"Refuse to go to war with us? We'll... remove you from our cafeteria menu! Take that!"
"... what do you mean they're actually Belgian?"
It's a commentary on all the unique and interesting ways Americans appear to measure things.
Sometimes people will take it further by, for example, converting a length in meters into football fields or bald eagle wingspans.
https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/pml/wmd/pubs/201...
Can’t leave out our fellow beacons of freedom!
If you tell the average (US) person 1000 feet, they won't be able to envision it. But if you say "a little more than three football fields", they can visualize that.
The point of strange units of measure is just to make a quantity relatable.
Those that use the metric system. Those that landed a man on the Moon.
The country is a metric country (see: Official definition of the US foot).
Its citizens, however, largely still roll coal measured by chains to the hogshead.
I try to learn but the only thing I think I have retained is that if the number has a negative 6 its most likely a small number.
> My problem with the metric scale is that when values are expressed in scientific notion they lose all reference to me.
As if the two are connected. But my point is that scientific notation is not part of the metric system at all. If you problem is with scientific notation, that is a problem with scientific notation, not metric.
If anything, with metric units most people outside of the sciences will use the metric prefixes and never ever use scientific notation at all.
As said above, it has nothing to do with the metric system anyway, it's just about dealing conveniently with very big or very tiny value (1⋅10^-9 meter is 3.9⋅10^-8 inch, no matter the unit you're using you'd be using scientific notation to express things that small instead of dealing with 8 or 9 zeros).
I think my particular problem is when dealing with electricity and physics.
I never once blamed the metric system and identified the problem as my in ability to comprehend values in scientific notation. I appreciate I shouldn't be so dumb and try to read about things I don't understand. It's a life long struggle.
You may be getting confused over prefixes vs base units because some pairs of prefixes and base units are so common they sort-of end up treated as a unit in themselves.
E.g. "kilo" is not a metric unit, but sometimes used as short for "kilogram", where "kilo" is the prefix for 1000 and "gram" is the metric unit. These prefixes are consistent for all metric units.
Fun fact: the metric unit for mass is … the kilogram, not the gram because f*ck consistency.
I've heard people recommend _Dead Pool_ (James Powell) but I haven't read it.
I swear that SF water started tasting worse after they started adding groundwater a few years ago:
https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/san-francisco-new-sour...
That’s not directly comparable to residential rates because you now need to pump that water up hill and through a distribution network to customers.
Further, 0.01 cents per 6.4 gallons is 500$ per acre foot which is horrifically excessive for agriculture where most water is used. Desalination is therefore still only viable in very niche areas without heavy subsidies.
Which suggests that something is egregiously wrong with residential water pricing.
The number they are quoting is 0.41 $/m^3. Per capita water withdrawals (including agriculture) in the US were ~1200 m^3 in 2015 [1]. That means the cost per person to convert all residential, industrial, and agricultural to desalination is only ~480 $/(person * year). Or approximately 6/1000 of US GDP. Even if we assigned all of that cost to agriculture and food, all that would mean is that the average person's food budget would increase by ~480 $/year. That is sizeable, but not even slightest bit infeasible. If we really needed to we could just assign 3% of the US federal government budget to preventing death by starvation and thirst by achieving full water independence.
Desalinated water is only uneconomical in comparison to unsustainable groundwater depletion. On a absolute basis it is very affordable and would not constitute a material problem for the US or any other developed country.
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/263156/water-consumption...
Anyway your numbers aren’t even close. Water needs to reach people not simply exist. Groundwater depletion really isn’t a thing in the east cost, it’s mostly a thing west of the Mississippi and mostly at fairly high elevations.
To offset water withdrawals of people living 2km above sea level that 1200 m^3 of sea water would need 6480 kWh before consideration inefficiencies. For much of the Midwest you’re spending more on pumping than desalination, but you also need pipes etc.
I am being a little flippant here. Transitioning to a desalinated water economy is a gigantic megaproject. I am not including the costs needed to add all the transport infrastructure, but we also do not need to convert over 100%. We only need desalination where we are consuming water in excess of water renewal rates. And if you need excess water you will need to move your business to where water resources are cheap. That or your business and people die of no water. I know what I prefer. Luckily, highly productive farmland which consumes the vast majority of the water is generally on flat, low elevation ground where transport costs will be low.
