Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by xeromal on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:42PM
(#37080782)
I've always felt us removing things like tonsils and appendix without a high barrier was always premature. I remember kids wanting to have their tonsils removed to eat ice cream for a few weeks. lol.
Even if we have legacy parts in out body, I'm fine just letting it fester in my body as long as it's not trying to kill me.
Feels very similar to thinking farming just needs 3 nutrients. Turns out better farming requires a lot more.
I am just a plain old bozo though so I could be talking out me ass
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by maximilianburke on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:55PM
(#37080937)
I think we're getting better about non-surgical interventions when it's not necessary. Appendicitis can, and is, treated with antibiotics, but the timing has to be spot on otherwise it needs to come out. I had to have mine removed because by the time I was seen in the hospital it had already burst. I think the only time that people pre-emptively remove appendixes is when you can't risk the chance of a burst; like if you're the over-winter physician at Amunden Scott South Pole station
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by ReallyAnonymous on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:34PM
(#37081402)
surgeon here:
antibiotic treatment works great as long as there's no peritonitis and/or no appendicolith seen on CT. However, statistics show that 30% of successfully treated patients go on to get appendicitis again within 1 year.
Anyway, I offer my patients a choice. Most choose surgery. Those conscientious enough without insurance usually choose nonoperative management because it's much cheaper.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by robbiep on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:06AM
(#37109659)
You literally imply there is one and describe it in the sibling comment reply.
Interestingly you present the possibility of a falsifiable hypothesis. Unfortunately due to the highly variable accuracy of diagnosis and propensity to treat (source: I was on The path to surgical training and now routinely diagnose appendicitis in my role as an emergency doctor) depending on health system capacity and availability to acute care the existing retrospective data doesn’t provide a satisfying result - what it does suggest is illuminating however; with a suggestion of a decrease in rate of incidence over the second half of the 20th century in industrialised countries, and a suggestion of increase in some developing countries. This would be more in keeping with an improvement in diagnostic capacity in both industrialised (less false positives) and developing (more false negatives) countries.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by hparadiz on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:23AM
(#37085072)
I had chronic strep and had mine removed at the recommendation of my MD Aunt and Uncle who both practice in Germany. I flew in and immediately got sick at their house. The flight must have wrecked havoc on my immune system. I could feel myself getting progressively sicker during the flight but I was completely fine at the start.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by xeromal on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:49PM
(#37080853)
Very applicable to programming too. I'm pretty conservative as a programmer and I've had coworkers want to completely change a segment but you never know why some weird programming was done. There be dragons sometimes.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by jaggederest on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:57PM
(#37081683)
As a software engineer who has sometimes specifically specialized in handling dragons, I always try to leave (sometimes voluminous) comments about why a thing was handled that way when it's not obvious to a surface reading.
Good practice in general but particularly so when you find a heisenbug that must be exterminated.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by hinkley on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:25PM
(#37081285)
I had my tonsils out for what at the time we thought was legitimate reasons, but well after they started phasing out the practice.
I recall when I woke up my throat didn't hurt (possibly due to painkillers), and when they brought ice cream and popsicles to sooth my pain I felt like a fraud. But the experience up to that point was traumatic to put it lightly, so you're damned right I was going to get all of the treats I could wrangle.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by orev on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:50PM
(#37080875)
They did not express any indication that they didn’t understand why ice cream is often recommended, so you don’t need to be explaining it. The point of the comment is that kids don’t understand what’s going on, only hear about the ice cream thing, and then want the same procedure just so they can eat ice cream for a week.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by randomdata on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:01PM
(#37081005)
Except they demonstrated interest in the response. Further, they are not the only person who reads the comments. Others may be interested to know the relationship between ice cream and tonsils.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by sam36 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:53PM
(#37080912)
My grandmother had hers taken out in the 1940's. Now she has a small pocket/hole that food gets stuck in which can cause her to gag and/or sometimes throw up.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by midoridensha on Thursday August 10, 2023 @10:04PM
(#37084252)
There was never a medical reason for those, only religious. American doctors tried to invent a medical reason, but those are the same doctors who told people that smoking is good for you because the tobacco companies paid them to.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by midoridensha on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:56AM
(#37085254)
Sorry, I forgot to mention that; you're absolutely correct, but that's for a tiny number of people who actually have some medical problem where circumcision is a viable remedy. I meant medical reasons for doing it to all male infants as some sort of preventative procedure.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by AuryGlenz on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:20AM
(#37085678)
Pre-puberty here, and as someone that was about 4 years old when my circumcision was done I can absolutely understand how ancient peoples would decide just to do every baby boy on the off chance they’d need it later.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by stephen_g on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:20PM
(#37091214)
True, during the healing process I had the same thought! Would have been rather more convenient to have just had it done as a baby even if I hadn’t needed it!
