News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by mikeyouse on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:23PM (#37256290)
An interesting counterfactual I think about a fair amount is what would cities like NYC or SF look like if they just built tons of housing. Given the allure and success of the tech bubble in Northern California - would their population be a few million people higher today if we just built as fast as humanly possible over the past 25 years?

Like if we just built enough housing to keep studios at $1k/month and 2-bedroom places at $2k/month -- everything else would have been cheaper as well (you wouldn't need to pay cooks and wait staff $80k/year for them to afford to stay) -- it would greatly expand the 'service' industry of e.g. teachers & daycare providers since they could afford to stay.

Bringing SF's population density to that of Paris's would give you ~750k more residents. Bringing Alameda County's population density up to that of Long Island would give you ~1.5M more residents. Certainly capacity for a few million more in San Jose and the East Bay. You'd potentially run into water issues but with that population and tax base, it'd be easy math to justify a huge DeSal plant. I dunno.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:33PM (#37256360)
The population would absolutely be higher and the economy would be better. More startups and more people willing to work for startups since housing costs are less of a burden.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by ryukoposting on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:44PM (#37256448)
Ask any startup worker from a mid-size midwestern city why this doesn't work in practice.

Reputation matters. Stereotypes matter.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:19PM (#37256686)
Not saying it applies to everyone. I'm sure they matter to some. But i'd also bet there are many people that would launch their own start up or work for one if housing costs were less of a concern.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:53PM (#37256521)
> Reputation matters. Stereotypes matter.

This is very oblique. What do you mean?

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by ryukoposting on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:03PM (#37256589)
I'm saying that 9/10 startups in Chicago could move 70 miles north to Milwaukee, pay less in taxes, offer their employees a shorter commute and a more favorable housing market, and position themselves in the "internship sphere" of three Big 10 universities instead of two, but they don't. The reasons for that trace back to the basic fact that there are fewer people in Milwaukee, fewer people who have been there, and thus, fewer people willing to move there sight unseen. Not to mention the perception of status that comes with the California tech valleys. I use Milwaukee as an example, but the same logic applies to Detroit and Minneapolis, among others.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:16PM (#37256662)
There are benefits from economies of agglomeration that are lost when relocating to distant areas for affordability which is the main reason the midwest or other parts of the country haven't been able to scale up startup economies. If everyone (founders, investors, employees, customers, vendors, etc.) are in one area, it facilitates better collaborations and also increases chances of random collisions. Employers get wider pool of talent; employees get greater options of employers that they can bounce around without having to relocate.

Edit (meant to add): I believe these factors explain this better than simply reputation or prestige.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by ryukoposting on Friday August 25, 2023 @10:22AM (#37262057)
You have a point, to be sure. For context, I live in Milwaukee and work for a Chicago startup. I recently found out that my current CEO is friends with someone I used to work with at a previous Chicago startup.

For fully or mostly-remote workplaces, to what extent does "economies of agglomeration" affect that company, relative to a more traditional workplace?

Also, in my experience, startups don't benefit from a plain ol' big talent pool in the same way that larger companies do. Startups require a very particular kind of talent, one whose supply is very limited no matter where you go, and doesn't correlate solely with total population. Here in the midwest, that supply seems to be directly correlated with proximity to the big engineering schools, which is why I mentioned the Big 10 (MSOE is also held in very high regard regionally, but again: prestige matters). Every Chicago startup I'm aware of has some tie to Northwestern, for example.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:07PM (#37256611)
Thank you, that's much clearer!
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by kkfx on Friday August 25, 2023 @09:15AM (#37261346)
FLOSS power the world IT essentially, and was born distributed, with typically 100% remote developers since most projects do not even have a forma HQ.

Density for IT is the least thing we need, communication, like classic Usenet, yes, but not physical density.

For economy in general beware: economy of scale works with a good but not too much density. If you densify too much the model collapse being unable to evolve at reasonable costs. Nowadays since we dream a near future with cars substituted by flying drones the right density is less than any modern city typical density and the right scale is being spread over vast territory.

Only few, industrial, activities demand higher density and localization.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by pas on Friday August 25, 2023 @03:47PM (#37266226)
nah, density and scale go hand-in-hand, but broken ass-backwards governance prevents adoption of techniques appropriate for the density to provide the services at scale.

it's ridiculous that we are still not building housing and transportation at scale. the automotive industry can churn out complete series of vintages faster than the construction industry sends an email.

housing is still this "my house my castle", which is fine until everyone starts to fight for, conquer and eventually annex the neighborhood.

the same sorry ass techniques are used to build housing as half a century ago, when total population was a billion less, when not 70% of the population lived in cities, and so on.

