News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:12AM (#38316830)
Chat gpt is not a good source of truth so can’t be used for information retrieval at scale. You might have a specific usage pattern that is very different to the majority of Google Search users so it works for you
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by cryptoz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:23AM (#38316902)
Searching Google is not a good source of truth either; especially their infoboxes which have been infamously and dangerously wrong. And if you follow a random search result link - well, who knows if the content on that site is trustworthy either!
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:34AM (#38316981)
But you’re in control of your information retrieval, you didn’t have an unreliable agent synthesise bits in the middle.

Again - to each their own. But what people use google for GPT doesn’t replicate anyway (and what the Google business was built on) - which is commercial info retrieval.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:06PM (#38322431)
As of a recent update, ChatGPT can do an internet search to answer "find a Thai restaurant near me." Of course, it uses Bing, not Google.

And for my single query above, ChatGPT searched multiple sources, aggregated the results, and offered a summary and recommendations, which is a lot more than Google would have done.

ChatGPT's major current limitation is that it just refuses to answer certain questions [what is the email address for person.name?] or gets very woke with some other answers.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Racing0461 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:30AM (#38316950)
the ad ridden shitware website filled with seo buzzwords with 100% opacity keywords also isn't a good source of truth. i'll take chatgpt over that.
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:33AM (#38316969)
Sure, use a different search engine then.

To each their own.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by taberiand on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:45AM (#38317049)
Personally, I don't have use case for comparing Google and ChatGPT that has truth as a requirement in the output.

For the majority of my use of ChatGPT and Google, I need to be able to get useful answers to vague questions - answers that I can confirm for myself through other means - and I need to iterate on those questions to hone in on the problem at hand. ChatGPT is undoubtedly superior to Google in that regard.

Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by Mentlo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:16AM (#38317275)
Agreed, but this will probably be limited to domains where there’s better products
Re:Three senior researchers have resigned from OpenAI by hilux on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:05AM (#38317200)
Google is not a good source of truth at all, for anything other than hard facts. And nowadays, even the concept of "hard fact" is getting a bit fuzzy.

Google search reminds me of Amazon reviews. Years ago, basically trustworthy, very helpful. Now ... take them with a tablespoon of salt and another of MSG.

And this is separate from the time-efficiency issue: "how quickly can I answer my complex question which requires several logical joins?", which is where ChatGPT really shines.