News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by dschuetz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:38AM (#38316603)
Are those the first cracks in the AI market bubble?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by huytersd on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:43AM (#38316623)
Is it a bubble if it’s useful and I use it dozens of time a day?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by dschuetz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:46AM (#38316643)
I agree AI is useful, but not to that extent to what it is valued on the market. I do not think that AI companies can deliver as much as they promise. With the driving core at OpenAI basically gone, I bet they will soon implode under the weight of their promises. Which means, investors will start pulling out their stakes. boom
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:04AM (#38316776)
Speaking for my own n of 1, ChatGPT Pro has almost entirely (>90%) replaced the Google search engine in my daily life. The results from ChatGPT are just so much better and faster.

That's got to be worth something, since Alphabet is a $1.7T company mostly on the strength of ads associated with Google search.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:12AM (#38316830)
Chat gpt is not a good source of truth so can’t be used for information retrieval at scale. You might have a specific usage pattern that is very different to the majority of Google Search users so it works for you
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by cryptoz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:23AM (#38316902)
Searching Google is not a good source of truth either; especially their infoboxes which have been infamously and dangerously wrong. And if you follow a random search result link - well, who knows if the content on that site is trustworthy either!
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:34AM (#38316981)
But you’re in control of your information retrieval, you didn’t have an unreliable agent synthesise bits in the middle.

Again - to each their own. But what people use google for GPT doesn’t replicate anyway (and what the Google business was built on) - which is commercial info retrieval.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:06PM (#38322431)
As of a recent update, ChatGPT can do an internet search to answer "find a Thai restaurant near me." Of course, it uses Bing, not Google.

And for my single query above, ChatGPT searched multiple sources, aggregated the results, and offered a summary and recommendations, which is a lot more than Google would have done.

ChatGPT's major current limitation is that it just refuses to answer certain questions [what is the email address for person.name?] or gets very woke with some other answers.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Racing0461 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:30AM (#38316950)
the ad ridden shitware website filled with seo buzzwords with 100% opacity keywords also isn't a good source of truth. i'll take chatgpt over that.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:33AM (#38316969)
Sure, use a different search engine then.

To each their own.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by taberiand on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:45AM (#38317049)
Personally, I don't have use case for comparing Google and ChatGPT that has truth as a requirement in the output.

For the majority of my use of ChatGPT and Google, I need to be able to get useful answers to vague questions - answers that I can confirm for myself through other means - and I need to iterate on those questions to hone in on the problem at hand. ChatGPT is undoubtedly superior to Google in that regard.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:16AM (#38317275)
Agreed, but this will probably be limited to domains where there’s better products
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:05AM (#38317200)
Google is not a good source of truth at all, for anything other than hard facts. And nowadays, even the concept of "hard fact" is getting a bit fuzzy.

Google search reminds me of Amazon reviews. Years ago, basically trustworthy, very helpful. Now ... take them with a tablespoon of salt and another of MSG.

And this is separate from the time-efficiency issue: "how quickly can I answer my complex question which requires several logical joins?", which is where ChatGPT really shines.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by jay_kyburz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:41AM (#38317027)
For the past week or so I have been typing my search queries into Open AI, Bard and Duck Duck Go to compare them.

I haven't finished making up my mind, the the AI's are doing OK. I have only been asking it for code snippets that are easily verifiable.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by beshur on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:36AM (#38316990)
Google ads span much more farther than in search - it's all over internet, on all websites, mobile etc.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by repomies69 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:34AM (#38316978)
I used it in the beginning, but now I am back to google... I don't think the results were better with ChatGPT.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by jliptzin on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:06AM (#38317212)
Google doesn’t care if you’re going elsewhere to ask deep questions about Rust or whatever. They care way more that people go to them to look for the best bread mixer, or find a good restaurant, or a local massage therapist. In that regard I think Amazon is still a much bigger threat to them.

GPT is very useful as a knowledge tool, but I don’t see people going there to make purchasing decisions. It replaces stackoverflow and quora, not Google. For shopping, I need to see the top X raw results, with reviews, so I can come to my own conclusion. Many people even find shopping fun (I don’t) and wouldn’t want to replace the experience with a chatbot even if it were somehow objectively better.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by konschubert on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:33AM (#38317395)
Yea. No.

