News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ryandrake on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:44AM (#37337957)
In the US, minds are slowly changing on free speech. 40% of Millennials are OK with limiting speech offensive to minorities[1] and the trend by age cohort is very clear. We may disagree but we old people are aging out, and the newer generations are less likely to be free speech absolutists. Another poll[2] shows 61 percent of Americans agree that free speech should be restricted, and 51 percent believe that the First Amendment, ratified in 1791, should be rewritten to reflect the new cultural norms of today.

1: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2015/11/20/40-of-mil...

2: http://campaignforfreespeech.org/new-poll-free-speech-under-...

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by uLogMicheal on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:23AM (#37338646)
We live in an age of government driven perception management at scale. From all over the world there are efforts online trying to erode free speech by either making things bad enough to convince others action against fundamental rights is needed, or by other more subtle means of manipulation. Do the people polled understand the current and historical significance of freedom of speech or have they been attacked into submission from division manufactured by sources that want the repeal of common freedoms?
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ExoticPearTree on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:50AM (#37338043)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_...

I do not have a better response than this. Some people never learn anything from history...

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by Ntrails on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:15AM (#37338494)
The argument works both ways. In a concrete example:

Burning the Koran is offensive, should it be restricted? No! Freedom! Next they'll stop us watching old westerns and doing fancy dress etc! We have to be able to prevent this being extended to things which affect me.

Burning the Koran is offensive, should it be restricted? Yes! If we allow it then they can burn the flag/constitution/bible/effigies of the president/??? we have to be able to prevent this being extended to things which affect me.

"First they did x" construction works in both cases non?

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by jlawson on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:28AM (#37338741)
Non, because they can already "burn the flag/constitution/bible/effigies of the president/???"

This is the status quo and it's accepted by nearly everyone on the free speech side. There is no sequence of future reductions in human rights to prevent.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by RandomLensman on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:08AM (#37338369)
A lot of countries had and have more restrictions than the US. Is Switzerland really worse than the US to live in, for example?
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by mvncleaninst on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:36AM (#37338878)
Switzerland is relatively niche, I think the UK would be a better comparison
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by thereddaikon on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:13AM (#37338455)
Its difficult to meaningfully compare small mostly homogenous nations with larger, more diverse ones. It not hard to imagine that when you have an overwhelmingly homogenous society, the need for free speech is greatly lessened because there are far fewer dissenting voices. Free speech is there to protect those minority dissenting voices, not the majority ones who will are going to hold popular and socially acceptable opinions.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by comte7092 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:19AM (#37338558)
The fact that you describe Switzerland as “mostly homogeneous” really undermines the credibility of your argument.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by thereddaikon on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:22PM (#37339699)
Switzerland oddly does not collect ethnicity information in its census but it does collect nationality and language information and its pretty easy to conclude that Switzerland is overwhelming white Europeans over 85% of which are German or French speakers.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by comte7092 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:32PM (#37339846)
Ah see now I have clarity.

You are indeed making the “things that work in other places won’t work in America because of differences in race and ethnicity” argument.

This is a fairly lazy analysis that plays on America’s often unspoken cultural beliefs around race. While it is true that race is a major cultural marker in America, this fact is not innate and the oft repeated argument that “homogenous” societies can do things that we can’t amounts to little more than “we can’t do it because we are different”.

The determinants of diversity in the sense that it might be relevant to a discussion on free speech depend on a multitude of cultural factors. You can’t just say “well they aren’t diverse because they don’t match the criteria set out and defined by _America_”.

95% of Americans speak English. If half the country didn’t speak English well that would make for a very different society and culture than the one we have now.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:54PM (#37340207)
Not quite true, epigenes have conclusively been shown, at least for a few generations, to be innate, inheritable, heavily modifiable by extreme enough environmental factors (such as starvation, violent crime, war, etc.), and even capable of skipping a generation and re-expressing later on like normal genes

Whether or not such changes lasts through several dozen generations is still undecided though.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by comte7092 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:59PM (#37340303)
What does that have to do with this discussion on free speech?
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:04PM (#37340386)
> This is a fairly lazy analysis that plays on America’s often unspoken cultural beliefs around race. While it is true that race is a major cultural marker in America, this fact is not innate and the oft repeated argument that “homogenous” societies can do things that we can’t amounts to little more than “we can’t do it because we are different”.

You italicized innate so I assumed you meant to put special emphasis on that part?

For example, it's at least theoretically possible for someone who had ancestors a few generations ago that were enslaved to suffer some bonafide inherited and disadvantageous epigenetic mutations.

Or for those who has ancestors who got shell-shocked in past wars, got involved in serious car crashes, etc...

