News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by drt5b7j on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:33AM (#37378425)
Google is a great example of "it's difficult to get someone to understand something if their paycheck depends on not understanding it".

Even before google was founded and the founders discussed how they could monetize their search, they understood that paid ads create a conflict of interest: the point of search which is to to return the most relevant results, but the incentive in paid ads is to return the best paying ads. One of their papers contains this point _in writing_.

However, every single time I pointed this out to a person working at google they immediately jump into Olympic level acrobatics to explain why the two things are not in conflict. I especially enjoy hearing the argument that in a free market the most relevant advertiser also happens be the one who can afford to pay the most. I've never worked at Google, but I would bet that part of their induction is to train their employees how to combat these ideas.

Anyway big picture google isn't one of the worst.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by lemper on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:39AM (#37378452)
well articulated.

if any of you google employees reading this thread, if you love open and free web, get out of google. you're part of the problem.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by guessmyname on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:48AM (#37378506)
> if any of you google employees reading this thread, if you love open and free web, get out of google. you're part of the problem.

Shouldn’t we give the opposite advice? To stay at Google in order to gain influence as to create initiatives to guide the company into a better direction?

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by generic92034 on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:56AM (#37378546)
You will not get into such a position if you are advocating for things that harm Google's bottom line (or at least you would not stay there for long).
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by scarface_74 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:02AM (#37378583)
So how do you have “free” without ads?
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by nottheengineer on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:24AM (#37378687)
You start differentiating between free and gratis.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by scarface_74 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:39AM (#37378773)
And you still didn’t answer the question. What does an “open” search engine look like and who is going to pay for the infrastructure?
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by ziftface on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:48AM (#37378834)
The same way libraries are free: they're actually paid for by taxpayers.

If the internet was invented in America's earlier days, a lot of these information tools would be a public service, similar to libraries, and we'd all be better for it.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by krapp on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:25AM (#37379057)
You're under the mistaken impression that Americans like their taxes to go towards public services. Many public libraries are underfunded, and what funding they get is sometimes wrapped up in censorship laws serving an increasingly hostile and paranoid constitutency. "Public service" is synonymous with "government controlled service."

Google would be no different. Forget any "innovation" any of Google's satellite projects may have had, they simply wouldn't exist, too expensive. The service would be stripped down to a bare bones minimum of functionality and farmed out to lowest-bid contractors to save money. The CIA, NSA and law enforcement would have backdoors everywhere (so no difference there), "controversial" sites would be delisted or fined (because broadcast decency laws would probably apply, and the taxpayers would insist any indecency be removed) and the whole thing would wind up privatized by the Republicans anyway, so it would still run ads at the end.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by ziftface on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:46AM (#37379190)
I hadn't thought of it that way, you're making some good points.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by scarface_74 on Monday September 04, 2023 @07:48AM (#37379580)
You have seen how governments have censored and banned books that went against their political or religious leanings?

You don’t think that they would do the same thing for search engines?

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by knorker on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:24AM (#37378686)
Not everyone at Google works on ads.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by superchroma on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:27AM (#37378703)
Not all the Nazis drove the trains to Auschwitz either.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by msoad on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:55AM (#37378540)
Now think of ChatGPT with this framework. Because it is paid to do, it will slowly try to convince you to buy something or even worse think of some politician or party differently. Scary stuff!
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by dmarchand90 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:11AM (#37378616)
The nice thing with ChatGPT is they've established a viable funding model through paid subscriptions from day 1.

On the other hand I predict that we will see the next ten years as a 'golden age' of steadily improving performance from ChatGPT, which will then plateau and 'enshittify'.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by mike_hearn on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:53AM (#37378861)
I don't think we know yet if it's viable or not. All they've said is that Plus is break even on "compute" (i.e. probably not training, definitely not staff/data costs).
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by random_ on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:03AM (#37378928)
I don't think that will be enough to stop ads there, given that $2k+ smart TVs are blotted with permanent factory ads now.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by xnx on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:05PM (#37384427)
Monthly fees don't stop cable TV from showing ads.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by wschfdkbrmcdf on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:18AM (#37378648)
It doesn’t matter in the slightest which Party you prefer
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by catchnear4321 on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:13AM (#37379745)
the presence of the preference matters far more than the preference itself, at least to those that profit from polarizing people.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by onionisafruit on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:34AM (#37379897)
It doesn’t matter which party you as an individual prefer, but there is big money in trying to change or entrench the preferences of groups of people.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by robertlagrant on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:56AM (#37378545)
> Even before google was founded and the founders discussed how they could monetize their search, they understood that paid ads create a conflict of interest: the point of search which is to to return the most relevant results, but the incentive in paid ads is to return the best paying ads. One of their papers contains this point _in writing_.

