Nope.
There were enough articles with outright lies to never believe anything from them until proven by numerous other, independent sources.
I.e. US republicans most often won't believe CNN and US democrats most often won't believe Fox.
The point here is, there are plenty of topics on which CNN and Fox coverage is very very similar: off the top of my head events in Israel and Taiwan
And on those topics, plenty of people just "trust the consensus" (or what appears to be the consensus, in western media)
https://www.peoplesworld.org/article/out-of-bounds-how-media...
They're politicking 101 made into 24/7 news media panic.
They're both charlatans and peddlers of lies and cheap tricks; they engage in propaganda and employ journalists who seem to believe that they're anything other than foot soldiers to stir up the masses against XYZ.
Everyone knows Fox News is trash, it's laughable when some continue to argue that CNN isn't.
Where XYZ can be anything, depending on which way the wind is blowing, sometimes it's each other, sometimes it's internal to the US, sometimes it's external
There's no need to be condescending.
The job of a news source it not to criticize, or not criticize, the annexation of Crimea. They're not a political party. Nobody but their mom really wants to know their private opinion.
The job of a news source is to provide news. All the news and articles Meduza produces follows the same pattern, where they would arrive at a predetermined conclusion regardless of the facts they are discussing, and the train of thought would go from A to B in a reasonably short route. If it's hard to derive the conclusion from some facts, they will be skipping reporting these where possible. If it's very convenient to derive the conclusion for unproven facts, they will be using these eagerly.
Propaganda is annoying to read, especially if you know you will disagree with their conclusion, which you obviously know in advance.
Yes, you are living in a tiny bubble. But at least you do not get to read propaganda pieces trying to derive prefabricated conclusions out of irrelevant small events. If anything large happens, you are going to hear of it earlier or later.
If you really want balanced coverage, choose a source from the other side which is so blatantly propagandist that you can have good laughs instead of grinding your teeth. I am reading The Guardian for that purpose.
Perhaps there are better ways to consume your news, but I don't know these.
> Yes, you are living in a tiny bubble.
How is that a tiny bubble?
> It is the century XXI, and the mainstream way seems to be subscribing to Telegram channels whose vibe resonates with you. Yes, you will be living in a tiny bubble.
I believe they mean "the mainstream way" puts you into a tiny bubble, but they go on to say:
> But at least you do not get to read propaganda pieces trying to derive prefabricated conclusions out of irrelevant small events. If anything large happens, you are going to hear of it earlier or later.
Thus, I believe they were advocating for a tiny bubble -- not accusing the previous commenter of being in a tiny bubble.
"It's not their job to have an opinion on the Nazi annexation of the Sudetenland, since they are not a political party, nobody but their mother cares if they think it is wrong."
Not everybody wants to read how mr. Hanz from "Der Jellyfisch" thinks that that the annexation of Sudetenland is wrong, day after day for a decade. We've got that already from you being in Switzerland, mr. Hanz.
Head-in-the-sand bullshit neutrality is why Switzerland is a moral toilet. Demanding that journalists be "neutral" is a sliproad to manipulation. These are nothing more than an abandonment of principles.
The public in functioning democracies is most definitely interested in reading opinionated editorial. Representing otherwise is downright obnoxious.
You will keep the audience who already agree with you, and often bet on that agreement (for example, by fleeing the country). You will, however, lose the rest of your potential audience by repeating your opinion over and over again. Since they know your position, they do not share it, and they no longer need that information.
Especially as you cannot answer any hard questions about your position, and you could not answer even if you didn't. As a journalist, you cannot really suggest any solutions, since you are not a politician. You can only whine. That gets old pretty fast.
- promote the idea of a ruling class separate from the people
- journalists that publish uncomfortable truths are "whining"
- just give up because no-one is listening
These are neo-Tsarist civics. As before, they form conditions for decay and conflict.
In reality, people have never stopped listening, and never will. They may stop hearing - when voices are intentionally silenced. It follows that a critical and editorial press is the hallmark of democracy.
