OpenAI etc. have huge amounts of money behind them, they very well have a fighting chance in court to defend their usage of scraping the internet.
These creative industries include all of software development, music, TV, movies, books, media, art, etc. You do technically solve the problem of copyright by shutting all those down, but I'm not sure it's a solution anybody will vote for.
If you can come up with a serious alternative though, which can sustain those creative industries without requiring copyright, now is probably the best moment in all of history to seize the day and make that happen. There's going to be a big shake-up regardless, it's the perfect chance for alternative models.
Bear in mind that dropping copyright entirely doesn't just hurt Disney and Sony Music though - with no copyright the GPL and all other open-source licenses are unenforceable, anybody can copy & sell anybody else's art or design without permission, Spotify doesn't have to pay musicians even $0.01 any more, etc etc etc. It's not an easy problem.
This is categorically false for both software and movies.
For other media, this ignores the effect of zero-effort copying.
The most obvious scenario that comes to mind for me is, imagine an independent artists launching their (book/film/album/etc) and the same day someone with more resources and experience takes the work and markets it better than the OG author ever could on their own.
I see a problem today, being spammed with shitty commercial "works" whereas I'd like to see something genuine and not just made for money.
However, abolishing copyright is not the same as making monetization illegal. My view is that people should be paid for their WORK, and copying something doesn't make the author work more.
This'd mean the funds 'd need to be bootstrapped (crowdfunding?) before the work is done, but then it'd be free to distribute it.
It makes no sense to add artificial scarcity to ideas, the cost of replication is inherently zero and all kinds of noxious consequences on society (like derivative works being impossible to create) shake out as a result. If the goal is encouraging creation why are you punishing and penalizing the creation of derivative works?
Letting megacorps monopolize popular culture for 100+ years after its inception is a relatively newfangled idea and it’s baffling that so many people just blindly accept that this is the way it has to be. Copyright works against individuals in almost all cases, we benefit much more from free interchange of ideas. Social diffusion and remixing is a fundamental human force and this AI stuff forced the issue by doing the exact same things with impossible precision and scale, such that the absurdity of the system for humans is revealed as well.
The current copyright regime is the social equivalent of “we could have a cop taking down license plates if we wanted”. And AI does the “so it’s therefore legal to automatically and instantly record everyone’s license plates at every intersection in the country 24/7”. The principle is the same but the ease of use reveals the absurdity of the principle.
Eg. If team cherry didn't have savings from selling hollow knight, I'd pitch in money for them to work on silk song.
The modern small artist doesn't even get paid for their art, but for things like their audience
Do you think Bing or Google are going to negotiate copying rights with the world's websites?
LLMs are proving that intellectual property has a bunch of holes in it. It's been unstable ground to defend since day one. Upon what principle should we believe that one can own an idea and all performances or derivatives of it? Patents and trademarks haven't really helped as much as they were expected to. Only recently did works as far back as 1920 enter the public domain. Additionally, some LLMs gobble up source code with mixed licensing structures. How is that to be handled?
Patents are about monopolies to produce something to hit a market, with the trade-off of showing everyone how it's made.
Trademarks just allow you to defend your name(s).
Copyright prevents other people from making money off of your work. For the rest of your life, plus 75 years.
Something is broken here, alright. While we're discussing intellectual property, what about one's DNA? Is it not a performance of biology? How about your fingerprint? Fingerprints are semi-unique, so it's also a performance mark. We've seen celebrities sue for the use of their likeness, so that's recognized to some degree as well. At what point will data subjects get rights, so that when another Equifax happens, they can be bankrupted and prevented from harming the public again?
Most are rhetorical, of course, but I really think generative language models are disrupting a lot of things we used to take for granted, and our models of creatorship are not refined enough to account for digital or statistical copying. Intellectual property as a concept is not compatible with a digital future.
Search engines index the web and point you at other people's work, along the way showing perhaps too much of that content (thus "stealing" users from the target webpage). But they don't reshuffle existing content into something apparently new and original.
The "malicious" case for generative AI is that it sucks in copyrighted work (vs. indexing it), rehashes and produces something that is supposedly original, but really a sophisticated rehash of copyrighted work.
It's hard for me to reconcile that it's somehow OK for a student to write a term paper about something (e.g. "Ulysses"), Wikipedia doing the same thing, but on the other hand, not OK for chatGPT doing it.
LLMs do.
As it stands right now, yes, Fair Use. But where do we draw the line? That line's been blurry for a while. Mostly limited to no more than 30 seconds of a performance, and no more than what's needed to quote literary works. Not sure about lyrics.
The issue is on some level, most things we create are derivative. Someone had to have the idea first, but once an idea is unleashed upon the world, it seems very difficult and unwieldy to put the genie back in the bottle.
