News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by ryandrake on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:12AM (#37338427)
To "steel man" the argument put forward by the state: The government doesn't have the right to regulate speech, but does has the right to regulate how people behave and conduct themselves.

In meatspace, these concepts are distinct: You can speak all sorts of horrible stuff while being peaceful and conducting yourself well. You can also say nice things while being violent and belligerent. Government surely has the right to stop you from being violent and belligerent. On the Internet, there is no difference between speech and conduct. You conduct yourself by speaking/writing. So how can we enforce good conduct without regulating speech? The states are trying to draw the line between speech and conduct, and that's not easy (maybe impossible) online.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by verisimi on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:27AM (#37338726)
> The government doesn't have the right to regulate speech, but does has the right to regulate how people behave and conduct themselves.

:)

These types of comments make me smile. The government is an idea is the minds of people. It doesn't/can't have rights. It's a non-existent entity.

And yet. People believe that it has the ability to create 'rights', and people will be somehow beholden to its pronouncements. Is government 'God'? I think to most people the answer is yes. It is their authority; such individuals are not an authority of themselves.

The proper answer, imo, is that nothing except for my own heart and reason can guide me as to what is morally right or wrong. No work of man (law, religion, government) can say anything to me. All these works (law, government) are badly bent towards a self-serving elite, for the extraction of wealth from those that believe in these phantasms.

We laugh at those in history who we are told tithed 10% of their work to their local lord in the feudal system, and 10% towards the church, but don't blink at paying 40% to the government.

There are really only individuals, but the mind control in most is very effective.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by AlexandrB on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:36AM (#37338860)
> The proper answer, imo, is that nothing except for my own heart and reason can guide me as to what is morally right or wrong.

I think if we had the ability to trace the origin of each belief about what is right and wrong you would be surprised by how greatly law, government, and religion have influenced you.

Edit:

> There are really only individuals

This must be why solitary confinement is considered such a great privilege when incarcerated.

Re:State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship by verisimi on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:14PM (#37339559)
> This must be why solitary confinement is considered such a great privilege when incarcerated.

Ha! Nice line.

But, in all honesty, totally controlling another person, confining them, is only an example of control.

But, if not in the individual, where do you think meaning or anything of value, occurs? The feeling/meaning/thought, is only within oneself, surely?