People stopping to use google for the small stuff will be the beginning of the end of google being the mental default for searches.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by jliptzin on Saturday November 18, 2023 @05:01AM (#38317586)
There is a wide variety of services available to people for specific use cases. When stack overflow came along, I used that for programming questions instead of google. But I still use google for most other searches.

I go to Amazon if I want to find a book or a specific product.

For the latest news, I come here, or Reddit, or sometimes twitter.

If I want to look up information about a famous person or topic, I go to Wikipedia (usually via google search). I know I can ask ChatGPT, but Wikipedia is generally more up to date, well-written and highly scrutinized by humans.

The jury’s still out on exactly what role ChatGPT will serve in the long term, but we’ve seen this kind of unbundling many times before and Google is still just as popular and useful as ever.

It seems like GPT’s killer app is helping guide your learning of a new topic, like having a personal tutor. I don’t see that replacing all aspects of a general purpose search engine though.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:48PM (#38322970)
Your last paragraph - yes! Many people haven't realized this yet.

She/he/it/them is an amazing programming tutor.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:12AM (#38317250)
Fair enough. My questions are more likely to be about Fast.ai, but I get your point.

Did you see the recent article about a restaurant changing its name to "Thai Food near me"?

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by ssnistfajen on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:01AM (#38316754)
Even if OpenAI implodes it will hardly impact other LLM-focused startups. In fact it would probably be a boon for them as people search for GPT alternatives.

Sam & Greg could start a new AI company by Monday and instantly achieve unicorn valuation. Hardly a burst.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by JCharante on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:44AM (#38317038)
Honestly this is exciting. Are they going to be the first company to achieve a $1 Billion evaluation within 3 days? Would they file the incorporation papers on Monday meaning they get that valuation within 24 hours?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Rastonbury on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:43AM (#38317478)
This is almost certain to happen if they can snag the talent, I bet his phone is blowing up with VCs right now, revenge move and now unshackled from a non-profit nature of OpenAI
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by gdiamos on Saturday November 18, 2023 @05:08AM (#38317636)
Where are they going to get the compute or the data?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by romeros on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:52AM (#38316694)
What's the use of a newborn baby?

AI is as real as the mobile/internet/pc revolution of the past.

So many use it obsessively every single day.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by lazystar on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:56AM (#38316724)
"This is good for bitcoin."
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by uh_uh on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:18AM (#38316873)
> I agree AI is useful, but not to that extent to what it is valued on the market.

I agree, it's greatly undervalued!

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by corethree on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:53AM (#38316696)
I paid the 20 dollar subscription. I don't even subscribe to netflix.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by treyfitty on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:46AM (#38316647)
Was the housing market a bubble if millions of people lived in it and spent 75% of their time in it?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by smsm42 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:34AM (#38316980)
Could be. Housing bubble happened even though most people lived in houses and still do. It's all in price vs utility. If the former gets way ahead of the latter, and people start trading just on future price raises, you've got a bubble.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by manojlds on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:46AM (#38316644)
Dotcom bubble...was/is the internet not useful?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by huytersd on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:53AM (#38316699)
It doesn’t feel the same since there are a handful of players in the space. I see your point though.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by saltmanfried on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:40AM (#38317014)
Calling chatbots AI is definitely a bubble
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by cheriot on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:56AM (#38316723)
Yes, a bubble is a mismatch between price and value. Saying value > 0 is not disproving a bubble.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by jsemrau on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:11AM (#38316820)
Is Mistral really a 2 Billion business after only 6 months? https://www.ft.com/content/387eeeab-1f95-4e3b-9217-6f69aeeb5...
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by mongol on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:57AM (#38316731)
It is a bubble if it is overvalued. I don't think it is, but nothing prevents something useful from being a bubble, if the valuation is extreme.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by mi3law on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:46AM (#38316648)
It can be useful in certain contexts, most certainly as a code co-pilot, but that and yours/others' usage doesn't change the fundamental mismatch between the limits of this tech and what Sam and others have hyped it up to do.

