News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by wongarsu on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:22PM (#37989538)
One option would be to just treat everyone. Every commercial pilot could have to complete 20 hours of therapy a year, with strict confidentiality so they can be open without jeopardizing their career. Or two mandatory hours per month with a psychologist, or whatever scheme works best.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by veqq on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:40PM (#37989800)
Therapy can often create problems ex nihilio if there isn't something obvious to handle e.g.: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000579672...

> eight-session DBT skills-training intervention (‘WISE Teens) (n = 563) or class-as-per-usual (n = 508). On average, the ‘WISE Teens’ intervention did not improve outcomes with significant deteriorations or null effects observed across outcomes relative to class-as-per-usual immediately post-intervention. The largest deteriorations were observed for depressive (d = −0.22; 95% CI = −0.35, −0.08) and anxiety symptoms (d = −0.28; 95%CI - = −0.41, −0.14

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by stevenpetryk on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:46PM (#37989872)
"ex nihilo" means "outta nowhere" for the normies like me.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by opan on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:19AM (#37996154)
This was probably the first time I saw the phrase used for something besides referring to the Minecraft mod that's used for skyblock packs.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by bmay on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:06PM (#37990134)
That study was done on early adolescents. How generalizable are those results to adult, white-collar workers?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by lazide on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:19PM (#37990304)
many adults have experienced the same. or say they have, in my experience. as to if it’s denial vs reality? good luck untangling the biases in any attempt to figure that out!

‘if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’ vs a world with a large segment of mental disorders basically resulting from someone having an existential need for something to not be broken (and no tools or time/resources to fix it).

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by colechristensen on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:45PM (#37993147)
It’s a sort of placebo effect. Diagnosing someone can create or amplify the effects of the diagnosis.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by kelseyfrog on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:38PM (#37993571)
Any treatment has iatrogenic potential, even therapy.

The commonly accepted rate of iatrogenic harm from therapy is 5%[1]. The six listed mechanisms don't involve diagnosis.

1. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-...

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by polartx on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:56AM (#38000063)
My purely anecdotal experience—my [then] wife began seeing a therapist to help with her seasonal depression. She didn’t work, and spent a lot of time on social media. Her therapist encouraged her to ‘choose you, put yourself first, etc’, this encouragement gave way to her early midlife crisis, infidelity, divorce, substance abuse, and her losing custody of our young children.

Therapy can very helpful to many people. I also think therapy can be equally detrimental, (or more-so) to many people. Therapists are people doing a job. Some people are bad at their jobs. A patient implicitly trusting a therapist giving harmful advice can have far reaching, long lasting consequences.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by willcipriano on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:19PM (#38001358)
I had a similar experience. Things were bad before but therapy increased my wife's (now separated) bad behaviors and instilled her with a newfound confidence that doesn't really fit her life situation.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by colinng on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:41AM (#38022462)
It also led to MRR (Monthly Recurring Revenue) and playing God for the therapist. Any way to out evil practitioners like that?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by SoftTalker on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:28PM (#37989626)
It's an option, but nobody will be excited about it. There's already a pilot shortage. (20 hours of paid time not flying a plane) x (all the pilots who fly) = a substantial loss of pilot availability. Plus some number of the majority of pilots who are mentally healthy would resent being "forced" to sit through mandatory therapy. They already have to do medicals often enough.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by ta1243 on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:33PM (#37989698)
Don't pilots have a maximum number of hours per year that's way under 2000, leaving a lot of "office time"?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by hammock on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:50PM (#37989929)
100-120 hours per month, which leaves 30-50 hours per month "office time" to use your term and that can easily be taken up with non flight time required tasks like planning, logs, safety, CE, etc
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by wkat4242 on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:36PM (#37993079)
And training, a lot of training to stay current and up to date on changes.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by pdonis on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:51PM (#37989936)
How much of that so-called "office time" is spent in remote cities waiting for the required crew rest time to complete before making one's next flight?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by srinivgp on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:31PM (#37989664)
> resent

Fine, step one, work on why you'd resent that.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by shadowgovt on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:38PM (#37989756)
[delayed]
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by mikepurvis on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:45PM (#37989867)
A perhaps less conventional intervention could be using starlink or similar to permit remote takeover of flights that appear to be going rogue. Potentially also addresses some hijacking scenarios (though maybe introduces others).
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by lxgr on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:17PM (#37990287)
Locking out a conscious crew in the cockpit? Never going to happen, for reasons others have already listed.

