There's a whole global economy out there.
Of course yes, but the article is about the American stock market. Even if it weren't, which other economies or stock markets do you recommend one invests in? I have in the past invested in Emerging and Euro markets, but they disappointment me tremendously.
It is also worth noting that American companies account for 25% of global GDP, which means investing in the American stock market (say the S&P 500) is an easy way to get broad exposure.
Note: I'm not saying the American stock market is the pinnacle of wealth creation, just that it has been the more obvious place to put one's money (if you have access to it).
All of them. You can use something like VWRA.
The idea is not so much to increase your absolute returns, but to diversify to decrease variance. (You could then load up on leverage to get back to the same risk levels as before, but with higher returns.)
> It is also worth noting that American companies account for 25% of global GDP, which means investing in the American stock market (say the S&P 500) is an easy way to get broad exposure.
In reverse, American companies also make up about 50% of global stock market capitalisation. So even investing in a global index fund like VWRA still gives you quite a big exposure to the US.
https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2023/04/13/a...
If they are not priced in, please feel to free to take up the appropriate short positions:
That will both turn a profit for you, and contribute to efficient prices for the rest of us.
On a domestic level, that's why you buy the S&P500, not YOLO everything on Tesla. Even if there's no other stock that 'you are more excited about than [Tesla]'.
There will be some other winners out there for sure, but how do you pick 'em? And even if you fully believe America has peaked and is now in structural decline, where do you place your long-term bets? The markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent, as the saying goes.
But you (most likely) don't have that restriction. Just buy a global index fund and benefit from diversification. No need to try to figure out which stock market (if any) is best.
> The Chinese economy has been strong but generally that has not reflected in the major indexes (Shanghai Composite, Hang Seng) and they whipsaw a lot.
That insight goes in the other direction as well: just because some country's eg demographics might be bad, doesn't mean her stock market is necessarily a bad bet. The demographic challenges might already be priced in.
You don't. You buy a global index fund.
> And even if you fully believe America has peaked and is now in structural decline, where do you place your long-term bets?
I have no definite opinions on the subject. I assume everything some armchair investor like me (or probably you) knows, is already priced in three times over.
I suspect most folks simply don’t know how to buy different kind of bonds and resort to buying bond funds or ETFs etc.
For the record, I don't think I claimed there is no alternative.
While bond yield might be higher right this instant (or for the last 6 months, say), does not automatically mean your risk-adjusted return over 20 years is likely to be higher (historically shares have outpaced bonds by a fair margin).
Which makes me wonder where you are putting your money and consequently whether:
(a) you would advise putting one's investment money into bonds
and
(b) at what point would you advise to switch
and
(c) do you think there's something that would be even higher yield than either
Excuse me, what bonds are returning that?
https://cbonds.com/bonds/100441/
Current META bonds yield ~5.8%
Barclays bond at ~10%
https://www.bondsupermart.com/bsm/bond-factsheet/US06738EBX2...
a return of 8-9% on broad market index like SPX in a year when the market made 20% profit tells me you're very risk averse.
Are Barclays bonds available for purchase via a consumer brokerage account?
Fwiw I am not saying to go and buy Barclays bonds, but merely exposing the fact that a market far larger than the stock market exists.
Edit: one thing worth pointing out is that there are also municipal bonds which are tax free if you live in the jurisdiction of the issuer.
https://www.municipalbonds.com/bonds/issue/79771PU86/
Here’s an example of the SF muni bond at 8.4% coupon currently yielding ~6%
[1] https://www.fitchratings.com/entity/the-coca-cola-company-80...
Of course if there is a recession, the stock market tanks and most importantly the Fed starts cutting rates you might do quite well (assuming you’re willing to sell those bonds afterwards).
I know, that should be illegal, but when does that ever stop them.
Looking at the S&P 500[1] over the past year relative to today's close:
Aug 15, 2023 Close = $4,437.86
Aug 15, 2022 Close = $4,297.14
Period Return = +3.3%
...and using the latest CPI-U data[2] over roughly the same period: Jul 2023 Index = 305.691
Jul 2022 Index = 296.276
Period Inflation = +3.2%
...I get a real return of +0.1%.Same exercise looking at Vanguard VTI ETF[3]:
Aug 15, 2023 Close = $220.37
Aug 15, 2022 Close = $215.78
Period Return = +2.1%
...I get a real return of -1.1%.[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SP500
[2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCNS
[3] https://advisors.vanguard.com/investments/products/vti/vangu...
