News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:30PM (#38103613)
BLS says US median programmer salary in the US was just under $100,000 last year.

20 years of a normal US tech salary won't let you retire. A top-few-percent one, maybe.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by mrits on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:34PM (#38103673)
That was a competitive salary when I started in 2005.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:48PM (#38103899)
Well, it'd also represent a raise for about 50% of programmers in 2022.

[EDIT] Further:

"The lowest 10 percent earned less than $54,310, and the highest 10 percent earned more than $157,690." (in 2022, still).

The ones who can retire in 20 years are making (ballpark) top-5%-of-field wages most or all of that time.

[EDIT EDIT] I didn't pick the best category for this, but the numbers only skew up 25ish % for the most-relevant one. Not a single BLS computer job category has a median particularly close to "retire in 20 years at this income" money. FAANG, finance, and a small segment of the startup market that's in that same category—yeah. Almost all the rest? No.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by dboreham on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:53PM (#38103979)
They classified people we don't think of as programmers as programmers. Classic job stats mistake.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:58PM (#38104071)
Ok, sure, that's one category and some of the others do have a higher median. Some of what we think of as "programmers" or "developers" will actually land in other categories, and also some we don't, will too.

https://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/...

But still, even the top-median category, "Computer and Information Research Scientists", doesn't have "retire in 20 years" median wages.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by polyomino on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:55PM (#38103998)
What's the distribution of experience though? In a fast growing field, most will be early in career, which will push this metric down relative to established fields with little growth.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:03PM (#38104160)
The question's whether 20 years of a "competitive" tech salary is enough money to retire.

I think one must have a very-skewed, bubble-bound definition of "competitive" for that to be plausibly true. Programming jobs don't pay enough to grant easy-mode early retirement for most of our field—even in the US.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by woobar on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:59PM (#38104095)
First, Computer Programmer is a strange occupation. According to BLS there are just 147K positions in the US.

Instead I'd suggest looking at Software Developers (1.5M positions) with median income at $127K.

Second, by definition median is not a competitive salary. I'd think top 25% of devs are getting competitive salary. Which is $161K [1]

20 years of savings at 30% of income will get you $2M. Which is not a fat retirement, but still doable.

[1] https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes151252.htm#nat

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:09PM (#38104275)
> Second, by definition median is not a competitive salary.

Yes, it is. For the field as a whole? Yes, it absolutely is. For specific segments of it? No. Some of those are higher. And others are lower.

> 20 years of savings at 30% of income will get you $2M. Which is not a fat retirement, but still doable.

Healthcare complicates early retirement badly in the US. Retire at (say) 45 with only $2m in the bank and you are... gambling. To put it mildly. Even if you live reasonably frugally.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by rootusrootus on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:29PM (#38104642)
> Healthcare complicates early retirement badly in the US. Retire at (say) 45 with only $2m in the bank and you are... gambling. To put it mildly. Even if you live reasonably frugally.

100% this. I'm almost 50, and as I look towards retirement, I think I should try to find a cushy job that'll last me to 65 without causing too much stress, because until you qualify for Medicare it's really hard to afford health insurance premiums unless you're fashionably wealthy.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by manzanarama on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:52PM (#38105037)
Really, what is a good ballpark for a family of 4? Is it like 5k a month?
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by woobar on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:58PM (#38105125)
I do not agree. If someone said "bringing regular salary in tech" I'd agree that median should be used. "Competitive" means we are talking about higher percentile within the field.

> Healthcare complicates early retirement

You don't have to stay in the US when retired. With 4% SWR one will be getting $80K/year. Which is more than median household income in the US and majority of the other countries. I am not advocating retiring at 45 with $2M, I am just saying it is not that crazy.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by ryandrake on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @06:27PM (#38106229)
I've always considered "competitive" to be a signal of "as close as possible to our average competitor". It doesn't mean good or high. When a job offer says "competitive salary", it's not a good sign. I assume they mean around average, maybe a little bit below average. If the job offer was offering a significantly great salary, the company would boast about it as more than "competitive."
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by deathanatos on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @07:06PM (#38106651)
"Competitive" is job listing filler IMO. Everybody is "competitive". I've seen "competitive" salaries wanting me to take a >30% pay cut.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by happytoexplain on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:51AM (#38114276)
Yes, absolutely - though it's a difference from colloquial English, where it does normally mean "good"/"better than average". Businesses just use it as a weasel-word.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by FireBeyond on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @06:35PM (#38106334)
It is also not going to be the easiest, emigrating to a country with a robust healthcare and social safety net as a retiree in your 40s.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by woobar on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @09:46PM (#38107948)
A lot of cheap countries provide good healthcare for a fraction of american costs. Also, not sure why one need a safety net when they already have a stable income which is multiple of what any such net can provide.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by shiroiuma on Thursday November 02, 2023 @12:41AM (#38109073)
Very true. This is a very big reason I left the US in my 40s, while I'm still working and can acquire permanent residency and later citizenship by having a job with a local company. I didn't want to be stuck in the US when I'm at retirement age and healthcare costs are unaffordable even with a decent nest egg, where a major procedure could wipe out all my savings.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @08:19PM (#38107252)
> "Competitive" means we are talking about higher percentile within the field.

