News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Carrot Problem by dale_glass on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:05PM (#37101586)
You should be suspicious of anyone outlining their strategy for success.

Because if I was lucky enough to stumble upon some great hack to make lots of money, why would I be telling people about it? Either I get competition, or I might get whatever loophole I was abusing closed.

So either I'm lying, or what I'm saying isn't possible to reproduce, or the usefulness of the technique ran out and now I'm just trying to squeeze a few more dollars by telling the tale, or I'm actually stupid and about to see my business model crash and burn.

Re:The Carrot Problem by TedDoesntTalk on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:45PM (#37101952)
Exception: you’ve exited and have nothing to lose by sharing
Re:The Carrot Problem by kurthr on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:50PM (#37102004)
Beware the, "I'm already a bitcoin billionaire so I'll share my secret to success". Either they're lying about the Lambos, or they suddenly got less greedy. One of those is more likely.
Re:The Carrot Problem by throwaway290 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:00PM (#37102095)
Unless they charge for the advice in which case it would be obvious, maybe they just know that keeping more people buying it is required for it to keep value
Re:The Carrot Problem by a1369209993 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:04PM (#37102689)
Or their actual secret to success is "Buy a bunch of bitcoin when it cost less than a dollar.", and any subsequent success is a artifact of that non-replicable starting point.
Re:The Carrot Problem by ilyt on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:01PM (#37104189)
Or, in rare cases where someone gets to billion dollars and says "okay it is enough": The opportunity is no longer there and world changed enough for advice to be near-useless.
Re:The Carrot Problem by lapcat on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:57PM (#37102065)
> have nothing to lose by sharing

Not necessarily true if "every successful business got there by doing something ugly".

Re:The Carrot Problem by Ozzie_osman on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:46PM (#37101968)
Or the boost to my ego of being admired for being so smart is larger than the boost to my ego of being even richer.
Re:The Carrot Problem by kurthr on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:47PM (#37101978)
In general this is true of influencer type garbage and "get rich" stuff. It's junk food for the fearful/hopeful/greedy mind.

However, there are entire industries that don't exist without a growing capable workforce. It's not like software programming would have been much higher paid, if we could have just kept it a secret longer. You need a certain number of skilled people to fill out all the positions and get large projects done. It's not like it's easy, or doesn't require training, but since it produces value everyone can win, because of the productivity of others.

Another example of this right now is building/contracting work. It's a skill that takes time to develop and you can't just do it from watching a video or reading a book, but it pays well. Right now a lot of older folks got out of the game so there's real demand and wages are high. If that demand doesn't get filled... it will be replaced with more automation. It's a case where, if there aren't enough workers economics will adjust to require fewer workers, perhaps dramatically so.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chrchang523 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:53PM (#37102028)
The possibilities you mention are definitely worth keeping in mind. However, they are not an exhaustive list; there are positive scenarios that are better than "trying to squeeze a few more dollars by telling the tale".

The hard part is recognizing them in the midst of a lot of chaff.

Re:The Carrot Problem by Karellen on Saturday August 12, 2023 @12:58PM (#37102074)
> if I was lucky enough to stumble upon some great hack to make lots of money, why would I be telling people about it?

Because you understand that the number in your bank account isn't the score of some weird game. Having more money than other people doesn't make you a better person.

If you have enough money to reach your goals - pay your rent, buy food, indulge your hobbies - that's good. If 20 other people also have enough money to reach their goals, that's a world with more happiness in it. That's a better world. So why not tell other people how to make money in the same way you did, and help bring that world about?

Re:The Carrot Problem by the_snooze on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:14PM (#37102242)
>So why not tell other people how to make money in the same way you did, and help bring that world about?

I think this does happen quite frequently. It's just that the knowledge gets passed through networks, so the most successful people help those who are socially near them (and probably not too different in terms of success and comfort).

This is the whole "insider knowledge" that the article alludes to.

Re:The Carrot Problem by Consultant32452 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:23PM (#37102329)
This comment is in no way an endorsement of Scott Adams, I generally do not like him. However, he recently posted something on Twitter that has been a brain worm for me.

>"Success is mostly imitation. We study successful people and then try to imitate what worked."

>"Imagine being Black, learning the history of slavery and racism, and being asked to imitate your oppressors to succeed."

