News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rezmason on Thursday November 02, 2023 @03:53PM (#38119096)
It's wrong to equate people abandoning free speech with people not wanting to host people with specific stances at a venue.

Free speech isn't about flinging the door open to everyone. It's about not incarcerating them, and not preventing them from speaking at all.

In my opinion, the people who blast "cancel culture" are often the people who tacitly assume that they are welcome everywhere by default. That's not anyone's right. And you don't infringe on someone's right to say what they want just because you won't sell them a megaphone.

What we're seeing is a young generation of left-leaning people who are motivated to shift the Overton window back from the cliff, because they no longer assume (as older generations have) that adults can wield a megaphone responsibly.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by jrh3 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:12PM (#38119400)
Freedom requires tolerance. We've lost a lot of that and what I think the author is going for.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:14PM (#38119425)
How about the paradox of tolerance? Should you tolerate intolerant views?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by hnthrowaway6543 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:23PM (#38119568)
From the article: is "Abortion should be completely illegal" an intolerant view?

I don't agree with the statement, but if someone agrees with that because they believe that life begins at conception and a fetus should have the same rights as a post-birth human: could you explain the intolerance there?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sjsdaiuasgdia on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:36PM (#38119771)
For most who hold it, this position is backed by the person's religious beliefs. It is intolerant because the implementation of their position is, in effect, forcing others to abide by their religious beliefs.

In addition to that, the implementations tend to be misogynistic, racist, and/or classist.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by hnthrowaway6543 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:44PM (#38119880)
> For most who hold it, this position is backed by the person's religious beliefs. It is intolerant because the implementation of their position is, in effect, forcing others to abide by their religious beliefs.

Is that not the case for many laws and cultural norms? Why is public nudity, or even public sex, illegal (in most/many places) if not religious beliefs?

Do you think people should be allowed to have sex in public? If not, are you not being intolerant and forcing your religious and cultural beliefs upon others?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sjsdaiuasgdia on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:59PM (#38120075)
Many of our laws were at least initially produced in a religious or other framework that implies universal morality. I am in favor of reviewing and reconsidering laws where we can't seem to find a non-religious justification.

For the public sex example you raise, we have plenty of evidence and experience that shows the further you get away from adults doing consensual sexual things either alone or around other consenting adults, the more likely it is that someone may be psychologically harmed. Getting the consent of everyone in a public setting is pretty hard.

Aside from religious folk, most people don't have a problem with strip clubs, sex clubs, sex parties, nude beaches, etc where a bunch of consenting adults are naked and/or behaving sexually around other consenting adults.

So no, I don't think people should be allowed to have sex in public, and it is not based in religious or cultural belief. It's based on evidence that non-consensual sexual situations (including observing someone else's sexual behavior) causes harm, and that it violates others' right to not consent to the sexual situation.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by AlexandrB on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:56PM (#38120034)
This ground has been tread many times already, but saying abortion should be illegal is closer to saying people must have sex in public. In both cases you're compelling a person to use (and abuse) their body a certain way (for ~9 months in the case of a pregnancy).

But even setting that aside, most anti-abortion advocates "give the game away" by also advocating against contraception. Their primary concern is not "murder", it's sex.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by pton_xd on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:49PM (#38119948)
It's obvious to me how some people would earnestly consider killing an unborn child to be equivalent to murder.

How is that belief "intolerant," except that you strongly disagree with it? Maybe you highly value the ability to kill unborn children, and they highly value the ability to stop that.

It's just a difference in values, no one is right or wrong. The whole point of speech is to discuss these competing values!

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Thiez on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:23PM (#38136367)
If the belief is rooted in religious dogma, as it usually is, there can be no productive discussion. Most arguments will boil down to 'because my book says so'.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:49PM (#38119950)
I am not religious, and am pro-life. I know a lot of other pro-life folks who are deeply religious. All of us share the same basic motivation: human life is inherently valuable and worthy of protection. For my religious friends, their faith is just one additional reason to believe in the value of human life.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by AlexandrB on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:59PM (#38120077)
I assume you and your friends also advocate against the death penalty, for sex education and access to contraceptives, and for a robust social safety net?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:09PM (#38120190)
> against the death penalty

Some are against it in all cases, others argue that violating other people's right to life means you forfeit your own. (Personally I'm unsure)

> Sex education and access to contracepion

Pretty low-salience issue for most of them. Many believe premarital sex is wrong, no strong opinions beyond that. I've never known any of them to argue against condoms, for example.

> robust social safety net

They tend to be skeptical of massive government welfare programs, but they are not Ayn Randists to any extent. All recognize that a culture of life needs to support mothers and their children at every step; many volunteer at crisis pregnancy centers to help with that.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by vacuity on Thursday November 02, 2023 @08:25PM (#38122519)
I think this is a filter bubble situation, because policymakers in certain states don't seem to be pro-life so much as anti-women's rights. And if policymakers are like that, a good portion of the populace either agrees or doesn't care. Perhaps they have different conditions for abortion but don't care to object. It's wrong to malign all Christians in the US as such, but some people are using religion as a facade. I think the facade is quite effective, considering the abysmal level of critical thinking in the US.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @09:20PM (#38123086)
> policymakers in certain states don't seem to be pro-life so much as anti-women's rights

Can you give examples of what you are talking about?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by supertimor on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:48PM (#38123836)
Not the OP, but there are many documented cases where the recent lack of access to safe abortions have risked women’s lives. These are what I found just with a quick search.

>“She was denied an abortion in Texas - then she almost died”

”Doctors told her she had cervical insufficiency, which is a weakening of the cervical tissue that causes premature dilation, and that her unborn daughter would not survive. She and her husband were devastated. "She was a baby that we desperately, desperately wanted," she said.

A standard course of medical treatment for an unviable pregnancy at that stage of development is to terminate, and extract the foetus. Waiting to miscarry naturally can put the mother at risk for infection, which can prove fatal. But doctors told her they couldn't terminate her pregnancy, as under the state's laws, it was a crime to perform an abortion when there was a foetal heartbeat, unless the mother's life was threatened. Essentially, the message was that she was not sick enough yet to legally justify an abortion. Three days later, Amanda developed a life-threatening infection and went into septic shock.”

