News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by testplzignore on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:30AM (#37984181)
https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v... has some actual details of what this is about.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Popeyes on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:43AM (#37984290)
Crazy story, so she shit-posted on a dubious forum, they shit-posted back and then she sued Google for defamation.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by aardvarkr on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:01AM (#37985017)
That’s my take too. It’s pretty ludicrous
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by nullifidian on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:46AM (#37985545)
That's UK/Australian legal/cultural norms for you.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Retric on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:50AM (#37985609)
So as is often the case the details are what matter. Google failed to remove defamatory content from their systems after being informed it was defamatory. That’s the case, and they lost because it’s their responsibility to respect such notifications.

It’s like that hot coffee lawsuit. She got 3rd degree burns on 6 percent of her skin and lesser burns over 16 percent, spent 8 days in the hospital and needed skin grafts. They were held 80% liable because the coffee was served at a seriously unsafe temperature, which isn’t total liability. But everyone seems to think coffee = hot and not that dangerous when ignoring the possibility it can be made more dangerous.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by fastball on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:13PM (#37987762)
I think the thing people are surprised by is that auto-complete searches count as defamation, not that Google didn't take them down.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Retric on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:55PM (#37988331)
The distinction is this wasn’t automated once a human looked at the complaint.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by anon84873628 on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:57PM (#37989205)
>In dismissing the innocent dissemination defense, which required that the publisher be a subordinate distributor who did not know or ought not to have known that the matter was defamatory, the Court stated that the defamatory nature of the content was self-evident from an examination of it.

It's not like the plaintiff went to Google with a prior legal judgment against the RipOff website telling Google to take it down. Apparently the court expects Google to remove (within one month) "self-evident" defamatory content if alerted to it.

That's a pretty interesting precedent to set. What makes defamation"self-evident"?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by caf on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:06PM (#37990830)
Primary publishers have to make that judgement all the time. If you get a book published by Harper Collins they're not going to let you put "anything not specifically already ruled defamation by a court" in it.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by adriand on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:45AM (#37984315)
This is an interesting detail - Google's autocomplete suggestions for the plaintiff's name were found to be defamatory:

> Dr. Duffy became aware that when people searched her name on Google’s search engine, the Google search bar provided an autocomplete suggested search term of “janice duffy psychic stalker”. [...] Google was also found [by the court] to be the “publisher” of autocomplete suggestions that came up when a user began to type the individual’s name in its search bar

Be careful with your UI!

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by unsupp0rted on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:27AM (#37984691)
It's not so much "be careful with your UI" as "when you're actually notified that your UI is treading on somebody, you better stop (treading on that particular person)".
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by code51 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:38AM (#37984813)
But how can you notify Google of anything?

Even when you report an important bug, bots and "product experts" just shrug it off. The only "notification" for Google is a lawsuit it seems.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by krisoft on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:42AM (#37984844)
> But how can you notify Google of anything?

Same way you notify any other company about anything. Registered letter sent to the corporate headquaters.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by KomoD on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:02AM (#37985034)
Have you tried that with Google? Or are you just guessing?
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Retric on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:34AM (#37985372)
Legally it counts as notification even if they never open the letter.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by dhimes on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:51PM (#37989128)
I'm not even sure it has to be registered. In at least one court case I know of (a local landlord case) the court assumed that a mailed letter was delivered properly.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by krisoft on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:45PM (#37993624)
> Or are you just guessing?

There is no guessing involved. That is how you notify a company.

I believe you are confused about what I am saying. I’m not saying that google will change anything just because you sent a registered letter. You send a notice, and they might change things or they might not. The notice in and of itself does not compel them to do anything.

What power does such a notice have then? In a court case you can say “your honour, we sent notice on day x, by registered mail, here is our retained copy of the content of the letter”. And the courts generaly assume that such notices were received and read (consult with your lawyer about any possible edge cases, of course). This is not generaly true if you send your notice via carrier pigeon, or shout it at their air vents, or stuff it in a teddy bear and flush it down the toilet. Those are less legitimate channels in the eye of the law.