I'm not sure if such factors should be considered legally, lest competition turn it into some kind of pity olympics, but there's a non-zero chance large segments of the population came out of the womb genuinely, innately, disadvantaged slightly.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by comte7092 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:33PM (#37340818)
> For example, it's at least theoretically possible for someone who had ancestors a few generations ago that were enslaved to suffer some bonafide inherited and disadvantageous epigenetic mutations.

Emphasis on theoretically.

> there's a non-zero chance large segments of the population came out of the womb genuinely, innately, disadvantaged slightly.

may be slightly affected. Again, how is this relevant to a discussion on free speech?

My point was that there is no innate reason why race would lead to politically divergent opinions, at least not to the degree that it would lead to such major discord that it would require a fundamentally different model of free speech in society.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:36PM (#37340852)
I agree? That's why I replied with a 'Not quite true' instead of a flat 'No' or 'that's incorrect' or some variation.

It's somewhat relevant since these epigenetic mutations can increase the probability of someone being a misanthrope, for example, that just hates other people and who doesn't care about their lack of free speech.

Or vice versa, someone with increased anxiety/nervousness/etc., and would be exceedingly disturbed by even small regressions in free speech rights.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by thereddaikon on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:40PM (#37342655)
No that's not the argument I'm making at all. But thanks for putting words in my mouth. It isn't about any intrinsic quality of race. But race does have a component inasmuch as any way to define an in and out group does.

White western Europeans have very similar cultures and societal norms due to their shared history. A Frenchman, Swiss and German are likely to have generally similar views on what would be acceptable speech for example.

But not all Americans have a shared culture and history that would influence their ideas. That's because, from even the very beginning, we have had a very civic minded form of nationality that 300 years ago was unheard of. And today is still fairly unique. But if I am a Presbyterian New Englander my cultural norms and what would be considered socially acceptable behavior will differ than a Baptist Southerner, A Catholic West coaster or an Atheist Midwesterner. There different regional cultures, religions, and cultural influences from our immigrant ancestors are going to shape things quite a lot. When I was growing up we called this the American melting pot. I don't know if that terminology is still used.

When you have a nation of immigrants they are going to have different ideas they want to express. Usually you will have one majority but many majorities. Traditionally that majority was rooted in the descendants of early English colonists. Sometimes derisively called WASPs. America has had a lot of strife between different groups interacting such as the large Irish influx during the potato famine. German and Italians during periods of upheaval in the late 19th century. Chinese immigrants on the west coast around the same time. Interactions and immigration both ways with our northern and southern neighbors. The consequences of the African slave trade. It goes on and on.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by brightlancer on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:26PM (#37341667)
> The fact that you describe Switzerland as “mostly homogeneous” really undermines the credibility of your argument.

I'd love to hear an argument about how Switzerland is heterogeneous, but here's what I found:

Switzerland is a country of ~8.5M, or the same population as New York City, or 2/3 the population of the rest of New York State, or less than the population of Virginia and 11 other states.

And Switzerland is ~40k km², a bit less than New York State.

What I'm saying is it's very small compared to the US, with 330M people across 9M km² of land.

As for homogeneity, Switzerland doesn't have birthright citizenship (where the US does), so foreign nationals may remain foreign for multiple generations; it's also part of the Schengen, permitting EU members to travel and reside without a visa or other permission. All of this makes an apples to apples comparison with the US much harder.

Switzerland is ~75% Swiss nationals, with ~25% foreign nationals, but ~85% of those are from the Schengen area.

About 15% of the US population is foreign born, but almost half of those are naturalized citizens -- there's also 10M+ foreign nationals in the US illegally (more than the pop of Switzerland), though any children they have in the US will be natural-born citizens (unlike in Switzerland). If we include the first US-born generation, it jumps to 28% of the US population. And when we look at where those immigrants come from, two of the top three origins are in Asia (India and China).

Again, I don't know how to make an apples to apples comparison. It's likely that Switzerland is more heterogeneous than some places in the US, while less so than others. But if I had to make a broad statement, yeah, Switzerland is much more homogeneous than the US, and I'd love to hear an argument against it.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by RandomLensman on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:18AM (#37338553)
How diverse was the nation that could enjoy the 1st amendment when it was passed compared to now? It is perhaps more a retrospective justification that would need data to support it.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by thereddaikon on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:23PM (#37339722)
America was if anything less diverse then than now. We've had many large periods of emigration since then. And that combined with the challenges with new technology tells me the first amendment is more important than ever.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by RandomLensman on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:44PM (#37340021)
Do you have any supporting data for that view or, rather, what might convince of the opposite of your view?
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by thereddaikon on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:28PM (#37342466)
Give me some authoritative statistics that show otherwise.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by fidotron on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:44AM (#37339020)
Switzerland also has a model of direct democracy that meets curious amounts of resistance when suggested virtually anywhere else.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:38PM (#37339943)
The US was designes as a republic specifically to prevent tyranny of the majority.

