News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:31PM (#37286822)
I'm so happy for folks who have unions and have gained benefits. I know that in the Software Engineering space we think we're all ninja elite 100x rockstar developers and we don't want to get benefits.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by VirusNewbie on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:39PM (#37286874)
I’m going to go down fighting keeping unions out of software. It’s the hill i’ll gladly die on.

You’re welcome to go work at a software union shop, like Boeing.

Writing low quality software that kills people, great job security even if you are at fault for peanut pay. I’ll take my non union job any day.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by mmole on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:49PM (#37286945)
This was definitely written by Jeff Bezos on a burner account
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:07PM (#37287097)
That's fine, you can want to be treated like shit if you like it. I know I'd greatly prefer not being under draconian rules and getting things like OT pay so that when I'm forced to work 80-hour weeks I actually benefit from it. You do you.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by VirusNewbie on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:46PM (#37300197)
Lol ok buddy. I guess i'm 'treated like shit' since I have to work 45 hours a week for my free coffee, food, massages, and large stock comp just so I can afford my giant house and tesla.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:52PM (#37300259)
Boss gave you two Oreos instead of one and you think you're hot shit despite them taking thousands. Makes sense bucko.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by VirusNewbie on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:10PM (#37301027)
I’m comparing my job to union jobs in software. You think unions are the answer. I know they aren’t.

What does my boss’s paycheck have to do with my argument? How does your comment convince me i’m not way better off than you and other union NPCs?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:45PM (#37301358)
Oh, you're that kind of intellectually vapid person who says "NPCs". We're done here. Enjoy life.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by asdff on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:19PM (#37287175)
Nothing like beating on the airplane to make your point, otherwise known as a mode of travel statistically safer than even merely walking.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by p1necone on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:39PM (#37287322)
I agree with your point, but there's a nit I like to pick when the statistics of airline safety comes up.

Comparing safety by deaths/injuries per distance travelled between different modes of transport does not make sense to me.

To prove the point imagine some hypothetical mode of travel that can take us to the nearest star - alpha centauri. Now imagine that 50% of people that travel via this mode of transport die, thats obviously not a risk anybody would be willing to take right? But if you use the same statistics as we use for aircraft safety it looks amazing, better than anything else by far.

Am I saying that aircraft are unsafe? Not at all - they're still very safe relative to other modes of transport, but the statistics that we commonly calculate to compare them seem totally meaningless to me. Comparing deaths per distance travelled only makes any sense when comparing modes of travel that actually go similar distances.

I also acknowledge that this is somewhat of a regional nitpick - it makes a lot more sense to compare aircraft with e.g. cars in the United States because taking an aircraft vs taking a car to travel between different states is actually a choice that many people are making. Whereas I live in a small country where there's very little overlap between aircraft trips and car trips.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by toomuchtodo on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:21PM (#37287184)
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by miffy900 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:42PM (#37287340)
> You’re welcome to go work at a software union shop, like Boeing.

> Writing low quality software that kills people, great job security even if you are at fault for peanut pay. I’ll take my non union job any day.

Boeing primarily manufactures and designs airplanes. The odds of dying while being a passenger on an airplane is about 1 in 200,000. Compare that to being a cyclist, which is 1 in 3,500. Or a pedestrian which is 1 in 485.

https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/how-safe-is-flying-heres...

Putting your stupendously bad comparison aside, I'd say most software devs/programmers don't really need to unionise, aside from video game devs. 80+ hour work weeks, constant burn out, consistently underpaid compared to most other devs who just program boring line of business apps; they just get treated very poorly.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by whatshisface on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:46PM (#37286915)
Engineers have always walked a fine line between labor and capital because while on one hand they own nothing and do not manage anybody, they are also individually valued and work directly within (in a sense being at the core of) the planning functions of companies.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:46PM (#37287380)
If you can get laid off, then you're not capital.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by whatshisface on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:19PM (#37287610)
Managers generally aren't part of unions because their job is to represent the interests of capital. I didn't invent it that's just how it has been for a hundred years.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by ydlr on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:35PM (#37287735)
Allowing supervisors to be fired for union activity is one of the most insidious parts of the Taft-Hartley Act.

