News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by peyton on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:09PM (#38314527)
Very unprofessional way to approach this disagreement.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by mochomocha on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:27PM (#38314700)
If you know anything about Ilya, it's definitely not out of character.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by peyton on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:44AM (#38316253)
Having read up on some background not sure I want this guy in charge of any kind of superintelligence.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by dragonwriter on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:10AM (#38316415)
Well, I definitely wouldn't want Altman in charge of any superintelligence, so "I'm not sure" would be an improvement, if I expected an imminent superintelligence.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:51AM (#38316686)
What if - hear me out - what if the firing is the doing of an AGI? Maybe OpenAI succeeded and now the AI is calling the shots (figuratively, though eventually maybe literally too).
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by ariym on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:56AM (#38316326)
what are you referring to
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by strikelaserclaw on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:13PM (#38314566)
When two people have different ideologies and neither is willing to backdown or compromise, one person must "go".
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by peyton on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:28PM (#38314708)
There’s no indication that any sort of discussion took place. Major stakeholders like Microsoft appear uninformed.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by strikelaserclaw on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:30PM (#38314724)
in a power struggle, you have to act quickly
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by fsckboy on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:37PM (#38314781)
I don't think it's that dramatic. In a board meeting, you have to act while the board is meeting. They don't meet every day, and it's a small rigamarole to pull a meeting together, so if you're meeting... vote.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by vanjajaja1 on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:52PM (#38314892)
are you suggesting they brought up a vote on a whim at a board meeting and acted on it same day
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by fsckboy on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:06PM (#38315000)
no, I was replying to a comment that said it was a power struggle in which the board needed to act quickly before they lost power.

The board may very well have met for this very reason, or perhaps it was at this meeting that the lack of candor was found or discussed, but to hold a board meeting there is overhead, and if the board is already in agreement at the meeting, they vote.

It only seems sudden to outsiders, and that suddenness does not mean a "night of the long knives".

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by lazide on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:49AM (#38315886)
How would the board have lost power?
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by fsckboy on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:10AM (#38317241)
that's what i'm saying, it was not a power struggle. I shouldn't have to make the other guy's argument for him...
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by dekhn on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:16PM (#38315087)
One imagines in this case the current board discussed this in a non-board context, scheduled a meeting without inviting the chair, made quorum, and voted, then wrote the PR and let Sam, Greg, and HR know, then released the PR. Which is pretty interesting in and of itself, maybe they were trying to sidestep roko or something
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by lsaferite on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:51PM (#38315403)
Not inviting the full board would likely be against the rules. Every company I've been part of has it in the bylaws that all members have to be invited. They don't all have to attend, but they all get invited.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by dekhn on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:46AM (#38315858)
sure. he could have been invited, but also not attended.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by vineyardmike on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:18PM (#38315098)
Basically half the point of this is that Microsoft isn’t a stakeholder. The board clearly doesn’t care or is actively hostile to the idea of growing “the business”. If they didn’t know then that they weren’t a stakeholder, they know now.

MS owns a non controlling share of a business controlled by a nonprofit. MS should have prepared for the possibility that their interests aren’t adequately represented. I’m guessing Altman is very persuasive and they were in a rush to make a deal.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by peyton on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:54AM (#38316311)
Microsoft is a stakeholder. It’s absurd to suggest otherwise. The entire stakeholder concept was invented to encompass a broader view on corporate governance than just the people in the boardroom.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by vineyardmike on Saturday November 18, 2023 @05:22AM (#38317755)
This is a non profit dedicated to researching AI with the goal of making a safe AGI. That’s what the mission is. Sama starts trying to make it a business, restructures it to allow investors, of which MSFT is a 49% owner. He gets ousted and they tell Microsoft afterwards.

It’s questionable how much power Microsoft has as a shareholder. Obviously they have a staked interest in OpenAI. What is up in question is how much interest the new leaders have in Microsoft.

If I had a business relationship with OpenAI that didn’t align with their mission I would be very worried.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by smoldesu on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:15PM (#38314584)
Or you introduce an authoritative third party that mediates their interactions. This feels like it wouldn't be a problem if so many high-ranking employees didn't feel so radically different about the same technology.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by oivey on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:28PM (#38314709)
Altman’s job was to be a go between for the business and engineering sides of the house. If the chief engineer who was driving the company wasn’t going to communicate with him anymore, then he wouldn’t serve much of a purpose.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by fsckboy on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:24PM (#38314677)
when did a board or CEO ever introduce an authoritative 3rd party to mediate between them? the board is the authoritative 3rd party.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by bushbaba on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:21PM (#38315120)
There's more graceful ways to do this though.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:53AM (#38316695)
You've summed AI X-risk in a single sentence.

