News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:20PM (#38294053)
No. Use Firefox and you will survive.

uBlock Origin works best in Firefox: https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by anonymousab on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:37PM (#38294318)
The nuclear option will eventually be to just banning Google accounts for using any ad blocking.

The question is whether that atmosphere would simply cause people to quit Google services vs. turn off Adblock altogether to continue using them. I would wager that the latter would be far more likely and common for the average person.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by mcronce on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:44PM (#38294412)
I agree with your intuition on the latter being more likely. And Google won't care about the minority of power users they lose. They've been outwardly hostile toward power users with Android for years.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by shiroiuma on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:22PM (#38298548)
Apple is even worse...
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by I_Am_Nous on Thursday November 16, 2023 @10:04PM (#38298939)
True, but getting an iPhone to tinker with is kind of like buying a book to rearrange the words into your own story. They crafted a beautiful walled garden for you, and the walls are a feature - which is definitely not for everyone.

That said, I have fond memories of installing Linux on my iPod Mini so I understand the joy of making devices do things they were never intended to do.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by xur17 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:49PM (#38294484)
> The nuclear option will eventually be to just ban Google accounts for using any ad blocking.

Or they just keep making it harder and harder to use alternative browsers that support ad blocking.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by Tommstein on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:55PM (#38298294)
> The nuclear option will eventually be to just ban Google accounts for using any ad blocking.

The collateral damage from that would probably lead to the mother and father of all class-action lawsuits, literal Acts of Congress, and EU fines that Google would have to get a second job in order to pay if they don't try to break them up outright.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by maxloh on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:53AM (#38302818)
IMO both will happen. People are going to continue using other Google services, but quit YouTube.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by dun44 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:15AM (#38303843)
That’s one reason why we need a YouTube archive that’s outside of Google’s control.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by Analemma_ on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:50PM (#38294498)
Firefox only survives because Google props it up. I don’t think Google can stop completely without incurring antitrust wrath, but they could probably start attaching strings and conditions to the funding.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:01PM (#38294667)
So you're saying the more users Firefox has, the stronger Mozilla's bargaining position.

You make a good case to use Firefox.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:53PM (#38295346)
Alternatively, the more users Firefox has, the more incentive Google has to twist Mozilla's arm. I doubt that ultimately defeats forks that are maintained by volunteers (https://librewolf.net/), and I don't want to discourage Firefox adoption, but it's not quite so cut-and-dry as "use Firefox". There will likely come a time that it's "use this community fork of old-Firefox-before-it-got-Googled".

Still not a case against Firefox; just pointing out there's more to the picture.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by leotravis10 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @04:34PM (#38295879)
In other words, if Firefox becomes popular enough, there's a chance that Google will deliver a nail to Mozilla's coffin in pulling their search deal and other funding which is the backbone of their business in a financial level.

Another example is that Mozilla has a LOT to lose if the DOJ wins in the US v. Google antitrust trial just for those deals.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by toyg on Friday November 17, 2023 @05:08AM (#38301583)
In the past, when FF was stronger, they took search deals with other engines (yahoo, bing). If their numbers go back up, it could be a viable strategy again.

Maybe I'm old, but doing the right thing on the internet has always been harder than just going with the flow. Using Linux in 2000 was very hard, using Firefox in 2001 was no walk in the park - but one gotta do what one gotta do, if one has some principles.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by saurik on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:59PM (#38294633)
> If it's not Manifest V3 that makes the Internet safe for advertising, it'll be a "browser integrity" token or some other kind of DRM-by-another-name.

So, no: Firefox will NOT save you.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:18PM (#38294892)
Not on its own it won't. It needs more people using it. It needs to support extensions like uBlock Origin, which it does.

Chrome is built to serve Google's interests, which is exactly as you'd expect.

Use Firefox for a web which better balances the competing interests of corporations and end users.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by gary_0 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:48PM (#38295262)
There are already plenty of banking sites and such that will turn you away for not having a standard-issue Chrome user agent header. Also, crank your browser's privacy settings too high, and any website with twitchy Cloudflare settings will give you the sisyphean "I'm not a bot" check box until you give up and go away (or come back with a Chrome that's hungry for cookies).