The only thing where I could see a remote landing system make sense is during the (very few) cases of crew incapacitation (e.g. Helios 522), but it would almost certainly be done in a way that makes it very apparent and easy to override for the crew actually on board, just like the cockpit door lock operates currently: Require authentication (a PIN code) for unlocking from the cabin-side; give the cockpit crew complete authority to override even that.

That very system has unfortunately contributed to at least one tragedy (Germanwings 9525), but I think the general risk assessment of "bad guy in the cockpit" being significantly less likely than "bad guy trying to compromise the good guys in the cockpit" still makes sense.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by koenigdavidmj on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:55PM (#37989981)
Then you have to trust a bunch of people on the ground to be sane, in addition to whoever is in the cockpit.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by dividedbyzero on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:02PM (#37990099)
And that system to be absolutely safe. Imagine a 9/11 scenario, but with thousands of remotely hijacked planes.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by jdminhbg on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:00PM (#37990063)
Trusting a bunch of people seems a lot better than trusting a single person. For instance, in this case, the two sane pilots were able to restrain the third and prevent a disaster.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by some_random on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:22PM (#37990340)
This is just completely untenable in reality, you're going to have multiple people jump in during an emergency (how do they know? will they be monitoring every flight at all times?) and potentially rip the controls away from PIC because they, by committee, decided on the spot that they could do a better job?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by kayodelycaon on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:51PM (#37990645)
Until somebody pulls a circuit breaker...
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by kylehotchkiss on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:08PM (#37990858)
The same satellite internet provider whose owner micromanages access to in times of crisis based on whatever idea is playing in his head? I'd really prefer starlink to not be a control mechanism for anything until the ownership changes hands. Maybe iridium would be a better choice, if we ever hit the point we'll need it (10+ years with single digit number of passenger fatalities tells me we don't)
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by inemesitaffia on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:39AM (#37999033)
Everyone does this. Everyone.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by sokoloff on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:05PM (#37991582)
I 100% trust my life better to two human pilots than to the same flight on an aircraft with a remote control system capable of taking over the aircraft's control against the wishes of those in the cockpit.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by mikepurvis on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:09PM (#38004745)
A reasonable concern, but I'm surprised at the degree of negative reaction to this— for example, who has the last word on control of a manned spacecraft? Obviously they are controllable from the ground, but can the personnel onboard take that back?

I feel like there's at least scope for an interesting discussion on what a takeover could look like and how the process could be abused and/or protected from abuse.

For example, what if it was something that could be requested using a "call for help" mechanism available elsewhere on the craft? Perhaps there could be buttons on opposite sides of the galley that would activate the distress call, so two flight attendants would have to collude for it— that would call the attention of the ground station to a pilot-incident-in-progress who could then receive telemetry and begin to investigate what was going on and go through some kind of clearance process to unlock the final takeover key that would let them disable the cockpit if deemed necessary.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by mikepurvis on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:43PM (#37989830)
Fair, but these pilot mental health incidents are not that common. We all rightly resented two decades of taking off our shoes in security because of that one shoe bombing attempt.

The trick would be to position it as being about broader spectrum welfare than just a binary determination of whether you're crazy enough to try to kill a plane full of innocent passengers.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by kkielhofner on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:37PM (#37991232)
Correct. I’m an aviation geek/disaster post mortem junkie and the only incident I’m aware of is Germanwings (obviously) and potentially MH370 depending on which scenario/theory you subscribe to.

There have been a few other incidents that essentially boil down to CRM (crew resource management) issues regarding pilots with clear and obvious personality issues that when combined with the wrong crew members has resulted in loss of life.

Basically, combine someone on the flight deck with seniority who’s an asshole with a junior and impressionable crew member and it can be a problem:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northwest_Airlink_Flight_571...

Either way aviation is remarkably safe generally speaking and I’m not sure I’d put mandatory therapy, etc towards the top of the list in terms of approaches to make flying even safer.