So what then? They received your notice and you can prove it. What will that change? Maybe nothing. Maybe everything. If you have some legally colorable argument, it can help you paint their action or inaction following the notice as willfull. In some circumstances that increases damages, or makes them liable.

In practice what it wins you is that it will be read by some lawyer kind of person, and if that person reads it and says “uhh, this person could sue us and that would be bad” then they usually have the clout to change things. That of course depends on what you are giving them notice about. If you wrote some rambling with no actionable ask and no chance of a succesfull lawsuite they will ignore it. They probably get plenty of those.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by munk-a on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:01AM (#37985015)
If a few people pursue a lawsuit against them I'm pretty sure they'll get more responsive. TBH Google is notoriously awful to communicate with - I don't know if you've ever dealt with one of their B2B products but they even hate talking to companies that pay them 10k a year.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by ezoe on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:11AM (#37985912)
The civil lawsuit by individual victims won't be effective. If it does, Alphabet and other US-based tech companies should have been behaved better decades ago. For them, this civil case means nothing. Think about it. Are you and all the people you know going to boycott Alphabet just for this particular civil case? No way.

The better solution is make a regulation which makes Alphabet and its boards criminal if they ignored it. But it looks like defamation isn't more important than copyright infringement in US.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by munk-a on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:13AM (#37985930)
I didn't say anything about boycotting - I suggested that repeated lawsuits like this one will force a change. Regulation is absolutely the ideal way forward but the US is horrible about effective regulation so the legal system is probably the most practical enforcement method we have.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DrJaniceDuffy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:02PM (#38004620)
I agree with you, regulation would be better. But much like the alcohol and tobacco industries tech corporations spend millions in funds on lobbying US lawmakers to avoid being forced to accept government regulation. Also my case actually has done some good. Someone contacted me to say because of it her lawyers were able to get content malicious content removed posted by an ex partner. Over the years I have been contacted by quite a few people who have said the same thing.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by justinbaker84 on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:26AM (#37987056)
They also hate talking to people who manage $200K per month advertising budgets. Even at that level advertisers just get very low wage support staff in India who can't do much.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by p3rls on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:11PM (#37992855)
I thought the 3:30AM emails were just because they missed me and couldn't sleep:(
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by kozikow on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:09PM (#37989381)
That's not just external facing problem. Even when internally you want to figure out something - e.g. get a quota for something it's very hard to locate who could get things done for you.

There is this attitude that humans shouldn't ever talk to other humans, but to systems. So if your use case is not handled by how the system was designed, talking to humans would take many months, so better just give up.

The problem may be even worse internally tbh. You want to use some project, there's old teams page, one email, you email person there and after 3 pings weeks later they reply they work now on a different team.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by munk-a on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:10AM (#37997986)
Yea - I used to feel bad about dodging the opportunity to work at Google but the more I've seen about their culture the happier I've been. I am sad I missed out on the insane SF salaries though.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by edgyquant on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:09AM (#37985101)
Just shrugging it off implies you’ve notified them. Then not caring is why they lost this lawsuit.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by lesuorac on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:11AM (#37985117)
> Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google

> But how can you notify Google of anything?

Clearly with a lawsuit. Per the other article in this thread [1], Google did nothing when she notified them but de-indexed the webpage following her initial lawsuit.

[1]: https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v...

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by braiamp on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:57AM (#37987568)
That's the most expensive way. Wonder why should it be that way?
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by BartjeD on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:11PM (#37987728)
So that 99.999% percent of folks won't bother them.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by wahnfrieden on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:30PM (#37988005)
Because it's the cheapest way for Google.

What else would motivate them to do something? Externalities that harm others are just gravy for business until it threatens their profit.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by lesuorac on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:50PM (#37990637)
Well their contact us also lists an address and a phone number [1].

But also, I mean if your qualm is small there's a thing called "small claims court" where you can get it settled probably cheaper than otherwise if you put a value on your time.

