Not everyone wants to pay top dollar for the most comprehensive gold-plated plans.
it is, but i imagine the insurance company is expecting a certain cost for some expected treatments, and use that to calculate your life-time value as a customer. If a new treatment that has better outcomes, but is more expensive comes along, the insurance company may stand to lose money, and thus, they prefer denying such a treatment and only offer the "old" one.
At least, that is how i would rationalize the behaviour. Whether this is actually the reason or not, remains to be seen.
Socialized medicine certainly has its issues, but if there has to be a "death panel", I'd rather it be composed of doctors than a bunch of bean counters.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amanda_Pritchard
Even if the chief was the doctor, they would be getting their funds from the political leaders, who are most likely not all going to be doctors.
Similar for a close family member with a strange heart and immune condition.
InsuranceCo BCBS had some bureaucrat without even a medical degree directly second-guessing the tests ordered by the literal Director of Cardiology at the world-renowned Mayo Clinic.
All I can think is: "Who the fck are you to even begin to question this expert, and deny his recommendation?". Now, IFF they had some actual peer reviewing it (e.g., the head of cardiology at Cleveland Clinic or Harvard Med School), that might be legit, but this is nothing of the sort. It's like the tech giant's arbitrary terminating accounts with support, except instead of cutting off your livelihood, they are killing you.
It is the death of expertise. It seems like practicing medicine without a license and without even seeing the patient (which is legally required before writing many prescriptions).
Why it is even close to legal is utterly baffling.
(I hope your dad continues to recover)
I think American healthcare is insane… and the slow sliding in the American style healthcare direction I see in the UK and even slower slide here in Australia, this slide is largely borne out of American healthcare business having no more room to expand and trying to export their business model overseas to expand their addressable markets… it’s insane to allow non medical professionals… to allow armies of accountants and actuaries… to decide how to treat patients.
It should be criminal, but it won’t be because the healthcare industry in America is so broken it will lobby till it’s broke to continue to be allowed to remain broken otherwise it might not be as profitable.
I think a licensed doctor/pharmacist employed by the insurance company has to make the decision, although, since they do not have liability exposure, I can imagine metrics can be imposed on them that make the quality of their work less than desirable.
If I don’t want to pay I can have a GP appointment with a short trip and a little wait sometime in the next 1-3 days… if I’m happy paying $40 Australian … I’ve got a GP appointment within walking distance tomorrow, no issues no bullshit, and I’ll even get some of that back from the government if I can be bothered, because anything that urgent is probably worth the money lol.
If I want to pay I can get specialist treatment, I’ve got private healthcare to cover fancy shit like regular physiotherapist sessions due to having an office job which will slowly and stealthily destroy your body no matter how careful you are… and glasses if I eventually need them… and stupid levels of dental because that’s my personal preference, if someone ever smashed out all my teeth I’m just completely covered … and that’s all on top of basically being assured care for anything serious disease or critical injury related by public healthcare… it’s just obviously the better arrangement. The most general risks are shared by the biggest pool of people paying for it… everyone paying for that with their taxes. If you want more… your free to buy it, and a lot of people do! It works great.
My Mum was diagnosed with Stage 4 lung cancer, and they went all out with radiation, chemo, experimental new treatments and a TON of tests and scans. They estimated she had 12 months to live, she made it just under three years and had basically every treatment and scan even conceived to fight cancer.
Money or insurance were never even discussed or mentioned once. It's simply not part of our world.
The US can do better.
I emotionally agree with this, but I don't have a good answer for the following situation:
1) A company develops a new, slightly more efficacious treatment, patents it, and prices it at some completely absurd cost (say, $1 million/month for daily pills).
2) Doctors understandably prescribe this treatment because it's slightly more efficacious than the pills that cost $16/month.
Where would pricing pressure come into play here? If insurance companies can't say "No, that price is ridiculous and we're not paying it." I'm honestly wondering what the solution for this would be.
Also, rarely is it the case that such expensive treatments are needed by more than a fraction of the population. I’d say there’s an argument to be made that we all aught to be okay with a small fraction of people getting healthcare that far outstrips their contribution via taxes – given that we never know if that one day may be us.
Yes, but that still must have limits. Society certainly should not pay one trillion dollars to care for a single patient. That’s too inefficient.
> then why shouldn't we?
Ultimately, there's only so much economy to go around. What percentage of it are you willing to dedicate to treating that one condition? What about everything that can't be funded as a result of that allocation?
But that is the purpose of high deductible health plans, to give healthcare recipients an incentive to to visit cheaper healthcare providers or accept generic medicines.
Technically, the insurance company is denying payment, not the treatment. Also, many times, the prior authorization requirements and formularies are given by the insurance company’s customer, such as the the government (Medicaid, Medicare, employer, etc). But the insurance company will take the heat, because that is part of what they are getting paid for.
Useful for when you need to give a Senator quick access to top tier healthcare, and older people a lower level of healthcare, and poorer people an even lower level of healthcare.
For almost every person in this country, for an expensive treatment, this is a distinction without any difference whatsoever.
Was it BCBSLA that chooses to use Elevance for reviewing claims and the guidelines for those claims? Or does the federal government dictate using Elevance? And are there varying federal government standards for different insured populations?
I have not researched it thoroughly, but I can envision a situation where BCBSLA sells the government a “fall guy” role, and the government (taxpayers) save money by telling BCBSLA to use a more restrictive formulary or prior authorization criteria for certain populations.
They didn't reverse the decision until we got a lawyer who knew the ins and outs of the appeals process. Thankfully, we were able to work through that fast enough for treatment to be effective... there's no way we could have paid out of pocket.
The ability of an insurance company to unilaterally deny treatment, or determine what type of treatment a patient receives, is obscene and should be categorically illegal. There is no instance in which a medical bureaucrat should should be able to, sight-unseen, overrule a patient's own doctor.
It's so frustrating.