(I.e. an AGI would be one of the two people here.)

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by anonymouskimmer on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:11PM (#38314549)
How so? It's just another firing and being escorted out the door.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by janejeon on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:16PM (#38314597)
The wording is very clearly hostile and aggressive, especially for a formal statement, and the wording, again, makes it very clear that they are burning all bridges with Sam Altman, and it is very clear that 1. it was done extremely suddenly, 2. with very little notice or discussion with any other stakeholder (e.g. Microsoft being completely blindsided, not even waiting 30 minutes for the stock market to close, doing this shortly before Thanksgiving break, etc).

You don't really see any of this in most professional settings.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by fsckboy on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:29PM (#38314715)
boards give reasons for transparency, and they said he had not been fully candid.

You are interpreting that as hostile and aggressive because you are reading into it what other boards have said in other disputes and whatever you are imagining, but if the board learned some things not from Altman that it felt they should have learned from Altman, less than candid is a completely neutral way to describe it, and voting him out is not an indication of hostility.

Would you like to propose some other candid wording the board could have chosen, a wording that does not lack candor?

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by janejeon on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:34PM (#38314760)
> You are interpreting that as hostile and aggressive because you are reading into it

Uhh no, I'm seeing it as hostile and aggressive because the actual verbiage was hostile and aggressive, doubly so in the context of this being a formal corporate statement. You can pass the text into NLP sentiment analyzer and it too will come to the same conclusion.

It is also very telling that you are being very sarcastic and demeaning in your remarks as well to someone who wasn't even replying to you, which might explain why you might have seen the PR statement differently.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by racketcon2089 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:57AM (#38316331)
When you look at the written word and find yourself consistently imputing clear intent which is hostile, aggressive, sarcastic, and demeaning which no one else but you sees, a thoughtful person would begin to introspect.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by janejeon on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:55AM (#38318476)
Again, I'm not sure why you and the other person are just out for blood and keep trying to make it personal, but you can clearly feed it into NLP/ChatGPT and co and even the machines will tell you the actual wordings are aggressive.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by jstarfish on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:40PM (#38322124)
I'll bite. I even led the witness on this one by outright asking if it's aggressive.

> "a deliberative review process by the board, which concluded that he was not consistently candid in his communications with the board, hindering its ability to exercise its responsibilities."

> The provided text is not explicitly aggressive; however, it conveys a critical tone regarding the individual's communication, emphasizing hindrance to the board's responsibilities.

Did you actually run this through GPT...or did you poll Reddit?

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by CamperBob2 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:10PM (#38323829)
Context matters. It's hyper aggressive by the standards of similar communications (press releases announcing management shakeups) by similar entities (boards of directors).

Obviously it's not aggressive by the standards of everyday political drama or Internet forum arguments.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by racketcon2089 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @03:41PM (#38337647)
A text being objectively measurable as aggressive is a very different supposition than a text being subjectively, contextually aggressive.

It's fair to say that usually if the board isn't obfuscating or outright lying in their announcements, that itself is an indicator of acrimony.

But usually, the board can financially incentivize a CEO to "step down" or even help them find a soft landing at another company to make it look like a mutually agreed on transition. Since they know this oustered CEO isn't interested in making nice in public, they really had no choice but to try to get in front of the story.

Given the fallout which is still spreading, I think they would've rather cut him a fat check for an explicit or implicit NDA and thanked him for his amazing contributions while wishing him well on his future endeavors if that option had been on the table.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by clnq on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:47PM (#38314859)
It is quite gauche for a company to burn bridges with their upper management. This bodes poorly for ever hoping to attract executives in the future. Even Bobby Kotick got a more graceful farewell from Activision Blizzard, where they tried to clear his name. It is only prudent business.

Certainly, this is very immature. It wouldn't be out of context in HBO's Succession.

Whether what happened is right or just in some sense is a different conversation. We could speculate on what is going on in the company and why, but the tactlessness is evident.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by ribosometronome on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:19PM (#38315106)
> Whether it's right or just in some sense is a different conversation.

The same conversation if it's "mature", surely? I'm failing to see how one thinks turning a blind eye to like, decades of sexual impropriety and major internal culture issues to the point the state takes action against your company is "mature". Like, under what definition?