Meduza and their ilk publishes the same uncomfortable truth tailored at comparatively small demographics. They fail to deliver their message to a wider audience because they don't understand it, have no message for it and perhaps don't really want to talk to it. That's what I was explaining. The only thing I'm seriously criticizing Meduza here is for their failure as journalists to get better coverage of their ideas. Part of which, their ideas aren't great.
Why more so than when the US destroy Afghanistan or some other place? What makes it worse and more worthy of being repeated because of authoritarianism?
A better comparison would be to the imperialist colonialism of the the 17th-19th centuries, as characterised by massacre, dictatorship, annexation, rape, child abduction, and the systematic and intentional destruction of entire cultures. This corresponds much more directly to the multiple Russian invasions of its neighbours in recent decades.
You storm into a country, you kill a lot of people, repeatedly, you do not care about these people in the slightest, you bomb weddings for a decade, you put up whatever government that you want there. But at least you did not annex the country, i.e. did not take responsibility for it and its citizens.
It is also "not a genocide", say you.
It's a totally different thing.
It doesn't matter what word you use: Genocide of X people is not worse than killing X+n in another country while calling it "victims from war on terror". This is not a competition of killing the most (if it were, the US would be in the lead).
The question is why does it matter what kind of government is causing the deaths? Why is it worse if X people are killed by an authoritarian regime than X people killed by a liberal democracy? If your Mother is killed by an authoritarian regime, is it worse than if your mother and child are killed by a democracy?
Instead of throwing whataboutism around, why not answer the question?
The question is in bad faith and a straw man. Nobody in this thread is defending US conduct in Afghanistan.
If you are not an American then it's quite obvious who is an aggressor in many, many invasions through the 20th (and now even 21st) century.
Care to imagine that same statement but with US?
But even given this... Would you say "Nobody cares what you think about Iraq, except your mother, so don't bother telling me about ..." Yeah it doesn't hold.
I believe, at most, that you would read it for a week, then give it another week and chuckle, and then abandon it.
Even if all of the articles are written in the good faith towards the facts and all.
In the mid 2000s, I pretty much did this, and I don't regret it. It would have been better for the world if the New York Times and Washington Post had leaned a bit more that way.
-> restricting what journalists may write
-> claiming the public has no interest in editorial opinion
-> labeling dissent as propaganda
The remark above is all three.
Which is kind of hilarious as US news sources are far less neutral than most of those politically colored newspapers!
also they got completely outlawed by the Russian regime, so they can't possibly get any advertising from Russian firms.
e.g. while Russia is responsible for invading, Victoria Nuland was caught red-handed orchestrating the Ukrainian coup/government that precipitated it.
Even Israel has more moderate/complicated views of it. On one hand they benefit from a strong West, on the other hand they possibly suffer from this particular proxy war (as it pulls Western resources & attention away from MENA into Europe). See Naftali Bennett's "tell-all" several months ago.
Fyi the leaked Nuland call (which I assume is what you're referring to), is of her discussing who they should support after the massive protests started and Yanukovych and his ministers left the country. She did not "orchestrate a coup". At most, it's the US trying to get Ukrainian parliament to pick the interim candidate they want which while is still manipulative, is far from "orchestrating a coup".
In order for there to be a coup, there has to be an unlawful seizure of power and that never happened. The president and his ministers left. I assume because the unrest of the people was so massive, he expected there would be a revolution. That would have been a coup, but even giving her support to a particular candidate the revolutionaries put forward, is not her causing a coup. Giving the revolutionaries weapons would be causing a coup. Sparking the revolution would be causing a coup. Getting one part of the government to overthrow the controlling part would be a coup. She did none of those things though (as far as we know).
Facing the reality of having no president and having no line of succession remaining, the Ukrainian parliament selected an interim president for an interim government until a new, full president could be elected and that is what happened.
