News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by reset2023 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:01PM (#38003667)
what's the point of a self driving car? There's too much money going to things that aren't needed.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by fletchowns on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:08PM (#38003766)
Is this just a troll comment?

- Zero traffic fatalities would be nice - Reduced congestion/traffic, people can get to places faster - Never having to worry about parking again - No more need for cars parked on streets, more space & safer for cyclists and pedestrians - Reduced income requirements for those that need access to a car

There are countless benefits. The transition period to get there will be a little tumultuous, but we'll get there eventually as a society

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by stfp on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:14PM (#38003873)
Except...

They won't reduce congestion and traffic, because people won't have to drive they'll be OK with being on the road longer. You just hang out in your living room on wheels.

Parking... Where are the cars going to park exactly? How far from the restaurants and homes etc? Won't the extra trips from/to parking lots create more traffic?

Reduced income requirements, that's a new one to me. These cars will have more tech that's more expensive to build and maintain. How does that make them cheaper?

50%+ of car trips are less than three miles... as a society what we need is a way to make those trips without cars.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by lamontcg on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:23PM (#38004029)
> 50%+ of car trips are less than three miles... as a society what we need is a way to make those trips without cars.

then you've only fixed 50% of car trips, and much less than 50% of vehicle miles and probably not done much at all for highway deaths.

all the urban bike infrastructure in the world isn't going to do much for rural and interstate problems.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by mhardcastle on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:11PM (#38004770)
Traffic is a function of how many cars go through a road/intersection per unit time, which is reduced if cars keep shorter following distances, which self-driving cars can do because of faster reaction times.

In the extreme, imagine if a light turns green and all cars in line accelerate at the same time. Intersections would let through a lot more cars.

Or think of freeway speeds where the length of a car is near-negligible. A one-second following distance means almost 60 cars pass a given point in a minute, versus almost 30 cars per minute for a two-second following distance.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by fletchowns on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @04:29AM (#38010578)
> They won't reduce congestion and traffic, because people won't have to drive they'll be OK with being on the road longer. You just hang out in your living room on wheels.

Traffic flows would become well coordinated and way more efficient, no more accordion effect and accidents to cause traffic jams.

> Parking... Where are the cars going to park exactly? How far from the restaurants and homes etc? Won't the extra trips from/to parking lots create more traffic?

It could be several miles from where the passengers are being dropped off. See above for why traffic won't be worse.

> Reduced income requirements, that's a new one to me. These cars will have more tech that's more expensive to build and maintain. How does that make them cheaper?

Of course new technology is expensive initially. Over time, it becomes cheaper and cheaper. Just like air travel, personal computers, broadband internet, etc.

> 50%+ of car trips are less than three miles... as a society what we need is a way to make those trips without cars.

More efficient use of the roadways from self driving cars would create opportunities for improvements in this area as well. Dedicated protected bike lanes, for example.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by starttoaster on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:10PM (#38003801)
Besides what the other user pointed out, there are tens of millions of people driving an hour or more every day just to get to work, and that time sink might feel a bit more bearable if you could relax and do whatever you wanted during that time rather than focus on all the obstacles around you. I don't know that the state of self-driving vehicles will be quite there in my lifetime, but some time in the future they will be, if we keep making progress on them.

You might like driving. For many, driving is stressful.

This is besides the point someone else brought up about how notoriously bad at driving humans can be, and the capacity for how much safer an automated car could be when the tech is matured.

Public transit like efficient railroad infrastructure across the US would be even nicer, but I've about given up on that for the USA. They're doing self driving cars because we sunk too much money in roadway infrastructure (sunk cost fallacy.)

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by stfp on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:17PM (#38003910)
> that time sink might feel a bit more bearable if you could relax and do whatever you wanted during that time rather than focus on all the obstacles around you

We could use... trains & buses. Self-driving trains and buses!

But self-driving individual cars, because they will make the time more bearable, will induce even more driving, which is the opposite of what we want.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by starttoaster on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:27PM (#38004103)
Oh, I completely agree. This is big tech solving a problem for humans, but ignoring a larger problem for humanity.

To give the benefit of the doubt, my assumption is that they're solving it this way because the road infrastructure and market for cars already exists. You'd see big tech working on automating public transit if states actually started improving their public transit infrastructure.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by tomschwiha on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:03PM (#38003700)
Who needs steam machines?

Progress is always good IMO.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by phlakaton on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:18PM (#38003918)
If you define progress as positive development, sure. But then that's just tautological.

If you mean it more generally, MattY would like to have a word. https://www.slowboring.com/p/the-techno-optimists-fallacy

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by stfp on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:23PM (#38004040)
Defining progress isn't that simple.

Self-driving cars isn't progress. Larger and heavier cars isn't progress. Cars with insane eye-searing LED headlights isn't progress.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:06PM (#38003742)
Progress can go in the wrong direction. Self-driving cars are an elitist attempt to avoid funding a far better solution: Trains.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by starttoaster on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:11PM (#38003816)
Better railroads would be a far better solution. But I think getting there will take a lot of convincing in America. So much money has gone into road infrastructure that I have to imagine there's a lot of sunk cost fallacy at play.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:16PM (#38003892)
Oh certainly, sunk cost, the industries entirely dependent on cars, etc. But we regularly have to rebuild those roads anyways, and how much money is being thrown away trying to make cars less awful?

