I can disagree with Republican cronyism and the endless "let some private contractor do it poorly" when the Federal government could just do it directly, and poorly, but with less indirection.
… I can also disagree with blue state's NIMBYism, "I got mine and screw you" attitudes towards housing, and work to promote things like better zoning laws, fairer tax legislation, better public transit, etc. at the same time.
(Note: the parent edited the above comment to add the CNN article. At the time I replied, it was only the NYT link.)
You know how NIMBYism is done in California?
It is usually along the lines of "We can't let developers profit!!" and "They are going to build luxury homes and not affordable homes!!".
When someone points out Republican's cronyism leads to bad outcomes in healthcare, and you respond with an opinion piece whose thesis is roughly "Blue states have bad policies that lead to unaffordable housing" … like that's basically textbook whataboutism:
> the technique or practice of responding to an accusation or difficult question by making a counteraccusation or raising a different issue.
Literally "what about housing" is raising a different issue here, one that's not related to healthcare, nor the Republican anti-pattern being discussed in this subthread…
You're further implying that Democrats are hunky-dory with the housing policy in states like CA, when they're not. Some are, some aren't, and AFAICT it wasn't exactly a partisan thing. As I alluded to, a lot of the YIMBY-iers there advocated for things like better mass transit — which isn't exactly a very Republican position.
> You know how NIMBYism is done in California?
> It is usually along the lines of "We can't let developers profit!!" and "They are going to build luxury homes!!".
I'm a former resident of Silicon Valley. I'm well aware how it's done. That doesn't make this not whataboutism, and it doesn't mean that there aren't democrats in those states who are fiercely against that line of argument.
Why would you expect a party's cronyism to be restricted to one industry? If you're implying that Republican's shouldn't be in charge of healthcare because it will result in cronyism, pointing out the cronyism is far from a partisan issue is not whataboutism.
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HealthCare.gov#Concerns_about_...)
Do you think not addressing root cause for high medical costs is good?
https://harvardmagazine.com/2020/05/feature-forum-costliest-...
I, in fact, think things like negotiating drug prices is good, sadly it was outlawed by republican policy: Medicaid Part D (One of the most expensive policies ever) -- the Biden "Inflation Reduction Act" addresses this Bush-era money-grab for drug companies.
Meanwhile, finding lower cost ways of providing health care still seems elusive in the face of provider and pharma legal efforts.
Our health care system is, like basically any other institution of note in the US, first and foremost a means to effect the transfer of wealth to our economic and political elites from the rest of us. We need to first come to recognize that our system is currently working as intended before we can think clearly on what to do about it and take effective action.
I'd argue that strident condemnations (ala your "our system is currently working as intended") is actually one of the features of the US political system that tends to create/preserve a subpar status quo: https://twitter.com/JohnArnoldFndtn/status/11063022464493690...
I don't believe that the US has a monopoly on greedy businesspeople or politicians, relative to other countries. But I do find myself wondering if the toxicity of our politics tends to filter out candidates with a good faith desire to serve the public. People who enjoy conflict tend to be jerks.
I disagree
It is intended to be profit maximizing.
That it is
I'm not sure what point you were trying to make. I don't think we have a monopoly on greedy businesspeople or politicians either, but I do think that as the epicenter of global capitalism, we dominate the market. You can't hope to solve problems if you won't allow yourself to accurately define them.
It's true that the tax code encourages philanthropy. That's not the same thing as philanthropy being purely a tax shelter.
> The report shows that global spending on health continually rose between 2000 and 2018 and reached US$ 8.3 trillion or 10% of global GDP
https://www.who.int/publications-detail-redirect/97892400177...
This is so obviously the wrong answer it is painful that anyone would write it down even in an internet forum.
https://dd17w042cevyt.cloudfront.net/pdf/vision/healthcare-d... shows that while it is easy to blame administrative costs for healthcare, most money goes to "patient benefits"
This sounds great, but really what it is doing is transferring money to pharam company profits: https://www.zippia.com/advice/us-pharmaceutical-statistics/
> Easy.