keeping housing density very high leaves space for other things around housing, eg. hospitals, schools, or ... ugh. parks. makes a lot of mixed development suddenly becomes economically worthwhile.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by 7speter on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:37PM (#37256387)
Theres a NYC nonprofit named Picture The Homeless that contends that if all the boarded up apartment buildings that have open storefronts on the first floor were lawfully required to open their stock to renters, rent in NYC could go down significantly just because of the sheer number of these apartments that are excluded from the market, to the point that there would be significantly less need to build new housing units.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by tutorialmanager on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:55PM (#37256532)
Why are so many units empty? The conventional wisdom is that being a residential landlord in NYC can be a nightmare. Can that really be the reason?
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by jeffbee on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:58PM (#37256553)
Increasing utilization requires a massive effort and cannot solve the crisis. Vacancy rates are currently at all-time lows. NYC's vacancy rate is the lowest in the nation, and the lowest ever measured in that city. To intuitively understand why increasing occupancy from. 97% to 98% is difficult, try filling your refrigerator to 97% by volume and then try putting one more thing in there.

Counterintuitively the way to attack the housing crisis is to increase vacancy. 10% is a robust vacancy rate that allows the market to function. New buildings are vacant by nature, so building new buildings until the vacancy rate hits 10% is the way to go. The market will clear, rents will decline, developers will make reasonable profits for providing a needed service and landlords will get kicked in the teeth, which is right and proper.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by kajecounterhack on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:31PM (#37256347)
SF needs more public transportation as much as it needs housing :(
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xnx on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:41PM (#37256416)
SF is getting the most modern public transportation system in the world via Waymo and (kind of) Cruise.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:44PM (#37256450)
Taxis are not a sustainable public transportation system; they're supplemental, at best.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xnx on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:05PM (#37256600)
What's not sustainable? Low infrastructure cost because they don't use expensive and custom rails. Infinitely flexible because they connect any two points on any schedule. Low operating cost because there are no human operators and they are mainly based on commodity vehicles. Rides could be subsidized for low income and would be a huge timesaver for things like grocery trips. They don't currently work well for extreme surge like concerts and sporting events, but there could still be custom shuttle buses for that. The technology isn't here yet, and it sucks that only one vendor is close, but it seems very promising.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:16PM (#37256658)
That "infinite flexibility" is the road network's greatest advantage and greatest curse: you can connect any two points because the network is built for individuals in private vehicles, not mass movements.

Self-driving cars may make our highways more efficient, but they can't change the basic fact that a road with individual-sized cars on it carries far fewer people per square foot than mass transit does.

(And note: we currently subsidize the hell out of our road network, in a way that's far less obvious to the public mind than our comparatively light subsidization of mass transit. It remains to be seen whether the average car trip is actually net cheaper.)

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xnx on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:28PM (#37256751)
That's a good reminder that there are a lot of hidden subsidies for roads too.

I imagine that we'll always have roads, but rails systems are optional, so the cost of roads is a given. Widespread use of self-driving vehicles should dramatically reduce the amount of lanes that need to be maintained though.

I'm familiar with the arguments about rail capacity vs cars, but I live by main road and train lines. The road is in use 24 hours a day, and the rails are mainly idle. My dream scenario is self-driving vehicles become ubiquitous and we replace all commuter rails systems with foot and bike paths.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:35PM (#37256808)
> The road is in use 24 hours a day, and the rails are mainly idle.

This is a measurement error: you might see 300 cars in an hour and only two trains, but those 300 cars are carrying 600 people while the trains are carrying 1500 each. The road appears busy and the rail system idle, but the exact opposite is true in terms of volume of people moved.

(It could also be true that the train system isn't well utilized in your area, but the fundamental point about scale and measurement is the same.)

As others have pointed out elsewhere in the thread, the main cost of mass transit is actually labor, not the rails (or even trains) themselves. The US is somewhat behind the times in realizing this; just about everywhere I've been in Europe has healthy mass transit systems that run cheaper and more reliably due to increased automation.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xnx on Thursday August 24, 2023 @10:30PM (#37257245)
Absolutely. I don't know how many cars/trucks/people are using the road (it's a highway, so it's a lot). I do know that the trains are mainly empty, just 40% of their pre-COVID usage. (Chicago)
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by jeffbee on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:46PM (#37256465)
On the other hand a self-driving bus route that comes much more frequently than any existing Muni line would be nice and cuts down on the main cost, which is operator labor.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:52PM (#37256509)
I can't claim to understand Muni's problems, but it occurs to me that an train is a much simpler problem (technically speaking) to solve than a self-driving bus. The former doesn't have to flow in and out of unstructured traffic, has only one degree of freedom, has well-deployed reference systems, etc.

