News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by robbywashere_ on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:35AM (#37131541)
Since chatgpt 'massive explosion on the scene' I have and still do predict; the amount of info-tech jobs will actually GO UP. This has always been the case with any tech innovation. I find it humorous; as pointed out in the article; there is an assumption that once an efficiency is discovered we will just throw our hands up; sit back and relax. This has never happened. The market runs on innovation and competition. New tech means more competitive edge.

If free energy is ever discovered (extremely doubtful), we will not help but boil ourselves from the excess heat it generates.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by Gravityloss on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @05:39AM (#37131908)
Well, what happened to film makers or photo development shops? Photography as activity didn't go away but some components became unnecessary or a middleman could be bypassed with the new digital camera technology. And the same happened with camera makers as people could take good enough photos with their phones.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by sydbarrett74 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:15AM (#37134294)
The above doesn't even touch on the analogue photography renaissance taking place. Polaroid cameras are being snapped up at flea markets all over the place. Zoomers and younger millennials are spellbound by the whole milieu.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by anon84873628 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:46AM (#37135373)
Oh come on, that's not the same at all. Horses didn't go extinct after the automobile either -- they still exist in quaint or niche cases, especially as a hobby for rich people. That doesn't mean their role in society came back along with all the supporting infrastructure. Are you looking to start a saddle making or carriage business?
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by sydbarrett74 on Monday August 21, 2023 @01:14AM (#37205725)
Factories producing LP's have been unmothballed, so if there is sufficient demand for supporting infrastructure, the supply will follow. My point still stands. Come up with a better retort.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by ben_w on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @05:45AM (#37131954)
Demand sometimes goes up, but not always.

More efficient food production has enabled higher demand (both more people and an obesity problem), but rich people with more money to spend on even more food… don't (at least not in ways that matter; literally gold plating a hamburger isn't relevant). And the growth in supply has been much less than the economy as a whole.

Cheap metalworking means steel is everywhere; but there are not that many blacksmiths making full suits of plate armour and longswords.

And the original example of the paradox, coal, is now in decline in many places.

-

So, what do I think will happen with AI and data?

Short term, sure, more demand as it's now possible to process things like getting heart rate and eye dilation from CCTV data, or use WiFi as wall penetrating radar for emergency responders, etc.

Long term (and in computing that just means >5 years because prediction is hard especially about the future), we might have automated everything. At some point, we will either automate everything directly (AGI), or automate the process of automating things "manually" (think narrow AI which makes narrow AI from watching human workers on whatever task for 6 months).

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by lordnacho on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:09AM (#37132081)
I suppose the difference is that coal, or energy, is an input into every process conceivable. Any kind of transport, transformation, or information about anything requires an energy source, and coal at the time was ideal. It even displaces food because you'd rather feed coal to a machine than food to a laborer.

You get a virtuous circle from coal cheapening everything, coal demand increases, so it becomes worthwhile to improve coal tech/infra, and that makes coal cheaper again.

Food itself is limited by declining returns. Your second steak isn't as good as the first, and at some point you stop even though you can afford it. Steel had a huge explosion but also ultimately found its limits.

So what about AI? Well for the moment it seems limitless. There's a ridiculous number of things we can image we'd do if AI became cheap. In that way you might think it will go the way of coal.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by bsenftner on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:08AM (#37132953)
And as "we" attempt large scale automation, attempting to "automate our world", the devilish details and fractal complexity of a dynamic human society will be realized. Automation is an attempt to "freeze a process" and then accelerate it's handling, efficiencies, and outputs through machines - but is that even possible at city scale, not to contemplate larger scales yet, with a dynamic competitive human society inside? Will human society be future identified by the "version of automation" that ran at that time? Will future human society be constrained by the the designers of the automation in place, requiring violent overthrows to establish a newer automation?