It's not just their papers. Their philosophy - which was a big part of everyone moving from other search providers in the late 90s - was never having ads in the search results.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by onionisafruit on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:30AM (#37379860)
I had forgotten about that, but now that you remind me I used to make that point when I recommended Google to friends. Now I feel like a sucker all over again.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by gizmondo on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:57AM (#37378553)
> I've never worked at Google, but I would bet that part of their induction is to train their employees how to combat these ideas.

You'd lose the bet. Rather I think the entire topic of monetization is glossed over.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by drt5b7j on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:40AM (#37379149)
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by gizmondo on Monday September 04, 2023 @09:37AM (#37380342)
I skimmed both articles and they seem to be about anti-trust, which is orthogonal to the relevance-revenue conflict you described. Have I missed anything, or did you think a random unrelated fact proves your point somehow?
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by wkat4242 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:04AM (#37378592)
Google may not be the worst but it's the biggest offender that reaches consumers.

Their BS motto "Don't be evil", it makes me sick thinking of it now. They really made the world a much worse place.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by ahofmann on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:11AM (#37378617)
While I understand what you mean, you should state at least one reason of why you think they are deeply evil people.

To me, it's the story of how they systematically convince small firms that they want to do business, only to screw them over. Like Google Earth and Terra Vision, for example. Also, from the beginning, the proximity to the U.S. government was very noticeable, such as Keyhole or leasing military land.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by Fluorescence on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:27AM (#37378710)
Just judge them by their own supposed goals, organising information. They fail. And they fail not for inability, but for greed. You can quibble about what types of non-good behaviour are evil, but first accept that "evil" was cute language.

They are a distorting middleman and their scale means the cultural damage is incalculable. They create a near monopoly search that offers no user control over it's behaviour and it functions to vanish small independent creators under commercial interests and adverts. Just look at one property - youtube - the inability to find title matched videos by search, the shovelling of shorts, the pruning of valuable user features etc. None of these have been about increasing user experience, user power or the access of information, it's about increasing Google's Smaug like horde of gold.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by sneak on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:18AM (#37378653)
https://cloud.google.com/blog/topics/inside-google-cloud/upd...

One can make a strong argument that actively seeking collaboration with an organization that runs a global network of extralegal and extrajudicial torture centers qualifies as evil.

AWS, for example, operates a special airgapped "region" at Langley for the CIA to store and process their data, which presumably includes operational information related to the global network of assassination and torture personnel they develop, own, and operate.

Many people give the military and military-adjacent a moral pass on things like mass murder (or mass murder adjacent things like extrajudicial assassination, kidnapping, or torture), but not all of us do. You may or may not personally disagree, but it is still a reasonable and cogent argument that seeking active collaboration with DoD qualifies for the title of "evil" on the grounds that it will more effectively enable mass murder, assassination, torture, and other deprivations of human rights.

Google also rebooted their censored search project, known as Dragonfly, to re-enter the Chinese market, which included the specific feature that would display government-provided AQI indicators/values instead of the real ones. Eventually word got out and they stopped again.

This shows that they are willing and able to collaborate with any government, no matter how repugnant their stance on human rights, if it will result in increased revenue or market access for Google. That's evil, in my book.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by jsnell on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:29AM (#37379850)
> This shows that they are willing and able to collaborate with any government, no matter how repugnant their stance on human rights, if it will result in increased revenue or market access for Google. That's evil, in my book.

Google actually left China and didn't go back. That's rather different to other large tech companies. Consider Apple, which not only never left China but become totally dependent on it for manufacturing the phones they sell elsewhere, and direct revenue from iPhones and the App Store. For example Apple is regularly giving user data to the Chinese authorities -- they get thousands of requests per year and handing over the data in the vast majority of cases [0]. Google has accepted one request in a decade [1].

So it's pretty odd to use China as an example of why they're evil. How can their leaving and aborting a later attempt to re-enter be worse than Tim Cook being held over the barrel by the CCP and doing little to get out?

[0] https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/cn.html

[1] https://transparencyreport.google.com/user-data/overview?hl=...

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by sneak on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:40PM (#37382142)
At present, China is the only place on all of Earth that can manufacture 50,000 iPhones per hour, which is on the close order of how many they sell.

In a certain sense, the iPhone is a wholly Chinese product. Without China, there is no iPhone, and there is no Apple-as-we-know-it-in-2023.

I am of the belief that Apple is doing everything in their power to change that, as even a cold war with China would put a rapid end to that.