We've already trained it on all the data there is, it's not going to get "smarter" and it'll always lack true subjective understanding, so the overhype has been real, indeed to bubble levels as per OP.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by tempestn on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:51AM (#38316681)
> it's not going to get "smarter" and it'll always lack true subjective understanding

What is your basis for those claims? Especially the first one; I would think it's obvious that it will get smarter; the only questions are how much and how quickly. As far as subjective understanding, we're getting into the nature of consciousness territory, but if it can perform the same tasks, it doesn't really impact the value.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by mi3law on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:02AM (#38317176)
My basis for these claims is from my research career, work described so far at aolabs.ai; still very much in progress, but form what I've learned I can respond to the 2 claims you're poking at--

1) we should agree on what we mean by smart or intelligent. That's really hard to do so let's narrow it down to "does not hallucinate" the way GPT does, or more high level has a subjective understanding of its own that another agent can reliably come to trust. I can tell you that AI/deep learning/LLM hallucination is a technically unsolvable problem, so it'll never get "smarter" in that way.

2) This connects to number 2. Humans and animals of course aren't infinitely "smart;" we fuck up and hallucinate in ways of our own, but that's just it, we have a grounded truth of our own, born of a body and emotional experience that grounds our rational experience, or the consciousness you talk about.

So my claim is really one claim, that AI cannot perform the same tasks or "true" intelligence level of a human in the sense of not hallucinating like GPT without having a subjective experience of its own.

There is no answer or understanding "out there;" it's all what we experience and come to understand.

This is my favorite topic. I have much more to share on it including working code, though at a level of an extremely simple organism (thinking we can skip to human level and even jump exponentially beyond that is what I'm calling out as BS).

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by calf on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:38AM (#38317438)
Then why can't the the grounded truth of ChatGPT be born of a body of silicon and emotional experience of zillions of lines of linguistic corpus?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by mi3law on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:25AM (#38318225)
Those zillions of lines are given to ChatGPT in the form of weights and biases through backprop during pre-training. The data does not map to any experience of ChatGPT itself, so it's performance involves associations between data, not associations between data and its own experience of that data.

Compare ChatGPT to a dog-- a dog's experience of an audible "sit" command maps to that particular dog's history of experience, manipulated through pain or pleasure (i.e. if you associate treat + "sit", you'll have a dog with its own grounded definition of sit). A human also learns words like "sit," and we always have our own understanding of those words, even if we can agree on them together too certain degrees in lines of linguistic corpora. In fact, the linguistic corpora is borne out of our experiences, our individual understandings, and that's a one way arrow, so something trained purely on that resultant data is always an abstraction level away from experience, and therefore from true grounded understanding or truth. Hence GPT (and all deep learning) unsolvable hallucination or grounding problems.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by calf on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:17AM (#38318665)
But I'm not seeing an explicit reason why experience is needed for intelligence. You're repeating this point over and over again but not actually explaining why, you're just assuming that it's a kind of given.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Paul-Craft on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:32AM (#38318819)
I don't see why "does not hallucinate" is a viable definition for "intelligent." Humans hallucinate, both literally, and in the sense of confabulating the same way that LLMs do. Are humans not intelligent?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by svnt on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:53AM (#38316698)
I would appreciate another example where a major new communications technology peaks in its implementation within the first year after it is introduced to the market.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by mi3law on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:50AM (#38317081)
FTX / crypto, which just imploded last year.

Look, I'm an AGI/AI researcher myself. I believe and bleed this stuff. AI is here to stay and is forever a part of computing in many ways. Sam Altman and others bastardized it by overhyping it to current levels, derailing real work. All the traction OpenAI has accumulated, outside of github copoilot / codex, is itself so far away from product-market fit that people are playing off the novelty of AGI / the GPT/AI being on its way to "smarter" than human rather than any real usage.

