Re:Free Speech Is in Trouble
by nwiswell on Thursday November 02, 2023 @04:46PM
(#38119905)
It's not actually a paradox, it's just playing with semantics.
Wiktionary[1] defines "intolerant":
1. Unable or indisposed to tolerate, endure or bear.
2. Not tolerant; close-minded about new or different ideas; indisposed to tolerate contrary opinions or beliefs; impatient of dissent or opposition; denying or refusing the right of private opinion or choice in others; inclined to persecute or suppress dissent.
Bigotry (or discrimination, or prejudice), in general, is a subcategory of the broad definition #1. You are indisposed to tolerate a group of people, or a religion, or whatever.
Seeking to suppress speech or marginalize opinions (of any kind) falls under definition #2.
English might as well have two separate words for these two definitions, in case there is no "paradox". It's only a paradox if you seek to suppress speech from people who seek to suppress speech with their speech.
Wiktionary[1] defines "intolerant":
1. Unable or indisposed to tolerate, endure or bear.
2. Not tolerant; close-minded about new or different ideas; indisposed to tolerate contrary opinions or beliefs; impatient of dissent or opposition; denying or refusing the right of private opinion or choice in others; inclined to persecute or suppress dissent.
Bigotry (or discrimination, or prejudice), in general, is a subcategory of the broad definition #1. You are indisposed to tolerate a group of people, or a religion, or whatever.
Seeking to suppress speech or marginalize opinions (of any kind) falls under definition #2.
English might as well have two separate words for these two definitions, in case there is no "paradox". It's only a paradox if you seek to suppress speech from people who seek to suppress speech with their speech.
[1]: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/intolerant