News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by anovikov on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:40AM (#37657822)
I wonder how this can happen without consequences. Is this even normal? Why Spain doesn't do anything? There are so many levers to pull. Think of citizenships of all Jews who repatriated to Spain after XVI century expulsions. Just make a hint over diplomatic channels that those can be revoked again.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by mathieuh on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:42AM (#37657845)
Because that would be collective punishment and illegal under international law. Of course, that doesn't stop Israel bulldozing Palestinians' houses.

To make it clear, I think it would be a very bad thing to revoke citizens' citizenship for any reason, let alone for the reasons you suggest.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by LegitShady on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:14AM (#37658134)
> Because that would be collective punishment and illegal under international law. Of course, that doesn't stop Israel bulldozing Palestinians' houses.

What does this have to do with random jews in spain?

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by mathieuh on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:29AM (#37658306)
It has nothing to do with them and I probably shouldn't have written it.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by bitcharmer on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:45AM (#37657870)
This is Israel. Firstly, you'll have to deal with some repercussions from the USA for taking any action. Secondly, try to criticise Israel and see what media brand you as.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by jamra on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:16AM (#37658153)
I really wonder, do you know that you hate Jews or is it a blind spot to your own prejudice? Collective punishment to every Jewish person is pretty hateful towards Jewish people. I see comments like these often enough but I’m always left wondering about the person posting it.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by mrpopo on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:39AM (#37658420)
Where did OP state that he hated jews? Is the Israeli government synonymous with Jewish people now? I have a lot of respect for Jewish people but a lot of resentment towards the Israeli government, as well as many Israelis.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by jamra on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:06PM (#37664311)
He wasn't talking about Israel. He was talking about Jews. Are you intentionally not reading what he wrote? I don't understand why this is a hard thing to understand. There is a huge difference between criticizing Israel and advocating for collective punishment of Jews. OP was doing the latter.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by bitcharmer on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:32AM (#37658338)
You just proved my point. Any criticism of the state of Israel which I was referring to will be called as hating on Jews.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by Chris2048 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:46PM (#37663982)
If it's Israel, not Jews, then what did you mean by "citizenships of all Jews who repatriated to Spain after XVI century expulsions" who are not Israelis?
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by jamra on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:10PM (#37664378)
No I did not. You are using this defense to target Jews more broadly than Israelis. You're being extremely prejudiced and I think you know you're doing it. The gaslighting is part of the message.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by denton-scratch on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:57AM (#37658595)
Have you stopped beating your wife?
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by jamra on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:35AM (#37686494)
Are you really defending comments suggesting that Jews should be collectively punished? Did you miss that from the original comment? I really hope so. Otherwise you're basically advocating for collective punishment based on peoples race.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by denton-scratch on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:11AM (#37687946)
"do you know that you hate Jews or is it a blind spot to your own prejudice?"

That question embodies the logical fallacy of assuming the consequent, and that's all my remark meant. I wsn't commenting on the substance of the discussion.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by jamra on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:27PM (#37696126)
I think you were. But honestly I was curious. I wonder when people defend prejudiced things if they’re doing it knowingly or if it’s a subconscious thing. Defending the collective punishment of Jews who were expelled from Spain for something a company did is a pretty wild leap. My comment was my attempt at pointing out the collective punishment of Jews, which was my issue with the OP. I don’t buy your argument that you’re somehow defending proper debate etiquette. The grandparent comment was very openly racist.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by denton-scratch on Friday September 29, 2023 @05:48AM (#37701379)
> I think you were.

Yes, that's clear; your original comment shows plainly that you interpreted my remark as antisemitic. It wasn't; it was pointing out a fallacy (and that formulation is nearly always used to point out that particular fallacy).

You can think what you like, of course; but screeching "antisemite!" based on nothing but your powers of telepathy is rather counterproductive.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by jamra on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:16PM (#37706377)
Your claim that I was making a baseless accusation is purposefully incorrect. You read the same parent comment suggesting group punishment for an entire people unrelated to the organization in question. I'm not judging you based on my non existent powers of telepathy, I'm judging you for your actions because you were sticking up for prejudiced statements. Your accusation that I was creating a straw man by conflating the advocacy of group punishment to the Jewish people by the Spanish government with antisemitism is wrong. That original comment was plainly and purposely in fact antisemitic. If you really are earnestly trying to be some sort of drive by moderator of debate, you're incorrectly applying it here. It is absolutely okay to "screech" antisemitism where it exists. The original comment was a clear demonstration of vile hatred against the Jewish people and I'm sure you were able to perceive that as well. But I guess you'll continue to evade, deny, and accuse your way out of owning your own behavior. In my personal life experience, I've come across many layers of prejudiced people. Some folks blatantly and openly spout racism. Others don't want to put quotable statements out there so they just sort of offer general support to the hateful folks without directly addressing the hateful statements as if they accidentally missed them. It's usually something about the rules or etiquette. What's the right way to call out racism? Do you suggest a more appropriate alternative? Or are you still suggesting that the racism in this case was a figment of my own imagination?
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by denton-scratch on Friday September 29, 2023 @05:06PM (#37710074)
> sticking up for prejudiced statements

I wasn't. I was calling out a fallacy. And upon reflection, in one short sentence you perpetrated TWO fallacies: you were also arguing ad-hominem.