There's a rural cost/benefit that ensures we will never not need cars, probably. But I can't fathom why eight lane interstates exist. If we can justify that many lanes of road traffic, we can certainly replace six of them with a train.

Self-driving trains? Easy. And no matter how hard you try, even the most efficient electric car will never end up greener than a train on a per user basis.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by ravenstine on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:07PM (#38003748)
The point is being able to read a book during your commute without getting assaulted or robbed.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by stfp on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:26PM (#38004088)
Yup. Most transit users are murdered while reading books on their way to work.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by hbrav on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:13PM (#38003852)
The phenomenon of viewing public transit as somewhere that you'll be assaulted or robbed is an incredible indictment of the US. I don't know how true it is though.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by add-sub-mul-div on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:31PM (#38004162)
People are swayed by anecdotes and dramatic headlines and politics and look for reasons to be afraid. People don't know how to measure risk in their day to day lives. It's an indictment of something, but not public transportation.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by robswc on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:45PM (#38004366)
Assaulted and robbed are the least of my worries. Its a small chance but its there. What I hate about public transit is the public part.

I've witnessed tons of anti-social behavior over the years taking the DC metro and honestly, have never been comfortable ever since I was a child and got stuck between two drunk men arguing after a baseball game. I was feeling claustrophobic and could even feel the spit hit my face. The car was packed and no room to really get away from it. I think its gotten better but I wouldn't know as I haven't used it in years.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by skyyler on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:08PM (#38003756)
Can't you do that in most countries with public transit?
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by add-sub-mul-div on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:19PM (#38003944)
Not if you want to go along with the trend of portraying cities as more dangerous than they really are.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by starttoaster on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:13PM (#38003848)
> without getting assaulted or robbed.

I think is the qualifier the other user put in to disqualify public transit. But yes, ideally.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by cryptoz on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:03PM (#38003692)
Something like 30,000 Americans alone are killed every year in car accidents. I think the primary idea is to reduce the constant death on the road by making machines that are safer at driving than humans. The toll that car accidents have on society is honestly unconscionable.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by hristov on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:06PM (#38003747)
That is a good point. A secondary benefit, is a self driving car can literally give most workers that commute about an hour per day of their lives back. For some people it will be two to three hours.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by klyrs on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:13PM (#38003855)
If your favorite hobby is sitting by yourself, strapped to a chair, sure, you get your time back. But the reason I'm allergic to commuting is that I prefer to spend time with my family.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by mrguyorama on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:16PM (#38003901)
How is being stuck in a small box for an hour "getting that hour back"? Most people don't want to read a book during their commute, they want to have less commute, so they can do actual things they want, like play with their kids or cook dinner or enjoy a movie in the comfort of their own home.

"Fixing" commutes by making everyone sit alone in their car while it does the driving part as if that's the problem with an hour long commute, is the single dumbest way to make cities better.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by stfp on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:32PM (#38004189)
We need to stop the deaths now, not in 15 years if and when the tech becomes good enough and adopted etc.

Every other country has seen a reduction in the number of deaths over time, without self driving cars.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by nvy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:08PM (#38003773)
If Americans were serious about reducing car deaths they'd ban gigantic pickups and SUVs with blind spots big enough to fit a Volkswagen. They'd ban cars from city centers and build bicycle highways. They'd invest in convenient rail infrastructure.

Instead we've got "it's a car but you can doomscroll while on your 45 minute commute and we harvest your data to sell ads".

This has nothing to do with public safety.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by HDThoreaun on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:16PM (#38003890)
This is the same mistake gun control advocates who want to take away guns make. Yes, Americans want to reduce death. But they want freedom more.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by farnsworth on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:25PM (#38004063)
When transit is good you can ride it wherever you want to, and you can do it drunk. That's my freedom
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by HDThoreaun on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:32PM (#38004179)
I do not own a car. Love living in a transit forward city. But I understand the reality, that is not a real solution for most Americans who live in suburbs where good transit is just not possible due to the original layout. Instead of trying to shoehorn a solution that isn't practical we should focus on ones that potentially are.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by farnsworth on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:45PM (#38005286)
Everybody says that transit isn't practical because suburbs exist. But nobody said that cars were impractical before suburbs existed (well probably some people did and it turns out they were right)
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by nvy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:22PM (#38004002)
It's just so stereotypically American to say "here's a problem society faces" and then in the same breath pretend the solution is to enrich the CEOs of a handful of tech companies peddling solutions that may or may not even ever succeed.

>But they want freedom more.

Sure, it's a very individualistic society where one's personal convenience is more important than societal good. But let's call a spade a spade and not pretend that self driving car companies are selfless benefactors out to solve pedestrian deaths.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by sergiotapia on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:13PM (#38003847)
- No more traffic

- No more car insurance

- Cheap transportation to work/school

- Less deaths on the road

There is plenty to gain from having true driverless vehicles accessible to the public.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by stfp on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:30PM (#38004148)
Meanwhile in reality: - More traffic due to induced demand as sitting in traffic becomes comfortable - Self-driving subscription in addition to all other car costs - More car-centric infrastructure needed as we realize that self-driving cars can't be made fast and safe for mixed street use with pedestrians, bikes etc.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by occz on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:06PM (#38004691)
I highly doubt driverless cars will have an actually positive impact with regards to reducing traffic, nor that they can go uninsured, nor that they will be a cheap option for commuting.

They might be safer than human drivers, but there are already superior solutions to that in the form of transportation systems that are not overly focused on cars.