And a followup tweet:

>"The most damaging reframe in American history is that using the universal tools for success is “acting white.” Solve that problem and we’ll have better visibility on the systemic racism that is primarily caused by the teachers unions."

Re:The Carrot Problem by jdpigeon on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:32PM (#37102402)
The last tweet is a little confusing. Teacher's unions? Really?
Re:The Carrot Problem by Consultant32452 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:38PM (#37102455)
I used to watch Adams' podcast. It would require a lot of context to fully make sense. Suffice to say he thinks teacher's unions are a big component of the problem here and imo the primary value of his comment here could be conveyed if you remove the tail end of that Tweet which puts it on the teacher's unions.
Re:The Carrot Problem by lostlogin on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:58PM (#37102634)
I’m not sure context helps him with his other outbursts.

“Based on the current way things are going, the best advice I would give to White people is to get the hell away from Black people,” the 65-year-old author exclaimed. “Just get the (expletive) away. Wherever you have to go, just get away. Because there’s no fixing this. This can’t be fixed.”

https://www.mercurynews.com/2023/02/23/dilberts-scott-adams-...

“The reality is that women are treated differently by society for exactly the same reason that children and the mentally handicapped are treated differently.”

https://ew.com/article/2011/03/30/dilbert-scott-adams-femini...

Trump is like the founding fathers and Jesus.

https://www.thedailybeast.com/dilbert-creator-on-how-trump-i...

There is a bit of coverage in the wiki. He writes a good cartoon but he is radioactive in his views.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Adams

Re:The Carrot Problem by Consultant32452 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:05PM (#37102690)
Terrible people are sometimes capable of saying things worth considering, and it's possible to consider one thing he says without endorsing or accepting other things he's said or even his personal context for the words being considered.
Re:The Carrot Problem by zlg_codes on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:36PM (#37102967)
It's difficult to defend a stance like one you're adopting, because of how quick to judge the general public is. They'd never know that someone like Ted Kaczynski actually held a PhD and wrote an interesting essay before committing to his campaign of terror. (Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski)

It's rather strange that people will choose to wholly dismiss a person based on one thing, without realizing that even "evil" people have more facets than a simple bevel.

Ted killed himself in prison a few months ago. What benefit could society have gained if someone had heard him out and took some measures to help the environment? Most people won't ask that question, because they have the intellectual and philosophical depth of a puddle.

One of the most illuminating things in my life has been discovering what the "bad" and "evil" side of humanity actually thought, instead of the version that the authorities or victors give us.

There's also this modern tendency to assume that whatever you read, you become. So superstitious.

Re:The Carrot Problem by weaksauce on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:20PM (#37103889)
> There's also this modern tendency to assume that whatever you read, you become. So superstitious.

Sure... but there's also a wealth of information out there and filtering out people with known abhorrent views is a decent first pass filter. maybe alex jones or some other neo-nazi dimwit has a few good ideas here and there but why would I subject myself to listening to them(and also enriching them in the process) when I could listen to people that aren't generally awful people?

Re:The Carrot Problem by setr on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:06PM (#37104225)
I think shallow views is a much better first-pass filter than abhorrent views; a sufficiently in-depth abhorrent view can and likely will have components worth taking from, even if their final conclusion is absurd (or just overreaching).

An acceptable-but-shallow view and an abhorrent-but-shallow view are equally worthless; effectively as much value an upvote.

Re:The Carrot Problem by ilyt on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:58PM (#37104178)
> Ted killed himself in prison a few months ago. What benefit could society have gained if someone had heard him out and took some measures to help the environment? Most people won't ask that question, because they have the intellectual and philosophical depth of a puddle.

Well it's not all that interesting question coz he wasn't exactly first or last preaching same thing about the environment, so there is a plenty of other people to listen to that do not happen to be crazy.

But in general I agree that the trend of disregarding someone's entire contribution to everything they contributed based on this or that opinion that is currently regarded as "bad". After all, if you dig far enough (especially in time, kids/teenagers do/think some utterly dumb stuff) you won't find an innocent soul alive...

Re:The Carrot Problem by pharmakom on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:11PM (#37104261)
Reading Ordinary Men changed how I feel about good and evil.
Re:The Carrot Problem by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:10PM (#37104252)
The thing to understand about Scott Adams is that if he says something that sounds outrageous, he's probably trolling you. He'll in fact describe how to do this in order to generate publicity, or as a mechanism to expose hypocrisy or bad logic. But when he's in the middle of it he'll commit to the bit.