...under threat of lethal violence. Their offices/residences were assaulted soon after they fled. Many people were murdered during the "protests".
> Giving her support of a particular candidate is not "orchestrating" any coup.
Please, let's be real. If Lavrov were caught saying things like "Trump should be President over Desantis. Let's keep Desantis out of government for now. Also let's be discreet about this. Putin is on board." and then all of that actually happened, like Desantis dropped out and endorsed Trump, what do you think the American reaction would be?
Some Americans even believe that something like this happened in 2016 ("Russiagate conspiracy theory"), but there is no evidence to support it. In reality, Trump was impeached over far less evidence.
We can debate semantics over the preferred definition of coup, but the bottom line is there was extraordinarily blatant foreign interference in Ukraine's democratic process, and the US government clearly played a central role and achieved their goals.
I can see how it can be called a coup because of the protesters' violence and arguing that difference is pretty pedantic so I have no problem with that.
The main point I was making was in response to the person so confidently claiming the US caused the coup. I don't think the call shows evidence of that. They only talk about coordinating their support for a candidate.
> If Lavrov were caught saying things like "Trump should be President over Desantis. Let's keep Desantis out of government for now. Also let's be discreet about this. Putin is on board." and then all of that actually happened, like Desantis dropped out and endorsed Trump, what do you think the American reaction would be?
If DeSantis dropped out because of Putin, it would be Russian influence again but on another level. Going to war level. DeSantis and Trump would be traitors and Russian co-conspirators, but I'm not sure if it would be a coup. Although I'm sure some would say that, the fact he was voted in would remain.
There is something to be said for manipulating the electoral process to a degree where it can't be called democratic, such as the situation in Russia at the moment where Putin's potential electoral opponents are jailed, killed, scared off, or oppressed to the point there is no other viable candidate to choose. So yes, I'd say there is a point where manipulating democratic process prevents it from being fair and is unlawful and it could be considered a coup in that scenario, but I don't think the US meets that threshold here. Would you call every other leader selection process where the US has given their support for a candidate a coup? I agree it is wrong and shouldn't be done, but do you really think it qualifies as a coup?
The US caused a coup in Panama when it bombed their infrastructure, invaded, and took their leader under arrest. The US caused a coup in Iraq when it invaded. The US caused a coup in Iran when it staged riots, paid off journalists, and paid off generals resulting in a change of leadership. There are many more examples of this, but all that was shown here was Nuland coordinated US support for a candidate. That's not enough.
The person who I originally responded to said it was a coup so confidently and absolutely as if it was another one of these scenarios. It was a strategic, diplomatic call exercising the US' influence. Not a coup.
> We can debate semantics over the preferred definition of coup, but the bottom line is there was extraordinarily blatant foreign interference in Ukraine's democratic process, and the US government clearly played a central role and achieved their goals.
Unfortunately semantics is where we have gone. The call does not show the US caused any coup. That's a significant mischaracterization. Influenced? Yes. Interfered with? By talking to their politicians, probably. Caused the overthrow of their government? No.
That's clearly a mischaracterization of what happened in Ukraine. Yes, Washington declared its support for the opposition in Ukraine. It also:
- bragged about spending $5 billion funding the opposition over preceding years.
- participated closely in the Yalta European Solution for decades, which was a forum for Washington power brokers + Ukrainian oligarchs.
- endorsed the overthrow of Yanukovych (i.e. by not demanding his democratic government was restored, which e.g. Washington did in Niger recently).
- and so on
It was a coup. It was primarily achieved through covert action, which by definition avoids yielding smoking guns that would cater to your personal, precise, technical definition of "coup", but given the totality of the circumstances we can only conclude that it was a coup.
What it seems like is that there isn't much evidence or sources. Anyone could claim anything was achieved through primary covert action and has not yielded any smoking guns or real evidence.
I could claim that all the coup hubbub was started by Russia as an attempt to ferment a civil war in Ukraine as a pretext for invading as achieved through covert action.