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65935189.amp

>“Texas abortion law means woman has to continue pregnancy despite fatal anomaly”

“At her 20-week ultrasound appointment, Beaton said her physician discovered the fetus had a rare, severe anomaly -- called alobar holoprosencephaly -- in which the fetus's brain does not develop into two hemispheres as it normally would, and the major structures of the brain remain fused in the middle.

The brain splitting into two hemispheres is a "critical stage in the development" and can impact the development of the nose, mouth and throat, Dr. Katie McHugh, an Indiana OB-GYN and abortion provider, told ABC News. The condition can result in a very painful life and death for the fetus, McHugh said.

Beaton said her physicians told her the baby could survive out of the womb for a couple of weeks, at most, in the event that the pregnancy ends in a live birth. Rouse agreed with this assessment, pointing to what she said is a lack of development of normal brain tissue and empty fluid filling the head.

"This anomaly is typically lethal for most infants within days to weeks," Rouse said.”

https://abcnews.go.com/US/texas-abortion-law-means-woman-con...

>“8 women join suit against Texas over abortion bans, claim their lives were put in danger”

“The suit alleged that Texas' abortion bans have denied the plaintiffs and countless other pregnant people necessary and potentially life-saving medical care because physicians in the state fear liability, according to a draft of the complaint shared with ABC News.

Texas has several abortion laws in place, prohibiting all abortions after six weeks of pregnancy, except in medical emergencies, which the laws do not define. One of the bans -- called SB 8 -- prohibits abortions after cardiac activity is detected, which kept several plaintiffs from accessing care despite their pregnancies being nonviable, according to a draft of the suit.

Under Texas' bans, it is a second-degree felony to perform or attempt an abortion, punishable by up to life in prison and a fine of up to $10,000. The law also allows private citizens to sue anyone who "aids or abets" an abortion.

The lawsuit is asking a judge to temporarily and permanently suspend the Texas law due to the uncertainty surrounding the meaning of the exception in the state's abortion bans.”

https://abcnews.go.com/amp/US/8-women-join-suit-texas-aborti...

>”Most Abortion Bans Include Exceptions. In Practice, Few Are Granted.”

“Last summer, a Mississippi woman sought an abortion after, she said, a friend had raped her. Her state prohibits most abortions but allows them for rape victims. Yet she could not find a doctor to provide one.

In September, an Indiana woman learned that a fetal defect meant her baby would die shortly after birth, if not sooner. Her state’s abortion ban included an exception for such cases, but she was referred to Illinois or Michigan. An Ohio woman carrying triplets faced a high risk of dangerous complications, including delivering too early. When she tried to get an abortion in September through Ohio’s exception for patients with a medical need, she was turned away.

The abortion bans enacted in about half the states since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June do not prohibit abortion entirely. Most make exceptions in certain circumstances, commonly to protect the health or life of the patient, or in the case of rape or incest. And as conservative state lawmakers prepare to take up new restrictions on abortion in upcoming legislative sessions, exceptions will be at the heart of the debate.

But in the months since the court’s decision, very few exceptions to these new abortion bans have been granted, a New York Times review of available state data and interviews with dozens of physicians, advocates and lawmakers revealed.

Instead, those with means are traveling to states where abortion is still broadly legal or are obtaining abortion pills at home because the requirements to qualify for exceptions are too steep. Doctors and hospitals are turning away patients, saying that ambiguous laws and the threat of criminal penalties make them unwilling to test the rules.

“Having the legal right on the books to get an abortion and getting one in practice are two distinctly different things,” said Laurie Bertram Roberts, the executive director of the Mississippi Reproductive Freedom Fund, a group that supports abortion rights.”

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/01/21/us/abortion-b...

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:05AM (#38124372)
Thanks for this comment, it must have taken you a while to put together. I agree that this issue is something we in the pro-life movement aren't doing enough to address. I think this is:

- partly pro-life legislators failing at writing legislation,

- partly doctors and hospitals being (understandably, there is precedent) terrified of the slighest risk of a malpractice suit, and

- partly pro-life legislators being (understandably, there is precedent) terrified that any slack put into the laws will be willfully miscontrued by activist judges to effectively nullify all restrictions.

In any case, it's an issue that we as a movement must have an answer for, and right now we don't. That's on us. Doctors need some amount of benefit-of-the-doubt to be able to do their jobs (though it can't be infinite either).

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by supertimor on Sunday November 05, 2023 @05:45PM (#38156460)
I generally agree that these are all issues that need to be addressed if these bans are to be put in place.

But— my biggest issues with these bans (aside from the ban itself- I am pro choice), is that they were hastily put into place with little to no thought into the actual implementation of the ban. It’s not like they didn’t have time to come up with reasonable legislation as this has been a major discussion leading up to the reversal of Roe vs Wade. But instead of taking time to legislate this properly (or talking to healthcare providers or doctors about what an emergency in cases like these might look like), they instead just pushed through these laws with zero clarity— in turn, affecting the quality of healthcare that women can now receive.

I don’t want to be a conspiracy theorist or anything but leaving “emergency” in the legislation without a single definition of what that is suppose to mean, seems almost intentional. If that’s not the case, then these legislators are so incredibly inept at their job that they should not be legislating at all.

To your second point, I think it is unfair to leave any of the blame at doctor’s or hospital’s feet given that these laws don’t actually define in any specific way what would constitute what an emergency is. You cannot blame a doctor for not wanting to perform an abortion if it will land them in jail. Without certainty in the law, the risk is way too great. Your point might be more applicable if the laws clearly defined what would constitute a legal abortion. But right now, the law is so nebulous that it is basically up to individual judges and no doctor or business is going to risk their lives on such an uncertainty.

If pro-life legislators were actually concerned with their law being misconstrued, I’d expect that they would actually want to put more clarifications into the law, not less. With the recent laws an activist could right now rule that they think an emergency applies to an abortion case (just as much as a judge could rule that their was no emergency, even if there was one). As it stands, the current law creates so much uncertainty that doctor’s and providers will just not take any action that might put them on the other side of the law. I suspect that the purpose of this lack of clarity is to insert as much uncertainty into the law so that people will be just too afraid to act. To me, it appears that these legislators are not acting in good faith.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @07:17PM (#38121794)
I think the issue divides when you cross the line from "personal belief" to "this personal belief should be a law."