Already the direct-democracy bills of county elections destroy me. The _majority_ has voted to steal from me to pay for their daycare, housing, and other non public good subsidies every single voting cycle.

A direct democracy allows majority theft with no recourse or limit. It's proposterous!

There was a reason for voting qualifiers at the founding of the country. I say we bring them back if we want to switch to direct democracy so that only those with skin in the game get to vote: restrict voting to only those persons that pay income taxes on agi.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by comte7092 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:48PM (#37340096)
> The US was designes as a republic specifically to prevent tyranny of the majority.

The phrase “try any of the majority” was rarely used by writers and thinkers in the founding period. It was alluded to in one of the 85 essays that made up the federalist papers and the coining of the phrase is generally attributed to a French writer several decades later.

Your characterization is largely historical revisionism.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:37PM (#37340862)
Thanks. I was unaware.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by fidotron on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:09PM (#37340469)
While I agree with you on certain points it is worth considering that US foreign policy proclaims to advocate for the spread of democracy and not the spread of constitutional republicanism.

I think Peter Thiel made some remark (maybe in his poorly moderated student youth period) along the lines of "Freedom is incompatible with democracy" which has an uncomfortable amount of truth to it assuming the state you are in remains actually committed to protecting those freedoms.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:42PM (#37340961)
It is rather obvious to me at this point that the federal government is not in favor of its design. It advocates for democracy because the goal is to install true democracies and then unleash the cia to run persuasion operations to influence voting outcomes.

It is very similar to the rhetoric I hear when the left talks about attacks on democracy. They don't seem to actually mean democracy. They seem to mean their version of it, as in those voters that are aligned with them.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by fidotron on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:53PM (#37341136)
> It is rather obvious to me at this point that the federal government is not in favor of its design.

Absolutely. The big questions are if the transition to this state is inevitable, and once the transition has occurred are you better or worse off than under the Swiss system.

Going by the state of both societies the Swiss one seems to have a lot going for it.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:28PM (#37341705)
I don't think it's inevitable. The Constitution still remains intact, and it is a difficult thing to defy.

I can say with certainty that I would be in jail for speech related offenses in any other country than the US.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by fidotron on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:46PM (#37341952)
While I do disagree about the inevitability I will admit to hoping to be wrong, and I do admire the spirit that treats freedom as so valuable.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by shrimp_emoji on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:59PM (#37344697)
Wouldn't the CIA be more easily able to manipulate a small pool of representatives than an entire population? Like, WAY easier? (You can't blackmail millions of people.)

Also, how is a minoritarian rule of the rich (plutocracy) a more just system than democracy? Yeah, they have skin in the game, and the game is protecting their wealth instead of contributing to the commonwealth. There's a happy balance to be found in there, of course, but you don't want to arrive at it via pitchfork.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:40AM (#37351403)
> Wouldn't the CIA be more easily able to manipulate a small pool of representatives than an entire population? Like, WAY easier? (You can't blackmail millions of people.)

Certainly, but if the government doesn't have regular election cycles it's an all-or-nothing approach.

Consider MBS. If he doesn't want to play ball with the cia, he won't, and there isn't much the cia can do about it. He's not going anywhere anytime soon, or potentially ever during his lifetime. Contrast that against a gov that holds regular elections. The cia gets the opportunity to influence the election outcome (chance 1) and then gets a chance to influence the winner if they're not already captured (chance 2), all the while knowing if they fail chances 1 and 2 they will get to try again in a handful of years.

> Also, how is a minoritarian rule of the rich (plutocracy) a more just system than democracy?

I don't consider it minoritarian rule. The minority can only say no change. They can't craft change of their own. This helps prevent the tyranny of the majority problem. However, the majority is what is needed to actually make changes, or more aptly a super majority. This helps to make change slow and harder, which is not a bad thing in my opinion, especially considering how the ruling parties tend to oscillate every decade or so.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by chmod600 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:52PM (#37341126)
Lack of free speech is a vulnerability, and is not really important until it is.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by logicchains on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:59AM (#37338219)
> 40% of Millennials are OK with limiting speech offensive to minorities[1]

That poll is from 2015 (and the other from 2019), not necessarily representative of current views. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/01/upshot/millennials-pollin... millennials are becoming more conservative as they age (and many were radicalised by the covid response).

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ryandrake on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:26AM (#37338697)
Financial Times reports the opposite[1] (population: UK and USA) so who knows? Time will tell.

1: https://www.ft.com/content/c361e372-769e-45cd-a063-f5c0a7767...

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by westernmostcoy on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:57AM (#37339257)
Your link is paywalled, but while looking for a way to read it I found the author has been criticized for this specific article you’re linking: https://fair.org/home/millennials-moved-right-nyt-cherry-pic...