This covers a paper that, while small in sample size, shows a reduction in age of 6 years. One of the major impacts of the drug cocktail is that it removes much of the fat that accumulates in the thymus as one ages.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by spandrew on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:34PM
(#37081406)
This type article declaring a thymus revelation is published every few years.
We've known the thymus is saving our lives — it's where the t in t-Cells derives from for years. There are very old studies of removing it from older humans and statistically seeing a decline in health. Most doctors will not remove it without a decent cause in older patients (intractable infection, for example). In those cases it's not that removing the thymus was a good approach. It was just the least-bad approach the physician had on hand to help their patient.
Never forget that everything we do, medically, is a stall. I'm glad we have blood pressure pills and better health spans than our grandparents. Eat a healthy diet, run 3 times a week, manage stress and... die anyway. That's the deal we were given as living things.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by xixo on Thursday August 10, 2023 @05:05PM
(#37081784)
I wish I could say my dad's thymus is saving his life, quite the opposite. He was discharged from the ICU/hospital yesterday after he nearly died from a "myasthenic crisis"—an event that most people with Myasthenia Gravis (MG) will experience. From what I understand, his thymus produces antibodies that destroys receptors connecting the nerves and muscles. He can't keep his head up, eyelids up, can't swallow and during the crisis could not breathe.
Interestingly, a small portion of MG patients have an enlarged/tumorous thymus and end up getting it removed, though there aren't necessarily clear benefits. It's also a quite invasive procedure they wouldn't perform on older folks like my dad (he shows no signs of it anyway).
Overall I agree with you though—this article is not saying anything new. As a concerned son who's spent more than his fair share of time trying to understand what's going on here, I wish it did. I also wish there were some treatments for my dad that worked. For now, exercising, eating healthy, lowering stress, and a healthy dose of steroids are currently keeping him with us. If anyone has advice, I'm all ears.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by dan000892 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @07:17PM
(#37082974)
My mother was diagnosed with MG 25 years ago. Her first symptoms were droopy eyelid and double vision. Plasmapheresis helped, Prednisone had nasty side effects (glad to hear that sounds not to be the case for your father), prismatic glasses to un-double her vision kind of helped?
As her symptoms increased—-speech delay, difficulty swallowing, eye misalignment, all stemming from fatigue-induced nerve conduction delays which can culminate in respiratory failure—-myasthenic crisis, they opted for thymectomy (open surgery). She was probably 50 and while the recovery was lengthy, it drastically improved her symptoms and the amount of activity she could do before arose symptoms appeared. No more prism glasses or multi-second speech delays, or weekly plasmapheresis visits. If she spent too much time being active or driving on a sunny day (squinting), she’d feel the ocular fatigue first and know she had to rest or take a prednisone. Now her eyes are failing for other reasons but the thymectomy bought her 25 years and counting.
I’m glad your father survived his crisis. It sounds like you’re doing all of the conservative treatments (which is good; steroid noncompliance is a risk factor for crisis).
There are new medications that directly reduce or deactivate AChR antibodies. Non-invasive video-assisted thoracoscopic thymectomy is more viable today too (and thymectomy has been shown to decrease the frequency and severity of crises even where the thymus was considered normal). Plasmapheresis remains generally effective, if time consuming.