It has been very effective in creating disunity among workers -- which most managers definitely are.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:24PM (#37287653)
CEOs have their own union, but they're called boards of directors. :-)

They sit around deciding each other's compensation and giving each other golden parachutes.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:24AM (#37305189)
But anyone can get laid off. CEOs get fired all the time, self employed contractors get fired from contracts. So then nobody is "capital". This is correct: the distinction between workers and capital doesn't exist outside of Marxist theory. We are all workers, and when we join or form companies, we are uniting.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:50AM (#37306334)
> But anyone can get laid off. CEOs get fired all the time, self employed contractors get fired from contracts. So then nobody is "capital".

The owners of the business, e.g., the stockholders, are capital.

There is some overlap, because employees can be compensated in stock, especially CEOs. The crucial difference is that when an employee is fired, they stop making a salary from the company, and they stop having any power in the company, whereas stockholders cannot be fired, and they continue making money from the company and having voting rights no matter what.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:39AM (#37306857)
But then you're trying to draw a binary distinction when some (many) people are both. The CEO is neither capital nor a worker in this scheme, or they could be both.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @09:05AM (#37307241)
I just explained the nuance in my previous comment, so I'm not sure what you're still confused about.

It is true that the interests of the CEO and the interests of the owners do not necessarily align. This is exactly why CEO compensation is often in stock: the theory is that if CEOs are compensated in stock, then their interests will align more closely with the interests of the stockholders.

Still, CEOs can be fired at any time, so they need to look out for themselves, and CEOs do have a kind of union, because they often sit together on the boards of directors of companies, and of course the boards of directors decide on CEO compensation (a massive conflict of interest). This is why CEOs often get massive golden parachutes: it's CEOs protecting other CEOs.

Even including the CEO, though, current employees typically own only a very small % of a corporation's total stock, which is exactly why they can be fired.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @12:07PM (#37309971)
I'm struggling with this distinction between workers and capital, when it seems to me that almost always there's no actual difference. Even if we take pure shareholders who aren't also employees, in practice, basically all of those shareholders will themselves be employees of funds of various kinds, and thus fireable. People who are pure private shareholders and literally answer to no-one, is possible e.g. Bill Gates and other philanthropists, but they're an extreme edge case and indeed most of them seem to spend their time giving away money to people who otherwise might struggle to find work, like researchers, so it's hard to view this type of "capital" as exploiting the workers.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:29PM (#37311125)
If you think there's almost always no actual difference, consider this: in the United States, the richest 10% of all households own >70% of the country's wealth. The richest 1% own 35% of the country's wealth.

The rest of the population may own some stock, but it's a pittance relative to the capitalist class. We're not running the show.

Regarding Bill Gates, he acquired his wealth by exploiting workers, not to mention everyone else, engaging in illegal monopolistic practices. Moreover, he's even wealthier now than he was before retiring from Microsoft and claiming to want to give most of his wealth away. And he's 67 years old, time's a wastin'. The problem is that wealth begets wealth. Gates doesn't even have to work to continue to accumulate wealth, so much so that he can't seem to give away money faster than he makes it.

That's the essential difference: having to work for your money vs. having your money (and also everyone else) work for you.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by kazen44 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:46PM (#37287381)
in classical manufacturing though, most engineers have to work together with tool and die makers to actually produce the tooling to create the product.

The guys actually physically building the tooling you designed to build a product are definitely unionized, and have been for a very long time.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by whatshisface on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:20PM (#37287615)
Right, plus their bosses are definitely not unionized, so there's that fine line between labor and capital.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by chasd00 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:48PM (#37286938)
> we don't want to get benefits.

Software engineers are the most coddled bunch out there. Our benefits are so far beyond the pale it’s embarrassing.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by cm2012 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:49PM (#37286953)
Seriously, like big tech has like 6 month standard paternity packages now. Try getting that at any other career in the USA.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:06PM (#37287080)
Most developers don't work for big tech. Y'all in that SV bubble.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by throwaway914 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:51PM (#37287423)
I have a pretty awful view of this:

In the less complex jobs, they struggle to get things like paternity leave and time off. We have those. We should be looking at those ridiculous things we think we don't deserve and organizing to get them. We could be a leading example for the industries that come behind us.

Paid time off is common in softwareland. Let's make it mandatory "you must take 4 weeks off minimum a year". We know "unlimited time off" is a guilt-tripping farce.

If 1 software dev can add billions of dollars of value to a company, we should be getting these ridiculous things. These things that seem like coddling us. Maybe even a formula for "if i added x% profit, I deserve y% of that"

I think hollywood is ahead of us on compensation formulas imo.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by hakfoo on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:09PM (#37287550)
We can't do Hollywood style compensation because we rely on actually functional computers which are obviously incapable of Hollywood math.