Basically, someone says X, which is crazy, because if X then logically Y would be true and Y is not only wrong but offensive. So he'll publicly assert Y and get people to argue with him, but the only real way to show that Y is wrong is to admit that X is wrong, which was the point.

And then the people arguing with him don't want to do that. They want to be offended by Y without admitting that X is wrong. So he has a bunch of fun with them because they've foreclosed themselves at the outset from winning the debate on the merits.

Re:The Carrot Problem by lazyasciiart on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:25PM (#37104375)
The thing to understand about this argument is that it is unfalsifiable nonsense. Anything he says that is wrong is him joking, you just can’t tell because he pretends so well! No, dude. He is wrong a lot and like a 5yo, when he realizes he cannot actually defend or explain something he did he falls back on “it was just a joke!”
Re:The Carrot Problem by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:50PM (#37104556)
Of course he's wrong a lot. The point isn't that Y is right, it's that X and Y are both wrong but you can't admit to that if you're a hypocrite.

And the "anything he says that is wrong is him joking" is the idea, because it works both ways. If someone says something which is actually wrong, you can make a convincing argument for why if you're willing to be logically consistent yourself.

But there are also things which are politically offensive yet true, and having a reputation for this kind of trolling is what allows someone to say those things out loud. Because then you make the same claim: "Maybe I'm trolling you, if I am just provide the counterargument."

Which you can't do if the counterargument requires you to admit that X is wrong and you refuse to do that, but you also can't do if there is no counterargument because Y is true.

It doesn't matter whether "is he trolling this time" is falsifiable. What matters is if you can disprove his claim. If you can, go for it. If not, what does that say?

Re:The Carrot Problem by diydsp on Saturday August 12, 2023 @08:22PM (#37105405)
Maybe but "get the hell away from Black people" isn't a "claim"; it's explicit rich white boomer racism.
Re:The Carrot Problem by roenxi on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:08PM (#37106309)
Adams was looking at a poll that said 47% of black people disagreed with the statement "It’s okay to be white.". If that poll was reliable then that would be a profoundly concerning statistic and evidence of some pretty strong racism on the part of the community surveyed.

The level of "rich white boomer racism" (which is a bit racially charged in itself, but sure we can go with that) really hinges on how credible he found the poll. It was Rassmussen and also a pollster stirring up trouble so realistically he should have just dismissed it as a likely lie by not-reporting-the-real-context of the question being asked (I personally suspect dodgy framing). Adams should have picked up on that since it is his area, but the argument would have been reasonable if he was silly enough to believe the poll.

Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:17AM (#37106631)
The African Americans I've known are very in tune to race issues. And the poll question comes off as a racist dog whistle, like an extreme form of "all lives matter". So I wouldn't put a lot of faith the the poll results, certainly not enough to publicly advise avoiding an entire group of people based on their skin color.
Re:The Carrot Problem by dragonwriter on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:32AM (#37106690)
> Adams was looking at a poll that said 47% of black people disagreed with the statement "It’s okay to be white.".

The thing about Black culture in America is that it is a product of very strong selective pressures to be aware of messages that carry meanings beyond what is on the surface, and, well, that one has a history:

https://www.adl.org/resources/blog/4chan-another-trolling-ca...

Re:The Carrot Problem by roenxi on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:11AM (#37106883)
If the black community is going to be persuaded by 4chan that "it is ok to be white" is a racist message that just suggests a mis-step by the leadership in the black community. The longer they tilt at the windmill the more silly they'll look.

If somehow that poll is picking up a real opinion then Adams has a point. That sort of racism has no place in modern society, it is acceptable to have any skin colour. And it is acceptable to assert that any skin colour is ok to have.

Which, coincidentally, is exactly the debate dynamic that Adams was likely trying to set up. The slogan is just too inoffensive and reasonable to complain about. The people trying to get worked up about it are just going to look bad.

Re:The Carrot Problem by dragonwriter on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:37AM (#37110431)
> If the black community is going to be persuaded by 4chan that "it is ok to be white" is a racist message that just suggests a mis-step by the leadership in

If you read the link, you would know that it was white supremacist phrase before the 4chan thing that saw a massive upswing in actual white supremacist use not following the isolated use of the supposed bait effort during and since the 4chan thing.

