Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship
by ecshafer on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:42PM
(#37341893)
Paradox of tolerance in the actual book draws the limit at being tolerant of violence. It does not in any way endorse becoming an authoritarian state and removing rights under the guise of heading off possible intolerance. There is a redditism of linking the Wikipedia page but ironically the actual book argues the complete opposite side as you are currently.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship
by mcdonje on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:16PM
(#37343791)
>redditism
Weird comment considering I'm explaining a point of view that many people on several social networks have. There are plenty of thoughtless knee-jerk comments in this thread in support of several different positions. Mine is not one of them.
It's also weird you're framing me as endorsing authoritarianism when I explicitly said how and why the position I outlined doesn't do that. There is nuance here that you're missing.
It aligns with the relatively widespread notion that equality and equity are not the same thing.
Simply put, a blanket freedom of speech for everyone can and will stifle the speech of some who do not feel safe speaking out, and/or who do not feel safe as a consequence of what others say.
That means there is no such thing as a complete and total freedom of speech. So the question becomes not if speech should be restricted, but how.
Within this conceptual framework, "free speech absolutists" are not only arguing for something that cannot exist, but they're arguing for something that harms others. So the solution that would lead to greater freedom of expression among the largest portion of the population is to paradoxically restrict speech that discriminates based on innate attributes.
I'm sure many here will disagree. I'm not writing this to get into an argument, but to explain a possible reason for the millennial polling. In the conversations since BLM, I do think this type of thinking is reasonably widespread.
I happen to agree with that viewpoint while also being quite concerned about any attempt of the government to stifle dissent, which I view as being antithetical to democracy. I do not see that as oxymoronic. Democracy is not easy or simple.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance