News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by 1B05H1N on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:04PM (#38595548)
Sorry, why would I pay 20/year bucks for this when I have my own website/infra?
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by p4bl0 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:23PM (#38595678)
If you have your own infrastructure to host all of these services then you're probably not the target audience. It's ok, it's my case too.

But you have to admit that $20/year is quite cheap for all of what is provided here, without having to manage it all yourself, and with a "no trackers no bullshit" way of doing things.

It's really the kind of services I don't need but would almost like to need! The last time I had this feeling was about Neocities :).

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by crawsome on Sunday December 10, 2023 @09:12PM (#38596916)
Github pages is free. A .info domain is $5/year.

That's already more than half the features you get with this, and you get to be on the actual internet, not some dude's silo.

As the post's age goes on, I see more criticism, and less positive reactions.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by monkeywork on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:15PM (#38597589)
>That's already more than half the features you get with this, and you get to be on the actual internet, not some dude's silo.

"the actual internet" ??

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by sedatk on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:24AM (#38598659)
> "the actual internet" ??

Microsoft's silo, they mean.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by crawsome on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:59PM (#38609250)
Yes, the real internet where domain names don't cost $20, and where my stuff doesn't need to live on some dude's server.

It's just someone else trying to do what Zuckerberg failed at.

You're paying $20 to go a level-deeper into complexity on someone else's proprietary platform. It's not only going to fail, but it's a bad idea.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by voxic11 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:21AM (#38612406)
Yeah instead of paying this guy, people should instead rely on the charity of big corporations like microsoft. Github pages are free and surely will remain that way forever without any strings attached!
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by rfrey on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:45PM (#38597712)
How is hosting your website using a Microsoft silo more "on the internet" than using this?
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by slalomskiing on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:32PM (#38597658)
It’s just a fun project why are you taking it so serious
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by crawsome on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:34AM (#38600483)
It’s $20/mo, and a lot of people are eager to spend it so it should be subject to due criticism.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by ipodopt on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:40AM (#38601535)
It's $20 per year, not per month... and there are promo codes for $5/year available most of the time. I don't use the site but browsed the guy's mastodon feed.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by crawsome on Monday December 11, 2023 @11:01PM (#38609268)
I stand corrected, but ICANN names are cheaper.

Anyone can start their own omg.lol with a $10/yr domain name, and charge others for OSS and basic features you can find elsewhere for free. It's a scam to those who criticize it, and it's a privileged club to those who pay the money.

But the social circle is polluted with brains who think this is a good deal, so it's not the kind of network I'd even want to be on.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by erxam on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:23PM (#38595673)
Even without taking into account the time investment in maintaining your own infra, it compares favorably with everything else. Even the most dirt-cheap VPS is a few bucks more expensive on a yearly basis by itself, and you still have to buy domains and similar.

Running your own infra only really works out if you either have access to great hardware for super-cheap or WANT the experience from setting everything up.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by cipheredStones on Sunday December 10, 2023 @06:14PM (#38595980)
It consistently surprises me how much software engineers devalue the effort of software engineering when it comes to their personal lives.

If you're a SWE in an English-speaking country, you almost certainly make $20 post-tax for at most one hour of work - 30m at SV salaries, as little as 15m if you're at a FAANG-ish company. Is it conceivable that you would spend less than an hour a year maintaining something like this if you were to do it yourself? I don't think so.

Most people can't earn money in increments of one additional hour, of course, but it still sounds strange to hear people say "why should I spend [the amount of money I earn in half an hour] per year when I could just do it myself [with an amount of professional effort I would expect to be paid 20x as much for]?"

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by crims0n on Sunday December 10, 2023 @10:01PM (#38597168)
I get where you are coming from, but I think the answer for a lot of us is... for the experience.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by cipheredStones on Sunday December 10, 2023 @10:22PM (#38597298)
That's a perfectly valid motivation, but if it's really what someone is going for, I expect to hear an objection that sounds something like "oh, that's cool! but I'd rather try out doing it myself" rather than the faintly contemptuous "why is this worth $X when I could do it myself".
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by akho on Monday December 11, 2023 @02:56AM (#38598536)
> Is it conceivable that you would spend less than an hour a year maintaining something like this if you were to do it yourself? I don't think so.