Maybe one day we'll have fully automated buses without any operators at all, but for the time being my understanding is that even self-driving cars still need a tender. The kind of bus volume (and corresponding idle drivers) you'd need to make up for a train's worth of commuters probably takes a heavy cut into any operator labor savings.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:32PM (#37256783)
Unfortunately, MUNI is not grade separated and the Muni trains do have to interface with traffic. Still easier than cars but similar challenges. And unlike the private industry in SF, the public agencies seem allergic to technology.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xnx on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:09PM (#37256621)
Waymo does have a support team, but it is not 1:1 with its vehicles. Trains a transportation system from a different era when there were peak commute times. They run at a fraction of their capacity now.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:20PM (#37256694)
The trains seem busy enough here in NYC (too busy: they need to run more of them).

I'm not aware of a city on Earth that's been able to obtain the kind of simultaneous density and livability that places like NYC have without mass transit. Comparatively dense cities without mass transit (like Manila) are choked in traffic; changing that traffic to electric traffic will make the air cleaner (good!) but will not address the latter problem.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xnx on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:58PM (#37256974)
NYC transit is great. Citibike and the ferry are my favorite parts. Crazy that you can't get a train from LaGuardia to Manhattan. $3.5 billion/mile is a lot to pay for new track! It's yet to be seen, but I'm hopeful that widespread use self driving vehicles of calm, quite, and safe transportation that flows like water.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by woodruffw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:08PM (#37257531)
> $3.5 billion/mile is a lot to pay for new track!

That's mostly paying for the tunnels, not the track. It shouldn't cost nearly that much, but it's not surprising that it isn't cheap either: the tunnels are being constructed under some of the densest and most expensive real estate in the world, and the resulting stations are significantly larger than others in the system.

And note: if you think that's expensive, you won't believe what it costs to repair highways in NYC[1].

[1]: https://ny1.com/nyc/brooklyn/news/2020/02/25/city-council-fl...

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:39PM (#37256404)
The public transit needs more ridership. Hasn't recovered as well as other cities from pre-2020 and is very low currently. Ridership would increase with transit oriented development (TOD). A lot of good opportunities for TOD around BART and Caltrain stations.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by nocoiner on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:35PM (#37256377)
With that tax base, is there any reason BART couldn’t be expanded and enhanced?
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by doublespanner on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:39PM (#37256405)
In my experience, the motivation for rapid growth in an area comes from an opposite direction to improving services in an area.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:45PM (#37256458)
BART is struggling to fund it's operations currently as ridership is down significantly from per-pandemic. Bart is already constructing a 5 mile extension into downtown San Jose and Santa Clara. But BART should not prioritize any more extensions after that. It is better for BART to focus on transit oriented development (TOD). There are many good opportunities for TOD. Currently. too many stations are surrounded by low density housing and surface parking lots. Also, it is better for BART to use money to improve operations as frequency is abysmal on weekends and nighttime. Better to use money on expanding service and building TOD before any further extensions.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by epicureanideal on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:54PM (#37256525)
Get the smelly mentally ill and drug using people off of Bart and I’ll use it more.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by farzinadil on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:22PM (#37256712)
I think the best way to do that is installing better fare gates that prevent fare evasion. Seems reasonable to believe anti-social people on BART causing trouble are fare evaders and a crack down on fare evasion would keep them off the system.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by epicureanideal on Friday August 25, 2023 @01:08AM (#37258292)
I’ve seen some supposed attempts to crack down on fare evasion but the people doing the enforcement seem to be intentionally misapplying it to say, old folks and working professionals who have only $2 on their clipper card and who are likely going to refill it when they arrive at their destination (which used to be totally normal), hitting them with $75 citations. Meanwhile the homeless and mentally unstable remain..
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by chrischen on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:43PM (#37256436)
SF public transit is actually decent. It was just a little pricey especially if you had to combine BART with Muni. And some people had a bad view of it as dangerous.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by jltsiren on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:12PM (#37256637)
New housing is pretty much the only valid reason to build public transit.

Good transit is expensive. The people who already live in the area are not willing to pay enough to justify the investment. They have already figured out their lives without the transit. If you want transit, you have to build it primarily for new residents. And the costs should be covered by increased land value, usually either by taxing the land, selling it, or developing it. Trying to cover investment costs with fares just destroys the value of the investment.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by el_benhameen on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:44PM (#37256453)
I wouldn’t be surprised (though I could be wrong!) if more housing stock and a larger population in SF/the bay proper would mean a commensurate decrease in the population in the suburbs and exurbs. There are a lot of lower wage workers who now commute from Stockton/Pittsburg/the Sacramento area who I’m sure would prefer to be closer to their jobs.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by WillPostForFood on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:55PM (#37256533)
Counter example - the suburbs around NYC have not suffered population loss to Manhattan. Though unlike the bay area, there is an extensive public transport system to get people into the city.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xwolfi on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:49PM (#37256491)
But let's assume the whole thing is a money blackbox, you must realize you cannot output that much good from the little change "build build build" without inputting something.