Apple is investing huge amounts of money in India to create a parallel supply chain for iPhones.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by jsnell on Monday September 04, 2023 @01:03PM (#37382391)
Yes, I agree. That makes Apple completely beholden to the CCP. If they anger the CCP, their whole business is gone.

But I fail to see how that makes any of this more acceptable. They had 15 years to diversify. They didn't, but chose to instead spent that time just becoming more involved with a brutal autocracy, gambling their whole company on it.

It was stupid (one of the rare strategic missteps by Apple), it was amoral, and somehow still this is seen as being totally fine while Google toying around with launching a single product in China but not doing it was quoted as evidence of them being evil in this very thread. And I kind of feel like your reply reinforces that point.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by wkat4242 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:59AM (#37378907)
For me it's the extreme surveillance they have introduced. Every website activity you do hits google. Smartphones log everything to google. Look on google maps, you can see exactly where you were every day in the last 10 years. This whole infrastructure should just not exist.

Yes I know you can opt out of some of it but they make it as hard as they can and many things like google analytics just can't be opted out of.

But I edited the deeply evil part as I also thought it was too harsh :) It was only there for a minute so I'm surprised you saw it. I do really believe they made the world a much worse place though. And yes if they hadn't someone else would have (like Zuckerberg). But that doesn't forgive it.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by robertlagrant on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:13AM (#37378626)
I don't think they made the world a worse place. Can you show your working? Pros/cons for the existence of Google?
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by wkat4242 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:58AM (#37378897)
Well everyone is now followed constantly in their activity by their technology. They really made the world a panopticon dystopia.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by robertlagrant on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:12AM (#37378970)
Well, they bought doubleclick, which was already doing that. I don't think Google invented this, and if they hadn't existed, wouldn't it have continued to happen anyway?
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by Fluorescence on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:16AM (#37378636)
I see it as a guilty conscience in anticipation of the inevitable.

Even the naive do not take long to realise that capitalism will fill the immoral corners of an opportunity like water. If you wanted a real commitment, you don't talk to yourself about sobriety as you walk into a bar, you have to tie yourself to the mast Odysseus-like. It needed a different form of governance, a non-profit that could have created sustainable non-evil. An IPO sells your soul not just your company.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by ssss11 on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:28AM (#37378712)
Pure doublespeak
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by shapefrog on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:10AM (#37378612)
> part of their induction is to train their employees how to combat these ideas

You dont need to indoctrinate people; the selection process takes care of most of the heavy lifting and the rest is taken care of by the fat paycheque and stock options.

imo there is absolutely nothing wrong with the conflict of interest, pretending it doesnt exist however suggests either dishonesty or a special kind of stupidity.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by drt5b7j on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:27AM (#37379071)
> imo there is absolutely nothing wrong with the conflict of interest, pretending it doesnt exist however suggests either dishonesty or a special kind of stupidity

Right, in principle I don't strongly disagree with you. Certainly in the short term the intelectual dishonesty bothers me more than making money by bumping up results.

But whether that is a real issue or not, depends on how relevant Google is in our society. If there's alternatives, people can try them. If there's no alternatives, having the power to control the results to benefit yourself is maybe too much power concentrated in too few hands. It's unclear to me where we stand right now. I haven't used Google search in many years (DDG), but I'm aware they're hugely influential to basically everyone else.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by The_Colonel on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:40AM (#37378782)
Yes, there is a conflict, but it's not an unsolvable one.

Google implemented a compromise - paid ads get displayed at the top, but they are marked as ads, so if you want the most relevant results, you scroll below the paid ads.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by thaumasiotes on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:46AM (#37378826)
Paid ads used to be displayed to the side of the results. Being displayed instead of the results isn't so much of a "compromise".
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by The_Colonel on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:51AM (#37378846)
"instead" suggests that the actual results aren't there, which isn't true.

You just need to scroll a bit. Google needs to tread the balance to stay usable, otherwise people stop using it.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by thaumasiotes on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:08AM (#37379706)
If the results are there, but not displayed, then whatever is displayed is being displayed instead of the results.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by The_Colonel on Monday September 04, 2023 @10:40AM (#37380911)
The results are displayed on the page, just a little bit below the ads.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by thaumasiotes on Monday September 04, 2023 @07:52PM (#37386325)
If you have to scroll, they are not displayed. You seem to have a working definition of "display" which does not include making something visible, but that conflicts with every actual definition of the term.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by The_Colonel on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:26PM (#37436591)
That depends on the size of the screen then? On my 15" laptop screen if I google "buy s23", I see both ads and non-ads without scrolling.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by dredmorbius on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:53AM (#37378862)
How those ads are presented has changed tremendously over time:

<http://searchengineland.com/wp-content/seloads/2016/07/googl...>

60% of people cannot tell ads from organic search results:

<https://www.smartinsights.com/paid-search-marketing-ppc/paid...>

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by The_Colonel on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:09AM (#37378955)
Indeed. Google is far from being a saint. The idea I'm disputing is that the conflict between organic results and ads is impossible to solve. Google solved it many years ago, but is now regressing from it.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by vinay_ys on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:52AM (#37378854)
One of the most shocking thing I experienced working at Google compared to my previous job (e-commerce with very thin operating margins) is that hardly anyone cared about potential revenue vs cost tradeoffs or monetization more broadly.

Vast majority of people are working on building some feature functionality or enhancing an underlying system infra for more scale or performance or such non-functional capability which they genuinely think will improve user experience and hence make users prefer to use their product more than anything else.

People didn't focus on business metrics (most people don't know what they are) – this was most disorienting for me. It took me sometime to understand the luxury provided by strong margin business that is google ads which allows you gloss over short-term inefficiencies while exploring new product spaces.

It is assumed monetization in the form of ads or subscription can be done if there is strong user engagement for the product and that revenue vs cost equation will work out. (If not, they kill it, which they do badly). Another culture at Google is people are openly critical of their product in very large internal discussion forums.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by mike_hearn on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:03AM (#37378927)
Some of the arguments aren't actually Olympian, although if you have a pre-existing bias against commerce or capitalism it may feel that way.

Most obvious example query of where PageRank totally fails: [flowers]. The correct top result here for 99.9% of searchers is a local flower shop or possibly a big flower delivery chain, but it's not the Wikipedia page for flowers. Likewise for [hotel near me] which an algorithm like PageRank will yield garbage for, [oppenheimer showtimes] and many other very popular query types.

Link based ranking just doesn't work for this sort of result. You need data that isn't on the web which means you then need a way to rank it. And how exactly do you plan to rank flower shops or movie theatres? You've got no data on which to do that. Even if they have a website at all (big if) people don't organically link to them. Attempts to gain ranking data via things like user reviews will fail, almost nobody real reviews local stores or cinemas so if you rely on that then either you'll be flooded with fake reviews, or companies will aggressively push people to write them, or both, and users hate both outcomes.

Ad auctions work much better. Users don't have to do anything directly, they just buy things from the best businesses as they see it, revenue flows to those businesses enabling them to bid higher for ads, so users see the most successful businesses as determined by the market as a whole, which is much harder to game than user reviews or PageRank.

When the original Google was built, it was built by students. Their first ever test query was the name of the guy who ran the university. Their edge was ranking publicly available web pages using link graphs, so they just weren't thinking about commercial queries at all and if that's the scope of your ambition then yeah it will look like ads are always a conflict of interest because the only model you can imagine is re-ranking organic informational results surreptitiously. Once they turned on their first search backend deal and got experience running a search engine with serious non-nerd user traffic for the first time, they realized there were tons of popular queries that their whole approach just sucked at and would always suck at. That's when they realized that in some cases "ads are information", as they put it.

That wasn't some sort of paycheque-induced intellectual blindness, if it was then Google would have gone bankrupt a long time ago. It was an actual fundamental realization about the nature of what people use search engines for.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by DrScientist on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:24AM (#37379046)
Very interesting.

At it's heart advertising is about informing potential customers about products or services [1].

One aspect you've missed though is the free-versus-paid dimension - here the competition is between people creating links, versus paid for promotion.

You could argue that reflects the value perceived by the paid or free 'customers'. However I think in the area of politics and ideas there is a dangerous imbalance - because of the power of professional promotion.

In essence common sense is being drowned out by paid agendas - because of the difference in impact a paid professional can make.

[1] Let's ignore all the dark arts aspects for now.

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by drt5b7j on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:24AM (#37379045)
That's one interpretation. An alternative interpretation is they realized that making non-paid results worse increases the clickthru rate for the paid results.
Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by soraminazuki on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:32AM (#37379104)
> I would bet that part of their induction is to train their employees how to combat these ideas.

Exactly. This has been reported [1] and expanded on [2]. In a nutshell, they have internal learning materials designed to train employees to not recognize anti-competitive behavior.

[1]: https://themarkup.org/google-the-giant/2020/08/07/google-doc...

[2]: https://zyppy.com/seo/googlespeak/

Re:Google was founded 25 years ago Today by tomjen3 on Monday September 04, 2023 @10:57AM (#37381089)
Advertised search also incentivise bad results so you will do more searches.