Imagine forced abortions - wouldn't that be insane? Some see forcing a woman to have a baby to be equally insane.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by vacuity on Thursday November 02, 2023 @08:37PM (#38122657)
This gets thorny when you delve into the metaethics. Basically, why is murder considered immoral and should be punished (or at least addressed)? Well, is abortion murder? If it is, then opposing abortions is the right thing to do. Personally, I'm leaning towards supporting , but I'm struggling to develop a reasonable moral framework. I do think a society should be founded on a minimal, solid foundation so as to curb the moral relativism. I don't want to be tasked with answering "what kinds of abortion are allowed in your ideal society" anytime soon.

I can't speak for everyone. If you feel that abortion is a fundamental right, then go stand up for it. (Of course, you are doing that.) But who can say that their list of rights is right?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:36AM (#38124582)
> Well, is abortion murder? If it is, then opposing abortions is the right thing to do. Personally, I'm leaning towards supporting , but I'm struggling to develop a reasonable moral framework.

I wasn't always strongly pro-life. I used to vaguely hold the standard European position (allowed up to 12-15 weeks with exceptions). What "radicalized" me, was the most cliché thing imaginable: photographs of abortion victims, from a clinic in my metropolitan area.

My memory of past events in my personal life is generally quite hazy. But the instant things "clicked" for me on this issue, is clearly fixed.

The images in question can be found here (WARNING VERY GRAPHIC):

https://www.liveaction.org/news/infant-bodies-infanticide-at...

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by vacuity on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:32AM (#38127753)
You weren't wrong with the "GRAPHIC" warning. Abortion clinics should find better ways of carrying out abortions, to ensure minimal pain and, if possible, the gruesomeness. I'm not persuaded towards pro-life by the images, though. If abortions are considered morally permissible and the techniques are reasonably considerate of the fetus, I would be failing my own moral responsibility by letting images deter me.

I mostly borrow Don Marquis' notion that killing an adult human is often murder because the adult had a "valuable future" (not necessarily valued by the person themselves). A fetus also has such a future, as opposed to, say, a sperm cell. Roughly, I say this is because a fetus denotes an entity of a well-defined process of continued life (development, birth, further growth). In fact, I think all morals and whatnot are ultimately based on prohibiting the bad, no good, negative stuff that people do to each other. In other words, to ensure everyone has a reasonably "good life". Although a fetus therefore has moral consideration, though not necessarily a "person" in the moral sense, a full evaluation of abortion must also include an account of the woman's moral consideration. I'm still trying to determine where to draw the line.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:43PM (#38124230)
An unborn child is an independent person, who (cases of rape excepted) came into existence due to a free choice of their mother. They deserve an opportunity to experience life according to their personal beliefs, just like everyone else. To kill them is to violate that right.

> Imagine forced abortions

Unfortunately, you don't have to imagine. Many US states allow surrogacy contracts with forced-abortion clauses.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Saturday November 04, 2023 @11:09PM (#38147701)
A fetus is not a person, I think is the argument.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Sunday November 05, 2023 @12:45PM (#38153466)
> A fetus is (not) a person

This question is the crux of the debate, and has always been. But in my experience, many pro-choice advocates are reluctant to address it directly; they prefer to talk about "rights" and "personal beliefs." Probably because, when you consider it seriously, the answer is inescapable.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:14PM (#38200693)
It is the crux of the issue, alongside bodily autonomy of the woman, which is important.

No serious, mature pro-life people pretend that abortion is a simple thing. People very much so understand the gravity of it.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:28PM (#38119646)
> is "Abortion should be completely illegal" an intolerant view?

Some would argue it is.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by hnthrowaway6543 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:33PM (#38119725)
So by your own admission, what speech counts as "intolerance" is not universal and subject to interpretation.

Could you explain who is responsible for deciding which views are considered intolerant, so that we know which speech we should not tolerate?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by saghm on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:50PM (#38119955)
> Could you explain who is responsible for deciding which views are considered intolerant, so that we know which speech we should not tolerate?

For starters, how about "people who aren't enrolled or employed at a private organization have no standing to demand access to the private organizations resources for amplifying their speech"? We can take a head count of people who are against this idea by having them publicly sign a petition demanding for support for a pro-choice speaking tour kicking off at Liberty University with stops in Notre Dame and BYU.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by TheCoelacanth on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:50PM (#38119957)
Abortion is often a life-saving operation. "Abortion should be completely illegal" is an assertion that some people in the audience should be dead. Yes, that is an intolerant view.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by canadiantim on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:20PM (#38119528)
Yes, absolutely yes. It’s not the popular views that need to be defended, it’s the unpopular speech that does
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:43PM (#38119858)
Unpopular speech needs to be defended, but not intolerant speech that infringes upon the rights of others to their own speech. Intolerant and unpopular aren't synonyms.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by RationalDino on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:18PM (#38120295)
20 years ago I would have reflexively agreed with your statement.

But today, many of the most intolerant people out there are loudly proclaiming their tolerance. And because their intolerance comes clothed in rhetoric about their tolerance, they are blind to the fact of their own intolerance. And so we get people like the guy in Los Angeles a few days ago where a guy kicked his way into a Jewish family's home while yelling, "Kill the Jews," and, "Brown people matter!"

I therefore am left wondering whether I agree with you. Do we agree on which speech is intolerant speech? It's no longer something that I can just take for granted these days.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by escapedmoose on Thursday November 02, 2023 @06:47PM (#38121463)
You can recognize that this is a very fringe case and not typical behavior of the “cancel culture” crowd, right?

Some people will choose “tolerance” as a convenient cover for objectively bad behavior, but a good number of popular “cancelation” calls are reasonably motivated when you look at them on a case-by-case basis. You’ll likely not agree with all of them, but there’s at least sensible reasoning behind them. Especially in examples like college campus speakers, where an invite for a speaker can be seen as the institution’s endorsement of the speaker’s belief.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by belorn on Thursday November 02, 2023 @07:45PM (#38122032)
Having a speaker's belief being potentially seen as being endorsement by the university for the decision of inviting the speaker to talk is a rather far leap from speech that infringes upon the rights of others to their own speech.

