News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by BurningFrog on Friday November 10, 2023 @10:44AM (#38220252)
Google has Search and Ads, which generate vastly more money than they need to operate. Google Search is one of the Great Inventions in human history, so I think the money is well deserved.

But this creates an environment where the natural empire building among managers isn't tempered by the need for their units to produce revenue covering their costs. So the organization tends to grow to where it consumes all the billions raining from the sky.

Disclaimer: Just a loose thought from a cynical ex Googler.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by EricMausler on Friday November 10, 2023 @11:39AM (#38220978)
Isn't that a good thing? It promotes creating jobs and sharing some of the wealth
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by gmadsen on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:58PM (#38222954)
No? the purpose of a job is to create value.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by EricMausler on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:09PM (#38223870)
Eh. The purpose of a job is to do the job.

Creating value feels more like the purpose of the business. Google is creating value, and I dont see the problem with them creating a bunch of easy jobs for people as a means of distributing that value

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by jokethrowaway on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:54PM (#38225055)
It's worse for everyone else (plus it's mentally terrible for the soulless drones taking paychecks). If Google didn't waste money they could offer more value to society.

It's like the government redistributing your money to bullshit initiatives

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by EricMausler on Monday November 13, 2023 @09:19AM (#38250363)
Are you saying Google is currently trying to offer more value to society and they can't find the funds?

My core stance probably comes down to: I don't see how putting money into payroll can be considered a waste to society. It's distributing money directly into the bank accounts of the working class.

They are in a position to provide value to society. They have as large a team of vetted professionals as they can. A bit cliche, but the horse has been lead to water

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by gmadsen on Tuesday November 14, 2023 @02:32PM (#38268360)
the opportunity cost of these people's entire working lives? How is that not a waste to society? Its not like Google is stashing its funds under a matress unless it doles out extra payroll
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by dazzlefruit on Friday November 10, 2023 @02:17PM (#38223206)
Imagine what could be done with that infinite money if Google had a real incentive to build more useful things.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by EricMausler on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:05PM (#38223818)
Would being tighter with their budgets and reducing headcount give them more incentive to build more useful things?

They built the useful thing already. It prints money. Let them house and feed a bunch of people as employees. Idk maybe I'm missing something

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by epicureanideal on Friday November 10, 2023 @11:10AM (#38220584)
> Google Search is one of the Great Inventions in human history

I don't know about that...

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by hennell on Friday November 10, 2023 @12:10PM (#38221416)
Compared to the alternatives at the time (and really now) it absolutely is. Without decent search the web is a mess, it's just mountains of information with no logic or organisation and the best content and information is nothing if you can't locate it.

These days their search is starting to turn. Too many sponsored results, no way to avoid the AI takeover or copycat sites. In short the search doesn't actually find you the best results. But still it's hard to avoid it. There's no better way to find what you are looking for wherever it is on the web.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by BurningFrog on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:09PM (#38222289)
People too young to know life before Google can probably not comprehend how deeply uninformed we were before Larry & Sergey made knowledge searchable.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by cookie_monsta on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#38224742)
I feel about the same amount of uninformed as I was pre- Google, maybe more so being that there are now whole categories of information that I know are pointless trying to memorise.

What's really changed for me is that now we don't have conversations that peter out because nobody has access to basic facts, i.e. whose population is greater, France or Germany. Now we just look it up, end the argument and move on.

Of course this was possible with other search engines. Google's utility comes conflated with the rise of the smart phone and mobile internet, all of which happened around the same time. Everybody having access to the answer to every question in their pocket is the real game changer.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by baq on Friday November 10, 2023 @02:02PM (#38223018)
We who remember altavista and having to ask librarians for information do know.

Google search specifically transformed society in a way comparable with railroads. Impossible became easy. Days of planning turned into minutes or seconds of googling. It really changed the world.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by pessimizer on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:12PM (#38223905)
> We who remember altavista and having to ask librarians for information do know.

I do, and this is a wild exaggeration. Altavista was excellent, and there were always databases online to look up books. Google was far better than Altavista for a short time because of Pagerank, and after Pagerank was gamed was only better than the alternatives because the alternatives had shut down their crawlers.

I miss Altavista. It would be nice to be able to grep the web for things that I want to find, rather than to beg search engines to suggest something for me that they claim their research shows that I might like, but is probably just profitable for them.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by jimbokun on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:25PM (#38224036)
> Google was far better than Altavista for a short time because of Pagerank

Well yes. That was one of the Great Inventions in Human History.

(Obviously not just page rank but also everything else that made it a working product, but that was the key innovation.)

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by n3150n on Friday November 10, 2023 @05:52PM (#38225645)
Compared to the invention of the Internet and/or the WWW, I'm of the opinion that calling Google (the search engine) or PageRank (the algorithm) one of the Great Inventions in Human History (and capitalizing it) is too far-fetched. The first is an indexer for the former, and the latter is not so different from eigenvector centrality, with the added spice of directed random walks.

