News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by willis936 on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:00PM (#38224451)
That's not the SCOTUS' job.

The legislative branch sets these rules. The judiciary just interprets them and makes sure the rule set is self consistent (new rules don't break existing rules). The SCOTUS has no business in drawing these lines.

Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by leotravis10 on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#38224733)
In the previous chapter of this years long battle, a appeals court ruled that the Pai-led FCC can kill Net Neutrality on the federal level but allowed states to create their own rules, something that the FCC wanted but failed to preempt states's rules.

Also, the ISP lobby tried to kill California's state law but was defeated three times. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/05/stung-by-3-court...

I expect the same battles to be fought when the FCC get the final votes on it and like I said, the Supreme Court may have to get involved to put an end to the back and fourth as ISPs will try their hardest to get to the highest court.

Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#38224732)
SCOTUS has always played a role in determining whether or not executive branch rules are in keeping with constitutional understandings, at least since Marbury.
Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by jtbayly on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:10PM (#38224583)
Which branch of government is the FCC?
Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by JDazzle on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#38224741)
It's the Executive Branch, which is headed by PotUS
Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by jasonjayr on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:20PM (#38224694)
Executive, with rule-making authority. (Rules that can be changed by the legislative branch)
Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by jtbayly on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:47PM (#38224965)
Precisely. Which is why it will end up being decided by the courts. Because the legislative branch hasn't passed a law. The unelected, unaccountable committee that changes at the whim of the president is not the place to legislate. If you want to pass a law, pass a law.
Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by WendyTheWillow on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:59PM (#38225101)
Unelected in a way, but their boss is elected, and they are absolutely accountable. There is no “whim” upon which these rules change, there was however an election that replaced their boss with someone else.

You either care about accountability and therefore laud their changing position based on that accountability, or you’re just parroting a blind argument conservatives have been making for a number of years now because you don’t like their most recent decision.

Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by paulddraper on Friday November 10, 2023 @05:21PM (#38225342)
The courts will rule on three things:

(1) Whether the legislature has given the FCC sufficient regulatory authority for the policy. (See Comcast v FCC which the FCC lost.)

(2) Whether the legislature or the FCC's actions comply with the Constitution.

(3) Whether the FCC enforcement complies with their rules.

Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by keernan on Friday November 10, 2023 @09:26PM (#38227084)
>The SCOTUS has no business in drawing these lines.

What's interesting about the US Constitution is that SCOTUS is the final arbiter of the limit and extent of the powers of the three branches of government. The words of the constitution (or statute) might say: 'SCOTUS has no business in drawing these lines' and SCOTUS can simply decide: "Those words do not really mean what they appear to say. We hereby rule that SCOTUS does have the right to draw these lines and hereby do so." (or any other issue you want to imagine).

And there isn't much the other branches of government (or the American people) can do about it other than: 1. impeach enough members of SCOTUS to alter the unfavorable decision; 2. increase the size of SCOTUS and appoint enough members to alter the unfavorable decision; or 3. declare a revolutionary war (and win) and create a new government

SCOTUS is the one branch of government with virtually unlimited and unchecked power; is appointed for life; and is not elected. Although the scope of its power has increased immensely over the past ~225 years, what is amazing is that it has remained in relative "check". IMO there is zero reason to expect that to continue to be true for another 200 years.

Re:The FCC voted to reimplement net neutrality. Now comes th... by mlindner on Tuesday November 14, 2023 @10:47PM (#38273095)
The check on SCOTUS is that it doesn't have any law enforcing powers. They're just men and women in long cloaks writing things down. Also, SCOTUS members can be impeached and they can say "no that impeachment is invalid" all they like as the police escort them out of the building.

Government is not like programming a computer. If everyone treats the government like it has power, then it has power. If everyone collectively agrees it doesn't have power then it starts to lack power.