I think we should question why people would associate a university with every guest speaker and everything they say as being authoritative statements of the university and their staff.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by escapedmoose on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:14PM (#38123549)
Unlike social media platforms, any given university only has so many physical spaces, blocks of time, advertising and logistics resources, etc. to host speakers. They’re selectively chosen and coordinated.

So when a speaker is invited who is, for example, blatantly hostile to the advertised mission of the university, it raises eyebrows. And it paints a contradictory pictures that devalues the university itself. Or worse, if the message is blatantly hostile to a subset of students, it could discourage some people from even wanting to attend!

People work hard to get accepted to universities which they respect, and they have a vested interest in maintaining their university’s respect in the public eye.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by belorn on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:11AM (#38127022)
Could you elaborate your point in how that infringes upon the rights of others to their own speech?

I can see from your point several value loaded points where students will disagree with each other. The advertised mission of the university being one of them, as people often argue what the point of university training is and how much of education is learning things, research, and social networking. Then there is things like the student theater, which are often not just blatantly hostile to a subset of students and very much discourage some people from wanting to attend to social events. Then we have fraternities and sororities which activity often paints a unfavorable pictures of university life, even going so far as being occasionally borderline criminal in their activities.

What should be a appropriate response to students who disagree on how the university experience should be?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by RationalDino on Thursday November 02, 2023 @08:46PM (#38122778)
The "kill the Jews" guy is a fringe case? Absolutely!

But from what I see, the cancel culture crowd mostly is the problem. Usually only one side is advocating against free speech, and it isn't generally the controversial speaker.

As for the controversial speakers, invites for speakers historically were not seen that way. They were seen as the university fulfilling its mission to give students the opportunity to encounter a wide variety of views. Furthermore that case demonstrates the problem. The financial problem for universities is that controversial speakers require security. And they require security because of the real threat of a radical mob of students causing physical harm. I'm going to go with the people who are actually trying to keep people from speaking here is the mob who is willing to support using violence to do so.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:56PM (#38120032)
How can speech infringe on the rights of others? Can you give an example?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:34PM (#38120514)
Shouting while others are talking, both literally and figuratively.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:58PM (#38120841)
> figuratively

Can you give an example?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by ericfrazier on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:05PM (#38120134)
Stochastic Terrorism
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by kps on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:28PM (#38119650)
“Intolerant” in this context does not refer to people with repugnant views, it refers to people who aim to suppress debate: “they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols.”
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by repelsteeltje on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:28PM (#38119642)
The question implies that I can affect intolerant views by choosing between being tolerant or not. :-)
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by wonttowont on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:29PM (#38119662)
People cite the headline of the "paradox of intolerance" without bothering to ingest the actually much more moderate idea behind it.

"I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise. But we should claim the right to suppress them if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols."

As much as you or I may disagree with them, it's totally absurd to claim that The Right (in the U.S.) is attempting to suppress The Left's arguments by "fists or pistols" when The Left is in the majority and most influential in almost all forms of media.

So the idea that The Left should be suppressing The Right under the principle of the "paradox of tolerance" is something Karl Popper called "most unwise" and that's putting it very mildly.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by AlexandrB on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:41PM (#38119835)
> As much as you or I may disagree with them, it's totally absurd to claim that The Right (in the U.S.) is attempting to suppress The Left's arguments by "fists or pistols" when The Left is in the majority and most influential in almost all forms of media.

???

It's the right that's encouraging people to show up with guns at LGBTQ events[1] and passing laws (enforced by an entity that has a monopoly on legal violence) effectively banning discussion of trans issues. The idea that "the left" has cultural dominance so it should be "anything goes" for right wing opinions is absurd.

[1] https://apnews.com/article/entertainment-eugene-oregon-educa...

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by wonttowont on Thursday November 02, 2023 @08:14PM (#38122394)
One can easily point to examples of armed protesters on The Left. But in no case is any group in the U.S. in a position to use force to prevent the other side from broadcasting their opinions.

The Right has Fox News and a few other things while The Left dominates almost all other media.

It's just completely laughable to argue that The Left is not getting a chance to "counter them by rational argument"

If The Right is winning some debates, and getting bad laws passed, that's just a reason for The Left to do a better job convincing people.

We're not living in 1920s Germany.

There's absolutely no excuse to resort to suppression, as that would be "most unwise" according to the very guy who put forth the "paradox of tolerance" idea that people love to simplify and distort.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by etchalon on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:48PM (#38119932)
There are people who show up to drag shows, armed.

They are not usually "on the left".

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by lightlyused on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:19PM (#38119511)
The intolerant have violated the social contract that binds our views on tolerance, so no we do not have to tolerate them.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by tekla on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:24PM (#38119589)
Yes
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by dmitrygr on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:29PM (#38119670)
God, I’m tired of this bullshit. The minute you don’t protect ALL opinions, you have no more freedom of thought or freedom of speech. Your “intolerance” is someone’s honest opinion. And their “intolerance” is yours!
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by nwiswell on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:46PM (#38119905)
It's not actually a paradox, it's just playing with semantics.

Wiktionary[1] defines "intolerant":

1. Unable or indisposed to tolerate, endure or bear.

2. Not tolerant; close-minded about new or different ideas; indisposed to tolerate contrary opinions or beliefs; impatient of dissent or opposition; denying or refusing the right of private opinion or choice in others; inclined to persecute or suppress dissent.

Bigotry (or discrimination, or prejudice), in general, is a subcategory of the broad definition #1. You are indisposed to tolerate a group of people, or a religion, or whatever.

Seeking to suppress speech or marginalize opinions (of any kind) falls under definition #2.

English might as well have two separate words for these two definitions, in case there is no "paradox". It's only a paradox if you seek to suppress speech from people who seek to suppress speech with their speech.

[1]: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/intolerant

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @07:17PM (#38121792)
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by jstarfish on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:46PM (#38119914)
Yes. That's literally what tolerance is. The only "paradox" is hypocrisy masquerading as ethics. Reframing tolerance of intolerance as a "problem" is just engineered rhetoric.