I do believe that the Internet/WWW is one of our greatest inventions, though, so this is just nit-picking. :)

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by pzs on Monday November 13, 2023 @02:44AM (#38247922)
"the latter is not so different from eigenvector centrality, with the added spice of directed random walk" - I think the parent's point was the impact not that the algorithm itself is unprecedented. You could argue in the same way that the wheel is just a solid symmetric disk connected to a hub in the center that helps vehicles move around on a sufficiently even surface. Note that I don't imply that PageRank is as significant an invention as the wheel.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by jimbokun on Monday November 13, 2023 @10:44AM (#38251490)
WWW was a simple layer over HTTP, inspired by many other existing hyper text systems.

Every great invention is just a simple addition to all the accumulated knowledge in human history up to that point.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by dustingetz on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:04PM (#38224519)
the web did that not google
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by baq on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:09PM (#38224572)
The web was a mess.

That hasn’t changed one bit. Google made it possible to find what you’re looking for. That was literally and figuratively revolutionary. This hasn’t changed either.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by baruz on Sunday November 12, 2023 @03:29AM (#38238432)
Altavista was around for quite a while, and I liked its engine better than Google’s for a long time. Also, Yahoo’s directory-style thing was pretty decent if you knew your way around a catalogued library.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by yterdy on Friday November 10, 2023 @11:02AM (#38220495)
Google could give it to schools with no heat or AC and outdated textbooks. Or help solve homelessness. Or fund fixing the country's bridges. "Sorry we really don't have the funds for more heads or ridiculous raises we're busy not being evil."
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by _Algernon_ on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:01PM (#38222168)
Google is a public company. The money either goes to shareholders or to employing people. There is no conceivable world in which this money would have gone to any of those causes.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by hobofan on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:33PM (#38222644)
I know that you probably meant to express that Google is the opposite to a public (= governmental) entity, but "private company" is not the term to express that. Google is a public company (= listed on the stock market for anyone to buy and sell), so the opposite of a private(ly owned) company.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by _Algernon_ on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:36PM (#38222670)
Probably mixed up private entity and public company. Fixed.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by naet on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:33PM (#38222642)
There's a conceivable world where we restructure incentives around our current form of capitalism and tax codes to encourage extra money going into humanitarian causes, instead of being spent on arbitrary capital maneuvers like stock buybacks.

Conceivable, but we probably won't get there anytime soon.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by fsargent on Friday November 10, 2023 @02:06PM (#38223068)
It’s very simple, that’s what the government should fund. That’s what our tax should pay for. If you really want to manifesto, then just read about land value taxes, don’t tax anything except what we want to disincentivize and land, which doesn’t distort the market. But this is entirely off-topic for this thread.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by johnsonjo on Friday November 10, 2023 @06:45PM (#38226072)
It sounds to me like you're explaining Tax Deductions through Charity which is already a thing.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by losteric on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:03PM (#38223788)
For-profit companies do philanthropy all the time. There is no requirement to divert money to shareholders (further, Google's not payingany dividends right now)
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by brainwad on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:49PM (#38224994)
Google does stock buybacks instead. The last yearly buyback authorisation was for $70b, so the "yield" is around 4-5%. It's very much in the blue-chip, return-cash-to-investors phase of its corporate life.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by wizofaus on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:25PM (#38224034)
Well there's certainly a conceivable one, and it's one probably many would agree would be much nicer one to live in. But accepted, not a realistic one any time soon.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by ttymck on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:25PM (#38224038)
No conceivable world you say?
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by _Algernon_ on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:32PM (#38224125)
That is indeed what I say
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by bloppe on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:50PM (#38225012)
Google has a large charitable arm called google.org, but your point is mostly correct, although the money they pay to employees (and to the government in the form of payroll taxes) isn't being destroyed. It's just cycling around the economy, and many employees donate decent amounts of their paychecks to charity (Google does 1:1 matching and encourages this)
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by nojvek on Friday November 10, 2023 @05:56PM (#38225691)
CEO would get outsed if the shareholders feel he’s not acting in the best interest to make returns.

Capitalism is a best that needs insatiable ever growing revenue and profits.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by baruz on Sunday November 12, 2023 @03:22AM (#38238396)
Vote-holding shareholders in a two-class share company, ie, Schmidt, Brin, or Page. Pichai just has to avoid annoying Sergey and Larry, really.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by edanm on Saturday November 11, 2023 @10:02AM (#38230859)
That's not true. Google makes money for stockholders, and they do whatever they want with that money. Some of them also certainly give money to charity, etc.