When I encountered your leading sentence with it's fallacious construction, I stopped reading your comment. I've read your latest wall-of-text reply, stuffed with accusations of racism and antisemitism. I think it's fair to describe your attitude as "screechy".

I'm not interested in debating the substance of the G+P with you; your style of "debate" consists of smears, fallacies and abuse. Not playing.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by formerly_proven on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:49AM (#37657909)
lol this guy is talking about denaturalizing Jews and you’re going “see what the media brands you for criticizing Israel”
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by fortran77 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:27PM (#37662749)
The lie of "We just don't like Israel's policies -- we love the Jews" is seen though very quickly in Hacker News. In fact none of the people commenting here give a crap about Catalans in Spain. They just want an excuste to attack a people they hate.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by bitcharmer on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:49PM (#37663112)
Exactly, if you criticize the Israeli government then you're a anti-semite and a nazi. No, you're literally Hitler.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by asdadsdad on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:55AM (#37657964)
So, solution to a private Israeli cybersecurity company that sells services to governments is to deport all Jews from Spain? You must be fun at parties.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by crabbone on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:41AM (#37658431)
I knew someone who worked at NSO, and if I recall correctly, they required security clearance from employees (doesn't really mean much / I don't know what kind of clearance was required). It also doesn't mean they are a government body or are directly controlled by the government, but it could indicate that they are (but, most likely, they ask for it because they have government contracts that require it).

Not saying this has to have any implications for Spanish Jews. Just not sure how actually "private" they are.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by petre on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:09AM (#37658748)
NSO founder Niv Karmi is "ex" Mossad. No wonder they require security clearance.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by asdadsdad on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @10:00AM (#37659425)
lots of people in Israel are ex-Mossad or ex-security services/army/special forces
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by crabbone on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:24PM (#37662717)
Are you sure he was actually Mossad, not some 8200?

Israel has mandatory conscription, and 8200 (the army intelligence division) is a very common source for hi-tech companies in security sector.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by Chris2048 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @12:24PM (#37677060)
No option to vouch on this one?
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by rowanseymour on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:21AM (#37658190)
Punishing Spanish Jews for the actions of the Israeli settler colony would be illegal and morally wrong.. and also what the settler colony wants.. they need more Jewish migration to continue displacing the local Palestinian population.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by helpfulmandrill on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:26AM (#37658260)
The right-wing of Israeli politics draws strength from the conviction that Jewish people aren't safe anywhere in the world other than Israel. This course of action would only strengthen that conviction. Politically, if not exactly a win, it isn't an unambiguous loss either.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by sesm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @10:41AM (#37660132)
Spain deporting Jewish people will be a huge win for Israel. Israel is an expensive country with mandatory military service and a temporarily-frozen war on it’s borders. It has to actively spend money on repatriation programs to attract population. If Spain gives them some citizens for free they will be happy.
Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by kmeisthax on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:43AM (#37659197)
Punishing the people who left the control of a particular government for what that government did is a heinous crime. What you're proposing is not out of line with, say, FDR rounding up Japanese emigrants and putting them into internment camps.

I also should not have to remind you that antisemitism is the national sport of Europe. Mass expulsions of Jews are still within living memory. Your proposal is to re-enact a genocide, all in order to stop a nation-state spyware vendor whose only power is paying people to shut up about software bugs. Fantastic. Here's your First Annual AWARD For EXCELLENCE In BEING VERY SMART[0].

Israel's history is complicated and deeply layered in tragic irony. Britain, as it is prone to do, promised two different groups of people the same land it had colonized, which provoked very predictable civil wars, property confiscation of Palestinians, etc. I'm skipping over a lot of context and simplifying, but the end result is a country whose motto is "for every genocide you commit to the Jews, we'll commit one to you". Zionism is, ironically, a right-wing nationalist meme, so naturally, Israel has a right-wing nationalist government that it can't escape no matter how much Israel's citizens wish they could.

All of that is a fairly long-winded way of saying that Israel will take the mass expulsion of Jews as a casus belli against Spain. They will not abandon or prosecute the NSO Group, they will instead pay them exorbitant sums of money to make life as miserable as possible for Spain and everyone else. If not outright invade them. Remember that Israel's government has a prime minister who doesn't give a shit about his own war crimes, a nuclear weapons program, and a tattoo on its forehead that says "POOR IMPULSE CONTROL".

[0] https://xkcd.com/1386/

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by asdadsdad on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @10:09AM (#37659583)
Israel's motto is absolutely not to commit genocides in exchange for the Holocaust. Your comment is just offensive. Zionism is not and was never a right-wing nationalist meme or movement. The right-wing has arguably done Israel lots of good in the past, despite its mishaps these days. Politics aside, what Israel is, is a highly-resourceful, incredibly sharp and defensive-offensive security powerhouse that produces offensive tools and capabilities for use in its wars and NSO is a spin-off of these capabilities. No need to drag the Holocaust, Jews, Zionism (Jewish national/self-determination movement) in the discussion.

edit: there's nothing to be "learned" or to be "avenged" from the tragedy of the industrialized genocide of people.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by zer8k on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @11:09AM (#37660509)
> what Israel is, is a highly-resourceful, incredibly sharp and defensive-offensive security powerhouse

This is zionism. The worst kind too. The kind that makes it seem like if the west stopped funding Israeli nationalist movements they'd last more than a day. Truth is if the west cut off funding tomorrow and pulled their assets back Israel wouldn't last 12 hours by themselves.