Also it varies a lot by sector, consumer staples for instance have been doing quite well over the last year.
If you have double digits inflation and can’t/don’t want to buy foreign currency the stock market is probably the best place to be. Just look at Turkey:
Have you ever actually used treasury direct to buy bonds? I cannot fault anyone for buying an ETF over using that horrible website.
I only ever used it once.
I think that's the wrong question, and a loaded one at that. It is probably more objective to think about government's role in providing a stable foundation for the private sector to produce wealth. There are countless examples of that, such as a reliable and just regulatory framework within which to operate, negotating treaties for international trade, creating infrastructure that lead to incredible wealth creation (think the internet), to name just a tiny few.
But the idea that a government first forms and then bestows upon us the gift of civilization would be incorrect. I suppose you're being flippant since you didn't bother to justify that comment.
This is because beyond a certain amount of complexity (e.g. on the path to civilization), you better have a government what orchestrates favorable outcomes.
One way to frame it might be a chicken/egg problem, as you say, but that just begs the question whether one can meaningfully exist without the other?
To give a related example: war often leads to innovation. In our current universe, the second world war lead to digital computers.
However, IBM (and others) were already hard at work improving their computing devices and would have landed at electronic, digital computers sooner or later, too. Without spending something like ~50% of world GDP nor killings tens of millions of people.
For another really egregious example: have a look at manned space exploration. Specifically the International Space Station. Google said its total costs were about 150 billion USD. Compare '20 Breakthroughs from 20 Years of Science aboard the International Space Station' https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/news/iss...
That least is pretty meagre. They even have to cite spending money by itself as a 'breakthrough'. Almost all of their 'breakthroughs' could have been done for cheaper with unmanned space flight (and most of them are useless and irrelevant anyway.)
They could have left those 150 billion USD with the taxpayer, and private industry would have surely used them better.
(I think that (most of) space exploration should be left completely to the private sector, not just the execution, but also the financing.
Even if you think that the government should be involved in the sciences, manned space flight is pretty much a more expensive version of unmanned space flight.
It's useful as entertainment only, so far. Eg the moon landing was great entertainment, better than a Marvel movie. But also more expensive. I don't think the government should be involved in providing entertainment.
But in any case, after the moon landing, the amount of inspiration coming out of manned space flight has dropped dramatically.)
If you’re fine with there being no space exploration whatsoever. Which is a reasonable view, it’s very expensive and highly unprofitable.
Why would a (rational) private corporation ever send a rover to mars or a drone to titan? It would be an absurd thing to do..
If there's enough will in the population to vote for spending tax payer money on space exploration, surely there's enough willingness to crowdfund the whole thing?
And if people only want space exploration if they can vote other people's money to finance it, but don't want to put their own money where their mouth is, I'm not sure that would be a ringing endorsement?
> If you’re fine with there being no space exploration whatsoever. Which is a reasonable view, it’s very expensive and highly unprofitable.
I like space exploration, but I wouldn't want to force other people to pay for my aberrant preferences.
Manned space exploration would probably not have been (much of) a thing. At least not until much later when the technology has improved.
Unmanned space exploration would probably still have happened to some degree. SpaceX has a lot of private customers.
(And I'm much less against governments financing unmanned space exploration than against them financing manned space exploration. That's just such a money sink.)
I don't know, roads?
You people would rather die than commit heresy against the Church of Free Market.
See also https://www.accessmagazine.org/spring-1993/private-toll-road...
Financing roads from tolls is fairly straightforward.
If one is optimistic about the private sector driving wealth creation (rather than the government), then one's view is likely that shares will still be higher-yielding on a risk-adjusted basis. Of course, other factors like time horizon and one's personal risk appetite also matter.
If, however, one is not bullish on the long-term wealth creation of American companies (and by extensions the stock market), then the question becomes where would you rather put your money? Personally, I have a hard time seeing better alternatives for the average individual.