News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by unsignedint on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @02:50PM (#37151832)
Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that TikTok is banned on government-owned devices?

The nuance matters; there's a significant difference between banning the app on government devices and extending that ban to personal devices owned by employees. The headline suggests a more extensive ban, but it's specifically about government-owned devices.

Furthermore, I'm puzzled as to why TikTok would be on government-issued devices in the first place. Shouldn't a standard MDM block non-essential apps by default? Why would they need TikTok on work devices, aside from perhaps a PR representative with an official presence there?

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by madrox on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @03:39PM (#37152524)
The industry has evolved toward blacklisting over whitelisting on devices. It reduces IT burden significantly should problems arise, and you should index toward trusting people to do the right thing.

Overall, this approach is better. When I started in engineering back in 2000, it was still a debate as to whether developers should have admin on their own machine.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by throwaway3618 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:18PM (#37153127)
Expect this to debate to come back with the growth of cloud-based IDEs
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by geraldwhen on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:05PM (#37154507)
Oh it’s still a debate. IT would have it so you can’t install brew if they had their way.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by NegativeK on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:23PM (#37154679)
We in cybersecurity know that you need to have brew/pip/npm/whatever installed and you need admin access, but it still absolutely _horrifies_ us.

Treating a dev box as anything other than a permanently compromised piece of hardware is a recipe for disaster, and that applies to our machines where we have to run those tools.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by devnullbrain on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:17PM (#37155150)
For us, it feels like our development is a loathed distraction from your quest to implement the platonic ideal of a secure machine, free from any indulgences like networking, external drives, and a fan given the chance to wind-down between the anti-virus stomping on the CPU.

I particularly like joining a new company and being expected to write and memorise several distinct, secure passwords before having the computing and network freedom to use a password manager. Having to tell my new manager I forgot my password is a riot.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by NegativeK on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:47PM (#37155386)
Look, I'll make a compromise with you.

I'll give you no AV/EDR/XDR/Mountain DewDR that'll use up your CPU if you'll grant me no external I/O ports at all on your computer. In fact, I'll throw you a bone -- no input devices on a fresh install and you can have all the output devices you want. And no input means no need to remember passwords!

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by martin_a on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:04PM (#37155044)
You wanna hear some horror stories from the field?

I need to do development regularly for our workflow systems. That includes a NodeJS based process, so npm has to work, I backup code to gitlab, need to use Postman/Insomnia to test APIs, whatever.

I don't have admin rights on my windows machine, because that's obviously unsafe. All the software on my machines is outdated, as I need to open a ticket for each and every update of VS Code and whatever I'm using and answering those tickets can take some time. Also I feel dumb doing that.

After "securing" the systems even more, IT changed the proxy server. npm didn't work from one day to another. They had to debug it for a week and finally gave up and just whitelisted it and whatnot. Will probably only survive until the next update.

gitlab doesn't work anymore, as basic auth is not supported by the proxy server anymore. I don't have the time (nor the rights - ha!) to fiddle around with that all day to get it working, so there's no versioning happening and "backups" or collaboration are based on local file systems or sending mails with the code attached, too.

My local environment of our workflow server can't connect to the app store to update the integrated apps. Something with the proxy, I don't know. So I'm developing against outdated versions of everything...

Want to connect to external APIs? Need to create a ticket so something besides Outlook and the browsers can connect to the outside world. Sometimes it doesn't work, so... you guessed it... make a firewall/proxy exception. Just takes a day or two.

Also updates in core infrastructure like proxy and firewall are not communicated. So you come into the office monday morning and everything is burning and nothing works anymore. "Yeah, we changed the proxy on Saturday..." Fuck it.

Final thing: One of my biggest projects is to provide a public API to create an easier onboarding experience and one standardized way to place orders with us... IT wanted to do it with their software partner, no other ways possible. We already had something ready we could have bought, deployed and customized in 3 weeks time. Now it's half a year later and the test version is ready. Endpoint URL looks like hell and _every single user_ needs to have his IP whitelisted to connect to the API. Even for the testing endpoints. For security reasons obviously. I'm just done with it.

edit: Yeah, slightly off-topic but had to vent somewhere. Thanks for your patience.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by madrox on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:11PM (#37155104)
If this isn't a government or a bank then run like hell because that company is ripe for being disrupted.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by martin_a on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:55PM (#37155455)
Nah, it's just that our company is part of a larger group (2k+ employees in Europe), so the IT tends to focus on the other companies more. Also my whole e-commerce stuff is very unique to us which reduces reusability for anything they set up for me. From there on it's just a short way to "this will only help him, that will help dozens of people" and your projects get pushed another quarter...

To be fair: Most of the people don't really need much more than SAP, Excel and Word and that's... "uncomplicated" to run with some proxy and firewall config etc.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by madrox on Thursday August 17, 2023 @07:43PM (#37169803)
I don't think anything you said alters my point, but I wish you luck. That's an awful environment.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by 1lint on Thursday August 17, 2023 @01:59AM (#37157796)
I recall someone in a similar situation who was able to convince IT to whitelist a cloud VM for testing website deployments. In addition to the website, this VM also hosted a wireguard server running on ports that happen to be commonly used for databases.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by jahsome on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @03:37PM (#37152502)
For precisely the reasons you listed, this entire article, but especially the headline, are safely labeled click bait.

Everything about it is technically accurate but it's carefully designed to be misleading so passersby think "that can't be right" and click to seek more, or worse, become furious and click to figure out who is responsible.

There's also the knock on effect of someone seeing the headline in one of their various feeds, and forming an opinion one way or another, without having clicked at all.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by asu_thomas on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:16PM (#37154616)
"Clicks" are not the purpose. Advertising is. It's ad-bait.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by xeromal on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:22PM (#37154668)
Click-bait is the common term though so it's stuck around.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by batch12 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:44PM (#37154874)
The title is the bait to get you to click through to the article. Without the click, there are no ads. So clickbait seems apt.

