News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by wand3r on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:14PM (#38359125)
Leaving aside much of the other craziness: Who did the board expect would replace him? Did they expect to install Ilya and he bailed last minute? How could you possibly be calling around on a weekend trying to recruit a CEO? Everyone is knocking the board, so I am not going to break new ground here, but WHAT TF were they thinking? My only thought is maybe they expected they could dump sama and slot in another high level figure and they would work it out, but there was so much immediate blowback that they bailed?
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by divbzero on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:59PM (#38359483)
I think they planned for Mira Murati to act as interim CEO, but were surprised when she wanted to rehire Sam Altman.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by gjsman-1000 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:17AM (#38359631)
I think the board was surprised when nobody bought their claim of Sam’s vague wrongdoing.

Actually, I think every plot twist we’ve seen has been a surprise for them as they have consistently acted without 5 minutes of foresight.

And not just with the drama. For example, according to Stratechery, the clause in the contract saying Microsoft couldn’t use GPT-4 as a foundation for their own models was recently removed in a contract revision. If you don’t like your CEO, and Microsoft likes your CEO, and Microsoft has the rights to your models and code, it doesn’t take much to add up 2 + 2 + 2 = 6.

Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by willvarfar on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:14AM (#38360030)
Hmm, that contract revision _would_ have been grounds for dismissing Sam, if only the board had known...?

The current story is that the board scrambled to find unconvincing grounds when explaining themselves to employees instead https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38356534

Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by eastbound on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:26AM (#38360474)
Well the board could have gone with “We fear a hostile takeover by Microsoft” if they really were afraid that Sam was doing that.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by konschubert on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:58AM (#38361148)
> Actually, I think every plot twist we’ve seen has been a surprise for them as they have consistently acted without 5 minutes of foresight.

Which is ironic considering how much they claim to be focused on long term risks :)

Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by user_named on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:50AM (#38359877)
I guess they weren't involved in the day to day enough to know that about the contract
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by siva7 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:39AM (#38360171)
That’s also not the job of a board
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by ubercore on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:49AM (#38361086)
In this case, with these stakes, I think it's in the board's purview to understand the implications of firing your CEO with no immediate replacement plan, and the current state of possibly the most important contract your company has would be relevant.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by cyanydeez on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @05:39PM (#38371494)
eh, I'm pretty sure there was wrong doing the difference is entirely whether you're on the profit side or the nonprofit side.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by guappa on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:39AM (#38364213)
I like how she has a wikipedia page that is 1 week old.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by lordnacho on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:12AM (#38360399)
One perspective that one often hears, but nobody seems to have brought up here, is that the role of the board is essentially a kind of joke that doesn't really do what it says on the tin. A bunch of friends of the management, given a lot of money for very little work.

People here have even pointed out how unqualified they think the board members are, or how they have conflicts of interest.

Picture yourself in this world where you essentially get free money for pretending to advise a company. Most of the time, you don't need to do shit. Other people have got you covered, the company does some well known widget-making business and everyone has known since business school how the business works. You just nod your head when there's a board meeting and otherwise try to keep a good handicap at the country club. When there's a decision to be made, you feel out which side will win and hedge your bets. You've get several of these board jobs, and each of them thinks the other memberships are why they are hiring you.

One day, your friend invites you to be on the board of a company that does something truly new and interesting. In fact some people say this is the modern day Manhattan project, taking humanity into a new yet potentially dangerous age. It's prestigious, and you think how different can it really be to any other business?

As time passes, you realize your strategy of just doing whatever the other board members are doing is not going to work. There is this really big question of what you should do about keeping things "safe", a vague idea that you've heard of from some prominent employees. It dawns upon you that you might actually have to think about what to do.

Eventually, you crap yourself, and you decide to use some of the formal powers of the board. You saw on Silicon Valley that the board can depose the CEO, maybe that should be done? You know a bunch of people who have talked about AI in the past, perhaps one of them has a clue about what to do?

Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by wand3r on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:54AM (#38360691)
I totally agree in general but usually early stage tech companies have decent boards. Usually because it is investors representing their interests. Also, in a nascent tech sector you usually have at least the appearance of strong reputation, like Theranos for example. That said, if we look at OpenAI like the non-profit it was founded to be, those are exactly as you describe, a fun way to boost reputation for rich people and dole out some cash to connections. Also, Sam and Greg were cut out of the board, they were likely the true boardroom know how.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by vasco on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:26AM (#38360475)
How many board meetings have you attended, in any capacity?
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by lordnacho on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:13AM (#38360822)
Several but not many, as a board member. None of the boards I was on had frequent meetings. But also I was always on the "working" side of the board.

My impression of the external side is somewhat similar to the view I'm presenting above. It's not that they are completely unqualified to comment on the company, they actually had tangentially relevant experience. But what did they really add, other than making our webpage look better? And if things went wrong, what would they really lose? They are just curious folks who are excited to be around business, and can introduce us to interested parties.

The other thing the board is supposed to do is pull the emergency break if stuff goes wrong. It's hard to know how closely they monitored that sort of thing, given it doesn't happen that much. Also if things get bad, do they jump ship or act like what a bystander might in a car accident, ie try to call emergency services but not stick their head in the fire? Because the rest of us have our heads in the fire.

Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by vasco on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @05:35AM (#38361867)
Thanks, never had the chance and it helps qualify your opinions vs an outsider.
Re:Former GitHub CEO Friedman and Scale AI CEO Wang Declined... by the_gipsy on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:33AM (#38360514)
I love this take!