[1]: https://about.google/intl/ALL_us/contact-google/

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jsnell on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:27AM (#37985285)
That's just a lazy meme take, there's obviously a documented process to request removal of content from their products, including Search.

https://support.google.com/legal/troubleshooter/1114905?sjid...

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by soco on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:42AM (#37986341)
The request process is indeed easy enough. Now, if you also expect it having results, guess what.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jsnell on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:05AM (#37986682)
The GP's complaint was about not being able to notify Google at all, not at not getting the right outcome. I'm pretty sure submissions to that form will have (trained) human eyes on them after some trivial spam filtering, it's not just redirected to /dev/null.

As for whether one could expect results, there are stats on how often this functionality is used in the EU (about 200k requests per year) and how often it is successful (about half the requested URLs are delisted):

https://transparencyreport.google.com/eu-privacy/overview?hl...

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by tadfisher on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:15PM (#37988642)
Not correct, the original lawsuit (from 2015) was predicated on the fact that she had indeed opened a removal request, and Google denied it, saying they could do nothing without the cooperation of the website owner (RipoffReport).
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by lazyasciiart on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:58PM (#37989219)
What is 'not correct' in the comment you're replying to?
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jeroenhd on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:32AM (#37985352)
You can't notify Google of anything, that's probably why Google needed to settle in the first place. It's their choice that they don't do any customer support.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by matsemann on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:56AM (#37985704)
Chrome has had a bug for ~6 months where for certain TLDs, it searches instead of going to the typed url. It happens for .no. Google isn't incentivized to fix it, since they now most likely get a visitor on their search page and earn some money.

Combined with a different issue, this is fairly dangerous: Google allows fake scam websites to pay to get the top ad. Above the URL you ended up searching for.

There are cases of people writing skatteetaten.no (our IRS) in Chrome, ending up in google search instead, and they then click the top result which is a phishing site stealing their credentials.

Impossible to get a human at Google to care for this.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by soco on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:41AM (#37986321)
That, and also the plethora of search suggestions like 192.168.O.1 (notice anything wrong?) happily presented up there. No, DDG doesn't show them, so yes IT IS possible.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by nolist_policy on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:04AM (#37986662)
Chrome has a public bug tracker.

I can't find any bug report for your issue.

Please post a link to your bug report, otherwise it seems like you didn't even try.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by matsemann on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:36AM (#37987230)
Why should I try? I don't use Chrome. I don't care about jumping through hoops to do free work for a big scummy company. I only knew of it from news reports recently after it finally got fixed.

https://www.kode24.no/artikkel/derfor-googler-chrome-no-nett...

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by nolist_policy on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:05PM (#37987648)
Great, it has a link to the bug: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=148880...

Fix was commited 7 days after the report was filed.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by doctorpangloss on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:17PM (#37989485)
Here's an example of Google bug tracking being pretty dysfunctional: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32380769

Anyway, Chrome's responsiveness on some random issue isn't at all representative of Google as a whole, which of course, it is impracticable for laypeople to communicate with a real person there.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by mbrumlow on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:20AM (#37986021)
I think that is the point. The bots and “product experts” failed to do their job. And as agents for working for Google failed Google.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by 6510 on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:37AM (#37986259)
The fascinating thing here imho is that until recently it was pretty expensive to communicate with customers at that scale. You would have to staff some XXL call centers and find some way to process the communications in the context of the technologies used.

We've seen the many useless chat bots attempt to remedy the puzzle but the situation is rather different with LLM's

I for example reported on yt that the subtitle font-size is to small to read. I didn't bother to investigate what drives the inconsistency but the font is much smaller than everything else on the page.

If humans have to read this, write a report, put it in a bug tracker etc it will never be important enough to do something about it.

An LLM could figure out which line of code determines the font size. It could establish if it is indeed smaller than the other fonts and when. Then it could combine many similar reports into a simple easy to read list of tweaks with code examples.

I hardly ever use subs and normally I sit closer to the screen I didn't bother to search for the issue on google. Writing this I find an article on a 3rd party website that explains there are settings for the subtitles. There is a warning on this menu that says the settings are not persistent and will only work for this video but after changing the font size it works for all videos.

