News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ryathal on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:34PM (#37343348)
You've drastically altered the reality of US history. Violence and guns were a huge part of it. Labor unions had actual shoot outs with union busting officers, Malcolm X was absolutely using guns (King also had them), some draft protests were intentionally violent. If you really look, almost every "peaceful" movement had violent parts or another similar movement that was violent.

Perhaps the greatest example is the race riots, specifically LA where the police completely abandoned areas and local shop keepers used their own weapons to protect their livelihood.

Furthermore, the right to bear arms is heavily limited, automatic weapons have been banned for around 50 years at this point, getting any gun is subject to background checks in basically every case, age limits are also in place, "dangerous" things like suppressors require additional fees and paperwork in order to own.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by camgunz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:57PM (#37343578)
None of this stuff looks like the Taliban's resistance or the Bolshevik Revolution. Besides a magnitude difference, the victory won was a moral one. No policymaker was afraid that they'd meet the guillotine unless they went along with the Wagner act. They were convinced, not coerced.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by shrimp_emoji on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:06PM (#37344735)
Malcolm X didn't accomplish anything. He was a loser who regretted everything before being assassinated by the Islamist Frankenstein monsters he created. All credit of civil rights advances go to MLK. Like Ghandi, he made a point of non-violent protest being the actual way to inspire change, and history proved both of them correct. Insofar as violence is effective, it's always more limited and bittersweet. Unless you're talking about wholesale revolutions and installation of new governments, but that's beyond the scope of civil rights.

And shopkeepers in the LA riots defended themselves with violence against violence. That's totally unrelated from using violence to inspire some kind of change in your society.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by giraffe_lady on Friday September 01, 2023 @02:28AM (#37347511)
That's an oversimplified way to understand nonviolent resistance movements that's insufficient to explain their success.

In every case where they have been successful, a radical movement with the will to violence at their flank is what brings the other party to the negotiation table. The plausible threat of a mutually destructive protest movement with unconditional demands makes the measured compromise of the peaceful group seem acceptable by comparison.

Look at the environmental movement for what happens without this. Decades of nonviolent protest and resistance, but without a plausibly violent fringe there is no reason for anyone to capitulate to its demands, and so no one has.