I'm not really pro-LLM since it enables business to leech off of FOSS even more efficiently. The disruption of LLMs seems to be accelerating our philosophical re-examining of copyright and licensing terms in FOSS. We will inevitably need a GPL in the future that disallows remixing via LLM or other generative text algos, due mostly because ensuring all of a result is freely usable is not easy. Limitations could be built in to only 'fetch' code licensed under permissive terms, like MIT or BSD, but the tendency of these models to 'hallucinate' means you really cannot know the legal standing of LLM-generated code, at present.
But ChatGPT is actually providing an alternative that obviates the original articles themselves.
Personally, I like the flexibility of an LLM being able to describe a process at different skill levels. This is of tremendous educational value to the world.
Even the link is a copyrightable item -- artistic effort went into creating it
Small snippets are allowed by copyright law. They are not infringing.
> and Google will show you their cached page if you ask for it.
Really? I haven't seen that in several years. How do you get it these days?
I always assumed Google quit giving you that option exactly because of copyright issues.
> Even the link is a copyrightable item -- artistic effort went into creating it
IANAL, but I'm pretty sure that the current state of copyright law disagrees with you. Can you point to some concrete evidence that you're right?
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:www.hac...
etc
There's also a link in the three-dot menu next to the search result, but it doesn't always appear.
It’s basically the “does this replace the original content” doctrine of fair use
What you're thinking of is "featured snippets". As far as I know, the justification behind those is that they are exact quotes that are followed by a citation (a link). Google argues those are fair use, since it's a properly referenced quote.
LLMs output a mashup of source material without attribution. This is 99% of the time against the copyright holder's interest.
No, they won't. Search engines have already fought and won this battle on fair use grounds because they make use of the copyrighted content differently than LLMs do. It's an absolutely fundamental distinction.
Patents and trademarks haven't really helped as much as they were expected to.
Patents have been a thing for nearly a millenia; Britain's patent system is credited with giving it the technological edge over its Medieval and post-Medieval competitors for world domination. Similarly, the U.S. patent system has been credited with the U.S.' technological prowess for the past 2 centuries.
Only recently did works as far back as 1920 enter the public domain.
Nothing is stopping artists from releasing works into the public domain during their lifetimes. That would of course would mean other people economically exploiting their works however they wished without any input or control from the artist...which is generally why most artists haven't done that.
While we're discussing intellectual property, what about one's DNA? Is it not a performance of biology? How about your fingerprint? Fingerprints are semi-unique, so it's also a performance mark
This is either a bad-faith argument. DNA and fingerprints are tangible things created without any sort of intellectual input. Therefore, by definition not intellectual property.
We've seen celebrities sue for the use of their likeness, so that's recognized to some degree as well.
This is another bad-faith argument. Celebrity likenesses are intangible property but are not intellectual property and are not afforded the same protections.
I really think generative language models are disrupting a lot of things we used to take for granted
LLMs so far have disrupted student papers. And that's pretty much it.
I’m curious if you can set me straight with a citation, or whether you would contest mine.
That is the problem. Technically, AI should be allowed to 'read' content, it isn't hidden, and it gets mixed with other content in a 'brain' like thing.
AI and Humans can both spit out a new product that is 'similar' and thus be sued on that similarity.
But it can also produce endless similar variations at low cost and fast.
It is the ease of creating new similar products.
You could just as well prompt the AI "make a Taylor Swift song, but different enough to avoid a lawsuit".
Think this is an entirely new problem that needs a new law beyond copywrite. Copywrite is not the correct law to us for fighting this. Copywrite law doesn't ban someone from reading the source altogether.Ask GPT something like "write a screen play for Othello using dialog like Tarantino, but with bit of style like Baz Luhrmann". It produces something pretty creative. And if you say, well it is just combining what came before, that also applies to humans, there are no new ideas.
Humans being complicated doesn't mean AI wont catch up. Its just time/money/engineering at this point.
In Nature, why would Carbon be more holy than Silicon.
It’s not derivative work though. First, a human didn’t create it, so copyright protections don’t exist on its output. Machines don’t enjoy copyright protections, people do.
It’s mechanically copying and reproducing part of its input data set. Making a tool that regurgitates others’ copyrighted IP is going to been seen as aiding mass copyright violations. Exactly like how Napster got sued: they’re holding a bunch of material they shouldn’t be. The only new twist to this case is the data is encoded in a transformer’s weights. This should be correctly seen as the same as having encrypted copyrighted data using a lossy algorithm.
This is not correct. AI models are tools that humans use.
This is like saying "it was typed on a computer therefore it doesn't enjoy copyright protections"
When you're using ai models to generate the art, it's not considered human enough. If you then make a bunch of modifications to it, sure, but giving the initial prompt is currently insufficient
Interesting and makes sense. I guess the best comparison I can think of is a random number generated with Math.random() is not copyrightable. But including that random number is a program is copyrightable.