Also: even if Millenials were becoming more conservative (which would be very strange for a lot of economic reasons alone), the definition of “minority” held by the media may not really apply if nearly half of the generation identifies as non-white. (https://www.census.gov/newsroom/archives/2015-pr/cb15-113.ht...)

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by AlexandrB on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:07AM (#37338353)
Most so called "free speech absolutists", when pressed, will support some limits on free speech (e.g. incitement or "fighting words"). Many even support more strict libel and slander laws. Elon Musk is the obvious, prominent example of someone espousing "free speech absolutism" while limiting legal speech on his platform but there are plenty of others.

So we're not really arguing about whether speech should be restricted, but where that line should be drawn.

I would agree that Millennials support drawing that line a little more broadly, but there is also a difference about which speech should be more restricted. The pew research piece you linked was specifically about offensive statements about minority groups, but what if you asked about whether trans educational material should be banned or whether the word "cis" should be considered a slur? I suspect that the demographics would be flipped.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ryandrake on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:12AM (#37338427)
To "steel man" the argument put forward by the state: The government doesn't have the right to regulate speech, but does has the right to regulate how people behave and conduct themselves.

In meatspace, these concepts are distinct: You can speak all sorts of horrible stuff while being peaceful and conducting yourself well. You can also say nice things while being violent and belligerent. Government surely has the right to stop you from being violent and belligerent. On the Internet, there is no difference between speech and conduct. You conduct yourself by speaking/writing. So how can we enforce good conduct without regulating speech? The states are trying to draw the line between speech and conduct, and that's not easy (maybe impossible) online.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by verisimi on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:27AM (#37338726)
> The government doesn't have the right to regulate speech, but does has the right to regulate how people behave and conduct themselves.

:)

These types of comments make me smile. The government is an idea is the minds of people. It doesn't/can't have rights. It's a non-existent entity.

And yet. People believe that it has the ability to create 'rights', and people will be somehow beholden to its pronouncements. Is government 'God'? I think to most people the answer is yes. It is their authority; such individuals are not an authority of themselves.

The proper answer, imo, is that nothing except for my own heart and reason can guide me as to what is morally right or wrong. No work of man (law, religion, government) can say anything to me. All these works (law, government) are badly bent towards a self-serving elite, for the extraction of wealth from those that believe in these phantasms.

We laugh at those in history who we are told tithed 10% of their work to their local lord in the feudal system, and 10% towards the church, but don't blink at paying 40% to the government.

There are really only individuals, but the mind control in most is very effective.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by AlexandrB on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:36AM (#37338860)
> The proper answer, imo, is that nothing except for my own heart and reason can guide me as to what is morally right or wrong.

I think if we had the ability to trace the origin of each belief about what is right and wrong you would be surprised by how greatly law, government, and religion have influenced you.

Edit:

> There are really only individuals

This must be why solitary confinement is considered such a great privilege when incarcerated.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by verisimi on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:14PM (#37339559)
> This must be why solitary confinement is considered such a great privilege when incarcerated.

Ha! Nice line.

But, in all honesty, totally controlling another person, confining them, is only an example of control.

But, if not in the individual, where do you think meaning or anything of value, occurs? The feeling/meaning/thought, is only within oneself, surely?

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by Dig1t on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:23AM (#37338642)
I disagree with the metaphor. In the past freedom of speech meant absolute free speech with a small blacklist of specific situations in which it would cause immediate, physical, danger to others. Everything else was okay, even if it hurts other peoples' feelings. It is an extremely GOOD thing to have for society, it is the main tool that the left used to gain the power that it has today. It is the main tool by which good people can overcome bad people in power.

The newer generation seems to be okay with moving from a blacklist -> whitelist approach where the range of acceptable opinions and topics are set by the group and things outside of that range are labeled offensive, bigoted, racist, something-phobic, or harmful in some other way and banned.

Responding specifically to your point about trans educational material, free speech absolutists are 100% okay with allowing trans educational material that says anything at all. I'm not kidding, think of whatever offensive thing you want to say about cis people, free speech absolutists are okay with you saying it.

"I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" is something I, and other free speech absolutists, truly believe.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by uLogMicheal on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:34AM (#37338838)
When people fear discussion they will disengage, leaving discourse to the most motivated or incentivized to program thoughts.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by foldr on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:47AM (#37339076)
>In the past freedom of speech meant absolute free speech with a small blacklist of specific situations in which it would cause immediate, physical, danger to others.