Israel is a hand-me-down nation on stolen land entirely propped up by actual western powerhouses like the US and UK. They have very little of their own technology, what they do have is largely inferior to modern 4th and 5th generation warfare materiel (even the Merkava is largely inferior to even most previous generation Russian armor), and if you pay attention to politics "send money to Israel" (aka militant Zionism) is the rallying cry of AIPAC. Israel's only real technological asset is their intelligence which isn't saying much considering that too is largely funded by the actual intelligence powerhouse: The United States.

> Israel's motto is absolutely not to commit genocides in exchange for the Holocaust

Palestine would like a word with you. Israel, historically, is also a fan of extrajudicial murder of it's critics.

> there's nothing to be "learned" or to be "avenged" from the tragedy of the industrialized genocide of people.

Didn't Mossad commit extrajudicial murder in Argentina and other "Escape" countries to "avenge" the holocaust? Sure sounds like they aren't the angels of forgiveness you claim them to be. Sounds more like you're whitewashing history because even if the bad guys deserve to die extrajudicial murder makes it hard to back your nationalist argument. Turns out this hobby continues with the extrajudicial murder of Palestinian civilians but I'm sure you won't want to talk about that.

As a meta note to all this I'm pretty sure you'll call me antisemitic because it's the only argument militant Zionist shills have when they're cornered about Israel's actual bloody and frankly disgusting history. They have no moral and ethical compass and the west looks past it. The west is happy to pretend they're actually not the same people as other genocidal middle eastern nations because they're friendly and a strategically important asset. This little fact, the only reason Israel is allowed to exist is because they're a strategically important asset in the oil war, is so often forgotten by zionist shills it's often useful to remind them.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by asdadsdad on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @11:38AM (#37660955)
I wouldn't call you antisemitic, but at least very anti-Israel and anti-Zionism you are. Zionism is, partly, believing Israel has a right to exist and that Jewish people have a right to self-determination and a right to part of that land. Part of it. I will never say Israel is 100% correct in its acts in the region.

Not sure what "worst kind of zionism" means. To me just sounds like you're an extremist, so let's keep moving;

Israel has lasted more than a few hours standing alone during the wars for its existence. Against no less than all of the surrounding Arab countries. It has prevailed.

Israel exports an insane amount of security tooling and weaponry to the US, UK, and others. Its army is very advanced and very well-trained.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has nothing to do with the Holocaust, no less because it makes 0 sense to claim that. What do the Palestinians have to do with Nazi Germany to begin with?

Mossad carries extrajudicial operations, sure. Every intelligence service has external projections. Did they think it was fair to capture Eichmann in Argentina and bring him to justice in Israel? Sure. Do you think it is? Does that have anything at all to do with Palestine? Nope.

> bloody and frankly disgusting history

just empty hate again.

> other genocidal middle eastern nations".

Not sure you know what genocide is.

> the only reason Israel is allowed to exist is because they're a strategically important asset in the oil war.

Israel is not "allowed to exist". It exists and it it has proved time and again, every single day, how it can stand its ground in the region.

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by kmeisthax on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:48PM (#37663090)
There's no need to drag the Holocaust into a reply to someone literally proposing a second Holocaust to solve a petty cybercrime problem? I'm sorry, what?

As for Zionism, the premise of any state specifically dedicated to one people over others[0] is a right-wing meme, regardless of who argues for it, or who is currently in power there. The premise is a base assumption of right-wing politics - even if you are left-wing today, accepting it will eventually lead you to the right.

Zionism has the unique context of coming off one of the worst genocides in modern history, which combined with further genocides elsewhere[1] makes it extremely difficult to morally justify anything less than 'Israel gets this land no matter how much blood is spilt over it'. However, that doesn't mean blood wasn't actually spilt over that land[2], nor that Israel wouldn't do it again if push came to shove.

[0] Yes, this includes Palestine, which is constitutionally antisemetic. Remember that the right-wing's favorite argument as to why their chosen other is terrible is to point to that other's right-wing.

[1] e.g. the expulsion of Beta Israel from Ethiopia

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1948_Palestinian_expulsion_and...

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by Chris2048 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:53PM (#37664074)
> a reply to someone literally proposing a second Holocaust

Except the idea this would lead to Holocaust is yours, not theirs.

and based on what? "antisemitism is the national sport of Europe" - but for all the European countries that allied against Hitler?

Re:Spain cancels Pegasus spyware investigation because Israe... by dang on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:16PM (#37665245)
Please don't set off hellish flamewars on HN. It's not as if the effects of casually dabbling with atrocity are hard to predict.

We've had to warn you about this kind of thing before. Not cool.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html