Should I report that as well? If nothing will be done with it why bother?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by tempodox on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:42AM (#37986333)
That's just it. This one time, Google got slapped for this kind of behavior.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by theptip on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:16AM (#37986870)
GDPR's "Right to be forgotten" has been a thing for 5 years now, this isn't a new concept:

https://support.google.com/legal/answer/10769224?hl=en

This doc explains the tools available and links to a "Personal Data Removal Request Form". Now, what they do with that in non-EU territories is another question.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by dkjaudyeqooe on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:44PM (#37988189)
Someone could make Google more responsive by publishing a guide on how to sue Google while representing yourself.

Some basic information about court procedure and submissions, and a guide to the relevant law, such as defamation, would let a thousand litigants bloom, and Google would soon have a very real problem on their hands.

Most likely you'd get Google's attention at the first step, and a probably solution.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by gshubert17 on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:20PM (#37989516)
If Google didn't index this guide, how would people find it?
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by dkjaudyeqooe on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:04PM (#37990803)
The original internet: word of mouth.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DrJaniceDuffy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:03PM (#38004636)
That's a good idea.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by shelled on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:47PM (#37988221)
At least that’s a thing in Australia or western countries. Here in India, where TrueCaller is very famous, TrueCaller is a platform for abuse.

Even after you use their delisting the customer care duty-fully informs you that your number can still be named and tagged on their platform.

After a while in my case they just didn’t respond.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by amalcon on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:47AM (#37985572)
That's a particularly weird one, because it's just populated with phrases people search often (as befits an autocomplete box). The point of search is to find things you don't know, though! I search for e.g. "XYZ scam" to find information to help me conclude whether XYZ is a scam, not to register my belief that it is in fact a scam.

I guess that goes to your point, though: maybe Google needs to make that clearer?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by csunbird on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:47AM (#37984333)
> Dr. Duffy posted a web report on the website “Ripoff Report” complaining about her dissatisfaction with the services she had received from the psychics on the Kasamba site. She also commented on the reports of others about the psychics. She created a chat group “kasambavictims” on Yahoo. Dr. Duffy also posted messages under a pseudonym, and began to email the site complaining that her friend’s wife had committed suicide due to bad advice given by the psychics. This was untrue.

Very interesting part. Later in the article:

> In relation to justification (truth), the Court found no evidence supporting Google’s argument that Dr. Duffy stalked or persistently and obsessively harassed any of the psychics.

Am I missing something important here? Dr. Duffy clearly defamed a business with a lie, and some other people (other site users) pointed this up, in a very cruel way, to her in a forum with user submitted content. Then Dr. Duffy sues Google instead of the Ripoff Report forum?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by xyst on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:28AM (#37984712)
Whether the plaintiff defamed another business or not is not the subject of this case. The case is about Google continuing to publish defamatory statements generated from “Rip off Reports” content despite being forced to comply with the request in 2011.

Now I do agree the plaintiff can also be sued for damages by the psychic company for defamation.

That’s my take on this. I do agree the premise of the case is odd. The in depth case review doesn’t seem to mention if she actually went through the process of having the primary publisher (Rip-off reports) remove the defamatory information.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by arp242 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:30AM (#37984721)
Posting messages and making up that a friend's wife committed suicide is not really "stalking" or "persistently and obsessively harassing". Immoral and possibly illegal? Perhaps. But that's not the same thing.

Also, Duffy was ripped off by Kasamba.

I think the crux of the matter is: even if you did something wrong, do things like that really need to be preserved on the internet under your real name for the rest of your life? Probably not. And do we really want Google to be suggesting this content years after this minor spat (guaranteeing that people will find it)?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jeroenhd on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:40AM (#37985453)
> Also, Duffy was ripped off by Kasamba.

Can you really be ripped off by psychics? It's not like you can sue a church because your prayers haven't been answered, so I'm not sure of religion or spiritualism can be a "rip-off".

If someone tells you they'll talk to your dead ancestors for money and you don't believe them, who's to say who's speaking the truth? The best you can do is use reasoning like "there's no scientific basis for an afterlife" but that's not a great defence if you're honestly trying to speak to the dead.

