News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by valianteffort on Sunday November 05, 2023 @01:37AM (#38148595)
Changing the calendar in general seems stupid. The gregorian calendar is already well established simple to understand. What benefit does changing it actually bring?

More importantly the US should switch to the metric system.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by sophacles on Sunday November 05, 2023 @01:47AM (#38148644)
There's a really high poe factor here....

Like your arguments against changing the calendar to something more rational are the same arguments a lot of US folks use to justify not switching to the metric system.

Well played.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by sneak on Sunday November 05, 2023 @04:06AM (#38149495)
The US already switched to the metric system in 1988.

https://www.nist.gov/pml/owm/metrication-law

15 USC § 205b

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/205b

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by kelnos on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:11AM (#38160319)
Your use of "switched" is leaving out a lot of nuance. Metric is by law preferred for trade and commerce, but what to actually use is left up to each individual and business, and individuals and business don't need to actually care about this law.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by cowsandmilk on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:39PM (#38156960)
> importantly the US should switch to the metric system

Why switch to a system that is widely agreed to be worse for normal human communication than the one we have.

Fahrenheit is far superior of a system, where 0 to 100 roughly reflects the range of temperatures one might expect in the lower 48. When you are outside that range, you know you’re in for very uncomfortable weather. Celsius doesn’t give much benefit beyond the vague water will freeze around 0.

And then we get to distance. The US has a system where a foot is divisible by 2, 3, 4, and 6. Metric is only divisible by 5 or 2. It is horrid if you need to divide things in thirds.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by decae on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:00PM (#38157124)
Is this a joke?
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by mensetmanusman on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:24PM (#38157293)
No, imperial base 12 is superior for carpentry and construction due to having more integer divisions. That’s why hour time is base 12.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by nwiswell on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:35PM (#38157361)
... What? Why does the foot being divisible by 12 help anything? If you're dealing with something 7.3 ft long, what's the advantage over 2.23 meters?

Hell, if you've got something 2.4 meters long and 7.87 ft long, it's the metric length that happens to be conveniently divisible by 12.

The situation with machine tools in the US is unbelievable, by the way. So many stupid mistakes have been caused by the confusion between mils (1/1000 of an inch) and millimeters. And many many tools and bits are designated in fractional inches rather than whole or decimal units (as in countries using metric) which is a massive pain in the ass because both CAD software and quick mental comparisons are generally not conducive to bizarre fractions like 9/64".

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by explaininjs on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:29PM (#38157743)
Carpentry and construction are both also areas where you don't really have an "exact" need to be at certain measure. You can usually get away pretty well with just picking a nice round number and going from there.

Machining is different, and metric is accordingly often used there.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by rrr_oh_man on Thursday November 09, 2023 @05:06PM (#38212040)
> Carpentry and construction are both also areas where you don't really have an "exact" need to be at certain measure. You can usually get away pretty well with just picking a nice round number and going from there.

This does not sound like you’ve done much of either. I spent my summer rebuilding my kitchen and, oh boy, do millimetres matter.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by lolinder on Sunday November 05, 2023 @09:33PM (#38158115)
> The situation with machine tools in the US is unbelievable, by the way. So many stupid mistakes have been caused by the confusion between mils (1/1000 of an inch) and millimeters.

To be fair, this wouldn't be an issue if we had only imperial units. It's only possible to mix these up because we have an awkward mix of both systems.

> The situation is legitimately a little bit different with minutes and hours, since we are able to specify units of time somewhat arbitrarily to match the units, i.e., if hours were 64 minutes instead of 60, many meetings would instead be 64 (or 32) minutes long.

The same situation is true of carpentry, though. when we're building something out of wood we rarely have specific dimensions we must meet, we're building something artificial and can pick the closest round number. 2x4s are 2" by 4" not because they need to be slotted into some naturally-occurring fixture but because it's a nice round number that is sufficiently useful. The standard ceiling height in the US is 8' not because of any law of the universe but because it's a round number that's easy to measure and easy to divide (quarters, halves).

Your examples of something 7.3 feet long or 7.87 feet long simply don't come up in carpentry because we'd usually just round up to a nice number and scale the whole project accordingly. And if we do have something that needs to be precise within +/- a certain tolerance, a base unit that is easily divisible is more likely to be able to round conveniently while remaining within the tolerance.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by kelnos on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:08AM (#38160294)
Ugh, so I was just making some new window screen frames to replace some that were missing, and what a pain that was to measure things out. I had fun dimensions like 21-5/16" all over the place. Now, they certainly didn't need to be accurate to a sixteenth-inch, but being off by even a quarter inch could easily make them not fit.

Too large and you just can't get the screen into the frame, and too small and it can just fall out, or at the very least leave gaps large enough that bugs can get through.

I agree with you that there are many things where we don't have a specific physical need for certain dimensions, so we just pick round numbers. But I think the cases where we do have to conform to some messy existing physical dimensions come up more frequently than you think.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by antod on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:35AM (#38160875)
Hours being base 12 is why time is way more painful to calculate with than other quantities, and why SI just sticks to seconds.

Would Americans love pre-decimal British currency? All those shillings and florins with lots of integer divisions? I bet the average metric hating American would be unironically demanding decimal currency back when faced with it.

I always get curious about how American construction works when I hear this argument. Do builders spend all their time dividing stuff into 3 rather adding, multiplying or subtracting? I would've thought adding a sequence of measurements up would be a far more common operation.