Desalination is a viable solution. Are there challenges? Sure. Can you do it without any sacrifices and without changing your lifestyle at all? Probably not. But if your alternative is insufficient freshwater resources desalination can solve that economically at scale at a modest cost and with relatively minor sacrifices.
Spending 8% of the US budget to subsidize exports would be lunacy. Ban Alpha exports from California largely solves the problem within the state as does a host of other possibilities like say charging a fee for using an aquifer.
Anyway it’s a self correcting problem, when farms can’t pump out water they will shut down reducing water use. The US is such a massive exporter that none of this will be noticed by US consumers.
I pointed out how even if we decided to support and subsidize the moronic use cases the US can still easily support a desalinated water economy if we had to.
In actuality, if we moved to bulk desalination we would see a reconfiguration of water usage to higher value usage since water would be immensely more expensive. However, despite being much more expensive, even if we massively overestimate water usage by including water wasteful export crops, desalination still ends up being viable including the usage that would almost certainly disappear if they did not get to defray their depletion externalities.
Massive overestimate comes out reasonable. Therefore correct estimate will also come out reasonable.
You need to fix the underlying issues or nothing changes. But by fixing those issues there’s no niche for desalination.
Desalination is a solution in search of a problem, not a useful tool here.
This seems like a false dichotomy.
Want to pump that cubic meter of water 100 km inland and the energy cost alone will be over $1/m^3. Ignoring pumps, piping, maintenence, land purchasing, cabling, planning permission, etc etc.
Where people live isn’t where people consume aquifers faster than they are replenished. Across much of the east coast farmers don’t bother with irrigation because even the cost of pumping water from a well and delivering it to their fields isn’t worthwhile.
West of the Mississippi the amount of rainfall drops and therefore the need for water skyrockets. https://us-canad.com/rainfall-usa-map.html The difference between 150 inches per year of rainfall and less than 25 is huge.
At the same time the average altitude above sea level also increases. https://gisgeography.com/us-elevation-map/
So if you want to get water where it’s needed in the US. That’s mostly up hill and a long way from the sea.
PS: Coastal cities can always out bid farmers for water, or use some desalination but that’s a tiny fraction of the overall water usage.
You know you cannot simply dump it back into ocean in one place. It is also a problem in Gibraltar or so to say they have it figured out but it costs them a lot of money.
This is not the reason the US doesn't desalinate. It is actually actively making things worse in the places where it can still extract water from aquifers. Removing the water allows salt water to penetrate those thus destroying the local ecosystems. It's also speeding up the desertification of other areas.
Desalinating ocean water (done right of course) is part of the solution, not the problem.
Solutions like discussed in the article are more interesting for smaller/rural setups. Interesting but desalinating at industrial scale is a solved problem already. Can it be done cheaper. Probably and that would be nice. But it can be done economically right now. The largest challenges here are bureaucratic, not technical.
https://www.yourgibraltartv.com/society/28113-tender-awarded...
Gibraltar apparently doesn't have sewage treatment because they have some salt-water flush system for toilets due to fresh water historically being so expensive there and they seem to have had difficulty getting a treatment system that works with that.
In one episode they discovered a way to use the transporter to become young again. You would think eternal youth would be a big deal, right? Nope, it was never mentioned again.
Eternal youth using a transporter would have been shouted from the rooftops.
I recall the CEO of terraformation (Yishan Wong) talking about using desal with brackish wells : https://www.terraformation.com/blog/solar-powered-desalinati...
so .01 * 300,000/6.4 is... $500.
How often do they need the water?
This is 2015 data. Not sure if the rapid rise in solar and wind has changed this, though it might over time.
In the last 15 years large scale desalination has become practical. It's one of the great engineering feats of our time.
We can now generate it at scale for less than $.01 per 6.4 gallons. This includes the cost of the electricity, which is about half the expense.
San Francisco charges $.02/gallon to residents, 12 times that price. It's now cost effective for any coastal city in America to supply residential water this way.
Lots of people still think desalination is still impractical, because it was 20 years ago. They just haven't learned about the new tech.
The tech:
https://www.energymonitor.ai/tech/can-desalination-save-a-dr...
Residential rates:
https://sfpuc.org/accounts-services/water-power-sewer-rates/...