I agree with your other points, of course. I'm just amused at the idea of suing psychics for not telling the truth.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by arp242 on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:01AM (#37985771)
"Ripped off" in the colloquial sense, not in the strict legal sense.

Most psychics don't actually believe what they're selling, whereas most priests do.

Prayer also works very different: a psychic will tell you "higher powers told me this man is a {good,bad} match for you", whereas a priest will tell you to "pray and ask God for guidance" and/or offer you some general advice, but they won't say "God told me to relay that [..]".

Should they be sued for it? Probably not. But I do think most psychic "customers" get ripped off by people who are essentially little more than confidence tricksters, but I don't think most people who go to church get ripped off (outside of the "send me your money and go to heaven" kind of twattery).

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by gspencley on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:11AM (#37985908)
> Can you really be ripped off by psychics? It's not like you can sue a church because your prayers haven't been answered, so I'm not sure of religion or spiritualism can be a "rip-off".

Well, I would suggest that both are a "rip off" in the sense that they offer claims without evidence.

But a distinction that I see between religious services and psychics is that religious services are not offering financial transactions in direct exchange for services. They ask for donations, and they may make claims such as "God answers all prayers", but you are typically not offering a religious leader money in exchange for some sort of quid pro quo like having a prayer answered.

A lot of "psychics" offer their "services" as "entertainment" in order to avoid claims of fraud. But the fact remains that a lot of people still believe.

My wife and I are performing magicians, and we make it clear that what we do are parlour tricks. And yet I've performed "mind reading" tricks for people in the past who were absolutely convinced that what I did was not a trick even though I presented everything as "magic tricks." It's fucking insane and deeply uncomfortable. I totally get why Penn & Teller stay away from mentalism entirely. And I think this is your point: if someone is determined to accept a faith based belief system, can they really be "ripped off" when reality doesn't deliver their fantasy.

In my opinion, it depends what you offering and the audience / demographic that you are targeting. Magic tricks for entertainment presented as tricks is one thing. A "psychic" (even one that offers a "disclaimer" that it is entertainment) who knows full well they are catering to people that want to believe it is "real" know what they are doing. It gets particularly heinous when these con artists prey on grieving people who just lost a loved one. It's hard not to view a con artist presenting bullshit to a mother who just lost her 12 year-old daughter in a car accident as not ripping them off.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Karellen on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:51AM (#37986460)
> But the fact remains that a lot of people still believe.

But also, a lot of people still believe in professional wrestling. Are pro wrestlers ripping people off?

Were pro wrestlers ripping people off worse in the '80s and earlier, when they tried really hard to maintain kayfabe, including denying the existence of kayfabe?

If you pay money to psychics and they tell you the sorts of things you paid them to tell you, is it really different from pro wrestlers or stage magicians? Or should that be "psychics", "wrestlers" or "magicians"?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by pixl97 on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:29PM (#37988862)
Answers to things don't have to be black and white, yes or no. You can also start a process up front saying it's entertainment then manipulate people to the point the initial statement no longer holds.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by gspencley on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:55PM (#38008220)
> But also, a lot of people still believe in professional wrestling.

Being a professional wrestling fan myself, I don't know of any, but ok I'll play along ...

> Are pro wrestlers ripping people off?

I've never heard of a wrestling fan going to a show for life changing advice, or in a desperate attempt to reconnect with their dead child. Nor have I ever heard of a professional wrestler offering such services.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Karellen on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @12:41PM (#38014745)
And psychics don't pretend to get into long-running feuds with each other, and pretend to settle those feuds with drop-kicks and suplexes, in front of mass audiences. (At least, not to my knowledge)

Did you think I thought, and was implying, that wrestlers and psychics provided the exact same services as each other?

Because I don't. You get that, right?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by rescbr on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:11PM (#37988587)
> It's not like you can sue a church because your prayers haven't been answered

Ah! You totally can! Every now and them there are news articles about lawsuits against the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by mcpackieh on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:34PM (#37989715)
> Can you really be ripped off by psychics?