More seriously, we need to make sure the entire team is getting the goodies. Even your fairy-tale 1000x developers depend on good ops/infrastructure, support and QA and clever management; if they can only hire on McStaff warm bodies, they're massively hobbling those "ridiculously compensated" devs.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by xethos on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:26PM (#37288159)
> We know "unlimited time off" is a guilt-tripping farce

Alternately, treat minimum time off like accountants. One cannot cook the books alone indefinitely if there's a week you're not there and somebody else has to do your job. Similarly, only having one guy that can fix specific issues that nobody else can touch means your sprawling Fortune 500 has a bus factor of 1 - which even executives can see is not smart business.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by johnnyanmac on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:18PM (#37289318)
>One cannot cook the books alone indefinitely if there's a week you're not there and somebody else has to do your job.

Oh well, they deal with that when they layoff people to get 2% lower expenses for earning's call. Why should I care about a bus factor if the company doesn't?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by pandaman on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:37PM (#37288246)
You are not selling unions very well: why would I want mandatory time off? If I want time off I will take it, my coworkers taking or not taking it does not concern me a single bit. More so, being forced to take time off is not a benefit for me, at my current work there is no PTO accrual so I feel forced to take time off and it's not ideal, other benefits are good enough to outweigh this but with everything equal I'd choose some place where I could cash out time off over the one where I can accumulate multiple months of time off over the one where I have to use-it-or-lose-it.

There are many such policies in a union, ask anybody who is a member of one and nobody is happy with all the policies of the union. Not to mention people who want to start a career and cannot even join the union (hello SAG) and cannot get a job because they are not in the union.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by johnnyanmac on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:16PM (#37289310)
>why would I want mandatory time off?

because even with "unlimited time off" it is a herculean task to get a long vacation approved. And without those plans, accrued time off is lucky to hit 2 weeks a year. So I have to not be sick or have emergencies for 2 years straight to get what is normal in the EU?

It's easier to force mandatory vacation than go through all that. US as a whole has horrible days off policies and I'd happily take some mandatory vacation. You are even free to use it to research stuff if you really want to get ahead or whatever.

> I'd choose some place where I could cash out time off over the one where I can accumulate multiple months of time off over the one where I have to use-it-or-lose-it.

Where are you where you can accumulate "months of time off"? Every plan I've had had max accruals of anywhere from 14-28 days. You literally hit a point where you have to use it, and this is after multiple years of accrual, not a single year.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by pandaman on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:40AM (#37289845)
There are alternatives I listed, the choice is not between "unlimited time off" and "mandatory". "Unlimited time off" would probably stand beneath "lose-it-or-lose-it" in my evaluation because with the former I'd be able to collect my PTO balance upon resignation.

>And without those plans, accrued time off is lucky to hit 2 weeks a year.

I never had less than 20 days (4 weeks) PTO, not counting holidays and Christmas lockdown and since I did not bother to negotiate any special PTO, I believe thousands upon thousands of my coworkers had the same luck.

>So I have to not be sick or have emergencies for 2 years straight to get what is normal in the EU?

I believe if you took a SWE job for what the normal in EU you could have also negotiated 10 weeks of PTO on top of that.

>It's easier to force mandatory vacation than go through all that.

It might be easier that that, whatever that is, but it's not desirable for me.

>Where are you where you can accumulate "months of time off"?

In the last TNC where I worked, I cashed out over two months of PTO (it capped over 40 days, 380 hours or some strange number like that) when I resigned.

>Every plan I've had had max accruals of anywhere from 14-28 days

So? If PTO is so important to you just make it a condition of your employment, it's just money for they employer, take more PTO, take less other comp. It's as same as if it had been made mandatory except people who are not interested in long vacations can have cash instead.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by johnnyanmac on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:54AM (#37289907)
>I never had less than 20 days (4 weeks) PTO, not counting holidays and Christmas lockdown and since I did not bother to negotiate any special PTO, I believe thousands upon thousands of my coworkers had the same luck.

I guess it's simply a problem of my industry if that's the case (you can probably guess it at this point). Or you found some extraordinary workforce, perhaps ones not based in the US.

>If PTO is so important to you just make it a condition of your employment,

I'd love for a $400k salary to be a condition too, but life is full of compromises. I simply haven't seen such deals in my industry, except for ones not based in the US, of course. I still have growth/networking plans for long term goals, so I'd rather not leave my industry just yet.

however, my industry also has horrible work conditions in general, so even if I do have a long term exit plan, I'd love for others to not go through my cruddy benefits. So I'm still all for a union.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by pandaman on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:07AM (#37289985)
I am talking about my employment as a SWE in various private and public businesses in the US since it's the topic of this HN post.