These speculations and similar strike me as infantile questions. I think as we approach our capabilities granted by AI, we will "see" the complexity of human civilization, in truth, for the first time. AI is a new set of eyes, data analysis is our vision, and as a civilization we've only been the three blind men examining an elephant. It's time to see what we are, and maybe, just maybe, mature enough to manage our own civilization without all our infantile infighting.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by pixl97 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:52AM (#37134709)
>Automation is an attempt to "freeze a process"

Law is not significantly different in this case, though I would say its impacts are even more sweeping than any automation would be. No competition in law unless you're comparing different countries.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by quickthrower2 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:13AM (#37132998)
The old sigmoid looks like exp problem
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by rsynnott on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:18AM (#37133047)
> At some point, we will either automate everything directly (AGI), or automate the process of automating things "manually" (think narrow AI which makes narrow AI from watching human workers on whatever task for 6 months).

Your second thing sounds suspiciously like just an extremely clunky AGI. Both would, I think, require significant technical breakthroughs which are not currently in evidence and may never happen.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by ben_w on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:16AM (#37133623)
> Your second thing sounds suspiciously like just an extremely clunky AGI. Both would, I think, require significant technical breakthroughs which are not currently in evidence and may never happen.

Clunky, yes.

Sufficiently clunky that I think it's already achievable by throwing money at workplace surveillance and passing the observations to a sufficiently expensive computer doing exactly the same things as current AI.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by 3cats-in-a-coat on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:31AM (#37132223)
This has never happened? Of course it has happened. There used to be buildings full of telephone switchers, did those jobs come back? We replaced horses with cars, the horses also never came back, and now we're the horses being replaced. I'm frankly somewhat bored trying to even recall every single example from history at this point, every time this myth about how "it always turns out fine" comes up. Survivor bias is a b**ch. "I wake up every day alive, therefore I'll live forever". Makes as much sense.

Maybe in 50 years some electronic brain LLM human-like androids will be posting here and saying "See, it worked out, sure, organics no longer exist, but we're humans as well, just more modern humans. Tech demand goes up every time. Lots of jobs!"

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by ace32229 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:09AM (#37132462)
There are more people working in telecomms now than there were when we had buildings full of switchers. _That_ is the point being made. Individual roles may go by the wayside but technological innovations result in industry-wide growth.

Also, to state the obvious, humans aren't horses.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by 3cats-in-a-coat on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:31AM (#37132621)
In the context of AI attacking the core competence of a human being: natural language communication, associative and rational thought, decision making, design, engineering, art... yes we're horses much like cars attacked the core competency of a horse, and therefore the market for horses collapsed.

The horses never recovered. We kept recovering as we kept moving into higher and higher level intellectual work, or natural language work and customer interaction (like sales teams, service reps, store clerks, tech support, call centers). All this is directly replaced by AI now. Low end and high end.

We have nowhere to run anymore. The idea we'll all be given god-like AI to wield insane leverage, simply because we're humans, is laughable. Think of the intellectual level of an average human. Think what the average voter is like in your country. Now, as Carlin joked, realize half of them are worse than that. Heck even think of our elite, our politicians, think of Trump, think of our top businessmen like Elon Musk. Most humans barely have the discipline to do the jobs they're doing now, where they can do a lot less damage than if being chimp-with-a-machine-gunned by given an army of AIs and robots to control.

We're being obsoleted. And the faster we are the better as we're a danger to ourselves if we actually decide to rule over AI, and we'll be played hard by it (no, AI doesn't have to "want" anything, but drugs also don't want anything and trick people into overdose and death).

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by joshuahedlund on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:07AM (#37132946)
> All this is directly replaced by AI now.

ChatGTP came out nine months ago and the US has added two million jobs in that time.

https://www.deptofnumbers.com/employment/us/

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by 3cats-in-a-coat on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:24AM (#37133093)
In the 70s one family had one working member supporting the whole family, currently it's becoming increasingly common for one person to hold multiple jobs and their spouse too. Multiple states are voting back child labor, literally, so add those jobs too, to the count. Working children. The job count is a BS metric at this point and doesn't reflect the quality of the jobs, or the quality of life. It means nothing.

Also "9 months" is kinda ridiculous to expect to see the long-term effects of AI. AI may be evolving fast, and it is, but business, laws, healthcare, regulatory agencies and so on are held back by gigantic inertia and some real safety cocnerns. It is still humans who have to integrate AI in their human processes, so the first few iterations will be slow and cautious to occur (after that... eventually AIs will run systems made by AIs so change will accelerate). For example, a startup tried to offer an "AI lawyer app" for traffic tickets, and lawyers sued the startup. Hollywood is starting to use AI as well, and writers and actors went to strike.

