With grid scale, above certain dimensions, you can store energy for months while maintaining economic viability.
Even for single days or weeks it makes sense. You need hot water in your home 24/7, but sun doesn't shine every day in most regions.
Flowing sand has issues with blockages and erosion.
Stationary sand has pretty low conductivity, so getting all the energy out of your 200 yard cube of hot sand might be a challenge.
You can progressively sink them in as the sand cools/ you want more energy out.
The same geometry that allows heat to be effectively trapped also prevents its fast extraction as radiation. A fluid that can relatively easily change its volume to surface ratio could have an advantage here, too.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_energy_storage#Molten_...
If you try that with solar radiation, you'll lose most of it back into the sky.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04473-y.pdf
(Equation 1 and surrounding discussion, and the energy-flow diagrams in Figure 1).
My idea was to now enclose this sphere in TPV modules - except in places where the parabolic mirror puts sunlight on it Let's say that's half of the sphere (but you could cut this number down if you chose a parabolic mirror with a long focal point).
Now you lose IR photons in across the part of the surface that you didn't cover in TPV modules. But you could but a IR mirror there, that is transparent for most of sunlight.
Arguably there should be a "white roof" campaign for urban areas, it would be a cheap way of reducing the urban heat island effect.
[https://www.homedepot.com/p/Henry-887-Tropi-Cool-100-Silicon...] [https://maps.app.goo.gl/TwrV57Jt2fGo2obw9?g_st=ic]
The fact we don't seem to be able to do this yet suggests I'm missing something, probably several things.
Batteries are faster to charge/discharge and more efficient per wh.
Both usually have less loss over time - it’s very difficult/expensive to avoid significant heat loss over time due to radiative heat loss, if nothing else.
Most batteries or pumped storage have much lower losses over time.
The problem is that a tungsten tank filled with molten salt is heavy. If you want to store a couple of MW/h, we're quickly talking about several thousand tons. You have to suspend it somehow inside that thermos. With materials, that don't conduct heat well, but still have some strength at 2000C.
There's been talk of doing solar concentration -> hot object -> thermophotovoltaic converter. IIRC concentrated solar already exceeds 40% efficiency so it doesn't make sense to add the extra step, unless you are using the solar concentration to "recharge" a heat storage system.
I buy the argument that thermophotovoltaics can become cheaper on a $/kW basis than comparably-efficient fluid/mechanical heat engines. The power per unit area is intrinsically orders of magnitude higher than for direct solar, so even if these cells are pricier than regular solar cells, they have a fighting chance. Also, both the power density and efficiency increase with temperature, and in principle the operating temperature can be higher than that of a turbine (since the materials don't have to simultaneously withstand crazy mechanical stresses and reactive chemical environment).
[0] https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2019/EE/C8EE0...
I wonder if you could use this with parabolic mirrors, though. Build a large mirror array, focus sunlight onto a big carbon sphere (maybe coat it with one of those new materials that are transparent for visible light but pretty reflective for IR), cover the top of the sphere in those new panels. They are more efficient than practically all solar cells and get much more power out the same area than solar cells. This should beat a photovoltaic parabolic mirror setup, right?