>I'd love for a $400k salary to be a condition too, but life is full of compromises. I simply haven't seen such deals in my industry,

I am not sure what your industry is, but in this particular thread the discussion is about programmers, and why they need a union to force mandatory 4 weeks off on everyone. If your industry is so bad that you cannot even trade PTO for your cash compensation then you might be better with unions, I don't know what industry that is and, obviously, I am not employed there.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by throwaway914 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:07AM (#37305450)
I'm viewing software engineers like FAA pilots, where they must have a certain minimum amount of time between shifts so they can't [necessarily] be exhausted. But that's pertaining to long shifts. In softwareland I'm used to seeing folks who are poor at recognizing their own fatigue. I understand there are some that do not want time away, but I'd say considering the impact of our work it'd be important to mandate time away. Maybe that's reaching, but I'm looking at it from a safety aspect and the potential to do harm if you're not careful/cognizant due to long hours and extended months of work to beat deadlines. Depends on the area you're working in, I'm sure - but it's a ridiculous thing I'd love to be commonplace. Paid time away: 4 weeks minimum that you must exercise. Doesn't have to be contiguous.

You're saying your work doesn't have PTO accrual: There's another thing we should lobby for.

How many times has productivity doubled since the industrial revolution? I would love the tech world to stand still for a time so we can demand these things that seem ridiculous, because we've been succumbed to wage slavery. Even that sounds odd: Software wage slavery - puh-lease, right? Except few things have expanded the economy of several nations in the world like software, like tech. We should be much more demanding.

</harp>

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by pandaman on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:21AM (#37306644)
And this is exactly why people fight with unions. It's not just they don't give benefits, they enable people who think they know better than oneself what one needs. In the USSR they had mandatory daily calisthenics for workers, so they would "stay healthy". With the current level of busybodies arrogance I won't be completely surprised if unions will do that too. Or ban parking lots so programmers "exercise" by biking to work, also a popular trope on HN etc. etc.

To get people on-board union organizers would need to come up with some real benefits that people would want from unions, not with what organizers themselves want.

>There's another thing we should lobby for.

Your mandatory 4 weeks off is mutually exclusive with PTO accrual, you do understand that?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by throwaway914 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @06:38PM (#37330073)
I think very much you're an outlier. Rampant fatigue in the tech sector is a huge problem.

I do not see how mandatory 4 weeks off (paid) are mutually exclusive with PTO accrual. In my own corner, I've been elected to a board to represent other employees. Something we're lobbying for is a certain minimum of mandatory paid leave - as well as circumstances where being overworked would accrue additional time. Am I mixing up terms?

Something we're trying to cut down on is 7 days a week, 14-hour days. We've attacked this from a cost point of view if we can't get leadership to understand the humanitarian need. We're now putting it in policy that working lengthy hours will accrue paid (admin) leave. So the supervisor ultimately hurts themselves authorizing so much overtime. They will have to settle the books, and lose that person for their minimum and accrued time.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by pandaman on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:03PM (#37331618)
PTO accrual: you have a PTO balance, which you can spend as you wish and which is filled by a certain number of PTO hours each pay period.

Mandatory 4 weeks: you have to take 4 weeks off each year. You cannot spend your PTO as you wish.

In my case I don't have accrual, my PTO balance is reset every 1st of January, if I have any days left, they are "gone". I get the same balance of Jan 1st if I had 30 days of PTO on Dec 31st and if I had 0 days. It's not ideal but still is better than mandatory time off as I still have a choice to let the PTO "burn".

As far as me being an outlier I think you just get industry experience from reddit and have not worked much. Wherever I worked managers sent emails with dozens of names on the cc: regarding PTO balance reaching cap, there were always giant threads whenever HR posted about PTO cash out or cap change polices etc. If people starved for PTO that would not have been happening.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by tchaffee on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#37287751)
UPS drivers just negotiated $150k TC by the end of five years. That's for unskilled labor.

Think about how much additional profit highly skilled engineers could capture from company owners if we negotiated as team against the organized team that company owners pay for.

Negotiating as an individual against a full time team seems nuts.