You'll have to specify when this golden age existed. I suspect that if you name any specific date, we could find all sorts of respects in which freedom of speech was much more restricted in the US at that time than it is now.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by Dig1t on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:18PM (#37339639)
I am not saying that it has always been perfectly implemented, right leaning politicians have been guilty in myriad ways of censorship over the years. But the ideal that we define as a culture is what I stated, and if we all agree that's what we want then we can work every day towards the ideal. It has been the ideal since the founding of the United States in 1776.

I know this to be true because my parents and grandparents told me that that is what their generation valued, and what they thought the definition of free speech should be.

If the majority of the people in a culture decide that they care about free speech then the minority of censorious bad people in power can be overcome.

How do you think the left got the power they have today? By being allowed to write whatever they want in opinion columns, make movies that insult corrupt politicians, write plays about evil industrial fat cats poisoning the water supply, marching through the streets with megaphones dissenting to war mongers.

Now we are saying it's okay to silence these people as long as we label them as "harmful" or "bigots" in some way. Even being anti-war is now somehow becoming associated with the alt-right taboo people that must not be talked about.

What we are seeing now is a generation of people who do not share the ideal of free speech, and are okay with censorship and an ingroup/outgroup by default.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by foldr on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:23PM (#37339723)
It's trivial to find historical examples of censorship in the US that wouldn't happen today. Here is one example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bertrand_Russell_Case

Can you imagine a situation now where CUNY was unable to appoint someone to an academic position because the Catholic church canceled them?

As another example one might mention the vast reduction of censorship in movies. Movies can be shown now that would have been unthinkable in at least the first half of the 20th century.

Granted, there may also be instances of present day censorship that wouldn't have happened historically. But it's naive and completely ahistorical to see any past period as some kind of bastion of free speech absolutism. Believe me, lots of people in your grandparents' generation also wanted to restrict free speech (particularly with regard to e.g. sexually explicit content, or anything that might be vaguely connected with Communism).

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:59PM (#37340294)
Can we at least agree on the premise that free speech should be absolute? The parent pointed out that the implementation has never been perfect, but the objective was correct?

Conditional upon that, why wouldn't we strive to correct the implementation? The opposite seems to be happening.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by foldr on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:03PM (#37340364)
What’s the point in having a debate on HN about whether or not free speech should be absolute? I doubt there’s anything new to say on the topic.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:36PM (#37340845)
My comment was in response to your initial response that nitpicked the OP's point that free speech was considered absolute in the past, contrary to the current climate which seems to be trying to do away with it and replace it with white listed speech.

The OP was discussing the ideology of free speech, not the implementation. My response was an attempt to bring the topic back to the ideology of whether free speech should be allowed in absoluteness, in contrast to your deviation towards implementation.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by rnk on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:26AM (#37338705)
I think your vision of free speech in the past is off, compared to my born in the 60s memory. There didn't used to be racist hate speech on the news or widely disseminated widely like there is today on reddit in certain groups. If there ever was a crowd saying things to say keep black kids out of their local school yelling, the news would probably minimize it. Hate speech wasn't common. It was happening of course, but not ever-present, but today it is very easy to see it.

Today's conservatives in my mind just say it out loud, and the typical news media isn't squelching it, and social media is broadcasting it to get more interaction. Today that hate speech is widely disseminated. That's why today's youths are more open to blocking it - because it's much more ubiquitous.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by jlawson on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:36AM (#37338872)
It's remarkable how you've managed to completely invert the reality.

Please link where racist hate speech is "widely disseminated" on reddit. (Reddit has been strictly controlled speech according to San Francisco values for a decade).

Or please show, anywhere in America, a "crowd saying things to say keep black kids out of their local school yelling".

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by MSFT_Edging on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:00PM (#37342926)
> Reddit has been strictly controlled speech according to San Francisco values for a decade

This is untrue in practice, often wrapped in dog whistles, or rephrased as "urban" or something else terrible. Reddit is still an extremely racist place and its basically a game to find new ways to be racist.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by shrimp_emoji on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:35AM (#37369923)
If Reddit is racist, every place is racist.

If racism is the natural condition of humanity, and you need ocean-boiling engines of censorship constantly watching and suppressing content to shape it into some bonsai fiction of humanity that pleases certain people, then we don't deserve otherwise.

I'd rather arrive at that pretty bonsai of humanity through education of society at a massive scale than censorship at a massive scale.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by rnk on Saturday September 02, 2023 @12:24PM (#37362944)
Another place to see it is on twitter. Now that we are in the post-Musk X time, there is much more there, it's not being blocked like it was in the past. The gist of my argument was social media sometimes allows a lot more racist speech, getting to my thought that this is why some young people want censoring of that, because they don't want to be confronted with it. Even advertisers have noticed - https://www.cnn.com/2023/08/16/tech/x-ads-pro-nazi-account-b....