It really isn't.
See this paper: Pozen, Alexis and David M. Cutler. 2010. Medical spending differences in the United States and Canada: The role of prices, procedures, and administrative expenses. Inquiry 47(2): 124-134.
https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/5343032/Medical%...
Look at Table 1 and Table 2, page 19/20; the difference in cost due to salaries/income is $490 per capita, the difference in cost due to administrative overhead is $616 per capita.
> Prescription drug prices in the United States are significantly higher than in other nations, with prices in the United States averaging 2.56 times those seen in 32 other nations. ... The gap between prices in the United States and other countries is even larger for brand-named drugs, with U.S. prices averaging 3.44 times those in comparison nations. ... “Brand-name drugs are the primary driver of the higher prescription drug prices in the United States
We could also move to 5 or 6 year degrees for doctors, like Ireland, instead of 4+4 schemes.
We can do more targeted immigration for doctors.
We can continue to expand the activities that can be done by non-doctors.
We can massively reduce the number of things that require a prescription.
Both parties are fundamentally wrong on a whole host of issues - the democrats are wrong on how markets work, and republicans treat poverty like it's a moral failing.
I dont know how to fix this situation, I need to see how the realignment we're in works out.
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-11-10/proposit... was unfortunate in my opinion.
"Whataboutism" is just pointing out you're applying a double standard. A rhetorical tool used since time immemorial.
The federal money is an extortion scheme.
The way federal programs nominally work is that people with money pay taxes to fund the programs. The people with money disproportionately live in certain states, which is the justification for making it a federal program -- then you can have a uniform national program even if some states don't have the tax base to provide it themselves.
But then the representatives from the states with money make it so the federal government doesn't fund the entire program. This benefits them first because they can shift some of the tax burden from the rich taxpayers in their state to the poorer taxpayers in some other state where any of the program's beneficiaries are. It tries to force every state to fund part of the program from their own tax base even if the people in that state didn't want it, because the alternative is to pay the federal taxes anyway but not get any of the federal money.
Then it benefits rich people again because the rich states, of course, implement the programs and get the federal money, but any state that refuses the scheme that disadvantages them is still paying federal taxes and gets nothing. So now you're getting a transfer of wealth from poorer states to richer states -- a penalty the representatives from the richer states intended when they constructed the program that way.
But the poorer states may not have the money to fund the state's portion of the program, and in any event refusing it is the only way the state government has to protest the federal program being constructed in that way. It puts pressure on that state's federal representatives to reform or remove the program.
So don't blame the poorer states for not implementing the program, blame the richer states for passing it without funding it.
Residents who do not have private or public health coverage still get health care. They go to the ER when they need help and they receive care in the most transactional and expensive way possible. The cost for this care is paid by all the other residents who do have private care (via higher prices) and in their taxes.
The goal of Medicaid is not to pay for more care, it is to better organize the care that is being provided, and in doing so, improve outcomes and lower the overall cost.
One reason Medicaid expansion has seen steady adoption, even in “red” states, is that earlier implementations have shown that this happens and the program is a net improvement.
Implying that a federal program is unnecessary because the states would have the incentive to do something anyway, but could then tailor the program to the geography and economy of their state instead of having something imposed on them that was drafted by Washington lobbyists.
> The goal of Medicaid is not to pay for more care, it is to better organize the care that is being provided, and in doing so, improve outcomes and lower the overall cost.
The problem is not that the patient pays otherwise, it's that the state if they want to implement Medicaid and get the federal money their tax base is paying taxes for regardless, has to put up even more money only to have the federal program dictate how they can spend their own money. That's the extortion -- they remove money from the state's tax base and only give it back if the state provides even more money and implements the program under the federal terms.
It gives the state no opportunity to make their own choices, which might have been more cost efficient. It destroys the "laboratories of democracy" the federal system was intended to have before lobbyists found a bunch of ways to cheat the constitution and take everything over centrally.
> One reason Medicaid expansion has seen steady adoption, even in “red” states, is that earlier implementations have shown that this happens and the program is a net improvement.