Of course pilots have a tough job and are responsible for hundreds of lives at a time and their needs should be looked after. But the incident rate just isn’t there.

“Aviation regulations are written in blood”.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by reisse on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:24PM (#37991800)
There is also, allegedly, Chinese Eastern catastrophe from last year: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Eastern_Airlines_Fligh...
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by nradov on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:55PM (#37994395)
EgyptAir flight 990 in 1999 is also suspected to be a suicide.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EgyptAir_Flight_990?wprov=sfla...

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by oicu812 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:29PM (#38004125)
Fedex Flight 705 was an attempted hijacking by a suicidal pilot.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Express_Flight_705

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by civilitty on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:50PM (#37989928)
It wouldn't have a significant impact on the pilot shortage. If you look at the FAA airman statistics [1], there are fewer active pilots today than there were in 2013. Not commercial or airline pilots, but all pilots total. The entire recruiting pipeline has collapsed, even though there are 25% more licensed instructors and double the number of student pilot licenses (starting in 2016, the FAA made them perpetual instead of a 60 month expiration date so that stat is actually meaningless).

There just aren't enough people involved in general aviation at the start of the funnel to feed the demand for commercial and airline pilots later. Changing some HR policies won't move the needle on that.

[1] https://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation_data_statistics/c...

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by lawlessone on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:45PM (#37990590)
For the work they do. Huge technical and communications skills requirements. The trust required. And shortages.

Pilots seem to very underpaid and overworked.

I'd think twice about flying on any airline if I thought or new they were anything less than pampered.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by TeMPOraL on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:15PM (#37990946)
> Pilots seem to very underpaid and overworked.

Seems to be a trend these days. The more safety critical the job, the worse conditions and pay are.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by SoftTalker on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:25PM (#37991801)
Competitive market and passengers view price as the overriding factor when buying a ticket.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by autoexec on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:15PM (#37993385)
passengers view what they can afford, or what they can't afford the least, as the overriding factor when buying a ticket. Passengers who have money don't buy the cheapest flights they can find and care more about leg room, direct flights, and agreeable departure/arrival times. Poor people (the majority of the US) take whatever they can get.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by axpy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @01:58AM (#37995260)
Mostly because passenger have absolutely no way to understand airline pricing. The exact same seat can change price 2x in 24h. With that in mind, it’s almost impossible to know if you are getting more for your money or if you are seeing a product of the algorithm.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:43AM (#37995504)
All properly competitive markets have thin margins and price being a major competitive factor. The problem isn't with that, but rather with flight staff, as a class, being unable to defend proper salaries and work conditions against the competitive pressures on airlines, and as a result they end up squeezed to near a breaking point.

(I'm no political or labor expert, but to me this feels like a case of the air crews being in need of an union.)

There's a public safety interest in fixing that, but like with other safety-critical jobs, there seems to be no way for that interest to become a force acting on the market. Yes, it would mean slightly more expensive flights, but as it is, the price floor on air travel is too low. Sure, current prices mean flights are available to more people, but that's just subsidizing the poor via having everyone accept a small but growing risk of death.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by SoftTalker on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:15PM (#38003049)
There certainly are pilots unions in the USA and other countries. I don't know what percentage of commercial pilots are unionized, and I don't know how much real power the unions have. When push comes to shove they may be prohibited from striking, as air travel is an essential service (remember when President Reagan fired the striking PATCO controllers). One difference there is that air controllers are FAA employees and pilots are employees of the airlines.

So, with pilots in short supply generally, and if they had a strong union you'd think that they'd be in a position to command good compensation.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:13PM (#38001258)
Airline CEOs are making at least three or four million a year.

Strange, the compensation in the executive class is never that heavily squeezed

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by SoftTalker on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:17PM (#38003073)
Because the CEO's pay is peanuts in the context of the financials of a major airline. They spend many multiples of that on one airplane.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by autoexec on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:14PM (#37993375)
Yeah, I imagine paying pilots better would help solve the "shortage" problem and ease the mental health burden as well.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by nradov on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:32PM (#37994278)
Yes, to an extent. But there is a long delay between raising wages and having a pilot ready to work for an airline. The pipeline takes years. It takes years to earn the necessary licenses and build up enough flight hours.