This is not a standard usage of the term in this context.

[EDIT] If you don't believe me, I'd encourage searching "competitive salary definition"

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by cyberax on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @07:39PM (#38106954)
> Healthcare complicates early retirement badly in the US. Retire at (say) 45 with only $2m in the bank and you are... gambling.

Uhh... Why? A very good health insurance is about $10k a year (PSA: the open enrollment period for 2024 has started today).

Even if you are unlucky to get a chronic condition that needs expensive care, that's still capped at around $6k a year by the out-of-pocket maximum.

So that's $16k a year per person maximum, over 20 years (until Medicare eligibility) that's $320k. If you want to include family, that's going to be around $500k. And that's the worst case.

It's going to be a huge chunk of the expense, but not insurmountable.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by xnx on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @07:58PM (#38107115)
Heathcare could [again] get twice as expensive in the next 20 years: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/price-changes-consumer-go...
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by ndriscoll on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:04PM (#38108070)
As a retiree, you can probably arrange to qualify for a free silver plan under the ACA. There are no asset tests, only income. This is true for other subsidies too. If you've mostly accumulated assets in excluded locations, you can also qualify for college tuition subsidies.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by cyberax on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @07:34PM (#38106921)
Heh. I worked at a startup, and they were sponsoring a Green Card for me.

They had to raise my salary to $165k because this was the _minimal_ allowed competitive salary for my position ("Senior Software Developer"), and the USCIS doesn't take stock grants into account. This was 2 years ago.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by randomdata on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:22PM (#38105483)
The median income is ~$30,000. That means you have ~$70,000 to invest each year. If we assume a 5% rate of return, you'll have ~$2MM after 20 years. At the same rate, that will continue to provide you $100,000 each year in retirement. Bad luck can happen, but generally speaking retirement should have been quite easy with that kind of income.
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by hotnfresh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:41PM (#38105748)
Median topped $40k in 2022.

The (just under) $100k is pre-tax.

You won't get much social security when you hit "retirement age" if you retire after only 20 years of working at that level of income, so you'll need more savings at that age than others do.

$100k/yr is a 5% withdrawal rate on $2 million, which might be a "safe" rate at normal retirement age (debatable) but is risky as hell if you start doing it at 45 and don't plan to die in your 60s.

If you've been saving that aggressively (as cash/investments), you won't own your own house, or at least, you definitely won't be anywhere near paying it off. That significantly raises your costs in retirement.

You have significant risk from healthcare costs until you hit medicare age (and even then...). You're probably looking at $5k-10k a year in premiums (individual) at age 45+, and still five figures of annual risk exposure despite already paying that much.

Retiring on $2m at 45 would be very likely to end in failure, even as an individual supporting only yourself.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by randomdata on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @07:32PM (#38106898)
> $100k/yr is a 5% withdrawal rate on $2 million

Yes, that's what the previous comment said. Of course, you don't need anywhere close to $100k, so you would still be reinvesting the bulk of it, just as you did throughout your career. That will see your returns continue to increase as you grow older.

> you won't own your own house, or at least, you definitely won't be anywhere near paying it off.

You'd have no trouble buying a home on a $30k income 20 years ago. They could barely give houses away back then.

> You have significant risk from healthcare costs

You still have $70k to play with each year. If you have to miss a year of reinvestment it won't hamstring you that much. As before, bad luck happens. It is possible you are the unlucky one. But generally speaking the money is there.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by ryan_lane on Thursday November 02, 2023 @12:28AM (#38108998)
> You'd have no trouble buying a home on a $30k income 20 years ago. They could barely give houses away back then.

I made a bit more than that 20 years ago and can guarantee you it wasn't anywhere near enough money to buy a house. Finding affordable apartments to rent on that salary was difficult enough. I lived in New Orleans, which wasn't a high cost of living city at the time. Maybe if you lived in the middle of nowhere that would be doable, but almost certainly not in a city.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday November 02, 2023 @01:20PM (#38116912)
their username is randomdata, not accuratedata.

my experience agrees with yours.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by fragmede on Thursday November 02, 2023 @12:34AM (#38109032)
> You'd have no trouble buying a home on a $30k income 20 years ago.

You're absolutely right - the banks would give you a loan you couldn't actually afford. I seem to recall this leading to some sort of financial problem in 2008, unfortunately.

Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by adra on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:35PM (#38105677)
I love your optimism. Some may be able to live off software at 30k/yr making 100/yr "somewhere", but not most places. My rent started at around 40% of my take home and adding taxes alone, my pay rate was well under this 70% fantasy which doesn't even begin to address any other "incidental" living expenses like food, transport, children, elderly, school loans, etc......
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much by randomdata on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @08:04PM (#38107154)
> My rent started at around 40% of my take home

You were paying ~$3,000 per month for rent 20 years ago? I remember renting a place 22 years ago for $250 per month.

Maybe you were in some super insane cost of living area, but if that's the case, why would you accept just an average developer salary? Average salaries are for average places.