So no, on our present course, Firefox will not save us. And even if every HN reader used it, that wouldn't even come close to pushing its usage share out of the single digits.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:55PM (#38295382)
> There are already plenty of banking sites and such that will turn you away for not having a standard-issue Chrome user agent header.

Don't use that bank.

> Also, crank your browser's privacy settings too high, and any website with twitchy Cloudflare settings will give you the sisyphean "I'm not a bot" check box

Don't use that website.

It's certainly true that you have no agency or self respect if you embrace a defeatist and submissive outlook.

So don't do that.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by shiroiuma on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:20PM (#38298519)
>There are already plenty of banking sites and such that will turn you away for not having a standard-issue Chrome user agent header

There are countless banks out there. I have bank accounts with several different institutions in two different countries and they all work fine with Firefox + uBO. If yours doesn't, why are you supporting them?

>Also, crank your browser's privacy settings too high, and any website with twitchy Cloudflare settings will give you the sisyphean "I'm not a bot" check box until you give up and go away (or come back with a Chrome that's hungry for cookies).

I haven't seen this. If a website is too much of a PITA to use, I just won't use it, and I suggest you do the same.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by crtasm on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:20PM (#38298522)
First I've heard of a bank rejecting firefox, do you have an example?
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by mvdtnz on Friday November 17, 2023 @04:17AM (#38301239)
No he doesn't, because he's lying.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:38AM (#38303336)
Your Bank of America example is over two years old and no longer valid:

https://www.bankofamerica.com/information/supported-browsers...

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by gary_0 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:07AM (#38303733)
Do you think the situation will improve while Firefox has 3% market share, down ~2% from 2 years ago, and with <1% share on mobile?

You're nitpicking, there are lots of corporate sites that only test against Chrome/Safari these days. I'd love it if Firefox would regain popularity, and Chrome would lose its stranglehold, but let's not stick our heads in the sand about the way things are going.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:17AM (#38303884)
> Do you think the situation will improve

The situation in the example you cited has improved. You're undermining your own position.

Use Firefox and be happy.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by archerx on Friday November 17, 2023 @02:20AM (#38300538)
Get a better bank.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by JohnFen on Friday November 17, 2023 @01:06PM (#38307449)
If a website is useless to me because I'm using the "wrong" browser, my solution is to not use that website. Easy peasy.

Even if it's my bank -- there are other methods of doing business with most banks, after all. And if my bank, for whatever reason, can only be dealt with through their website then I'd change banks in a heartbeat.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by saurik on Thursday November 16, 2023 @05:14PM (#38296348)
Are you failing to respond to the point about the web environment integrity digital rights management proposals because you don't understand it, or because you somehow just don't think it is relevant? Like, in a world where Google gets that deployed and websites start to rely on it, what, exactly, do you think your ad block extension is even going to do?
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by shiroiuma on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:22PM (#38298538)
How exactly is YouTube going to implement this new stuff on millions of embedded clients, namely smart TVs and other such devices that have YouTube clients built-in, and which never get updated? If YT tried to implement some kind of DRM like this, they'll instantly lose a large portion of their userbase.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by I_Am_Nous on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:50PM (#38298786)
They can afford to play the long game and roll it out over a decade or so if it means complete control of the web. By then old devices can be "reasonably" dropped from support for some BS Security excuse or another.

Edit: an example is Windows 11 requiring new enough processors for security reasons even though it would run on older PCs.

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by archerx on Friday November 17, 2023 @02:22AM (#38300553)
I will not use those sites simple as. If there is media I want I can get it from the high seas, for free and have a better view experience. The corps have more too lose in this game. If they want more piracy and this is how you get more piracy.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by narinxas on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:05PM (#38294725)
firefox and being able to compile it on you machine may do the trick for a little while

but policy decisions aren't like technical ones.... principles are at play at every layer above the strictly-technical discussion

Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by clouddrover on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:06PM (#38294741)
Right. So make the principled choice and use Firefox now.
Re:Google resumes transition to Manifest V3 for Chrome exten... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:00PM (#38297892)
But as it stands Firefox (Mozilla) is wholly dependent, financially, on Google.

One could argue that Google can "kill" Mozilla easier than it can kill uBlock.