Heresy's track record does not lend itself to the idea that silencing views we disagree with is a practice worth continuing. After the Church, only dictators have ever insist on the necessity of censorship. The anti-speech demographic's interests neatly align with the most intolerant, most-abusive oppressors throughout history.

Catholics and Hitler-- that's the company you keep when you suggest speech needs limits. News flash: I don't have to like what you have to say. I'm expected to fucking deal with it. You can do it too.

The "words are violence" crowd sure throw a lot of words around, themselves, while arguing that others should not have the same right. Everything everyone else has to say is "hate speech!" How far the goalposts have moved from burning crosses, nooses and death threats.

Galileo was a heretic. Martin Luther was a heretic. That's the company the rest of us keep. Haters, the lot of us.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Kye on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:58PM (#38120066)
>> "Catholics and Hitler-- that's the company you keep when you suggest speech needs limits. News flash: I don't have to like what you have to say. I'm expected to fucking deal with it. You can do it too."

This is a model Godwinning. You don't see it much these days. I feel like I'm in a museum.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:24PM (#38120374)
Should they tolerate your intolerant views?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by hightrix on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:27PM (#38120407)
Let's take a more recent example to show how the statement "should you tolerate intolerant views" is meaningless or even harmful to the truth.

"COVID was leaked from a lab in Wuhan"

At various points in time in the last 4 years, this statement has been considered 1) hate speech 2) tin foil hat conspiracy 3) a possible scenario 4) a plausible scenario 5) a disputed fact that may or may not be true.

If we were to "not tolerate intolerant views" then there would have been no further discussion to get from stage 1 to stage 5 and the world would still believe that it was transmission by a rodent.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by axpy on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:53AM (#38125731)
The same statement in different contexts are interterpreted differently. Saying COVID came from China is not an problem but using the term "China virus" as a way to promote racism is problematic.

Same is true about the possible lab leak. In your example, it was originally hate speach because it was pulled by the media and some part of the population in a very racist way given only vague conjectures. I do think at that point it made sense to stop talking about it in the media because a it was not very well backed and of a low plausibility. It's just damn hard to strike the right balance when we are mostly geared toward emotional response. Same thing happened with vaccine and treatments.

I do think we need to be careful about proper communucation on some subject because of the high potential for misinterpretation. This is especially true when we are talking about highly technical subjects that might not be obvious to everyone.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by leereeves on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:12PM (#38123996)
Since you cite the paradox of tolerance, you should be familiar with the quote from Karl Popper, the philosopher who invented the concept:

> I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be unwise.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by saghm on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:34PM (#38119749)
What's ironic to me is that requiring colleges or websites or whatever to give literally anyone a platform seems like it's infringing on _their_ speech. The argument seems to be that "speech" includes "access to a platform to amplify one's view", but if that's true, then doesn't the owner of the platform have freedom over that "speech" as well? Forcing someone to use their power of speech to say things for others sounds much more like a violation of "freedom of speech" to me.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:45PM (#38119894)
Would your view be affected by whether…

- the university itself is hosting the speaker, versus a student group?

- the university receives taxpayer funding?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by saghm on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:23PM (#38120360)
> the university receives taxpayer funding?

No more than the fact that most households in the US received stimulus checks doesn't give me the right to demand time to pontificate to their family about whatever I want.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by threatofrain on Thursday November 02, 2023 @06:36PM (#38121325)
It depends. Ought a society be able to create a policy to allow an exception to speech liability to encourage the growth of platform companies? Or, when YT hosts a pirated version of Naruto, are they responsible?

Because then, in some sense, what's hosted on YT is not YT speaking. But in another confusing sense, society sometimes sees it that way, so if YT becomes known for hosting unpleasant things it will damage their reputation overall.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by saghm on Thursday November 02, 2023 @07:16PM (#38121783)
You're conflating several different things here: civil liability, intellectual property, and a constitutional right to free speech without government interference. If you say something damaging to someone else (or violate their IP, I guess), and they successfully sue for damages, that's not the government limiting your speech, it's the government protecting the rights of someone else, because your rights don't trump anyone else's. Not being allowed to speak at a university isn't the same because you don't have a fundamental right to speak on other's property; in the same way that "freedom of speech" doesn't give you blanket protections for infringing IP, freedom of assembly doesn't give you blanket protections for trespassing. In both cases, the key point is that you have the right to say _what_ you want, but _where_ you can say it still needs to avoid infringing on others rights.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by ashton314 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:24PM (#38119593)
> It's wrong to equate people abandoning free speech with people not wanting to host people with specific stances at a venue.

I agree.

There's a problem, though, when the venue is a university.

Universities are where the search for truth should be the foremost objective. Dogmatic politics should not govern what is true or not true—that is born out by evidence, discussion, and persuasion.

Consequently, we need opposing viewpoints at universities. If someone says something that you think is wrong then you should refute it, not silence it. If your position truly is more correct, then it will win in a contest of argument, testing, and persuasion.

The problem we're having is a growing imbalance in viewpoints present on campus. People are afraid of speaking their mind because of disproportionate wrath and consequences for exploring ideas deemed "taboo" by popular movements that are so certain they're right.

I just finished reading The Constitution of Knowledge: A Defense of Truth by Jonathan Rauch, and I recommend it to everyone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Rauch

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by saghm on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:08PM (#38120169)
> Universities are where the search for truth should be the foremost objective. Dogmatic politics should not govern what is true or not true—that is born out by evidence, discussion, and persuasion.

So why aren't the people who are angry at Harvard students for "cancelling" views equally outraged at the lack of pro-choice and LGBT views at Christian universities? If we're trying to avoid getting stuck due to dogma and search for the truth, I'd like to be given the opportunity to make the argument that claiming that any sort of social policy should be based on the belief that the omnipotent being who created the universe thousands of years ago told some people to write some stuff down lacks evidence, is unpersuasive, and impossible to have any reasonable discussion about.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by insickness on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:36PM (#38119778)
This is a purposeful misinterpretation of the question asked. They didn't ask whether a venue should or should not host people with a specific stance. They asked:

> should your school ALLOW or NOT ALLOW a speaker on campus who previously expressed the following idea

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rezmason on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:09PM (#38134327)
I'm not misinterpreting the FIRE survey, because I'm not interpreting the FIRE survey— I'm interpreting Nate Silver's stance in his article. After all, he's framing this as the left abandoning free speech.