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by clnq on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:41PM (#38315296)
[delayed]
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by watwut on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:02AM (#38317169)
> Mature, as in the opposite of ingenuous

To tell it in an exaggerated way, maturity should not imply sociopathy or completely disregard for everything.

Obviously I am referring here to Kottick situation. But, the definition where it is immature to tell the truth and mature to enable powerful bad players is wrong definition of maturity.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by clnq on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:18AM (#38318684)
I respect your belief that maturity involves elevating morality above corporate sagacity. It is noble.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by watwut on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:53AM (#38320276)
I am not even demanding something super noble from mature people. I am fine with the idea that mature people do compromises. I do not expect managers to be saint like fighters for justice.

But, when people use "maturity" as argument for why someone must be enabler, should not do the morally or ethically right thing, then it gets irritating. Conversely, calling people "immature" because they did not acted in the most self serving but sleazy way is ridiculous.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by ShamelessC on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:18PM (#38321862)
That comes across as pretty condescending. It's not like you have some sort of authoritative high ground about what does and doesn't constitute professionalism in the business world. It sounds to me that your version of professionalism is in line with what gets prescribed at your average mindless corporate human resources or public relations department. Which is fine, but there's zero proof that that is the correct way to do things, and it's actually naive on _your_ part to accept the status quo as is. And, as I said, incredibly condescending to assume it is somehow the "mature" point of view.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by ryandrake on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:48AM (#38316660)
People get fired all the time: suddenly, too. If I got fired by my company tomorrow, they wouldn't treat me with kid gloves, they'd just end my livelihood like it was nothing. I'd probably find out when I couldn't log in. Why should "upper management" get a graceful farewell? We don't have royalty in the USA. One person is not inherently better than another.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:20AM (#38318188)
Because upper management have more power than you or I. If either of us were fired, it's unlikely to be front page news all over the world.

It sucks, but that's the world we live in, unfortunately.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by clnq on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:28AM (#38318788)
> Why should "upper management" get a graceful farewell

Injustices are made to executives all the time. But airing dirty laundry is not sagacious.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by anonymouskimmer on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:56PM (#38322304)
All I saw was one phrase indicating there was cause for termination, with no additional explanation. This doesn't seem like airing dirty laundry to me.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by insanitybit on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:42AM (#38320738)
Because no one cares if you get fired but people really care if a CEO gets fired. The scope of a CEO's responsibilities are near-global across the company, firing them is a serious action. Your scope as an engineer is, typically, extremely small by comparison.

This isn't about being better at all.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by DonHopkins on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:23AM (#38316134)
>The wording is very clearly hostile and aggressive

At least we can be sure that ChatGPT didn't write the statement, then.

Otherwise the last paragraph would have equivocated that both sides have a point.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by jdminhbg on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:14PM (#38314576)
It's not "just another firing," the statement accused Altman of lying to the board. Either he did and it's a justified extraordinary firing, or he didn't and it's hugely unprofessional to insinuate he did.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by chasd00 on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:17PM (#38314604)
Oh man the lawyers have to be so happy I bet they can hardly count.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by anonymouskimmer on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:19PM (#38314625)
I read that word as not being forthcoming moreso than actively lying. But I don't read many firing press releases.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by adastra22 on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:56PM (#38314923)
Hugely unprofessional and a billion dollar liability.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by rdtsc on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:26PM (#38314689)
It was actually a great move. Unusual, but it goes with the mission and nonprofit idea. I think it was designed to draw attention and stir controversy on purpose.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by kcb on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:44PM (#38314829)
Is it a winning move though? The biggest loser in this seems to be the company that was bankrolling their endeavor, Microsoft.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by rdtsc on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:28AM (#38316539)
At this stage, no publicity is bad publicity. If they really believe they are in it to change the future of humanity, and the kool-aid got to their heads, might as well show it off by stirring some controversy.

Microsoft is bankrolling them but OpenAI probably can replace Microsoft easier than Microsoft can replace OpenAI.

Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by toyg on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:38PM (#38324107)
They don't need Microsoft anymore, they have a queue of potential funders.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by kcb on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:36PM (#38327972)
You think those funders will stick with their insistence on the direction of not creating products and making money.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by toyg on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:23AM (#38330065)
It's more about "making all the money" Vs "making some of the money", with that "some" still being pretty big. Maybe they won't get 100bn but will get 10bn just fine.
Re:Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing by hindsightbias on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:26AM (#38316527)
Not if the AGI was making the decision. A bit demanding to think the Professionalism LLM module isn't a bit hallucinatory in this age. Give it a few more years.