I don't know if we prefer a world in which Google itself made these kinds of contributions and not the people who own Google.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by BurningFrog on Friday November 10, 2023 @01:11PM (#38222325)
> Or help solve homelessness

Google has tried building housing in Mountain View, but they can't permits easier than anyone else.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by butlike on Friday November 10, 2023 @03:53PM (#38224374)
Too bad that's the only spot in the world
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by yterdy on Saturday November 11, 2023 @08:59AM (#38230332)
If only Google had an arm of the company dedicated to convincing politicians to do things it wants to see done legislatively.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by johnsonjo on Friday November 10, 2023 @06:36PM (#38226005)
There are 500k homeless people in the US alone [0]. Let's compare that to Google's net income (money gained after all expenses including taxes, etc.) for a quarter (quarter is 3 months with $70m on a good quarter and $30m on a bad one [1]). If we were to give every cent of Google's earnings to each homeless person in the USA then each homeless person could get a $46 pay check ((net_income_per_quarter / homeless_population) / 3 [2]) per month from Google on a good quarter and a $20 paycheck per month on a bad quarter [3]. But, you have to ask yourself what this sort of wild and crazy idea would cost Google. I'm no expert on that, but I assume it would not be good. This is just some simple back of the napkin math, but it shows how simply infeasible solving homelessness or poverty is even for a company as big as Google. This is why I usually believe solving homelessness can not be achieved by money alone, and just the scale of the problem makes it so intractable.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_Sta...

[1]: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GOOGL/financials

[2]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%2870000000+%2F+500000%...

[3]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%2830000000+%2F+500000%...

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by BurningFrog on Friday November 10, 2023 @07:49PM (#38226470)
Homelessness is mainly caused by the physical reality of there being too few homes for the number of people.

The good way to change that is to add more housing (let's ignore the option of removing people).

Giving homeless people money doesn't end the physical reality at all. It can make some homeless people able to afford housing, but an equal number of housed people will replace them as homeless.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by edub on Friday November 10, 2023 @08:26PM (#38226669)
I might be misunderstanding what you are saying, but if there are less than 600k homeless people in America and over 15 million vacant homes, it doesn't seem to be "caused by the physical reality of there being too few homes for the number of people".
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by BurningFrog on Saturday November 11, 2023 @08:23AM (#38230086)
That 15m number may be true, but it doesn't mean what it seems.

It's mostly homes that are between occupants. A tenant or owner moves out, and it takes a few weeks or months for someone new to move in.

It's also homes in depopulated town where there are not enough jobs anymore.

Neither is a practical source of housing for the homeless in SF.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by yterdy on Saturday November 11, 2023 @09:01AM (#38230345)
>It's mostly homes that are between occupants.

Citation strongly needed.

>It's also homes in depopulated town where there are not enough jobs anymore.

I'm not sure I need to explain what happens when people move to a depopulated area?

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by sk5t on Friday November 10, 2023 @07:55PM (#38226497)
Google’s quarterly net income is in the $10 to $20Bn range. Take another whack at that math?
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by johnsonjo on Saturday November 11, 2023 @12:07AM (#38227800)
Okay I was wrong about that I was also wrong about the quarterly part the numbers were not per quarter but per year. Again back of the napkin and I’m glad to have people point out the flaws in my argument.
Re:I Skipped to the Ending by tomalpha on Friday November 10, 2023 @08:29PM (#38226688)
The yahoo link you reference in [1] notes “All numbers in thousands”

I think you might be off by 3 orders of magnitude and google could “afford” to pay every homeless person a thousand times more than you’re suggesting.

I further think that undermines your argument about the problem being fundamentally intractable due to the scale.

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by johnsonjo on Saturday November 11, 2023 @11:02AM (#38231456)
That is true it says all numbers in thousands also I noticed I accidentally was on years and not quarters. So 11k a month for example is the new number for a good year [1] and 5k a month is the example for a bad year [2]. So yes now it seems more tractable than it was before, but my argument was just supposed to show one reason why it was intractable there could be many other reasons, though my argument fell flat for that one reason there are still many other reasons it could be intractable.

So the question still remains is it tractable? The answer given my above argument is still up in the air, because the honest truth is there are many underlying assumptions in my argument so again it doesn’t really say much about it being tractable. It was only trying to say it was intractable which again it fell short of doing. For example in the per month. After Google dumps all or even some of their profit into that for even one month it is somehow going to still reach the same profit margins the next month the proof for that is up to someone trying to prove it’s tractable. There are too many other variables like this that exist and it really needs a much bigger burden to show that something like that is tractable.

[1]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%2870+billion+%2F+12%29... [2]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%2830+billion+%2F+12%29...

Re:I Skipped to the Ending by epolanski on Friday November 10, 2023 @10:17PM (#38227336)
Calling Google Search one of history's great inventions is beyond delusional starting from the fact that Google didn't invent website indexing and searching if anything it had better algos and was less disrupted by the various waves of SEO spammers that killed the likes of Yahoo or Lycos or Altavista, etc.