We might chat about all sorts of random things, but many times there's something that happened before, let's call it event X, that leads us to talk about a certain topic, say topic Y (like when you mention a cool shirt a friend just bought).
Then, if they see an ad about that later, folks jump to the conclusion that "Facebook was listening" to their chat. But what's more likely is that this topic was already trending among people like you, and that's why it popped up in your ads.
So, it's not that talking about it made it appear in your ads. It's more about a common event that sparked your conversation about it and also made it show up in your ads.
I told my mom i wanted a vacuum cleaner for christmas - guess what, facebook advertises to all your friends what you're shopping for. "lookalike audience" - to your point.
Simon does a great job highlighting why this doesn't make sense from the technical and business standpoints: https://simonwillison.net/2023/Dec/14/ai-trust-crisis/#faceb...
It's played out over and over again, especially with Facebook. They don't deserve the benefit of the doubt, even when "logically" the ROI for the company doesn't make sense. Facebook specifically can't be trusted at the executive level either; that culture trickles down.
You can’t use net profit as a yardstick of rationality in the corporate world, but especially Corporate America. People will seek revenue that results in negative returns on investment. There’s nothing rational about it, which is the problem.
They can increase revenue by making ethically terrible decisions. Full stop.
"We're not actually transcribing every word you hear and say, we're just using capabilities that the Stasi could only dream of at rates of speed they couldn't even conceive of, and it's just that these coincidences happen so often that it looks like we're transcribing your speech. Come on, be less paranoid."
If people think "they listen to me through the microphone" it distracts them from understanding what's actually happening - the whole sequence of things you listed there.
Which means they can't take measures to protect themselves, or campaign for better practices - because they're working off the wrong mental model of how this stuff works.
It's not a common event. They were totally random conversations. That's why I noticed that something is going on. I am not sure if they really listening on the microphone or what else they are doing but it's super creepy and should not happen.
But the whole „facebook listening to you” os absurd - on iOS you would see a system notification that the microphone is active, I assume on android as well. Also, it would take crazy amounts of bandwidth/battery/processing power to pull off.
It would also be trivially discoverable - a ton of people are listening to what apps are sending out, and even if encrypted, it would be noticeable by the outgoing traffic volume being high.
It is virtually impossible to pull off even today, as anyone who ever developed anything on mobile can tell you
The ELI5 version is that it can watch everything and then keep the bits that happen just before the person hits the button.
That’s how they can catch things that explode or do something and you aren’t sure when it will happen. Like popcorn popping.
Siri is basically doing the same thing.
Siri also misfires. And that data can be sent in.
What's funny about it is that counterclaims will often be that this information doesn't necessarily need to be coming from reading your chat messages. It could be that they just know you happened to be chatting to that person -- despite "metadata" supposedly not being personally identifiable information -- and then one or more parties started to look up on google the topic they were discussing. As if that's supposed to be less invasive.
Technology good enough is indistinguishable from magic.
What we need is basically GDPR except that consent can only be collected in the form of a signed and notarized contract.
The only solution I see is to make it illegal to use personal data. Especially make data brokers illegal. When you give a company access to your data, you often agree that they will pass the data to third parties who then pass it on and suddenly everybody has your data because you have permission to use your data.