News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by ben_w on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @05:45AM (#37131954)
Demand sometimes goes up, but not always.

More efficient food production has enabled higher demand (both more people and an obesity problem), but rich people with more money to spend on even more food… don't (at least not in ways that matter; literally gold plating a hamburger isn't relevant). And the growth in supply has been much less than the economy as a whole.

Cheap metalworking means steel is everywhere; but there are not that many blacksmiths making full suits of plate armour and longswords.

And the original example of the paradox, coal, is now in decline in many places.

-

So, what do I think will happen with AI and data?

Short term, sure, more demand as it's now possible to process things like getting heart rate and eye dilation from CCTV data, or use WiFi as wall penetrating radar for emergency responders, etc.

Long term (and in computing that just means >5 years because prediction is hard especially about the future), we might have automated everything. At some point, we will either automate everything directly (AGI), or automate the process of automating things "manually" (think narrow AI which makes narrow AI from watching human workers on whatever task for 6 months).

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by lordnacho on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:09AM (#37132081)
I suppose the difference is that coal, or energy, is an input into every process conceivable. Any kind of transport, transformation, or information about anything requires an energy source, and coal at the time was ideal. It even displaces food because you'd rather feed coal to a machine than food to a laborer.

You get a virtuous circle from coal cheapening everything, coal demand increases, so it becomes worthwhile to improve coal tech/infra, and that makes coal cheaper again.

Food itself is limited by declining returns. Your second steak isn't as good as the first, and at some point you stop even though you can afford it. Steel had a huge explosion but also ultimately found its limits.

So what about AI? Well for the moment it seems limitless. There's a ridiculous number of things we can image we'd do if AI became cheap. In that way you might think it will go the way of coal.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by bsenftner on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:08AM (#37132953)
And as "we" attempt large scale automation, attempting to "automate our world", the devilish details and fractal complexity of a dynamic human society will be realized. Automation is an attempt to "freeze a process" and then accelerate it's handling, efficiencies, and outputs through machines - but is that even possible at city scale, not to contemplate larger scales yet, with a dynamic competitive human society inside? Will human society be future identified by the "version of automation" that ran at that time? Will future human society be constrained by the the designers of the automation in place, requiring violent overthrows to establish a newer automation?

These speculations and similar strike me as infantile questions. I think as we approach our capabilities granted by AI, we will "see" the complexity of human civilization, in truth, for the first time. AI is a new set of eyes, data analysis is our vision, and as a civilization we've only been the three blind men examining an elephant. It's time to see what we are, and maybe, just maybe, mature enough to manage our own civilization without all our infantile infighting.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by pixl97 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:52AM (#37134709)
>Automation is an attempt to "freeze a process"

Law is not significantly different in this case, though I would say its impacts are even more sweeping than any automation would be. No competition in law unless you're comparing different countries.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by quickthrower2 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:13AM (#37132998)
The old sigmoid looks like exp problem
Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by rsynnott on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:18AM (#37133047)
> At some point, we will either automate everything directly (AGI), or automate the process of automating things "manually" (think narrow AI which makes narrow AI from watching human workers on whatever task for 6 months).

Your second thing sounds suspiciously like just an extremely clunky AGI. Both would, I think, require significant technical breakthroughs which are not currently in evidence and may never happen.

Re:What coal and Jevons’ paradox tell us about AI and data by ben_w on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:16AM (#37133623)
> Your second thing sounds suspiciously like just an extremely clunky AGI. Both would, I think, require significant technical breakthroughs which are not currently in evidence and may never happen.

Clunky, yes.

Sufficiently clunky that I think it's already achievable by throwing money at workplace surveillance and passing the observations to a sufficiently expensive computer doing exactly the same things as current AI.