Whether the trolling effort was ignorant of and accidentally tapping into and energizing the preexisting racist usage or a knowing effort to leverage and provide cover for it is something that we’ll probably never know, but what we know for sure is that it is not the origin.

Re:The Carrot Problem by roenxi on Monday August 14, 2023 @04:44AM (#37118815)
If the white supremacists are advocating agreeable and common sense positions then well done to them. They've successfully made a good point. If they claim that the sky is blue or water is wet they will be on similarly safe ground.

Being a white supremacist doesn't mean they are automatically wrong about everything. In this case reality and slogan have, by happy chance, coincided.

> “The point of IOTBW,” explained one Twitter user, “is to bait shitlibs into showing their ass to normies. The beauty is in the simplicity.”

I think the Twitter user in the article has a more accurate position on this. If the black community were fooled by this into thinking that there is something wrong with the slogan, that is on them. I still don't believe they were, it is more likely that the poll was inaccurate.

Re:The Carrot Problem by AnthonyMouse on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:42AM (#37107275)
> Adams should have picked up on that since it is his area, but the argument would have been reasonable if he was silly enough to believe the poll.

This is still in the same format as the above. His claim is that if 47% of black people disagree with the statement "it's okay to be white" then said white people should stay away from them. That's Y. Whether the poll is accurate isn't even the point -- and purposely choosing a poll with an artificially large number could be part of the troll.

X is the belief "it's not okay to be white." Which presumably doesn't actually have a 47% prevalence, but it's also not zero. What he's implying is that if a large proportion of black people actually believed this, his statement would be a completely plausible response from a significant proportion of white people. Which is a bad outcome. So believing X is bad, and increasing the prevalence of the belief X is bad, because if X then Y.

Re:The Carrot Problem by lazyasciiart on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:16PM (#37117090)
No, it’s not just that he is wrong a lot. It’s that when he is wrong he (and his fans) refuse to actually admit that he is making false claims and poor arguments, and pretends “I was joking!” is some kind of clever escape, and not a sign that nothing he says is worth engaging with. I don’t bother to disprove it when a five year old says “you stink” either, because they also couldn’t care less about the truth and logic of their statement.
Re:The Carrot Problem by the_af on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:40PM (#37106470)
A long time ago I reached the conclusion whoever plays "crazy" or "fool" long and consistently enough is in practice crazy/fool. It makes no difference what the person believes inside their mind, if they always play the fool, they are fools.

Scott Adams has been like this for a long time. Trolling or sincere makes no difference, if he acts like a bigot he is one.

Re:The Carrot Problem by AnthonyMouse on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:00AM (#37107355)
So are all satirists bigots? Is Stephen Colbert? Or is the only difference when someone doesn't want to admit to having been successfully trolled?
Re:The Carrot Problem by the_af on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:26AM (#37108885)
No, professional satire by definition doesn't count. In interviews they often tell you their real opinions or how they construct their character. I guess if they always stayed in character and never gave any interviews you could make a case...

You're begging the question re: trolling. You don't know they are trolls; you merely believe so. In fact, there's no way to tell real opinion from flamebait with the people under discussion. That's the whole point: if they always act like fools, they are fools.

Re:The Carrot Problem by AnthonyMouse on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:20PM (#37111959)
> In interviews they often tell you their real opinions or how they construct their character.

But that's exactly what Adams does.

> In fact, there's no way to tell real opinion from flamebait with the people under discussion.

Sure there is. If it's of the form "there is a valid argument against this, but it's inconvenient for partisans to make that argument" then it's flamebait.

Re:The Carrot Problem by the_af on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:13PM (#37113205)
I don't think that's the case for Scott Adams. You're giving him too much credit.

There's no way to tell the form you claim is flamebait. You assume it is, but you don't know for sure. If it requires too much assuming, it's indistinguishable in practice for the real thing.

An act that is kept up 24x7 is the real thing as far as I'm concerned.

Re:The Carrot Problem by tomcam on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:56PM (#37103135)
1. No evidence at all that teacher unions help students. Test scores have gone down drastically all over the country for the last 30 years or so.

