Re:Nikola founder to be sentenced for federal fraud charges
by zozbot234 on Monday December 18, 2023 @02:21PM
(#38686924)
The whole point of passive investing is to not pick winners and losers, to leave that part of the job to professional speculators (including, yes, short sellers). Because you aren't going to do any better than them on average, even if they do on occasion pick some duds (like Nikola).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Nikola founder to be sentenced for federal fraud charges
by hunter2_ on Monday December 18, 2023 @04:22PM
(#38688499)
Sure, but I'm talking about when the professionals that you leave it to end up being negligent. Picking a dud occasionally isn't negligent, but I'm wondering if continuing to hold something fraudulent longer than reasonably necessary to ingest damning evidence and dump it might be.
Re:Nikola founder to be sentenced for federal fraud charges
by balderdash on Monday December 18, 2023 @07:21PM
(#38690229)
This might be the case if you paid a professional manager to actively manage a portfolio - but not when you are paying the manager to track an index.
Re:Nikola founder to be sentenced for federal fraud charges
by bsdpufferfish on Monday December 18, 2023 @03:27PM
(#38687728)
Imagine you invested in the index minus Nikola. This isn't improbable as several hours of due diligence would have raised concerns.
This shows that the choice of stocks included in an index is not arbitrary. You don't get "better on average" automatically just by buying the 500 stocks on a list someone sold to you.
Re:Nikola founder to be sentenced for federal fraud charges
by sgerenser on Thursday December 21, 2023 @11:09AM
(#38722316)
The share of Nikola in a total-market index fund was so tiny as to be negligble. If one person invested $100K in a total market fund, and another put together thier own "total market minus nikola" fund, even with zero trading fees, the latter might be up maybe $10 or so over the former. After fees and slippage, they're almost certainly behind.