Also, when you say "This is a purposeful misinterpretation", you're making an assumption that's disrespectful. What if I had misinterpreted the FIRE survey, as you suggest? Why do you believe I would do so purposefully? If you think I'm attacking something you're defending, I believe you've misjudged me.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by smsm42 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:21PM (#38119537)
You know perfectly well it's not about "selling them a megaphone". It's about shutting them up. We witnessed it with Parler - the whole network infrastructure was mobilized to not let them exist, in any way, in any form. And that's not the only case - spaces hosting dissenting views are constantly attacked with the aim to shut them down, permanently, forever. It's not about being "welcome everywhere", it's about not being able to exist anywhere.

> because they no longer assume (as older generations have) that adults can wield a megaphone responsibly.

No, because they assume they are entitled to decide who gets to speak and who doesn't, because they are good people and anybody who disagrees with them is evil and must be stomped into the ground (if necessary, physically).

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:33PM (#38119724)
> dissenting views

This has strong "oh you know the ones" energy.

https://twitter.com/ndrew_lawrence/status/105039166355267174...

Conservative: I have been censored for my conservative views

Me: Holy shit! You were censored for wanting lower taxes?

Con: LOL no...no not those views

Me: So....deregulation?

Con: Haha no not those views either

Me: Which views, exactly?

Con: Oh, you know the ones

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by smsm42 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:28PM (#38120409)
You know perfectly well that there are many views beyond "lower taxes" that are or were getting censored on large platforms. For example: origin of COVID, efficiency of masks and COVID mRNA vaccines, side effects of the above, necessity of lockdowns and vaccine mandates, election integrity, modern gender theory, gun rights (or anything related to guns), criticism of certain religions, and many others. You know, "the ones" that the government wants suppressed today - "the ones" that they get suppressed today. Your pretending that only something so heinous that ever their proponents do not dare to speak openly about it is getting censored is plain false, and I suspect you know it's false, you just like to pretend it's not because it allows you to cheaply dismiss all the concerns of your opponents as "the ones" and censor them while basking in your own moral superiority.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by the_snooze on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:32PM (#38119708)
There are cases where one group of students invites a speaker, and another group shows up to crash the event. That happened earlier this year at Stanford when their Federalist Society invited a Trump-appointed judge [1]. For all the justifiable problems with FedSoc, don't those students still have a right to host such an event in peace?

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/12/us/stanford-law-free-spee...

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by etchalon on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:45PM (#38119895)
Those students have a right to host the event and the other students have a right to protest the event. Behold, free speech.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by the_snooze on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:56PM (#38120024)
>Duncan, who has defended Louisiana’s gay-marriage ban and a North Carolina law restricting transgender people from using their preferred bathrooms, was repeatedly heckled by students and couldn’t speak more than a few words without interruption.

Would you consider this fair protest? It's a legally tricky issue [1], but I'm of the view that normalizing this leads to a dangerous social environment (e.g., shouting down LGBT speakers at their events).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler's_veto

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by etchalon on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:16AM (#38124450)
I don't think there is such a thing as a "fair protest". Protests are, by their nature, designed to be disruptive.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by xeckr on Thursday November 02, 2023 @03:58PM (#38119167)
So... who then gets to have a megaphone?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sanderjd on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:08PM (#38119328)
There are many ways to acquire a megaphone in 2023. Far more than ever before. But it is not one size fits all.

The thing that remains the most common thing to do is to petition an established platform with an established reputation to lend you one of theirs, eg. by applying for a job at a media network of some kind, or creating an account under the terms of service of a platform.

Another way is to build your own megaphone that only requires abiding by the much looser terms of service of an ISP or the email providers of subscribers or even just the mail system, but these require building your own audience from scratch.

And yes, the uber-wealthy can just buy a megaphone outright, which is definitely lame.

Most people will fail to acquire a megaphone in any of these ways, which is not surprising. It would be (is...) way too noisy with everyone having a megaphone screaming at one another, trying to be heard above the cacophony.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rezmason on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:03PM (#38119248)
Generally, the people who get one are: - the ones who buy one - the ones who borrow one - the ones who find one - the ones who make one

And if you hurt someone with a megaphone, you should expect to lose it.

In other words, a megaphone is just like every other thing on the planet.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by diob on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:09PM (#38119355)
Reminds me of my history teacher in 2008 telling me about the free speech zones that already existed to squash meaningful speech / protest. And regardless, the feds would bus you up and force you to leave cause what are rights. Just literally drop you hundreds of miles away cause what are you gonna do about it.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by smsm42 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:22PM (#38119561)
Good people, obviously. Or, whoever the mob on the closest college campus prefers to.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by atoav on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:21PM (#38119539)
You can give yours to whom you like, I can give mine to whom I like. If you seem reasonable and can talk about your idea of how the world should be without making up things and putting down people, I might just do it.

Karl Popper coind the term »paradox of intolerance«. A free society has (in order to remain free) to be intolerant towards intolerant people, otherwise those intolerant people will use the tolerance you give them to abolish the free society and therefore all tolerance.

So e.g. I would not give my megaphone to any faction that issues death threats to all their political enemies, especially not if their political enemies are chosen by culture, gender, race, political stance alone.

This in my eyes is not only a reasonable stance to take, but one that anybody who knows about the history of democracy around the world will find reasonable as well.

No I can assure you that the enemies of the free society also wouldn't give their megaphone to anybody. They just won't be honest about why. They will make up reasons why it is always the person of color, the women, the kid, the gay person, etc. whose books they need to burn.

So maybe as a liberal European I don't understand the whole US freedom of speech thing, but if one side decidesnot to give the megaphone to a screaming hateful holocaust denier and the other side literally sweeps school libraries to BURN BOOKS I don't have a hard time deciding which side is worse.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by tootie on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:23PM (#38119580)
Whoever grabs it? Nobody has a right to a megaphone.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by jasonlotito on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:13PM (#38119410)
Everyone has a megaphone already.