What would help more in the long run is for airlines to hire untrained candidates and then pay them to go through training. Lots of people would like to become pilots but can't afford to pay for their own training. Some foreign carriers already do this.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by fasthands9 on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:39PM (#37989779)
I've seen meta studies that suggest talk therapy reduces suicide risk by about 25-percent.

That's obviously significant, especially in terms of the cost of a down airliner, but I'm also a bit dubious that it's the most effective here. It seems like screening could be more effective in preventing needless death, even if there are some controversial false positives.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by lotsofpulp on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:45PM (#37989868)
I’m dubious of being able to measure that claim.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by some_random on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:23PM (#37990349)
Only by the highest standards in psychology research, n=33 undergraduates
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by function_seven on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:00PM (#37990769)
n=33 ain't bad. That means you will have data on 33 Calibri participants, and you get 33 more Arial participants as well.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by nradov on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:12PM (#37990213)
What specific screening protocol would be used? Have the sensitivity and specificity been quantified? How repeatable are the results for the same patient population across different practitioners?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by Horffupolde on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:29PM (#37989644)
The problem is that once they admit that they have suicidal thoughts, you can’t just continue therapy. They shouldn’t keep flying.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by some_random on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:40PM (#37989797)
Someone having suicidal thoughts does not alone indicate that they're going to attempt suicide, much less attempt suicide by crashing their plane. Unfortunately this relies on the shrink's judgement, which of isn't remotely reliable.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by catern on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:49PM (#37989909)
If you predictably do that then the pilots won't speak truthfully in therapy in the first place.

The only way to get the lesser benefit of therapy is to precommit to not report suicidal thoughts.

The greater benefit of "pilots honestly report their suicidal thoughts and then they are stopped from flying" is simply impossible to achieve, and if you foolishly try to get it anyway then you won't even get the lesser benefit.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by lazide on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:22PM (#37990336)
Welcome to society since, well, forever.

you didn’t think that strong silent man stereotype came from nowhere, did you?

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by function_seven on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:08PM (#37990861)
You're not wrong. But for this to work, the therapists' notes must be forever sealed regardless of circumstance. The first time a pilot darts their plane into a mountainside, and the investigation reveals that they told their therapist about their suicidal thoughts, this precommitment policy will vanish. The therapist will be blamed for 174 deaths. The FAA will apologize for allowing pilots who express ideation to keep flying. Etc.

It's similar to telling your doctor about illicit drug use. Don't do it unless you really trust your doctor to (a) not take adverse implications from the disclosure and (b) not write it down anywhere. Chances of both (a) and (b) are tiny. So, just lie about illegal drugs when asked. Do your own work on making sure to avoid interactions between prescribed drugs and recreational ones.

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by mvncleaninst on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:43AM (#37995884)
> If you predictably do that then the pilots won't speak truthfully in therapy in the first place.

Why do you think anonymous therapy isn't a thing? There has to be a reason, I wonder what it is...

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by snickerbockers on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @05:22AM (#37996627)
Aren't therapists supposed to make an exception to the doctor/patient confidentiality when the patient is taking about wanting to kill himself and take a plane full of people with him?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by jacquesm on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:30PM (#37990424)
Doctor-patient relationships normally preclude health care people from sharing such information.

This was (and still) a major issue flagged after the Germanwings suicide/crash.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-crash-germany-conf...

Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by nradov on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:31PM (#37989677)
How would we assess whether the scheme works? What are the metrics?
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by LostInTheWoods on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:33PM (#37994282)
We need some kind of screening for these high-stress PTSD inducing roles ... a Voight-Kampff test. Or limit the number of years one can be in these roles.
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by gymbeaux on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:33AM (#37994873)
Won’t someone think of the shareholders???
Re:Off-duty pilot tried to crash Alaska Airlines SFO flight,... by mvncleaninst on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:01AM (#37996009)
> with strict confidentiality so they can be open without jeopardizing their career.

I'd go a step farther, make it anonymous by design so that real name and identity are never disclosed. That way it builds the confidentiality into the system instead of just giving the illusion of it

but... this is probably never going to happen (at least at scale), it isn't profitable enough

but a good historical analogy would be those confession booths in churches. except, instead of going to the local one the confessor goes to one that's far away enough