Hype in tech is real. Overhype and bubbles are real. In AI in particular, there's been AI winters because of the overhype.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by svnt on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:13PM (#38324515)
It seems we are talking about multiple different things. I never denied hype was a thing.

You’re talking about hype cycles now. Previously it seemed like you said AI was not going to be advancing.

LLMs are maybe headed into oversold territory, but LLMs are not the end of AI, even in the near term. They are just the UI front end.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by KaiserPro on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:11AM (#38317244)
> major new communications technology peaks in its implementation within the first year after it is introduced to the market.

Peak is perhaps the wrong word, local maximum before falling into the Trough of Disillusionment.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by onion2k on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:00AM (#38317157)
There have been bubbles in the housing market in the past - houses are quite useful.

It's a bubble if the valuation is inflated beyond a level compared to a reasonable expected future value. Usefulness isn't part of that. The important bit is 'reasonable', which is also the subjective bit.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by miohtama on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:23AM (#38317333)
Electric cars are useful as well, but still, most electric car startups are -90% down from the peak. A financial bubble does not mean the underlying product is bad.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Sharlin on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:36AM (#38318319)
If the compute is paid with imaginary hype money? Doesn’t matter how useful a service is if providing it turns out to be unsustainable.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Tohhou on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:55AM (#38316714)
You must not use AI if you think this. AI is not the bubble. Everything AI will replace is the bubble.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by clauderoux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:15AM (#38316847)
AI today is in a weird position. What I can do today with AI was _inimaginable_ just 1 year ago. However, for a lot of people, the concept has worn out so fast, that they don't realize anymore what has happened... Some very intelligent people said some very silly things, such as that it was a bad search engine (it isn't a search engine) that it was a glorified word guesser (it doesn't exactly work as your telephone word suggestion). And so on and so forth. People always try to understand new technology through the lense of older technology. I do it, you certainly do it. This is how we grasp novelty. But AI is in a different dimension. I have been working in the domain for 30 years and I really didn't think we would reach this level in my life time. Talking to a computer to bring it to make some quite complicated task is INCREDIBLE... However, since communication is really ubiquitous for Humans, we tend to forget that it is an incredible achievement... In less than a year, we went for Scify ("Her") to reality, and in less than a year people have become blasé for something so fantastic... This is what consummerism did to people... They can't wonder more than a year...
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by ncruces on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:52AM (#38317096)
It's a wonder. But if capex and opex are insane, and go up with every generation, the magic fades quickly.

Like, GitHub Copilot may be amazing, but if it looses money for every added user, if power users loose the company 4 or 8 times what they already pay, then maybe it's not an efficient use of compute resources.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by code_biologist on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:08AM (#38317227)
Yes, this. What made tech companies valued at higher revenue multiples than other industries is that new users could start using a product at near zero marginal cost once the tech was built. New revenue at zero marginal cost. AI is great but expensive to operate and the expense grows in direct proportion to usage. New users come in and you have to stand up a new data center full of H100s to serve it.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by calf on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:43AM (#38317475)
> Talking to a computer to bring it to make some quite complicated task is INCREDIBLE...

Are there any good examples of this? I struggle to use ChatGPT, maybe I'm using it not cleverly (or deeply) enough.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by clauderoux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:18AM (#38318169)
Recently I had to share a documentation written in Word, which I had to format in Markdown to put it on Github. I transformed my document into a text file for each chapter and then I asked chatGPT to transform each of these files into a Markdown page. And I also asked it to improve the English. Then I asked chatGPT to translate each of these files into different languages. The result is here: https://github.com/naver/tamgu/tree/master/documentations Basically, I did in a couple of hours, something that would have taken weeks of tedious work
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by calf on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:21AM (#38318713)
OK then that's tedious work, not complex work.

I know that lots of people have personal stories of using ChatGPT but I was hoping something publicly reported on or like a showcase of truly impressive usages somewhere.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by clauderoux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:19AM (#38320510)
You are kidding right. Taking a raw text file and detecting every single header, sub-headers, keywords and pieces of code to add the right markdown tags is a simple task to you?

Have you ever tried to make a Python program to do exactly that?

I only used couple of sentences to build my prompt...