And when that failed they used there 'little green men' to start the civil war instead.
And if you want to see the sparking of the coup, this [2] is a video of John McCain (who was working alongside Nuland) instigating and emboldening the protesters, "America is with you. Europe is with you. The destiny you seek lies in Europe!" At the same time this was happening, Nuland was on the ground with protesters, memed as 'handing out cookies.'
Try to imagine something comparable happening in America. Imagine America was a relatively weak nation, and you had e.g. leading politicians from China out there rallying the protesters in DC, telling them that "China is with you! The destiny you seek lies in China!" That is going to not only dramatically embolden the existing protesters, but also draw out people from everywhere in the country who start thinking 'this could be it.' And indeed it was "it."
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity#Detailed...
The main point I was making was in response to the person so confidently claiming the US caused the coup. I don't think the call shows evidence of that. They only talk about coordinating their support for a candidate.
> And if you want to see the sparking of the coup, this [2] is a video of John McCain (who was working alongside Nuland) instigating and emboldening the protesters, "America is with you. Europe is with you. The destiny you seek lies in Europe!" At the same time this was happening, Nuland was on the ground with protesters, memed as 'handing out cookies.'
I've seen this mentioned before. While I think it's clear who the US supported in this coup and the US certainly was influencing the situation, calling John McCain's speech three months before Yanukovych left, the sparking of the coup, is very disingenuous. That speech didn't cause the coup.
I could definitely see the US actually being behind the coup though. They've shamelessly done it countless times throughout history. It's just nothing said so far is evidence of it.
Beyond this, I think you're also aware that if the US is sending people like McCain and Nuland to visibly rile up protesters, "we" were also doing far more behind the scenes, to make sure the coup could succeed. The number of protesters involved in the final attack on the Ukrainian Parliament was extremely small, relative to the earlier mass gatherings - numbering about 20,000 people. There was no real reason to think they would win, yet you had cities, police departments, and others openly and overtly defecting to the protesters, the military refusing to carry out orders and so on. That seems extremely unlikely to be organic, because if the protesters had failed overthrow Yanukovych, which one had every reason to think would be the case, then the defectors would have faced extremely severe consequences, up to and including charges of treason.
Oh there's also another funny little point. When the final charge on the parliament began, riot police managed to successfully scatter the first wave. Many protesters being pursued by riot police managed to evade them by taking shelter in... the Canadian Embassy. It's all about as organic as nuclear waste.
The US can show their support for the protesters (if only to get them to think favorably of the US), regardless of whether or not they think the coup will work. It's not evidence they caused the coup.
I agree with the rest of that paragraph up until the last sentence:
> There is 0 doubt that Yanukovych was the legitimate democratically elected leader of Ukraine, but because he made interests that were not aligned with those of the US, of course it didn't matter.
I think the people of Kyiv are the cause of the coup, not the US.
The rest of your comment does not provide good evidence of the US causing the coup. Like I said before, it's clear who the US supported, but none of what you presented is good evidence toward the US causing the coup.
I think there is too little and too weak evidence here to say the US caused the coup.
Unless you have evidence of a bribe, staging of protests, blackmail of officials, puppeteering of officials, attempted assassination of officials, government spy, some record of this plot, or some other good evidence along those lines directed toward causing the overthrow of the Ukrainian government, I don't think you can call the Ukrainian coup orchestrated by the US.
The gist of the agreement was that the opposition candidate would become prime minister and Yanukovych would remain president until the elections (which didn't materialize because he fled the country).
Note that there was no US at the table. Nuland and Pyatt weren't "orchestrating" anything. In fact, they were frustrated that the US wasn't participating in the talks, hence the "fuck the EU" in that call.
All this leak shows is that US officials were trying to influence negotiations to which they weren't invited.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agreement_on_settlement_of_pol...
It's a very tired canard to call it a coup, of course, but it's important to be accurate about these details.