This something, the tax rate increase, or any other way to finance this whole operation like an increase in loan risk by large builders, would probably be phenomenal enough to make it completely off putting to most workers. People are not rational long term altruist thinkers: they want the best deal possible, and it's not to make SF more affordable in 30 years by over financing house construction today before they finally die of proud exhaustion like "I contributed to cheap rents for my descendants".

I prefer natural selection: you talked of Paris, the city is half stable now. It's always been the hyper center of France, we've always had higher inflow than outflow, prices have raised slowly every year since 1800 at a higher pace than wages, and now it's going down. We're developing stuff elsewhere, not only the outskirt but other part of France entirely that people would dream to move to after a stay in Paris.

The alternative you propose is to build the city I live in now: Hong Kong. Here, since we can't escape anywhere, all we can do is build build build. Our long inflow of desperate Chinese has made construction efficient, fast and cheap enough. Price are more commensurate with wages than Paris, even if they can appear absurd to the poor people in America. But, do you want to live like me in a small 2-room flat on the 44th floor of a giant tower surrounded by other towers ? That's the future you propose, eventually. Lots of homes in the single most important city, the dream !

I like the alternative: to just jump elsewhere and start over. Let the people starve due to mortgages in California and build a new hub in Ohio or whatever, they'll figure it out eventually.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by gnopgnip on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:55PM (#37256530)
The economy is not a zero sum black box. With a better allocation of resources, (the density of paris in the most desirable areas) it can actually result in lower taxes, shorter commutes, etc.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by xwolfi on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:01PM (#37256575)
But why oh why does everything need to be in Paris ? We're not retards in Lyon, Rouen or Bordeau. Even Marseille can handle some stuff. See the point ? Why waste to hyper densify one crappy city/area when we could spread development keeping low density ?

Or maybe I guess I mean: low density provide more benefit to more people than hyper density, the only future proposed by OP, will ever compensate due to "low rent" (which will explode once there's not one single meter square free left), because once you chose SF as the only IT hub that ever will be and commit for 25 years of future development, then no IT worker will ever think of any other city and will move there faster than you're building anyway. Just like Paris for French people: the only place I wanted to go after Uni was there, because that's the only place with interesting/important/paid jobs: isn't THIS the issue ?

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by gnopgnip on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:25AM (#37258060)
Building housing where people want to live is a good thing

Low density development isn't sustainable because it greatly increases transportation costs, long term maintenance costs aren't sustainable

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 25, 2023 @03:12AM (#37258981)
Transportation costs in hyper dense cities are not cheap either. Tokyo spends a lot of money on new metro infrastructure, they have a world class system but it isn’t cheaper per person than what they have in other smaller cities.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by rr808 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:53PM (#37256942)
I live in NY metro and my 2 bed apartment has $2k/mo city tax. As cities get denser costs get more expensive. I replaced my HVAC, hot water heater and rebuilt a bathroom and it cost me the same price I could buy a whole detached house in Chicago.

Urban sprawl Houston style is the only way to keep costs low as you suggest, and I wouldn't want to live there.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by dublinben on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:15AM (#37262653)
New York has been getting less dense though, which is the point of TFA. As demand has outstripped supply, prices of real estate and everything consequent to that (labor, professional services, retail goods, transportation etc.) will increase in price as well.

"Costs" in Houston don't look so much better than NYC when you add the significantly higher transportation expenses to their lower rents. Also, local salaries are a third less, so you have that much less money for everything.

Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by HDThoreaun on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:21AM (#37262716)
As you pointed out houses are cheap in Chicago and the north side is quite dense, comparable to most of Brooklyn.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by mushbino on Thursday August 24, 2023 @10:49PM (#37257401)
Of all the cities that have been rapidly expanding housing, the zero of them have become more affordable. I used to think market rate housing would bring down prices but it has proven to not. What we need are affordable housing units, price caps, rent as percentage of income, rent control, and things along those lines. Singapore and Vienna have done a good job but 70% of all housing in Vienna is government owned and 80% of all housing in Singapore was built by the government.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by HDThoreaun on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:23AM (#37262743)
Cities that rapidly expand housing are much, much cheaper than cities that don't. Houston vs Austin, Chicago vs. new york, phoenix vs LA. Yes all metros are getting more expensive, that's because there are no cities in this country that are building faster than people are arriving.
Re:NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions by thunky on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:38AM (#37261023)
I disagree with the entire premise here.

Forget about the housing market, take a step back for a second and try to rationalize the idea of cramming millions of people into a small area to work on their computers together? I don't think so.

Computers didn't exist when Manhattan grew, there were natural reasons for people to cluster together and live on top of eachother. Now, not so much.