Is it conceivable that that you would spend much more than an hour maintaining this? Including making your stuff fit the mold, working around the limitations, and, inevitably, moving your stuff to a new service when this one fails, as they do?

Also: a VPS replaces quite a few of these services. Maintenance beyond initial setup and occasional update is rarely needed if you are the only user. People tend to overestimate these things.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by uiberto on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:23AM (#38599604)
Didn't you know that everyone on HN bakes their own bread?
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by jodrellblank on Sunday December 10, 2023 @07:06PM (#38596289)
> "Even the most dirt-cheap VPS is a few bucks more expensive on a yearly basis by itself"

Not if you get a Black Friday special; here[1] was $14.95/year for 40GB SSD, 1GB RAM, 1TB monthly bandwidth, 1CPU core.

RackNerd were offering $10.28/year[2] for 10GB SSD storage, 768MB RAM.

Hudson Valley offered $8/year[3] for 10GB SSD and 512MB RAM

[1] https://lowendtalk.com/discussion/190984/from-14-95-yr-10-gb...

[2] https://lowendbox.com/best-cheap-vps-hosting-updated-2020/ (sold out)

[3] https://lowendbox.com/blog/are-you-serious-hudson-valley-hos...

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by tredre3 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @07:19PM (#38596361)
So to beat omg.lol's price you have to hunt for a bargain, then hope the price doesn't double in the following year?

Oh, and you also need to own a domain already, otherwise it's an extra 10-20 bucks per year.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by jodrellblank on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:52PM (#38597750)
No, you can get a free Unix account on sdf.org with web hosting and email if you want the kind of thing omg.lol does and don't want a VPS. It's just "Even the most dirt-cheap VPS is a few bucks more [than $20/year]" is outdated, they're available less than half that price. If budget is what you want or need, then "hunting" (visiting Lowendbox.com) is something you are likely willing to do.

I don't know omg.lol but if it only gives you a subdomain rather than a domain, so do free dynamic DNS providers like noip.com or formerly dyndns.org (not sure if they still do).

If you want to register a domain, you also have outdated pricing; .de is $4/year after the first year at Porkbun.com, .ovh is £2.99/year after the first year at OVH.com, internet people say .ru is available for $1/year.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by Cyberdog on Sunday December 10, 2023 @07:12PM (#38596318)
As with many other things, I'd advise against picking a VPS plan based on price alone.

I've found Vultr to be both affordable and of consistent quality for my modest needs (personal and business web hosting plus IRC bouncing). I pay about $5/mo or $60/year.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by jodrellblank on Monday December 11, 2023 @12:33AM (#38597948)
That's fine, but the complaint was that a VPS is "a few dollars more [than $20/year]" as if that was an objectionable amount/increase. In that case, money is the main decider and $60 is much worse, and $8 is much better. People fighting for "a few dollars" a year are likely to be expecting (or unhappily tolerate) lower quality.

I've had pretty good experiences of Linux VPSs for around $20/year from several companies.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by airstrike on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:09PM (#38595583)
So that you don't have to worry about outages, updates, bugfixes, certs, permissions, vulnerabilities, ... like you do on your own website/infra?
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by akho on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:00AM (#38598556)
It's the same infrastructure, with the same outages.

The other points are something for the developers of your software distribution to worry about, same as if you buy a packaged service.

Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by dsr_ on Sunday December 10, 2023 @06:02PM (#38595906)
You are not the target audience.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by james_pm on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:07PM (#38595571)
I happily pay $20/year so I don't need to worry about it. Not everyone can or wants to run their own infra.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by zeekaran on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:46AM (#38601598)
If I have to spend even one hour per year maintaining my own, this service is cheaper.
Re:Omg.lol: An Oasis on the Internet by dannyw on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:18AM (#38625212)
How much did you spend on your last lunch?

Why did you pay 5x the price of ingredients?