Imagine the US was a relatively weak nation, and during the leadup to the mass protests comes riots around January 6th, in DC, you had leading politicians from China or Russia giving speeches in DC: "Russia is with you. China is with you! The destiny you seek lies in China!" Think about the impact this is going to have on people dissatisfied with their government. It's not only going to work as a catalyst towards radicalism for the existing protesters, but also draw out others who might otherwise not have been interested because 'This could really be it!'
"We must face the fact that the United States is neither omnipotent nor omniscient that we are only six percent [4% now] of the world's population, and that we cannot impose our will upon the other 94 percent of mankind that we cannot write every wrong or reverse each adversity and that therefore there cannot be an American solution to every world problem."
The sort of wisdom and pragmatism completely absent from politicians since JFK.
> Most of the world (i.e. outside the 15% of the population that is Western) views it as a nuanced situation with guilt on both sides.
...is a statement that cannot be supported by any known facts. It is a falsehood (if not an outright lie) used to bolster a tenuous argument.
Both of these are absolutely rampant in the West at the moment, but not so much in most of the rest of the world (at least not on this topic). People, left to their own devices, are generally pretty awesome. It's only when you introduce self righteousness and propaganda that we turn into unthinking animals. It's no coincidence that self righteousness and propaganda go hand in hand with war.
> Both of these are absolutely rampant in the West at the moment, but not so much in most of the rest of the world.
You think propaganda-driven homogeneous dogmatic thinking doesn't exist in China and India...?!
As for my comment, I was obviously just referring to this topic.
The claim of "orchestrating a coup" is unsupported by evidence, and any both-sidesism does not do justice to the fact that:
a) Ukraine has the right to elect whomever they want to govern their country, despite Russia's preferences to create vassals of its neighbor states
b) Russia has twice invaded Ukraine (as well as other neighbors like Georgia) and thus directly caused hundreds of thousands of deaths on both sides
Between Ukraine and Russia, only one of them is illegally occupying the territory of the other, only one of them is operating torture chambers in the territory of the other, and only one of them has kidnapped more than a million children from the territory of the other. There is no both sides between Russia and Ukraine in terms of guilt.
https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/04/03/ukraine-apparent-war-cri...
https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2023/03/war-crimes-i...
Israel is doing a great deal to support Ukraine with humanitarian and non-lethal military aid (like helmets) because Iran is on the other side, although you are correct to note that the situation is complicated, largely because of Russia support for a bloody regime in Syria.
https://kyivindependent.com/on-support-for-ukraine-israel-pe...
People focused on US actions during the Yanukovych years seem to believe that he himself was legitimate, when there is much evidence that he was corrupt, anti-democratic and supported by Russia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Yanukovych
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/odr/yanukovych-luxury-resid...
As for the 15% claim, I would add that a large part of that 15% supporting Ukraine includes countries that share a border with Russia or its vassals, including eastern EU and NATO states, as well as Japan and S. Korea. Those countries have the most skin in the game, and their position and actions in this conflict should be given much greater weight than the rest of the world. It's not a coincidence that they want Russia's wars of expansion to stop in Donbass.
Acknowledging the systemic flaws of liberal democracy is not a conspiracy theory. In fact, it is the opposite: it explains the reality of modern democracy in terms of structural factors and incentives. That said, he also describes actual conspiracies e.g. how particular advertisement campaigns operated.
This was well-understood a century ago.
The people who regurgitate what they learn in their state-approved textbooks/movies are more akin to conspiracy theorists; it requires a certain level of fantastical thinking to believe that USA, on a national level, has a de facto democratic system.
That is kind of crazy if you take into consideration that one side invaded the other.
Popular contradictions today: It's a human right to dress and act like any sex one chooses. It's evil and horrible to dress and act like a different race.
Global warming is the biggest threat to mankind. Coming into the office is more important.
Flying around the globe is to talk down to others who are doing more about global warming earns praise.
So basically you picked a side and trust only what news agree with your beliefs?