I didn't mean to imply there wasn't racist public speech in say the '60s, of course there was, but it wasn't repeated on the news much. If you went out in a crowd you'd hear it, but the news paper usually gave some nicer repetition.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by jlawson on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:06PM (#37367101)
You said 'another place' but you didn't show us anything in the first two places.

So - you have no links to all that racism you're describing on reddit?

And no evidence of crowds yelling to keep black kids out of their schools either?

Again - You're saying there's so much racism. Substantiate your claims. Please provide the links to show us that what you're describing actually exists.

(It doesn't exist, because all these social networks very strictly police speech to prevent racism, as does society at large.)

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by cocacola1 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:13PM (#37339543)
You’re referring to the 60s US? The Civil Rights movement? The decade where George Wallace, when inaugurated as governor of Alabama, declared “Segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever”? The decade Martin Luther King, Jr. was assassinated? The decade the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act and 24th Amendment were passed? When Southern Democrats flipped to Republican over civil rights?

I fear you might be viewing the past through rose tinted glasses.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by rnk on Saturday September 02, 2023 @12:19PM (#37362901)
I think I didn't state my case very well. I was thinking that the news was censoring that, the newspaper and/or walter cronkite didn't repeat the specific racist comments, it wasn't out to the home consumer. Of course they were yelling vile things out loud, people were saying them. But it wasn't repeated in the media.

Today it's repeated in social media incessantly, nazies saying things on twitter is another example.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by PartiallyTyped on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:04AM (#37338288)
There's no such thing as free-speech absolutionist, it's only a matter of finding the right words to trigger someone into a visceral reaction.

The problem is that it's impossible to prove a negative of this nature because you are always met with no-true-scottsman responses.

Reality is, if you press any human hard enough, you will find something, that's just how things are.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by pseg134 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:08PM (#37339434)
And how did you come to discover this “reality”? You are just projecting you opinion on everyone. Some people don’t think like you.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by gradExMachina on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:37PM (#37339907)
I have plenty of examples of hypocritical free-speech "absolutionists" to back my belief, but again, people will throw the good ol' no-true-scotsman response.

You are just projecting your inability to use data on everyone. Some people don't think like you.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:15AM (#37338490)
Unfortunately it applies to the whole Constitution. Those same people believe that the 2nd Amendment was only for a state-sanctioned militia and not for protection against tyranny, and simultaneously that it only applied to muskets and not modern weaponry. Confusingly, they don't believe that the 1A only applies to things written via quill and ink.

I fear for the near future.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by giraffe_lady on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:22AM (#37338632)
It's not so much that we're idiots, you see, but that we're reevaluating based on how things have been playing out the last 70 years.

For example very noticeably: the most powerfully tyrannical developments in the modern US are the retributive legal system, state violence against poor and minorities, crackdowns on sexual and reproductive healthcare, oppression of sexual minorities. And these policies are overwhelmingly supported by the same people who purport to value so highly their ability to fight tyranny with guns.

And at the same time we're seeing a growing grass-roots racial terrorism campaign, again enabled by the same people & policies. Lotta "lone wolves" out there who independently decide they need to shoot up a bunch of black or asian or jewish people.

So again it's not that we're fucking stupid. We just see that you're not willing to use that power for us, and we want your friends to stop using it to kill our folk instead.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:47AM (#37339052)
I just think it's odd that you think that the solution to being picked on is to remove your right to defend yourself from being picked on. The 2A wasn't supposed to be just for "bigots". Use your rights. Relying on the government to protect you from bigots only works when the government itself isn't comprised of bigots. Then you'll really regret not having rights to effective individual defense.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by 8note on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:37PM (#37339912)
It's a right to have a gun, not to use it.

Even then, it's not a very strong right, since for the past 30 years at least, the common reason for cops to shoot people is "I thought he had a gun" with suggestions that people carry bright orange wallets to avoid being mistaken for having a gun

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:55PM (#37340231)
And what is the point of "arms"? Why would the second most important right enumerated, be only placed there merely for keeping weapon-shaped trinkets in the household?
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by bobbylarrybobby on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:47PM (#37346191)
Given the state of things at the time the country was formed, “we need you at the ready to handle Injuns” may well be the answer.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by tempodox on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:03PM (#37339353)
“rights to effective individual defense” isn't going to cut it against a government armed with nuclear weapons, tanks, and what not. The notion that a few guns will protect you against government overreach is outdated by at least a hundred years.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:06PM (#37339414)
1. The largest military industrial complex / empire the world has seen to date, struggles with underequipped, undereducated insurgents fighting for their beliefs already.

2. You assume the whole military would be unified in drone striking their fellow countrymen. I wager a large chunk, likely more than half, would splinter.