The better question is: why do you feel it's okay for me to force you to listen to my megaphone?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by xeckr on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:28PM (#38119640)
I will plug my ears if you're just generating noise with it.

But if we're in public, especially at a place which ostensibly exists for the purpose of exchanging ideas, then I will begin by assuming that you are trying to make some kind of point, and that you judged that this point is important enough to overcome the embarrassment of shouting through a megaphone to an audience that on average preferred you didn't.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by tootie on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:16PM (#38119462)
Especially asking college students about their college hosting speakers. That's literally their tuition money paying for it not to mention an indirect connection to their reputations.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rtsil on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:38PM (#38119801)
Agreed. Left-leaning students might not be so much against Free Speech than against being associated with controversial ideas (including some that they share). Twenty years ago, nobody outside the campus knew who the speakers were and what the guest lecture was about. Today, anything controversial will be on social media that very same day, and social reputation matters.

Do they really want to deplatform those ideas, or simply not share the same platform?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:28PM (#38120419)
It might be a student group paying for it on their own dime.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:05PM (#38119290)
Correct, free speech doesn't mean you should give everyone a free platform, especially at a school that you pay to attend!
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by seiferteric on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:22PM (#38119551)
Sure but inviting controversial speakers used to be seen as valuable to challenge ones beliefs on the off chance you might actually be wrong about something. Now it seems that thought never crosses their minds.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by mrguyorama on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:41PM (#38120611)
>valuable to challenge ones beliefs

Did US colleges bring in a lot of Pro-vietnam speakers?

If you want a marketplace of ideas, you have to be willing to accept that the market sometimes rejects ideas, good or not, for the right reasons or not.

Any market can warp, for any length of time. That's like a fundamental flaw of markets. In financial markets we try to regulate away the negative and flawed parts of market theory, occasionally succeeding. Should we regulate the free marketplace of ideas?

Free speech doesn't mean everyone listens to you. Free speech means the government doesn't put you in jail for saying something.

There's this weird claim that you can somehow define "free speech" to be more applicable than just limiting government, but if you limit my right to react to speech in any way, how is that freedom? If I react by never associating with you ever again, and telling all my friends that you are an asshole, and should be avoided at all costs, and they listen and tell their friends because they trust my opinion, and on and on until nobody likes you and nobody wants to listen to your speech, who's rights were violated?

"Freedom of speech" should not mean "I owe you attention"

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by seiferteric on Thursday November 02, 2023 @06:01PM (#38120873)
> Free speech doesn't mean everyone listens to you.

The article is mainly about speakers on campuses. No one is forcing you to attend a speech. The issue is that people show up anyway to try and shut it down. That is a problem.

I am struggling to understand who is forcing anyone to listen to anything?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @07:17PM (#38121796)
The issue today is it is rare that these speakers are operating in good faith. It's painfully obvious to many that many "controversial" speakers on both sides of the political aisle are only intentionally being controversial, rather than holding radical beliefs that happen to be controversial. They're trolls, basically.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by smsm42 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:24PM (#38119592)
Paying to attend a school does not mean owning the school. People who want to hear the speaker also paid to attend, but somehow their money is not as green. Unless somebody promised them when they paid that they will never ever hear a word that may disturb them or be in the vicinity of a person who they disagree with - which I am sure not even the most woke college ever would be willing to put in writing - paying for education does not mean having a veto on everything happening on campus.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by ofslidingfeet on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:03PM (#38119260)
If that's the argument, we should pull public funding then. More generally, I actually sincerely support the concept of free speech, so I want people to have free speech. Since that is my position, it's hard for me to see much use in figuring out all the times I should be allowed to restrict someone's speech.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by campbel on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:42PM (#38119851)
Are you suggesting not providing a platform is the same as restricting someones free speech?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by atoav on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:28PM (#38119661)
You pretend here that the public has no interest OR isn't allowed to have any. That is false. It is e.g. in the public interest to sustain our democratic free order so we can remain to live in a free society, where no wannabe dictator controls the markets or applies the laws as he pleases. It is also in our interest that the truth gets more stage than lies and fearmongering.

Now maybe you can draw the conclusion yourself why supporting and showcasing opinions that threaten said democratic free order don't have to be supported by the public. If the public does support that, it is merely a courtesy or a misunderstood idea of tolerance.

But collectively as a society we live under a set of rules and are given a set of freedoms, all of which you can like or scoff at. But what you cannot do is demand the freedoms to then spout opinions about abolishing the very freedoms that enabled you to speak. No free society for example has to support the spread of the ideas of the likes of ISIS. In fact there have been multiple nations that even went into armed conflicts precisely on those grounds (if we ignore other geopolitical interests for a moment). That being said, what if in the West there was something akin to ISIS? Should we invest our public money into having their speech amplified? Just because their speech needs to be heard?

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Nasrudith on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:02PM (#38119246)
That at the end is a highly dangerous and paternalistic assumption. Deciding that adults "can't be using their rights responsibly". Seriously it is downright stereotypical CCP justification for shooting and torturing protesters. That said dissent is intrinsically "irresponsible" because of the "potential damage" to the "harmony" of the state.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rezmason on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:04PM (#38119269)
The megaphone isn't your right. You're confusing it, again and again, with speech. The megaphone isn't speech, and you aren't entitled to it.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Nasrudith on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:30PM (#38119688)
Then I guess the Supreme Court has been very confused for centuries of case law. Because they have had press and speech as synonymous.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:38PM (#38119803)
I think you have it confused.

You have the right to publish almost whatever you want.

But nobody is required to give you a platform. Whether that platform is a social media site or a stage and a microphone.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sophistsworld on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:06PM (#38119304)
I think it's very interesting that you keep mentioning megaphones when one manifestation of whats said in TFA is left wing activists literally shouting down speakers that had been invited to speak at their universities.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:07PM (#38119327)
What does that have to do with their mention of megaphones?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sophistsworld on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:09PM (#38119347)
Because they are using megaphones to do so.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by roflyear on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:10PM (#38119372)
"Freedom of speech" is not "equity of speech" - I think this is all OP is trying to say, and I agree with it.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sophistsworld on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:04PM (#38119276)
There are a few possibilities how a comment like yours could come to be in the year 2023 about a topic like this.