Why leave so much profit on the table? For what good reason?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by mym1990 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:20PM (#37287177)
In 2022 only about 12% of those employed in the US were part of a union...so you are pretty far off from being the only one not 'gaining benefits'.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:28PM (#37287234)
I never claimed exclusivity in being treated poorly as labor.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by bontaq on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:43PM (#37287358)
The part I've been trying to explain to coworkers is that the union isn't just for software engineers at the company, but for the support staff as well. We have it good but I have seen support and sales staff get bullied pretty hard.

Sure you might not even get a raise with a union, but perhaps those same benefits of remote work when needed, unlimited vacation, and an hour lunch can be extended to every worker at the company.

The most expensive workers teaming up with the least expensive to give them more power is a good thing, I think.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by gochi on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:09PM (#37287551)
Funny enough, that's probably the worst way to convince engineers due to the belief that is rooted in this field which is both rockstar qualities and a false sense of security due to companies (so far) overpaying to reduce talent pools. So bringing up support staff and sales usually results in the mindset that they should just switch fields.

Instead talk about sports unions, like the NFL Player Association, and that usually gets them re-evaluating all they've been previously understanding about unions.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:54PM (#37288367)
Funny how proponents have to talk about sports or actors' unions to sell developer unionization because we aren't sports players or screen actors. Try talking about what actual engineering unions do instead, like the SPEEA.

(Frankly, I can't think of any unions of engineering professions aside from the SPEEA in the US and I couldn't find any in a casual Google search. Anyone know of any? And if there aren't any, well, people might want to think really hard about why.)

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:54PM (#37288751)
> And if there aren't any, well, people might want to think really hard about why.

The Conservative's demonization of unions for the last several decades seems to have worked quite well.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:23AM (#37305179)
And I've seen support and sales staff bully software engineers, often for being too white or male for their liking. So they should unionize on our behalf, for fairness and justice?
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:53PM (#37287433)
Software engineers often have a strange attitude, thinking they don't need unions, when pro athletes who make $millions per year all have unions. There's a myth that with unions, everyone will make the same compensation, but that's not even remotely true in pro sports.

The reason to have a union is that no matter how much money you make, the owners of the business have more money and power. Collective bargaining is a counterweight to the power of ownership.

And it's not just about money, it's about working conditions. For example, labor unions could fight back against back-to-the-office demands, whereas without a union, employees are forced to individually consent or lose their job.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:13PM (#37287579)
Well us software engineers can look at some of the ways that unions are run, and decide for ourselves if we like those "benefits".

For example, seniority requirements and enforced degree or qualification requirements don't sound like something I would want, nor would the many other software engineers like myself who didn't go through the "proper" path of getting a CS degree.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by candiddevmike on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:20PM (#37287617)
Degrees are not a requirement for unions, and most unions try and foster apprenticeship models. Additionally, seniority benefits/protections would be huge for our industry as there is a lot of rampant ageism and young naive work alcoholics.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:40PM (#37287771)
> and most unions try and foster apprenticeship models

This is example the problem I am talking about. This is a barrier to entry. Instead of being allowed to just apply for a job, and accepting it, you have to "do you time" in a low paid apprenticeship.

This puts up a barrier to entry to new people wanting to join, because union members want to reduce competition.

I am not just talking about degree requirements. Instead, I am talking about any barrier to entry. Unions have a very real and logical reason to put up barriers to entry. It reduces the supply of labor and increases prices for existing members, at the expense of people trying to break into the industry.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by candiddevmike on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:45PM (#37287811)
There's a lot of stuff you will learn in an apprenticeship that a lot of folks in our industry miss or skip, like soft skills, teamwork, risk/reward, effort/value, etc. I personally think everyone should be required to spend a year or two in tech support hell, or understand why a senior person thinks and researches before they start writing code, for instance.

You say barriers to entry, I say putting in the time to ensure you're someone I want to work with in the future.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:23PM (#37288133)
> I personally think everyone should be required to spend a year

Ok fine. You are free to say that you want barriers to entry and want to prevent people from getting jobs, by making them do all this other stuff.

But other people like me do not want that. We do not want to be forced by a union to do all these things, and instead want to be able to negotiate on our own to get a job.

A union being an unrelated 3rd party should have no say in that kind of business arrangement.

And there are a whole lot of other people, just like me, who would never have been able to get into the industry if we were forced to jump through all these hoops and we will not support organizations that pull up the ladder behind us.

> You say barriers to entry, I say putting in the time to ensure you're someone I want to work with in the future.

Its funny how you are almost directly contradicting your previous statements here.

