News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by malcolmgreaves on Thursday August 17, 2023 @09:52AM (#37161587)
> AI consuming copyrighted data and producing an output has to be considered a derivative work (or indeed, the model itself will be considered a derivative work) or IP protections are effectively broken.

It’s not derivative work though. First, a human didn’t create it, so copyright protections don’t exist on its output. Machines don’t enjoy copyright protections, people do.

It’s mechanically copying and reproducing part of its input data set. Making a tool that regurgitates others’ copyrighted IP is going to been seen as aiding mass copyright violations. Exactly like how Napster got sued: they’re holding a bunch of material they shouldn’t be. The only new twist to this case is the data is encoded in a transformer’s weights. This should be correctly seen as the same as having encrypted copyrighted data using a lossy algorithm.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by tticvs on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:30AM (#37162207)
> First, a human didn’t create it, so copyright protections don’t exist on its output. Machines don’t enjoy copyright protections, people do.

This is not correct. AI models are tools that humans use.

This is like saying "it was typed on a computer therefore it doesn't enjoy copyright protections"

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by 8note on Thursday August 17, 2023 @03:11PM (#37166528)
This has a ruling, see https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2023/05/04/us-copyright-offi...

When you're using ai models to generate the art, it's not considered human enough. If you then make a bunch of modifications to it, sure, but giving the initial prompt is currently insufficient

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by tticvs on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:42AM (#37186485)
> The Copyright Office granted copyright to the book as a whole but not to the individual images in the book

Interesting and makes sense. I guess the best comparison I can think of is a random number generated with Math.random() is not copyrightable. But including that random number is a program is copyrightable.

I'd say that a corollary to this is that if the images/words generated by the machine are not copyrightable then they cannot also be _copyright violations_

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by brrrrrm on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:25AM (#37162116)
I think attempts to tease out this distinction is going to make these laws unwieldy to use in practice
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by dilap on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:09AM (#37161838)
Seems unfair as we converge on AGI. If I memorize the lyrics to a song, is that a copyright violation? The lyrics are encoded in the arrangement of my neurons, after all.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by endisneigh on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:24AM (#37162104)
I don't know why people use these analogies. No person can memorize terabytes worth of lyrics.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by arthurcolle on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:48AM (#37162539)
What if someone could? What if rainman could
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by justinclift on Thursday August 17, 2023 @03:19PM (#37166624)
What if rainman could fly too? I guess rainman wouldn't need an airport for short haul trips.

So, "good on rainman".

Now, for the rest of us...

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by dilap on Thursday August 17, 2023 @03:57PM (#37167114)
Does that invalidate the analogy?

The point I'm trying to make is if you rule these behaviors illegal, then you're necessarily making intelligent AI illegal, because humans are capable of the same behaviors.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by endisneigh on Thursday August 17, 2023 @05:20PM (#37168260)
Plagiarism is already a copyright violation so I’m not sure what your point is, and what you’re alluding to is literally what the post is about…
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by paulmd on Thursday August 17, 2023 @11:12PM (#37171044)
Plagiarism is not a copyright violation, it’s a violation of the social rules of private (academic) institutions and imposed by those institutions upon their members.

If plagiarism was a copyright violation then citing the source wouldn’t make the copyright violation go away. Putting the artists name in the title of the YouTube doesn’t make it not a copyright violation.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by hnaccount141 on Thursday August 17, 2023 @11:49AM (#37163536)
That's not what GP is saying. The (potentially) copyright infringing part is the reproduction of copyrighted material, not the encoding itself. In the same way that learning the lyrics to a song isn't copyright infringement, but performing that song live without permission would be.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by justinclift on Thursday August 17, 2023 @03:17PM (#37166604)
Perhaps the difference is that you're a human doing it, and the other isn't?