Edit: reworded for clarity

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by karaterobot on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:37PM (#37155314)
Probably clickbait, but increasingly I wonder whether things like this can be chalked up to the fact that most online publications are pretty much amateur hours these days. They might have just genuinely not thought about the difference, or picked up on it. Saying it's clickbait implies a level of sophistication I'm no longer sure most newsrooms possess. If it were only that the headlines were misleading, I'd say it was an irresponsible editorial policy, but you see so many basic mistakes in the copy as well that, at the very least, it would have to be a combination of bad ethics and incompetence.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by jahsome on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:18PM (#37155612)
Most of the time I'd agree with you. But this is the Engadget. They're just too successful/savvy and established for this particular instance not to be deliberate.

There is a lot of truth in much of what you said, but headlines specifically aren't really a product of the newsgathering process. They're kind of a microcosm of journalism and treated completely differently than the rest of the article for a variety of reasons, historical and modern.

More to the point, in the admittedly small number of newsrooms I've been in, the headlines were hand crafted by fairly senior editors.

In any case, the truth is probably somewhere between disingenuous and negligent, but the outcome is the same: more traffic.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by Arrath on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:02PM (#37152898)
> Furthermore, I'm puzzled as to why TikTok would be on government-issued devices in the first place. Shouldn't a standard MDM block non-essential apps by default?

This has been my question every time one of these articles about another entity banning TikTok comes up. My locked down corpo-phone only whitelists like a dozen apps for me to choose to install, largely online banking apps for the big guys, not a single social media style app.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by alexjplant on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:09PM (#37152997)
> Furthermore, I'm puzzled as to why TikTok would be on government-issued devices in the first place. Shouldn't a standard MDM block non-essential apps by default? Why would they need TikTok on work devices, aside from perhaps a PR representative with an official presence there?

Government-owned != government-administered. I'd imagine that in many cases petty cash or OpEx allocated on a program/office/business unit basis is spent indiscriminately at the end of the fiscal year to avoid losing it in the next one. Since the equipment is purchased with a credit card and goes through Accounting (who probably doesn't have the wherewithal or care to tell the IT department about the iPad line item on that Best Buy receipt) it isn't CapEx and therefore escapes the IT department's line-of sight. These devices probably then get used as an end-run around draconian IT restrictions at work and/or as de-facto personal devices for the employee and their family (the latter of which is probably justified by the employee's belief that this is a "perk" that compensates for their low compensation or reward for some perceived moral good that arises from their work).

I'm speaking completely hypothetically, of course. I bought a refurbished iPad with my own money last year for use exclusively at band practice.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by adolph on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:54PM (#37153678)
MDM might be of two tiers, where those distributed by IT are full MDM and those under a "bring your own" policy have more limited access (i.e. email/calendar/contacts only). For example the iPhone issued to me as a "pager" doesn't even have the camera app.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by dzhiurgis on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @05:20PM (#37154021)
> Why would they need TikTok on work devices

Because it's an information source..? Just about every other media app copied the format, but they won't be able to copy content.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by theultdev on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @05:33PM (#37154158)
there's no government employee that needs information from TikTok to do their job
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by Zak on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @05:54PM (#37154398)
Someone who's in a communications or social media position likely does, and they should have a dedicated device purely for that function.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by DrThunder on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:33PM (#37154780)
They don't. There was a time when government eschewed social media entirely even though it was available. They're not private businesses and I see no reason for them to be using social media in any official capacity. There are plenty of ways to communicate with your voter base that doesn't involve Twitter battles or ridiculous Facebook propaganda posts.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by Dan_Sylveste on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:13PM (#37155934)
Also government usage of social media aids the flow of misinformation, by blending info from trusted providers (the govt, in theory, lol) with info from untrusted providers.

There's a reason the .gov domain exists.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by whycome on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:52PM (#37156197)
That’s like saying they don’t need ears. It’s a place to see what people are talking about. It’s a place to see how people are talking. It’s a place to gauge responses to certain events. It’s increasingly a place to see news happen before it is shared via any other medium. You go where the people are, you don’t tell them where to go and then get upset when they’re not there.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:09PM (#37154547)
It wasn’t. It’s a knee jerk because of the legislative grandstanding on the topic.

Once South Dakota banned it, a gotcha question for a leader is “why do you allow Chinese spies to steal government data?”

It’s stupid and performative, but that’s how it works.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by NegativeK on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:23PM (#37154681)
> Shouldn't a standard MDM block non-essential apps by default?

Yes.

But there are some (big) assumptions here:

* The MDM (or EDR for desktops) is well managed. * People with admin access aren't circumventing it.

Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by georgeplusplus on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:44PM (#37155762)
A lot of government workers use their issued phones as their full time phone for personal use and they do not lock down those phones to the extent you suggest. I can’t speak for New York city government specifically but the phones work ecosystem is locked behind an app similar to a Microsoft 365 login
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by hgsgm on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:19PM (#37155975)
The common sense interpretation is that the rule applies to work devices.
Re:New York City bans TikTok for government employees by ecf on Thursday August 17, 2023 @08:29AM (#37160553)
You can’t expect journalists to not make up clickbait headlines. This is 2023, and we’ve seen what they did with LK-99.

Perhaps a controversial opinion but I can’t wait for an LLM that directly feeds off of the source: like AP news, or Arvix, and automatically provides an RSS feed of non-clickbait headlines with substantive articles if I decide it’s worth reading. I cannot wait to get this profession out of my life, and I will happily pay to make it happen.