2. The teacher unions are against school vouchers, which almost completely eliminates competition in the districts that need it most. A large majority of black families are in favor of school vouchers.

Re:The Carrot Problem by rodrattt on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:48PM (#37102543)
Just a thing I noticed since I don't know Scott Adams etc. — surely being a slave couldn't be considered a success‽

I'm sure I'm missing the meaning here somehow but to me it's quite obvious we may imitate something successful and not imitate something unsuccessful.

Re:The Carrot Problem by dark_star on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:22PM (#37102830)
The quote is talking about emulating the white oppressors, who oppressed people to gain wealth and power.
Re:The Carrot Problem by barrkel on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:57PM (#37102625)
The implied theory in the paraphrased quotes is that Black people are not successful in part because they have learned a framing where success requires acting like a slave owner, or acting white. That is, behaviors that correlate with success are tainted with being the way (oppressive) white people act.
Re:The Carrot Problem by CMCDragonkai on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:07AM (#37106592)
This obviously can't be true for African Africans. Even including former colonies.
Re:The Carrot Problem by Consultant32452 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:00PM (#37102653)
I think this part clarifies it:

>The most damaging reframe in American history is that using the universal tools for success is “acting white.”

If you are not American it may not be clear. One specific example of a "universal tool for success" being marred in this way is that black kids who are successful academically are sometimes bullied for "acting white." I've intentionally found a left leaning source discussing this phenomenon. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/07/acting-whi...

Re:The Carrot Problem by porkbeer on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:42PM (#37103012)
My darker friends often caught hell from associating with a 'white boy' like me. The racism problem is bad on the other side too and many people discount this, but it may be a bigger problem than the obverse for culture and progress.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chasd00 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:35PM (#37104017)
Didn’t even Obama face some of this in his campaign because he wasn’t “black enough”? I think SNL even had a running gag about it.
Re:The Carrot Problem by jancsika on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:30PM (#37102382)
OP would presume they covered that in their last OR branch:

> or I'm actually stupid and about to see my business model crash and burn

In other words, they wouldn't be able to reach their long term goals because one of the 20 other people are going to eat their lunch. (And all will in fact attempt to monopolize their lunch.)

Re:The Carrot Problem by tomcam on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:54PM (#37103118)
Oops, I didn’t realize you had made this comment, which is better than mine:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37103107

Re:The Carrot Problem by lordnacho on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:09PM (#37102188)
Reminds me of the constant hum around Renaissance Technologies. Everybody brings up that rumour about them using satellite data and other exotic stuff, but there's no way that is the difference between winning and losing.
Re:The Carrot Problem by edgineer on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:45PM (#37102517)
"Success" could include a type of "business model" but other positive-sum games, too.
Re:The Carrot Problem by gnicholas on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:57PM (#37102616)
I'm not sure I'd go this far. Think of the advice that PG gives, which is along the lines of: make something people want, get it in front of those people, and work very hard.

This is very useful advice to someone who has never heard it (though the last one is very obvious), and it doesn't really take away anything from PG to say it loudly. He is especially unlikely to care if people use his advice to get rich, since he is himself already very very rich. But even someone who was not rich wouldn't really care unless there is a good likelihood that he is giving his competitors a leg up by sharing this advice.

And for someone like PG, there's a net benefit to giving this advice because (1) it will lead to more people who are willing to work hard becoming successful (which will lead to useful products/services being available in the world — including to PG), and it helps to build PG's brand.

The thing you do have to worry about is when there's a potential conflict between (1) what they did to become successful and (2) what they want people to think they did to become successful. That's what this article is about. People want you to think they got ripped by lifting a ton — not by using steroids.

Re:The Carrot Problem by somsak2 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:45PM (#37103043)
What a cynical take. For your own sake, I'd recommend looking for more positives in others.
Re:The Carrot Problem by tomcam on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:53PM (#37103107)
Well I did it when I had a very successful SAAS 20 years ago that still exists. I ended up with multiple competitors who stole my business model completely, right down to the micro payment system I devised. I had a fantastic run, became friends with several of my competitors, and eventually sold my business to one of those competitors. I never hid anything about how the business was run. I just delivered on the fundamentals and wasn’t greedy.

I never sold a course or a book or charged for any advice.