Previously, you tried to argue that degree requirements, or other barriers to entry are not a thing. And now you are giving reason why you actually support those requirements?

Do you not see the direct contradiction that you made in like 2 posts?

Instead of that, you should have started off by saying "Yes I want there to be requirements, enforced by a union. I want you to be required to get a degree or do an apprenticeship, or a number of other things/ insert random thing X".

But you didn't do that. Instead, you disagreed with my factual claim that there are requirements, which you have immediately now backed off from without admitting that your original statement was wrong.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by deprecative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:34PM (#37288224)
> A union being an unrelated 3rd party should have no say in that kind of business arrangement.

A union is, in fact, a related second party. It is comprised of employees of that employer. You seem to be under a grave misunderstanding of what a union is. I recommend learning about what they are and put the koolaid down.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:37PM (#37288248)
> You seem to be under a grave misunderstanding of what a union is.

You seem to have a grave inability to interpret words to find out what someone's central point is, if you think that anything that I said relied on some definition of what a 2nd or 3rd party is.

I don't care about your word game. What I care about is my ability to negotiate my own job, with my own contract, and to not be forced to follow the union contract that includes barriers to entry by the previous posters own admittance.

I do not think that people should be forced to get certain requirements, or get a CS degree, or any of that nonsense, before they can work in tech.

And playing a word game does not overrule that central point.

Do you have any comment at all on this central point, or is the only comment at all that you have on some dictionary definition of 1st, 2nd, or 3rd party?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by candiddevmike on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:57PM (#37288390)
There is already a loose, undefined apprenticeship system in technology with the intern/junior roles. With a union, the pathway would be more defined, not required a college degree, and folks would get paid fairly and not have to job hop to get a raise. We'd also open access/be more inclusive by formally removing the need for college degrees and the HR "must have 15 years of rust experience" shenanigans.

We might even get real engineer licensing programs and become an accountable part of society...!

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:47PM (#37289118)
> With a union, the pathway would be more defined

By defined you mean requires as per the contract or even the law.

Yeah, no. We do not want to be forced into your requirements.

And we will fight and sabotage all of these efforts, because we know what it is that you are advocating for, and we will not pull up the ladder behind us.

Fortunately, the anti union side is winning in the tech industry, and those who want enforced barriers to entry are losing so much that none of this is even a real conversation in the industry right now.

> We might even get real engineer licensing programs

So literal legal requirements. Yes this is what us anti union people want to prevent.

This is why you will never has us on board. Because when your mask comes off, and people are actually honest about what they want implemented, it becomes clear that it was always exactly the stuff that we were trying to prevent.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by satvikpendem on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:51AM (#37303939)
Everything you say here, I agree with the sibling. I would not want to be in a field that has the requirements you're talking about. It is precisely why I joined a computer science major and job and not a computer engineering one.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:39PM (#37288261)
> "...seniority benefits/protections would be huge for our industry as there is a lot of rampant ageism and young naive work alcoholics."

Already trying to lock out the young, energetic, and ambitious using seniority systems? At least you're honest about it.

If you're young and you're considering supporting unionization for developers, keep in mind that people like the parent poster are your future seniors. They're marketing unionization to you to secure their own jobs and then maybe yours as a secondary consideration.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by candiddevmike on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:14PM (#37288516)
I don't know what causes folks like you to be so selfish and short sighted. You're going to be a long-termer someday (or you'll be in management and work towards exploiting union folks). Your life shouldn't revolve around work. Having the peace of mind of being shielded from layoffs because you've been working for 20+ years is huge. Hot shot developers and the rugged individualism doesn't jive with human life--most of us want to work to live not live to work.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:34PM (#37288630)
But you're not preventing layoffs, you're guaranteeing that they happen to recent employees, who rightly do not prefer this.

The same also makes it more expensive for you to switch jobs (you lose your seniority), which reduces your negotiating leverage.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:27PM (#37287679)
> enforced degree or qualification requirements don't sound like something I would want, nor would the many other software engineers like myself who didn't go through the "proper" path of getting a CS degree.

I don't have a CS degree either, and I'm not sure why you think labor unions would impose them? Degree requirements come from the company, not from the employees.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#37287749)
> I don't have a CS degree either, and I'm not sure why you think labor unions would impose them?

Labor organizations lobby for qualifications because it helps people who have them of course.

Additional requirements lower the supply of labor, and therefore increase wages for people who have those qualifications.

An example of a similar union where this is done is in the screen actors guild. They don't just let anyone in. Instead, they require you to do a certain amount of work before you are allowed to join.