What happens when you need to divide something into 3 a second time? Or you need to divide an arbitrary length into 3? Or what if you need to divide into 3 sections, but there is something extra between each section (like a frame or a post), or you have to account for the width of the cuts etc?

Is an 8x4ft sheet (eg plywood etc) really easier to mentally divide into 3 (on either dimension) than a 2400x1200mm one?

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by hoseja on Monday November 06, 2023 @06:46AM (#38161303)
Base 60 actually, honour your Sumerian betters.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by g8oz on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:48PM (#38157855)
Clearly the rest of the world is just misguided.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by firebat45 on Sunday November 05, 2023 @11:20PM (#38158822)
Neither Farenheit nor Celcius are "superior" on their own. However, Celcius slots in to scientific notation nicely, which gives it a huge benefit.

I'm Canadian. I deal with a bastard mix of metric and imperial daily. Farenheit is the one unit I've never needed to learn in the slightest. I can deal with lbs, feet, inches, etc.

As for claiming base 12 is superior because you can divide by 3, what happens when you divide by 10? Surely if base

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by Gibbon1 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:35AM (#38159236)
Well it's inferior to base 11. Because with base 11 you can divide by 11.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by demetrius on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:48AM (#38159847)
> When you are outside that range, you know you’re in for very uncomfortable weather.

Which is... Pretty random? What is "very uncomfortable"? 'Switch to autumn/spring clothes' uncomfortable (<20ºC)? 'Switch to winter clothes' uncomfortable (≈0ºC)? 'Get a sweater below your winter clothes, and maybe double trousers, too' uncomfortable? (<-20ºC)

Celsius fits the mental model of normal human communication quite well if you use it.

> Celsius doesn’t give much benefit beyond the vague water will freeze around 0.

Which is a very major shift: rain turns into snow, roads get slippery, you should dry your hair extra-carefully (> 0ºC it's raining anyway, you'll get wet anyway, why bother; <0ºC it will turn to ice on your head, you definitely don't want that).

Water freezing is a VERY major weather shift.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by kelnos on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:00AM (#38160233)
> Celsius fits the mental model of normal human communication quite well if you use it.

That last bit is the key: Fahrenheit also fits the mental model of normal human communication quite well if you use it.

The F vs. C wars are silly; if you were raised using a particular unit system, then that system will most likely feel the most natural to you. If you didn't, you can certainly learn another and adapt, but for most people it won't feel right.

This is all just fine. Yes, it's annoying when you travel to a place that uses a different unit system than you're used to, but life is full of such things, and we should just live with it rather than trying to argue what's "right". Nothing is right, nothing is wrong. Whatever is, just... is.

(Note that I'm not making any arguments about which one is better for math or science or whatever. Just about what feels comfortable. For the record, I do think many things -- including global interop -- would be easier if we all used metric. But I don't think, no matter how hard I try, I'll ever be able to "feel" celsius properly.)

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by valianteffort on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:09AM (#38160305)
Your argument appears to be that Americans are too stupid to figure out metric.

Water freezing around 0 is a good indicator that the temperature is cold enough to kill you given that you're mostly water.

If I'm dividing a length of wood in thirds, I use my metric ruler, and I mark out three even cuts. It's crazy how they sold me a 2x4 in feet and it still divided into centimeters.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by pezezin on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:55AM (#38160577)
> Why switch to a system that is widely agreed to be worse for normal human communication than the one we have.

Widely agreed by whom? Because the rest of the planet thinks otherwise.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by jampekka on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:30AM (#38160831)
I agree that base 10 is not optimal but the US/imperial distance system is hard to defend.

A foot is 12 inches, a yard is 3 feet and a mile is 1760 yards. And don't get me started on the weight and volume units.

I entertain a hypothesis that such inconsistent unit systems (and heavy usage of fractions instead of decimal or other positional system) do make people less apt in handling numbers. Having lived for a while in England (which is legally metric but in practice imperial for many things) for a while, I think it is reflected in how things involving numbers are often stated in quite convoluted terms.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by JeremyNT on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:35AM (#38163131)
> Fahrenheit is far superior of a system, where 0 to 100 roughly reflects the range of temperatures one might expect in the lower 48. When you are outside that range, you know you’re in for very uncomfortable weather. Celsius doesn’t give much benefit beyond the vague water will freeze around 0.

First, 0 and 100 F seem completely arbitrary.

Second, if they have such immense value, people using centigrade could manage to remember "-18" and "38."

My brain is sadly stuck on the default "F" units since I grew up in and continue to reside in the US, yet even I can remember general mappings of Centigrade to "how it feels" as a human. This is not a difficult thing to do/learn.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by iisan7 on Monday November 06, 2023 @11:41AM (#38164879)
I sometimes appreciate the extra dynamic range of Fahrenheit for describing temperatures relevant to human environmental comfort. With C you need to use a decimal point and significant digit. It's rarely that important though. You could get by using just the even numbers of F temps for casual purposes, or while numbers of C.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by JeremyNT on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:30PM (#38167587)
I personally doubt I could ever really tell a 1F difference.

Other factors (sunlight, wind, humidity) make that level of precision kind of useless for a "how does it feel" situation, which IMO just further degrades the value of 0-100F thing as conveying any particular significance.

Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by mensetmanusman on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:22PM (#38157271)
Not until the metric system mandates metric time.
Re:The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 ... by fragmede on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:49PM (#38157476)
Not until the metric system realizes that 60 is the better base.