The funny thing is, although I mentor people for free they often don’t call after the initial conversation because they think I’m somehow trying to get money out of it.

So I guess you’re right?

Re:The Carrot Problem by blobbers on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:32PM (#37103461)
Loose lips sink ships, right?

Yeah, this is why hedge funds keep secrets, and sell side analysis isn't very trustworthy in the investment world. If their info was so good, they would act on it instead of publishing it.*

* some people act on it, then publish it in order to push prices in their favor.

Re:The Carrot Problem by Scene_Cast2 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:38PM (#37103518)
This is exactly why I don't understand the strategy behind sites like https://www.quiverquant.com/

My optimistic theory is that it might be a form of social activism to enact change, as opposed to a plain carrot problem.

Re:The Carrot Problem by blobbers on Thursday August 17, 2023 @02:15PM (#37165826)
No, they have a premium paid subscription. They're doing it to make money.
Re:The Carrot Problem by winwang on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:28PM (#37103950)
It's even worse in the case of hedge funds (well, arbitrage in general), because any given strategy has a maximum amount of profit it could make before the market loses that specific inefficiency. Or at least, that's the theory.

It's basically like finding a gold mine and telling everyone to come over and take what they want from it.

Re:The Carrot Problem by habitue on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:06PM (#37103768)
> Because if I was lucky enough to stumble upon some great hack to make lots of money, why would I be telling people about it?

People like explaining things to other people. They like sharing knowledge, they like having other people pay attention to and listen to the knowledge they share. I am pretty convinced that it's an evolutionary adaptation that we feel a compulsion to explain and share interesting things we've learned.

Your logic probably overcomes this built-in tendency for sharing things when the alpha is very directly tied to one's success. So, for example, a hedge fund manager isn't sharing their trading strategies.

But if an executive is explaining how OKRs worked for them, or an engineer is saying typescript was a big help, our first instinct shouldn't be to assume it's a psyop. Those things are not the singular competitive advantage of a company, success is the aggregate result of many different things.

Re:The Carrot Problem by nuancebydefault on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:18PM (#37103872)
Another reason that they disclose strategies might be that it makes them feel good about themselves. -- Whoah you have such I pretty girlfriend! How did you accomplish this? -- Well i went to those and those places, worked out at the gym and behaved like a cool guy in this and that way. (he feels good talking about it)

Even if it is true, who says it would work for someone else, maybe the real reason for success in this case is just being pretty or rich.

The problem is not so much carrot stories, the root of the carrot problem is that some people look up to other people's accomplishments and want it too. It is easy then to see/follow/come up with patterns that have nothing to do with it.

Re:The Carrot Problem by ilyt on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:51PM (#37104134)
I think that's only when you actually cheated/lied/used loopholes to get where you are.

I'm not losing my senior engineer job because I tell some soon-to-be junior engineers how to be good at the job. Neither will say an established artist or maker; they already have their brand.

Re:The Carrot Problem by Cpoll on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:43PM (#37104508)
By that token, we should be suspicious of you for telling us how to avoid bad strategies for making money :)
Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:48AM (#37109478)
Indeed, we should. Yet the best way to maintain a successful strategy (which isn't widely known) is to keep it quiet. So either the secret got out and they're trying to hold back the flood by claiming it doesn't work, or honestly have been burned and are hoping to gain some reputational advantage by warning others.
Re:The Carrot Problem by joshspankit on Saturday August 12, 2023 @08:28PM (#37105440)
Some do this to diversify. Not only are they getting the income from the single trick, but now they are getting it from courses, ad revenue, consultancy, and whatever else they can use the leverage on.

IMO that’s a smarter play than having zero income if the trick runs it’s course.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:00PM (#37105614)
If you're a billionaire, it's hard to imagine a book about you making a difference in your fortune. It's also a waste of time for a billionaire to be a consultant. There's no leverage.
Re:The Carrot Problem by joshspankit on Monday August 14, 2023 @03:32PM (#37125717)
Billionaires are basically a different species.

I don’t think anything about them can be used to judge whether a thing is true for everyone else.

Re:The Carrot Problem by samstave on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:23PM (#37106391)
Also, everyone who I have worked with which outlined their success path were never anyone to be trusted as their path will never be 100% yours, and thus, they will always pick theirs over supporting yours...

especially if they work in sales, HR, product, BOFH :-)