I'd say that a corollary to this is that if the images/words generated by the machine are not copyrightable then they cannot also be _copyright violations_
So, "good on rainman".
Now, for the rest of us...
The point I'm trying to make is if you rule these behaviors illegal, then you're necessarily making intelligent AI illegal, because humans are capable of the same behaviors.
If plagiarism was a copyright violation then citing the source wouldn’t make the copyright violation go away. Putting the artists name in the title of the YouTube doesn’t make it not a copyright violation.
This has napster -> subscription spotify energy. But the only people happy about that are Spotify and people who found it distasteful to download music illegally. There just wasn’t a consumer-friendly option for a while, so the black market was the only market.
So. The enforcement mechanism is what… a scary DMCA letter?
(There will definitely be a stupid DCAIA in the next congress)
In an (unrealizable) regime where all copyright holders are compensated, that would include picopennies for the discussion we’ve had!
Copyright largely remains about the PRODUCTION of content, not about the CONSUMPTION of it.
Someone who grew up reading Marvel comics being able to make new original comics in that style is perfectly ok. That same person perfectly replicating an Avengers comic is going to land them in hot water.
The focus on infringement really needs to be on what LLMs produce, not their training.
There definitely needs to be something like a secondary pass added which checks output against a vectordb of the training set to avoid too close derivative IP outputs (and ideally checks for jailbreaking or inappropriate content at the same time).
Any production services would need to subscribe to a service like that to stave off litigation on infringement, much like how the oft repeated complaints regarding YouTube copyright infringement eventually dissipated as content tagging was added (and shifted to complaints over too broad application of it).
A generative AI model having read the NYT but producing new original news articles in the style of a newspaper is a very weird argument for infringement.
A human driven service or an automated one that takes current NYT articles and summarizes or reworks them, publishing itself and cutting them out of the ad revenue is more problematic (but also widespread already and generally considered protected).
Services which exactly duplicate their articles would be more clearly infringement, but there's no evidence that's even a fraction of what ChatGPT is doing.
Criminalizing training would set back whatever county did so significantly in global competition for a critical new economic (and defense) trend, and would ultimately only be a minor stop gap for copyright holders as you'd simply see a market for secondhand generated content from foreign models trained on copyrighted data but then producing content that was itself not copyrightable but could be used to train domestic models.
There's a headline out today about several ex-Google Brain engineers, including a co-author of “Attention Is All You Need”, setting up shop in Tokyo. [1] That's not a coincidence.
> Amid rising questions about the fairness and legality of using publicly available information to train AI models, Japan affirmed that machine learning engineers can use any data they find.
> What’s new: A Japanese official clarified that the country’s law lets AI developers train models on works that are protected by copyright.
> How it works: In testimony before Japan’s House of Representatives, cabinet minister Keiko Nagaoka explained that the law allows machine learning developers to use copyrighted works whether or not the trained model would be used commercially and regardless of its intended purpose. [2]
IANAL so don't know what the implications of this are when it comes to cross-border copyright enforcement. It's hard to imagine Japan rolling back this type of legal safe harbor. It's a boon for attracting AI startups from elsewhere and giving the local tech industry a competitive boost.
What's to stop other venues looking to grow their tech industry to do something similar? And if they do, would it create a race to the bottom type of dynamic at the expense of copyright holders?
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-08-17/ex-google...
[2] https://www.deeplearning.ai/the-batch/japan-ai-data-laws-exp...
So now you’ve divided the world into those who use the best tech, and those who are not allowed. And that is what openAI wants, they’re betting courts are going to rule that however tainted the source, that we can’t put lightning back into the bottle.
It's extremely easy to get the latest generation of AIs to produce outputs that in many fields sans-AI would be trivially considered as IP infringement.
While there are many interesting reasonable legal & technical arguments that it's not, the result completely undermines copyright protections regardless. If that's accepted at scale, copyright in practice will change completely. In effect, the choices are "block this, or entirely destroy copyright protections in many industries". You can't allow this without eventually allowing everybody to simulate their own NY Times reporters, produce their own Marvel movies, and create their own Taylor Swift albums.
If you do allow that, the many many affected industries have catastrophic problems.
Problematic though copyright laws are, I see no world where all those protections go away any time soon, and so if the courts don't agree to protect copyright already in this scenario, then it will eventually be legislated to make that happen. AI consuming copyrighted data and producing an output has to be considered a derivative work (or indeed, the model itself will be considered a derivative work) or IP protections are effectively broken.
There's a grace period now while we work our way there, but the politics is pretty clear and with no plausible path to "let's drop copyright completely" ASAP, I just don't see any other result in the medium term. Doesn't mean the end of generative AI by any means, just a slowdown as we move to a world where you need to negotiate rights and buy data to feed it first, instead of scraping everybody else's for free.