News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by paxys on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:04PM (#38449831)
An entire breed of online contests is going to have its chess moment soon. It doesn't matter how pointless cheating is in any context, people are still going to do it, and at some point spending the time and effort in building tooling and enforcement for it just isn't worth it.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by jacobr1 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:55PM (#38450373)
Increasingly I think the answer to things like this is different divisions. Have an AI-supported leaderboard, have a Cyborg/Pharmacist Olympics, provide roughly equal venues so that people self-bifurcate. You won't stop all cheating in the non-augmented divisions, but you greatly reduce the incentives by providing alternative outlets. You also getting much better data to identify what augmented activity looks like (since it is done the open) to stop a lot of the cheating if it occurs.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by andrewla on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:20PM (#38450728)
How does that reduce the incentives? Better to win a human-only division by cheating than to win the augmented division by playing legitimately. "Better" being a kind of sociopathic view of it, but certainly a player who wins a human-only division gets more social cachet than someone who places 300th in the augmented division, so long as people believe that the human-only division is actually human.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by criddell on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:16PM (#38449978)
Isn't the easy solution to get rid of the leaderboard? Ungamify it.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by paxys on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:41PM (#38450204)
A large chunk of people are only doing it because of the gamification.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by criddell on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:10PM (#38450570)
When you say "doing it" you could be referring to the Advent of Code or cheating with AI. Both are true.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by neptudemon on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:12PM (#38450597)
We don't need to cater to them, though
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by dymk on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:17PM (#38449997)
But games are fun when people play by the rules
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by tshaddox on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:26PM (#38450068)
If the rules are inherently difficult to enforce, that's a fundamental problem with the design of the game. If the rules are reasonably enforceable, but a particular administering body doesn't competently enforce them, that's a problem with that administering body.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by dymk on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @04:04PM (#38451298)
Rules being difficult to enforce is a function of society being low or high trust. Low trust societies effectively incur excess overhead, having to audit players and set up draconian rules. Some games just might not be possible. It's more pleasant and efficient for everybody to live in a high-trust society.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by tshaddox on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @08:37PM (#38454324)
There may be some independent “level of trust” in a given group of people that could be quantified, but I don’t think it’s a very powerful explainer of which games do or don’t work. Very minor rule changes can cause a huge change in the difficulty of enforcing other rules.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by jimbokun on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:44PM (#38450245)
But enough people will not play by the rules to make it pointless.

Maybe they could have leaderboards for smaller groups that you arrange with your friends and colleagues that you trust.

Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by dymk on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @04:05PM (#38451311)
Setting up the game so it's only played in a high-trust environment is probably the only fix
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by mcphage on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @09:55PM (#38468873)
> Maybe they could have leaderboards for smaller groups that you arrange with your friends and colleagues that you trust.

Which Advent of Code has.

Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by JohnFen on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @05:24PM (#38452269)
This seems like the obvious answer to me, but I am one who thinks the gamification of everything has been a bad thing.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by gerikson on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:14PM (#38449952)
AoC has always been easy to cheat at. After the first 100 correct answers have been submitted, the solutions thread on the subreddit is opened and anyone can copy and paste a solution.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by Barrin92 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:37PM (#38450169)
also the top 100 leaderboard people are so fast, for a lot of the days where the questions are easy enough for chatgpt to substantially help, the best people are literally done below 1 minute.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by dylan604 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:13PM (#38449934)
and then all of the people that don't cheat will get tired of the contests always being won by cheats and just stop. if these are paying users that stop paying, then you have to decide if the cost to slowing down the cheating costs more than the money from the users.

we'll just go back to old school raffle ticket contests.

Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by larrydag on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:16PM (#38449982)
Agree. Just create a leaderboard division that includes AI. Don't fight it. Embrace it
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by tuckerpo on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:32PM (#38450121)
Counterstrike and Quake have had "cheater" servers since their inception -- this doesn't stop people from cheating in non-cheat servers.
Re:Please don't use AI to get on the global leaderboard by dymk on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:17PM (#38449994)
That doesn't stop people from using AI to get on the "non-AI" division of leaderboard.