One is ignorance.

It's possible you simple don't know what the article is about. That left wing activists are now routinely shouting down or otherwise harassing invited speakers that they disagree with.

That, in the broader context of the topic, you are not aware that the USG has been dictating who and what to silence to Facebook and Twitter.

That you never heard that the UK now records 3000+ arrests per year for social media postings. Most recently a man who was wondering why there are so many palistine flags in his town.

Well, if that's the case, you should read more and post less.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rezmason on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:12PM (#38119397)
Your assumptions about who I am and what I know bother me.

Why do you equate me with the USG or the UK? Why do you assume I condone these actions you're describing? You can answer these questions, but they're rhetorical.

It's weird that a moderator* is telling me to post less in the comments section of an article about free speech being under threat, in a conversation about the nature of free speech. But I think we agree that we each have the protected right to our thoughts and words, but not the right to post them here.

Edit: I may misunderstand what a green name on Hacker News means. Are you a moderator, or a VIP?

Edit 2: *Oh my god, it's the opposite: green names are new people to the platform. You didn't exist half an hour ago. That's the last time I reply to mentholated flamebait.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:14PM (#38119435)
> Edit: I may misunderstand what a green name on Hacker News means. Are you a moderator, or a VIP?

Account less than 2 weeks old.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sophistsworld on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:20PM (#38119530)
Very few people on the pro free speech side are saying they should be given soap boxes for free. On the other hand the "protected right to our thoughts and words" is under major assault as my examples show. Redirecting the debate from the later to the former could be confusion born out of ignorance or be bad faith.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by rezmason on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:24PM (#38119586)
I'm not ignorant or acting in bad faith just for disagreeing with you. You can inspect my stance and speculate on where we agree and disagree, or you can ignore me. I'm choosing to ignore you.

But first: welcome to somewhat-anonymous online discourse. I sincerely hope you stick around. Stay hydrated!

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by etchalon on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:25PM (#38119607)
The majority of the "pro-free speech"'s concerns seem related to their entitlement to a consequence free soap box. De-platforming, shadow-banning, moderation etc. are the heart of their current fight.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by campbel on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:46PM (#38119913)
Exactly, the goal posts have moved quite a ways from "free speech" being related to government censorship.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by davidw on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:29PM (#38119672)
> mentholated flamebait

The whole discussion aside, that's one of the funnier things I've read about HN as a platform, and I've been here quite a while.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by kgwxd on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:49PM (#38119945)
I laughed so hard, I'm creating a carton of mentholated accounts to upvote it 200 more times.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by moribvndvs on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:15PM (#38119447)
They aren’t a mod, it’s a brand new account they made 18 minutes ago to shitpost you.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:16PM (#38119461)
> to try and flame you

More generously, they just have an opinion they don't want tied to their possibly-public-identity main account.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by sophistsworld on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:22PM (#38119550)
Why is it a shitpost?
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by amanaplanacanal on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:51PM (#38119968)
> the USG has been dictating who and what to silence to Facebook and Twitter.

No. They haven’t. The people that you listened to that said that are lying, for political purposes.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by esdf on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:33AM (#38125237)
Perhaps not as extremely as that statement may imply but I wouldn't say it is inaccurate with this in consideration:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34142030

https://www.thefp.com/p/how-twitter-rigged-the-covid-debate

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by ars on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:52PM (#38119982)
> It's wrong to equate people abandoning free speech with people not wanting to host people with specific stances at a venue.

So instead the title should be Conservatives are more willing to host people they disagree with?

I'm not really sure your argument helps your case very much.

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by chrismcb on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:57PM (#38120041)
Very little of "cancel culture"has you do with being "welcome anywhere by default." The problem with cancel culture is the punishment outweighs the "crime." Some people who have been "cancelled" (cancelled meaning they lost their job, or a gig, or something similar) a guy sitting in a company vehicle, cracking his knuckles. A drink singer talking to his best friend in an empty alley in the middle of the night. Other people who have said something on social media (now, or ten years ago)
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by nerdix on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:49PM (#38120713)
I'm not sure about the specific examples mentioned.

But there used to be an adage about mixing religion and politics with business. That adage exists because there has always been the risk of ostracization when sharing political and religious opinions publicly. Contrary to popular belief, that is not some new phenomenon. It's just that social media made it more likely that someone will see your political opinions (thus increasing the chances of ostracization..you are broadcasting your opinions to the world after all) and made the consequences more visible (so you hear about that guy that was fired for saying the wrong thing today whereas 30 years ago you would not have).

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by threatofrain on Thursday November 02, 2023 @06:09PM (#38120977)
I think the disagreement is on whether something even deserves to be considered a moral crime, and not whether the punishment fits any crime.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by Georgelemental on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:26PM (#38120397)
There is a difference between:

- A private organization deciding not to invest its private resources into hosting a particular speaker

- A university that receives a fortune in government funding forbidding a student group from independently inviting a speaker to campus

Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by tlogan on Thursday November 02, 2023 @05:49PM (#38120719)
And this is how freedom dies.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by alienicecream on Thursday November 02, 2023 @06:27PM (#38121202)
Oh good, young left leaning people anyways have the answers, and they're always the right answers.
Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble by belorn on Thursday November 02, 2023 @06:54PM (#38121540)
> In my opinion, the people who blast "cancel culture" are often the people who tacitly assume that they are welcome everywhere by default. That's not anyone's right.

I would say that a very large part of modern society and praised historical rebellion against oppression has been about making everyone welcome everywhere by default. Religion, culture, and political views has all been central battlegrounds where people tried multiple times to keep people separated and then when that failed institutionalize rules where people must be welcome everywhere by default.

US law is a bit fixated on making free speech about federal law, but individual states have even there illustrated that anti-discrimination do also apply to people outside of government. The US-specific legal trick is here to define specific speech to be directly associated with "protected classes". That is a nice trick, but is in practice indistinguishable from just extending free speech to areas outside of government. Other places like the EU don't go that route and simply define free speech as a human right with the specifics of enforcement given to each country to mostly define for themselves.