Once I went to a psychic who offered to read my fortune out of a crystal ball. Later I found out the ball was actually glass. Glass! That's an amorphous solid, the exact opposite of a crystal. How can you divine any truth such a chaotic structure? The very premise is ludicrous; she may have a large glass ball but clearly she had lost the rest of her marbles.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by slikrick on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:43AM (#38014007)
can you really not be ripped off by psychics? I mean come on
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by AdrianB1 on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:27PM (#37989619)
even if you did something wrong, do things like that really need to be preserved on the internet under your real name for the rest of your life? Probably not

Why not? It is a historical record of sort, like Nero burning Rome. Does Nero has a right to be forgotten? Also where is the freedom of speech of telling people that Nero burnt Rome?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by arp242 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:57AM (#37994956)
Nero is dead and dead men don't suffer from a bad reputation. Nero was also emperor, whereas this person is not a public figure. It needs to be proportionate, and "rest of your life" sounds disproportionate for something like this.

It also depends on how unique your name is how badly you will get "punished". My name is unique; as far as I know I'm the only person on the planet with my name. People named "John Smith" have an easier time being anonymous.

(aside: it's not clear that Nero actually started the fire by the way, the sources on it are rather thin and recently some historians have begun to suspect that a lot of what we "know" about Nero was essentially propaganda from his opponents. This is actually another point of consideration here: not everything that's reported is necessarily accurate, fair, or balanced.)

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by AdrianB1 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @05:47PM (#38006128)
Dead people don't suffer from a bad reputation, but bad people should, dead or alive. Don't want a bad reputation? Don't be a bad person. It's that simple. What you did will be there forever, think before acting.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by kikokikokiko on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:20AM (#37984625)
I find it amusing that I feel no empathy at all to ANYONE involved in this case. The "psychics" are just low-life scammers that prey on the stupid/mentally ill, and things like this case are bound to happen to them from time to time. Google is Google, everything that makes the evil tech lords suffer a little bit is a plus for mankind. And this woman seems to be just an insufferable crazy cat lady, so good riddance to all involved. It's a win-win-win for humanity.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DrJaniceDuffy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:33PM (#38005107)
I'd rather be 'an insufferable cat lady' who stands up for her rights than an asshole - lol!
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by munk-a on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:04AM (#37985044)
Google was not a party to this interaction until they voluntarily chose to be. That's a huge thing to remember with aggregators and the like - they're voluntarily reposting information and accept the benefits along with the liability of doing so. Platform immunity does exist for a lot of the common situations - but it doesn't cover everything.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by carlosjobim on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:25AM (#37985263)
> Am I missing something important here? Dr. Duffy clearly defamed a business with a lie...

What you're missing is that you can't defame a business. Only if that business is very strongly connected to a single person.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DrJaniceDuffy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:31PM (#38005072)
I'd like to clarify if I may. Firstly, thank you for you comments. I indeed did get scammed at a time when I was going through a very bad depression which actually had a physiological cause. I thought the website Ripoff Report was a legitimate complaint website. In fact, there are hundreds of complaints about Kasamba (and under its previous name 'Liveperson)on both Ripoff Report and other websites. I started a support group for others who were scammed. It is not a crime to for vulnerable people to be scammed - people lose millions each year to scams. The defamatory content about me was written to try and stop the support group. Kasamba 'experts' were scamming vulnerable people of thousands of dollars.

I had 18 days to prepare for the first trial and no idea what I was doing. A friend did commit suicide but I couldn't obtain any evidence. The court can only rule on the evidence before it and I had no idea what I was doing in a court room in which I was alone and facing a bank of highly paid lawyers. In the second trial (2022) I had a witness from the support group to say that someone did commit suicide but she was terrified that the Google lawyers would know her name because they previously distributed legal documents about a friend of mine to techdirt.com.