The main reason is because states can't afford to run their own equivalent program under their own terms when the federal government is raiding their tax base and then only returning the money with strings attached -- one of the major ones being that they have to spend even more of their tax dollars on the program whose terms are dictated by the federal program.
And this is not the only federal program that operates this way. So much of the poorer states' budgets go to spending money in order to get federal tax dollars under federal terms that they can't afford to do something different. Both accepting and refusing the money leaves them with not enough resources to do something on their own -- if they refuse it they end up with less money than they started with because tax dollars leave the state only to fund the program in other states, but if they accept it they have to pay even more and lose the ability to make their own choices.
It's unsurprising that many states would knuckle under to that level of coercive pressure -- the coercion is the intent. Otherwise the program would be a block grant, or simply not exist at the federal level so that federal taxes would be lower and state taxes higher, allowing similar programs to be operated by the states.
Notice that of all the people who downvoted that comment, not a single one attempted to defend having the program as a coercive centralized mandate from the federal level -- which was the criticism -- and instead the only argument is that a program of that nature is good. But whether the general idea is good or not is a separate question from which level of government should construct it.
Especially when it turns out that a lot of people the money is coming from aren't actually rich, and a lot of the "people" the money is going to aren't poor people at all but major corporations.
Many state elected leaders, however, have strong individual incentives to avoid any change that exposes previously hidden costs to their constituents, because then their opponents can accuse them of raising spending and/or taxes. (Even though they all know the cost has been there hidden all along.) This is the same incentive structure that inclines state politicians against spending state money on environmental protection, workplace safety, infrastructure, and many other areas where the federal government ends up taking the lead.
You seem pretty plugged in and sympathetic to the point of view of state elected officials. The idea that federal taxes are money stolen from states, for example, is a classic state politician talking point.
But I think you might be surprised how many federal actions are secretly supported by state officials who publicly campaign against them. They get to benefit from the material improvements delivered by the federal program, while blaming Washington for out of control spending, unfair coercion, etc.
But this is just defending the general concept of such a program, not a reason it has to be constructed at the federal rather than state level.
> Many state elected leaders, however, have strong individual incentives to avoid any change that exposes previously hidden costs to their constituents, because then their opponents can accuse them of raising spending and/or taxes.
How is it that federal elected leaders are immune from this incentive? And if they are, isn't that bad, because they would then for the same reason have no incentive to implement programs efficiently?
> The idea that federal taxes are money stolen from states, for example, is a classic state politician talking point.
It's a straightforward economic effect. Bob earns his wages which are then spent by some combination of Bob, the state government and the federal government. If the federal government takes more then the state government and Bob get less, and Bob is going to be in a bad way if there isn't enough left to make rent.
Meanwhile if the federal government uses the money for Medicaid then the state doesn't have to collect the money the federal government spends on it, but then it's the federal program setting the terms -- and if the state doesn't like those terms, Bob still has to pay all of the same federal taxes. The state can't use his money to operate their own program instead.
Federal spending is currently ~25% of GDP, which is more than it is for most states -- and a huge chunk of the money attributed to states is the state portion of the money required to implement federal programs. By the time you also pay for state programs whose funding couldn't reasonably be reallocated to something else, there is nothing really left. The states have lost the ability to try to do better because the federal government has locked up all the money.
> But I think you might be surprised how many federal actions are secretly supported by state officials who publicly campaign against them.
Well of course they do. They're opportunistic politicians. If they can't reasonably implement useful programs because the money they'd have to spend is already going to the feds then their remaining option is to claim credit for not spending it.
The point is, what would happen if the states were actually left with both the problems and the resources to solve them?
If so you might not be qualified to be a republican governor.
Wouldn't it be much better to hire your friends as IT consultants, make broken systems as confusing as possible, and continuously change the rules, and then starve the half-assed system of funding in an attempt to keep people from signing up for coverage at all? What makes this plan doubly republican-friendly is that all players are your donors and most victims are minorities.