3. There's not much point in nuking the place you wish to rule. There won't be much left to rule.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by tempodox on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:37PM (#37346540)
Still, I'd bet that a bunch of lawyers and huge funds for campaign contributions would give you better chances than the contents of your armory.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:25AM (#37351230)
It's unfathomable to me how you people are completely incapable of seeing how both are useful, and one doesn't need to exist on its own without the other.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by Quillbert182 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:15PM (#37339589)
Yet we lost to the Taliban, who had none of those things.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by camgunz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:40PM (#37341867)
But we won against the Iraqi insurgence and ISIS. We probably would've beaten the Taliban too but JB personally hated being there, so here we are.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by cmh89 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:59PM (#37342107)
We didn't lose to the Taliban for any other reason beside not having a clear picture of what victory would look like.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by giraffe_lady on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:07PM (#37339416)
I'm a materialist, and as such I see that the "right" to own and use weapons in this way is conditional on things outside the control of individuals. What do you think happens to a black man who shoots a cop in self defense?

We depend on us to protect us from bigots. And it's more effective and less morally compromising to do this when the bigots don't have guns. As it is an honest self defense class for my people starts with "have someone who knows how prison commissary works" and ends with "get right with the lord" because that covers the full spectrum of likely outcomes when a nonwhite person defends themselves with a weapon in the US.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by hellojesus on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:42PM (#37339987)
But the fact remains that by defending yourself, at least you'll minimize the chances of meeting your god(s).

As the saying goes, better to be judged by 12 than burried by 6.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by camgunz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:40PM (#37342656)
We have limits on all rights: the rights against unreasonable search and seizure (exigent circumstances), the right of freedom of expression (imminent lawless action), the right to freedom of association (imprisonment, parole), etc. For some reason we accept these but not on 2A, as we think it's this fundamental right to secure freedom.

But I think this overlooks how we've won our freedoms over the last century. Suffragettes didn't take mayors ransom. Labor unions didn't march on DC with firearms. Civil rights activists didn't surround police departments with shotguns. Protests against the draft were literally flower power.

The idea that rights flow from violence in today's world just doesn't track. It's way more likely you secure your rights with strikes, marches, and protests than with armed resistance. The truth is the idea of a noble rebellion violently struggling for freedom is a Confederate fantasy, which is the aesthetic preference of a certain demographic. It's maybe less romantic to them to run boycotts and strikes (and actually win the popular vote), but that's how things work these days.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:31PM (#37343301)
Why do they have to be mutually exclusive? It's a backup. It's like saying "yeah my server runs super stable and I haven't had any power outages in the last few months, so I don't need a UPS, so I'll throw mine away." Which is great, until your data is irrevocably corrupted and you regret your decision.

You're right, marching with guns doesn't resolve civil issues most of the time. That's not the point. It's for when all other options are exhausted. And we won't truly appreciate it for what it is, until that time comes, by which point I hope we haven't complacently thrown it away because we couldn't learn from history (again).

"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible, make violent revolution inevitable." ~ JFK

It's really based on "hasn't happened to me, so it probably won't happen to me" logic. Which is stupid when you're setting rules for generations to come. All good things come to an end, and the US will too. It will be a slow boil until we realize we're in a seriously corrupt and unrepresentative state that can only be fixed through force. It has happened time and time again, and to think we won't meet the same fate is incredibly naive. At least we have an enshrined fighting chance to reset the way we want.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by camgunz on Friday September 01, 2023 @06:45AM (#37349057)
Yeah but in this case your UPS causes tens of thousands of unnecessary deaths a year and lots of knock on effects like cops always having to worry about a suspect being armed to the teeth, metal detectors in schools, etc.

> It will be a slow boil until we realize we're in a seriously corrupt and unrepresentative state that can only be fixed through force.

There's no evidence this is happening, certainly not to the degree we should suffer the current level of gun violence to combat.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by seanw444 on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:23AM (#37351214)
All of those things will happen whether we ban legal ownership of firearms or not.

Metal detectors in school can still come in handy for things like knives, unless you intend to ban those too. Way more people die from car accidents and drug overdoses, and those numbers don't have millions of legal self defense encounters to balance them out. Cops will always be concerned about their safety. You can kill someone if you simply gain physical control over them. An unarmed person charging you is just as dangerous as an armed one, in terms of use-of-force continuum.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by camgunz on Saturday September 02, 2023 @09:37AM (#37361424)
These all have simple counterfactuals in other countries, like EU countries. The idea that violence won't decrease if we ban guns is completely disproven, empirically.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ryathal on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:34PM (#37343348)
You've drastically altered the reality of US history. Violence and guns were a huge part of it. Labor unions had actual shoot outs with union busting officers, Malcolm X was absolutely using guns (King also had them), some draft protests were intentionally violent. If you really look, almost every "peaceful" movement had violent parts or another similar movement that was violent.