The catch-22 of course, is that the union screen actors guild contracts prevent all but a minimal amount of non-union jobs on a certain production, therefore putting up barriers to entry for new people wanting to join the industry.

You need to be in the actors guild to be able to work in the industry, and you can't get into the actors guild unless you've already worked in it! Catch 22.

It all makes perfect sense for the goal of a union to be to decrease the labor supply, thereby helping the existing members.

I'm sure other people can come up with similar examples.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:49PM (#37287852)
I believe that you are misinformed. Non-members of the union can audition for and get union jobs, and they can work union jobs for up to 30 days before having to join the union. Eligibility to join the union comes after 3 days as a background actor in a union job or 1 day in a speaking role in a union job.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:21AM (#37305165)
> I'm not sure why you think labor unions would impose them

Because unions have often in the past imposed various credentialling requirements, followed by quotas on the credentials given, as a way to push up wages.

For example the UK health system is wrecked by this. Medical unions insist on very low numbers of school places, too low to meet demand, so the government is forced to rely on immigration to fill the gaps. The unions love this because they're all overtly left wing organizations and want mass migration, also they see immigrants as free Labour voters. But being unable to actually train sufficient doctors is a bad place for the country to be in.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:55AM (#37306388)
As a US citizen, I have no knowledge of UK medical unions. However, if the only example you can cite is from the UK, then it shows the practice is not common. Moreover, the UK health system is socialized, so it isn't a free market in the first place.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by toldyouso2022 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:03PM (#37287494)
A union turns into a guild fast. I don't want programming to be monopoly of people with a degree, slave to the cartel's rule, programming is a human right and it must remain absolutely free!

A programmers union is too dangerous in this world, especially in these times

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by tomlockwood on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:13PM (#37287575)
What evidence is there that unions turn into guilds? There were more guilds in preindustrial times and modern unions haven't become guilds.
Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by unshavedyak on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:12PM (#37288036)
I view unions like i view government. It's possible, sometimes likely, that a government becomes a horrid entity for control over people.

However. Governments, and perhaps Unions, are by definition (correct me if i'm wrong?) an entity that is by the people and for the people. Some for-profit company or individual has no ethical obligation to treat workers correctly, fairly, etc. So if we remove unions and government, what power do individual people have?

To that idea then, people need a gov/union to have a voice - but govs and unions also need to be built with an extreme attention to oversight. Which we usually fail to implement correctly. Nevertheless it's the only tool we have - to give individuals power by distributing agreement. So to me the question isn't for or against gov/union, but rather how we can build them to scale and last. Especially in the face of pressure to corrupt.

Happy to hear opinions on where this is wrong, though.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:16AM (#37305142)
> Governments, and perhaps Unions, are by definition (correct me if i'm wrong?) an entity that is by the people and for the people

I never heard of this definition for unions! Unions definitely aren't for or by "the people", that would mean everyone. Unions are - by definition - a group of arbitrarily defined "workers" lined up to fight the "management", another somewhat arbitrary group. They are inherently exclusionary and divisive.

Unless you're a communist, in which case you think managers, company founders, shopkeepers, farmers etc aren't really people.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by unshavedyak on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:30PM (#37314991)
Not sure i follow.

> a group of arbitrarily defined "workers" lined up to fight the "management", another somewhat arbitrary group. They are inherently exclusionary and divisive.

So is _any_ group but "all". "For the people" doesn't literally mean "all people". Government would also not be "for the people" by your definition, given that we have no (real) global government.

If we get together and form a union, ie our joint effort towards a common goal, have we not formed an entity for the people (us), by the people (us)?

Your argument seems odd. "But it's not for everyone" is.. well, yea - nothing is. Literally. What can you say that is "everyone"?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lotsoweiners on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:18PM (#37288098)
> programming is a human right and it must remain absolutely free!

Weird statement. No one is trying to stop you from programming. They are talking about credentials to be employed professionally.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by toldyouso2022 on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:15AM (#37289691)
Nobody is forced to buy work from someone, but with a State sanctioned cartel you are forced to buy from the cartel instead than from whomever you want.

The weird statement is yours when you say they don't stop me from programming. They do!

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by jrockway on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:43PM (#37287794)
I think most software engineers are a little uncomfortable with the whole arrangement of employment to begin with, and any backlash against unions is the backlash from having to face this somewhat subservient reality. The origin story of getting a computer, some library books, and spending 10,000 hours alone with your computer seems pretty common. With that mental model, why would you want someone who isn't a software engineer interfering with your career? You built it yourself, and you don't need any help. I think that's where the attitude comes from, and it's probably something worth talking yourself out of. (Nobody is discounting their hard work, but the more BS other people deal with, the more time you can spend alone with your text editor.)