Obviously things like that will hold AI back for a while. But not forever. AI is inevitable.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by mcculley on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#37135054)
> In the 70s one family had one working member supporting the whole family

Do you have a citation for this? I googled around and couldn't find a graph for "number of earners per U.S. household by year".

I am wondering if it was the case that most households in the 70s had one earner or if it was mostly middle class or upper middle class households that had this luxury.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by pengaru on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:50AM (#37135425)
Have you heard the phrase "vanishing middle class"?

It was easier to be in the middle class then, for myriad reasons.

In the 60s you'd be given kitchenware just for filling up your tank at a gas station...

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by mcculley on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:06PM (#37135648)
Of course I have heard the phrase. I am asking if anyone has data to back it up.

edit to add: I am not specifically interested in the middle class, which is ill-defined. I am interested in the overall income of households and how that has changed.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by truculent on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @02:41PM (#37137625)
Elizabeth Warren wrote a book in 2003 (The Two-Income Trap) on this topic. I will admit that I haven’t read it, but I assume that has some solid references.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by mcculley on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:13PM (#37138024)
I have also not read the book, so I will not make any assumptions about it.

My understanding is that throughout history, most households had at least two people working/earning (many homes were farms). Then we get some television shows in the 50s-70s that show how well the upper middle class lived. Now in 2023 we have people thinking that everyone in the past lived as well.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by pengaru on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:29PM (#37138950)
> My understanding is that throughout history, most households had at least two people working/earning (many homes were farms). Then we get some television shows in the 50s-70s that show how well the upper middle class lived. Now in 2023 we have people thinking that everyone in the past lived as well.

Prior to womens liberation in the USA, it was a very different scene for the ladies my man. The people who lived through this stuff are still alive, just talk to some old folks about it ffs. You're acting like ubiquitous stay at home mothers are a myth promulgated by television. There was a time when that was the primary form of employment for women. Men were paid well, and they supported their wives and families.

I'm a late Gen-Xer who grew up in a pretty average part of a fly-over midwest state. Even then it wasn't too unusual to meet housewives during the whole dating and meeting parents phase of life. We're not talking high class demographics here.

My parents are Italian immigrants with limited means and even they did the traditional patriarchy with her staying home. Mom only pursued employment once when dad got injured so bad he was laid up for an entire year, and it was a big ass deal. Concrete construction worker, blue collar AF. I'd estimate ~50% of the homes on my childhood block were stay at home moms. It was already trending towards dual income everywhere, but it wasn't always that way at all.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by mcculley on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @05:16PM (#37139374)
I am also a Gen-Xer (born 1972). I am also of course aware that many women in middle class households had no income. I am asking about households in general, especially those below middle class. Obviously, men who were paid well could keep a wife at home. Most men were not paid that well.

Again, if anyone has any data or statistics, I am interested in that, not anecdata from those who were born into the middle or upper middle class.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by tetrep on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:02PM (#37136379)
I don't know for how long this data has been tracked / how to compare it over time, but the census does cover labor force participation (look at the Family Group tables): https://www.census.gov/data/tables/2020/demo/families/cps-20...
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by renewiltord on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:10PM (#37135703)
This is a false story about the '70s. Movies aren't reality.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by add-sub-mul-div on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:55AM (#37133372)
Come on man. Unemployment rate is a trailing indicator. If this technology is to displace jobs at scale it will take a few years at least for that to unfold.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by joshuahedlund on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:56PM (#37138566)
It might. But how many more months of increasing employment do we need to have to disprove the claim "All this is directly replaced by AI now"?
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by somewhereoutth on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:10AM (#37134235)
> natural language communication, associative and rational thought, decision making, design, engineering, art.

Except of course LLMs (and any other AI technology even on the farthest horizon) does exactly none of that.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by AmpsterMan on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:05PM (#37136431)
I think the concern is that LLMs approximate that enough for decision makers to replace jobs. What critics see is a world where consumers and lower skilled workers get shafted in order for... what exactly?