Perhaps the greatest example is the race riots, specifically LA where the police completely abandoned areas and local shop keepers used their own weapons to protect their livelihood.

Furthermore, the right to bear arms is heavily limited, automatic weapons have been banned for around 50 years at this point, getting any gun is subject to background checks in basically every case, age limits are also in place, "dangerous" things like suppressors require additional fees and paperwork in order to own.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by camgunz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:57PM (#37343578)
None of this stuff looks like the Taliban's resistance or the Bolshevik Revolution. Besides a magnitude difference, the victory won was a moral one. No policymaker was afraid that they'd meet the guillotine unless they went along with the Wagner act. They were convinced, not coerced.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by shrimp_emoji on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:06PM (#37344735)
Malcolm X didn't accomplish anything. He was a loser who regretted everything before being assassinated by the Islamist Frankenstein monsters he created. All credit of civil rights advances go to MLK. Like Ghandi, he made a point of non-violent protest being the actual way to inspire change, and history proved both of them correct. Insofar as violence is effective, it's always more limited and bittersweet. Unless you're talking about wholesale revolutions and installation of new governments, but that's beyond the scope of civil rights.

And shopkeepers in the LA riots defended themselves with violence against violence. That's totally unrelated from using violence to inspire some kind of change in your society.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by giraffe_lady on Friday September 01, 2023 @02:28AM (#37347511)
That's an oversimplified way to understand nonviolent resistance movements that's insufficient to explain their success.

In every case where they have been successful, a radical movement with the will to violence at their flank is what brings the other party to the negotiation table. The plausible threat of a mutually destructive protest movement with unconditional demands makes the measured compromise of the peaceful group seem acceptable by comparison.

Look at the environmental movement for what happens without this. Decades of nonviolent protest and resistance, but without a plausibly violent fringe there is no reason for anyone to capitulate to its demands, and so no one has.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by shrimp_emoji on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:22PM (#37344855)
Please be a friend to freedom; it needs good, intelligent people like you.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by Nifty3929 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:47AM (#37339062)
This is a consequence of what and how we teach and treat our students in school. School is considered to be a safe space where students are shielded from any speech that might offend them. Students who say thing that offend, or might offend, are punished.

No surprise that this carries over into broader public policy as those students become adult voters and officials.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by mcdonje on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:31PM (#37339845)
It could be that millennials are more familiar with the paradox of tolerance, at least in practice if not in name.

It aligns with the relatively widespread notion that equality and equity are not the same thing.

Simply put, a blanket freedom of speech for everyone can and will stifle the speech of some who do not feel safe speaking out, and/or who do not feel safe as a consequence of what others say.

That means there is no such thing as a complete and total freedom of speech. So the question becomes not if speech should be restricted, but how.

Within this conceptual framework, "free speech absolutists" are not only arguing for something that cannot exist, but they're arguing for something that harms others. So the solution that would lead to greater freedom of expression among the largest portion of the population is to paradoxically restrict speech that discriminates based on innate attributes.

I'm sure many here will disagree. I'm not writing this to get into an argument, but to explain a possible reason for the millennial polling. In the conversations since BLM, I do think this type of thinking is reasonably widespread.

I happen to agree with that viewpoint while also being quite concerned about any attempt of the government to stifle dissent, which I view as being antithetical to democracy. I do not see that as oxymoronic. Democracy is not easy or simple.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ecshafer on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:42PM (#37341893)
Paradox of tolerance in the actual book draws the limit at being tolerant of violence. It does not in any way endorse becoming an authoritarian state and removing rights under the guise of heading off possible intolerance. There is a redditism of linking the Wikipedia page but ironically the actual book argues the complete opposite side as you are currently.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by mcdonje on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:16PM (#37343791)
>redditism

Weird comment considering I'm explaining a point of view that many people on several social networks have. There are plenty of thoughtless knee-jerk comments in this thread in support of several different positions. Mine is not one of them.

It's also weird you're framing me as endorsing authoritarianism when I explicitly said how and why the position I outlined doesn't do that. There is nuance here that you're missing.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by akira2501 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:55PM (#37340215)
Cool. Did anyone ask them "how do we decide what's offensive to minorities?" Or "what is a just process for determining how an entire race of people become offended?"

It's such a pitched question it's ridiculous. It's even worse that you're pretending it says anything about attitudes towards freedom of speech.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by tmaly on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:53PM (#37344148)
How big is the sample size in these polls?

What was the wording of the questions?

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by slowmovintarget on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:13PM (#37352678)
That is because these same 51% are no longer properly educated about the reasons for the First Amendment to exist.

These same people are taught that speech and violent action are the same, and that words are harmful, rather than actions. Worse, they're taught an equivalence that not saying the "correct" things is also violence.

Free speech is table stakes for a free people.