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by calf on Saturday November 18, 2023 @05:25PM (#38325284)
No, what is the computational complexity of the task? The computational complexity of the problem is not about how long your code is or how long you took to write it.

I don't know your CS background but perhaps I do not view the terms "complex" and "tedious" the way you assume. A tedious parser is certainly tedious to write, but it is not (necessarily) complex. And from an engineering standpoint it is questionable that you lost all the formatting information from Word, which would have already demarcated what things were headers, code, and so forth. So, you had to use a roundabout way—an LLM—to recover that information from the semantics.

If what you're really arguing is that ChatGPT works well for language translation tesks, in this case translating mixed prose, code, and foreign languages--sure I guess that's great at productivity and removing tedium, but it's not that surprising a usage given what LLMs are. They are language translators.

In other words you're saying it's complex but your argument reduces a task that is straightforward but tedious for humans, to the problem complexity of natural language processing.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by lazystar on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:02AM (#38316758)
AI art is already boring. its all a fad, eventually the cracks start to show and you can't unsee those cracks. very similar to bitcoin. tbh.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by eurekin on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:22AM (#38316898)
The interesting to boring scale depends on novelty. Given the ai oversaturation it works exactly as expected.

AI Art is currently in very early stage. In the real art space (3d modeling, sculpting, animation, vfx, animation, rigging, retargeting), it could make huge breakthroughs and multiply true artists' productivity in significant ways

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by nottorp on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:00AM (#38317153)
I've noticed that those who worship productivity tend to appreciate "content creators" not artists :)
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by eurekin on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:48AM (#38317500)
During my brief venture into 3d graphics I often found that 1 hour of truly creating is spaced between ten hours of fixing up UV's, redoing topology, finding cause for the seam, trying to make a watertight mesh for photon tracing, fighting the subdivision algorithm to retain details, diverting a edge loop, where it causes the less distress.

I call the first hour true productivity. The last part is, from the perspective of the end product, simply a wasted time. That's very similar to the boilerplate code everybody agrees is a necessary evil in the programming.

If AI allows to reduce the #2 it truly will have positive impact

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by nottorp on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:39AM (#38318883)
It's interesting how some terms we use reveal our world view. What does referring to art as "product" imply?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Tohhou on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:07AM (#38316797)
You're one of the ones who used to call bitcoin "buttcoin" didn't you? Very sure of yourself, very wrong.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by 9dev on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:39AM (#38317012)
Oh, you mean because Bitcoin didn’t turn out as a stupidly-high risk speculation object without any value rooted in reality, wasting a sizeable portion of the power production of a world threatened by the climate crisis, swinging between orders of magnitude in valuation on Elon‘s whims? The Bitcoin that is irrelevant everywhere else but the crypto bubble itself?
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by carstenhag on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:19AM (#38316875)
Seeing btc is still quite useless apart from a few legitimate reasons, otherwise mostly being used for illegal purposes: yes, btc is a failure.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by lazystar on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:20AM (#38316882)
after i lost everything in the mtgox scandal, i used my last bitcoin to buy a lenovo thinkpad, which i used to learn computer programming and network engineering.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by smcl on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:41AM (#38317453)
Come on man, we're all on the AI hype train now. Get with the program, you're one bubble behind!
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by CamperBob2 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:17PM (#38323911)
"This radio thing is a dead end. I usually just get a bunch of static when I turn it on, or maybe an electrical shock. And even if it works, it's only a question of whether a tube burns out before the battery dies." - lazystar's grandpa, circa 1923
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by lazystar on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:21PM (#38325952)
as i mentioned earlier, i was one of the first generation of bitcoin users. the problems with it have yet to be fixed.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @11:14AM (#38333986)
This isn't bitcoin.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by throw_m239339 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:19AM (#38316879)
I think something terrible happened at OpenAI and we just don't know what it is yet, we will eventually. But I believe something unethical happened, something that might be even illegal. For the board to deposite the CEO, it means that the board doesn't trust him anymore.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by seydor on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:06AM (#38317207)
$MSFT might be down but all others are probably going to be up