Humans aren't horses, because horses don't participate in the wider economy, but it seems increasingly swaths of people are being laid to pasture, so to speak, effectively becoming horses.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by tarkin2 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:19AM (#37132527)
In the context of the currently defined job market, then jobs certainly will go down, in the same way the job market for switch operators went down.

In the longer term, then there's a fairly good argument more jobs, and specifically more roles in newly defined jobs, will be created.

What happens to those currently employed, and I'm not just talking about 23 year olds fresh out of university, in the current job market is the question.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by visarga on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:26AM (#37132584)
Don't worry, this time the new tech wave has human language interface and can even tutor beginners one-on-one.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by 3cats-in-a-coat on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:41AM (#37132700)
It can tutor them to do what? You do realize, if AI is capable enough to "tutor" someone, it can simply do their job, for 1/1000 the cost.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by visarga on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:21PM (#37138140)
Humans will still have their advantages to AI. We got different "training".
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by rsynnott on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:25AM (#37133100)
I’d read the author’s argument as being, at least narrowly defined for data workers, that this will _not_ happen. Which I think is probably actually generally correct; if data work is cheaper you will do more of it, so, say, a 50% efficiency gain for data workers will not generally mean that you want half the data workers.

This has arguably _already happened_; I’d be reasonably confident that there are more people working with data now than there were 100 years ago when the business was rather more filing-cabinet-oriented, say.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by allturtles on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:54PM (#37137105)
> There are more people working in telecomms now than there were when we had buildings full of switchers.

I don't think that's true. This blogpost [0] says there were 1.3m telephone operators in the U.S. in 1950. This BLS data [1] says that there are about half that many people in the entire telecom industry today.

[0]: https://conversableeconomist.blogspot.com/2020/02/telephone-... [1] https://www.bls.gov/iag/tgs/iag517.htm

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by adammarples on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:15AM (#37132501)
So in your opinion since telephone switches and automobiles were introduced, the telecommunications and transport industries have in fact "sat back and relaxed"? I think the opposite.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by rsynnott on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:21AM (#37133069)
You’re assuming that LLMs make humans _unnecessary_ to a process (in this case data workers), the author is assuming they make humans _more efficient_ but still part of the process. Barring major unforeseen breakthroughs, I think the author is more likely to be correct here than you.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by CuriouslyC on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:13AM (#37133584)
If there's limited demand for a thing and increased efficiency lets half the people fulfill that demand, half the people are going to be out of work. The reduced cost to produce the thing might end up producing more jobs in the economy down the line, or it might not.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:11AM (#37134240)
> There used to be buildings full of telephone switchers, did those jobs come back?

Even if you count telephone operators as “info tech” jobs (usually, they aren’t, but whatever), yes. All those that were lost from the peak of 420,000 around 1970 were all retained and extra added in the explosion of total IT jobs from 870,000 (if you count the phone operators, 450,000 by the usual count) to over 4.6 million today.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by jasfi on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:39AM (#37132266)
AI can automate a lot of things, but not everything. There are also error rates which aren't zero, which can cause more problems than are solved if we assume that these systems don't need human direction and monitoring. So human jobs aren't going anywhere.

We need to learn how to effectively utilize AI for a net positive benefit. This isn't that difficult.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by hoosieree on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:35AM (#37133827)
It's strange to read editorials from the early days of automation - we expected to be Jetsons; instead most of us got 1984 so that a few of us could be Jetsons.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by jbjohns on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:11PM (#37137988)
Yes, I agree, tech innovation always brings more total jobs. But that doesn't mean everyone working now continues working and more are added. Many people will be left behind. It's not that they throw their hands up, sit back and relax. It is that the skills they possess become worthless overnight and the next thing they could learn takes a years long investment, and may not be viable by the time they get there.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by kristianp on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:46PM (#37154900)
> If free energy is ever discovered (extremely doubtful), we will not help but boil ourselves from the excess heat it generates.

Love this evocation. Although you missed a chance to say we'd boil the oceans!