I did not know it at the time but Ripoff Report is an extortion racket. Evidence supporting this from the US courts was put into my recent liability judgement. In fact, how it operates is that the website publishes often false content and then charges tens of thousands of dollars to remove it. A 2023 judgement found that it charges USD$5,500 to remove a link https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-casd-3_22-cv-00...

There are a number of other cases, for example, https://casetext.com/case/xcentric-ventures-llc-v-borodkin-7 in which the court has upheld the extortive business practices.

I could not sue Ripoff Report because of section 230 of the communications decency act and the speech act of 2010. I only filed proceedings because I thought it would result in removal. I was wrong and Google decided to use me as an example and refuse to 'mediate'. I just wanted it removed but google decided it would try to bully me into going away rather than mediate or remove it properly.

This is the latest 2023 decision on liability.https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/sa/SASC/...

This is the second liability

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by anon84873628 on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:50PM (#37989118)
The most interesting sequence of the decision to me:

>The Court reasoned that only once Google acquired knowledge of the paragraphs by reason of Dr Duffy’s notifications and failed to remove them within a reasonable time thereafter would the necessary mental element be present for Google to be a “secondary publisher”.

> ...

>The Court then turned to look at the notice given by Dr. Duffy, to ascertain whether it was sufficient to fix Google with the relevant mental element. The Court concluded that Dr Duffy’s communications with Google comprised adequate notification to them of the allegedly defamatory material, this was despite the fact that some of the URLs were incomplete in these communications. The Court also implied that a reasonable time for removal of content would be one month, which had not been met by Google.

>...

>The Court rejected Google’s defenses of innocent dissemination, qualified privilege, and justification (truth). In dismissing the innocent dissemination defense, which required that the publisher be a subordinate distributor who did not know or ought not to have known that the matter was defamatory, the Court stated that the defamatory nature of the content was self-evident from an examination of it.

Emphasis on the last line.

It's not like she had to go to Google and say, "here is a court judgment showing this content is defaming me" to have it removed. She simply had to notify Google that this "self-evident" defamatory content was being served by them.

That seems like a significant precedent to set. I don't really think it is fair to expect Google to determine which content is "self-evidently" defamatory (edit to add: amongst all the takedown requests they will receive)

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by TimPC on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:55PM (#37989174)
I think it's a fair precedent. If Google feels the content is not defamatory they can take that position in court with consequences if they are wrong. The downside is this ends up like the DMCA where companies are likely to take down all content complained about because of the risk/reward tradeoffs but if we already do that for alleged copyright violations doing it for alleged defamation seems much more reasonable to me. They also don't have to remove all self-evidently defamatory content, just all self-evidently defamatory content they are notified they are serving.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by chaostheory on Monday October 23, 2023 @01:56PM (#37989201)
This will continue the trend for more censorship in search.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by barbazoo on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:14PM (#37989439)
How will this add to "censorship"?
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by l33t7332273 on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:24PM (#37989564)
Google and others will likely prefer to take a hardline stance on what is “self evidently” defamatory, and when you combine heavy handedness with automation, you will almost surely be censoring legal content.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by AdrianB1 on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:24PM (#37989566)
Similar to that quote, it is self-evident. If you can be punished for stuff that you index (as a search engine), you will start to self-censor to avoid punishment.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by kedean on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:59PM (#37991509)
Censorship is not and cannot be a blanket defense for companies to get away with not moderating their content, and for Google this information is content.

Google in particular left behind the excuse of "we just serve what's already available" when they started weighting results for political and commercial gain and labelling things as factual. They clearly do not act as a dumb pipe for information gathering.

IMI, as soon as they started exercising editorial privilege on data they serve, they became responsible for this kind of thing. Uncensored search results can only come from an engine that isn't censoring for their own benefit anyway.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by kulahan on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:06PM (#37991593)
The court case seemed to hinge largely on the fact that she TOLD them the info was there, that it was defamatory, and they chose to keep it up anyways. Had they taken it down, they would've been fine.

So this doesn't seem like much of a precedent at all: If you are told you have defamatory content, you need to remove it. They don't really have to change much (anything?) about their search engine to make this happen. Maybe a link for "need content removed?" or whatever.