The other thing that people probably worry about are protecting the net negative members on the team. Those that make more work for the team, derail meetings, block things from being submitted, etc. Nobody wants to hear "well our contract doesn't allow us to fire them".

Like all engineering, there isn't a solution with no downsides.

I think unions deserve serious consideration. Our working conditions are not perfect (know any software engineers with wrist problems, back problems, or sleep apnea?). Our benefits are not perfect (love being forced to take a mandatory vacation every year paid out of my personal vacation balance). And, we have pretty much zero sway among the government. (Do you think that if attorneys were paid in illiquid shares that every time you received them, you'd have to send a hand-signed letter to the IRS?) There is certainly something to be gained; software prints money, and the people that make it deserve their fair share.

Even on HN, commenters are shocked by the FAANG salaries, but you know lots of people are making way more money. Someone just paid $7M for the two story house behind my apartment. I'm guessing they're not a couple of software engineers. Why is that? Is it because we self-sabotage? Is there not that much money in software after all?

Someone should look into all of this, but as long as we see ourselves as individuals and not a group, we will be easy to ignore.

(Uh oh, now I sound like a communist.)

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:29PM (#37288605)
> Our working conditions are not perfect (know any software engineers with wrist problems, back problems, or sleep apnea?). Our benefits are not perfect (love being forced to take a mandatory vacation every year paid out of my personal vacation balance).

Are these not things you would expect to be able to negotiate on your own? Who are you working for that would rather lose you as an employee than provide you with an ergonomic keyboard?

> And, we have pretty much zero sway among the government. (Do you think that if attorneys were paid in illiquid shares that every time you received them, you'd have to send a hand-signed letter to the IRS?)

This is the most significant thing that unions actually do, but it seems weird to bring them in for the things they're "supposed to do" (negotiating with employers), when you don't really want that (they protect bad team members), because what you really want is something else.

And in that role a union doesn't really fit here, because you have interests shared with people who wouldn't be in it. Even if you have the same legislative goals as every other software developer, what sense does it make to unionize your own tiny startup or small business, or some entity which is already majority-owned by the employees?

Maybe what software developers need is not a union, but a PAC?

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by johnnyanmac on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:37PM (#37289056)
>employees are forced to individually consent or lose their job.

that's the thing, software workers are used to just walking away, because their skills are versatile and demand is high. A national level athlete can also simply retire on a few year's funds (or hell, sell themselves as an influencer. You don't think a youtube channel alone of LeBron wouldn't generate a 6k income from weekly "advice"?), but they tend to have a competitive drive to stay in the game, literally. You don't grind your entire childhood's physique away because you're gambling on the chance you retire at 30 (even if that is the most likely thing to happen due to injuries).

To be frank, the vibe I get from the internet seems to be that a lot of SWE's are indeed minmaxing to get out of the workforce ASAP.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:59PM (#37289193)
> that's the thing, software workers are used to just walking away, because their skills are versatile and demand is high.

But walking away voluntarily is different from having to walk away because your employer gives you an ultimatum. Especially when you're facing a market that has been hit by mass layoffs by many tech companies, and especially if you're looking specifically for a WFH job when many companies are demanding return to the office, precisely reason you'd be walking away in the first place.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by johnnyanmac on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:27AM (#37289776)
>But walking away voluntarily is different from having to walk away because your employer gives you an ultimatum.

Is there a real difference between walking away due to an ultimatum and walking away due to the prospect of better pay or work conditions? Especially in the case where you started pre-pandemic and technically WFH was never indefinitely promised?

Either way, you are voluntarily choosing to seek a better job with better work conditions. The only difference is that you may not be able to be as covert in the ultimatum situation.

Re:Labor unions are pushing hard for better pay and hours – ... by lapcat on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:31AM (#37292071)
> the prospect of better pay or work conditions

> to seek a better job with better work conditions

> The only difference is that you may not be able to be as covert in the ultimatum situation.

The words you use here are interesting: "the prospect", "to seek".

The only difference is that you may not be able to find a better job with better work conditions if you're operating under the gun of unemployment and in a significantly worse job market.

> technically WFH was never indefinitely promised

It some cases it was indefinitely promised, and then employers broke the promise.