momentum, ‘value’, etc. that all set various rules, and are applied in similar ways too.
The analysis I’m talking about isn’t that different, and is still analysis based on fundamentals. It’s just used a bit differently and intentionally trying to be coarse and relatively transparent/mechanical. Private funds keep it opaque and ‘secret sauce’, and have the freedom to do whatever (within the limits of their charter).
Other indexes have more in depth rules that cover exactly the other elements you’re discussing (sector specific indexes, ‘green’ indexes, ‘good governance’ indexes, etc.).
They still use the same analysis tools though.
This is incorrect. Not all ETFs. These funds are sector focused (vehicles). A regular S&P500 ETF will not hold NKLA.
Look: https://money.cnn.com/quote/shareholders/shareholders.html?s... Top ten holders are Vanguard, Blackrock, & the other usual providers of index ETFs.
This shows that the choice of stocks included in an index is not arbitrary. You don't get "better on average" automatically just by buying the 500 stocks on a list someone sold to you.
As passive accounts for more than half of the total market funds/flows, blatant frauds that somehow manage to be included in these funds have an easier time surviving (and the larger the market cap, the more inflows their shares receive). In the 2021 stock mania there were other factors at play too.