MG sucks. From one son to another, I hope you can get a few more good decades with your parent too.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by Calavar on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:35PM
(#37081413)
This is a total fluff piece. We've known for decades that the thymus is an important part of the immune system. It's not an organ that's been believed to be vestigial, like the appendix.
> For the study, Kooshesh mined data from 1,146 adult patients who had undergone thymus removal, alongside demographically matched control patients who had undergone similar surgeries but kept their thymus
Sure, you can demographically match all you want, but I don't think this is a research question that can be answered with a retrospective analysis. The problem is that you haven't controlled for why surgeons decided to remove the thymus in some cases and not in others. Was the disease more severe in patients who got thymectomies? Was it differences in training between the surgeons? Was it just an arbitrary decision on the part of the surgeons? This is a critical confounder regardless of whether you've matched the demographics. You really need a randomized control study to answer this sort of question.
> Although the risk of autoimmune disease did not differ substantially between the groups in the overall primary cohort (relative risk, 1.1; 95% CI, 0.8 to 1.4), a difference was found when patients with preoperative infection, cancer, or autoimmune disease were excluded from the analysis (12.3% vs. 7.9%; relative risk, 1.5; 95% CI, 1.02 to 2.2)
What? What is this? Was this subgroup a preregistered, or did they just go fishing when their primary hypothesis didn't pan out?
I'd categorize this study as noteworthy, but not groundbreaking the way the press statement is selling it.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by mlyle on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:44PM
(#37081536)
This is a research question you can't answer with a prospective analysis either, because it's not ethical in most cases to randomize whether you're removing a body part.
The best we're going to do is a careful case control study (and research in animal models). And the evidence is enough to imply strongly that we should expend a little more effort to avoid removing the thymus.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by Calavar on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:49PM
(#37081588)
> This is a research question you can't answer with a prospective analysis either, because it's not ethical to randomize whether you're removing a body part.
But that's exactly what we did with the appendix, multiple times [1, 2].
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by mlyle on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:50PM
(#37081612)
I had thought about this and had amended this to "in most cases" before you posted.
If the standard of care is removing the appendix, and you have a strong reason to believe that something less may be superior, you may be able to conduct a randomized trial.
But any other combination of facts is going to be hard for an IRB to swallow.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by anon84873628 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:49PM
(#37081585)
Yes, but some believed this function was most relevant in adolescence, with the importance fading in adulthood. The purpose of the research is to understand the role of the organ in later age.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by joe__f on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:56PM
(#37081670)
I believe that the appendix is now understood to be a store for gut flora so that the microbiome can regrow after an infection or bad episode of diarrhoea etc.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by bookmark1231 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:09PM
(#37082403)
It’s been conjectured by some researchers that maybe this is the case, particularly for infants. But there’s very little evidence for it. As far as I’m aware there have been no studies that are able to statistically distinguish between people with and without an appendix in terms of actual heath outcomes
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by delfinom on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:34PM
(#37082591)
Otoh, I wouldn't say that dismisses the appendix having a potential role. Part of the problem is we barely have a grasp on gut flora and it's full impact on human health, and several studies show that impact can be over years including potentially being one cause of dementia.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by runnerup on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:44PM
(#37082658)
I believe it’s only posited to be useful for isolated small groups where everyone might get the same stomach bug at the same time, and have no other humans around with a healthy gut biome to “re-infect” them. Which explains why in dense modern society we couldn’t find a difference that the appendix makes, because we get reinfected with healthy microbiome from sharing germs with all the other humans in our big cities - some of whom didn’t just get a terrible stomach bug at the same time as us.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @07:39PM
(#37083152)
> Which explains why in dense modern society we couldn’t find a difference that the appendix makes, because we get reinfected with healthy microbiome from sharing germs with all the other humans in our big cities - some of whom didn’t just get a terrible stomach bug at the same time as us.
Do you have any citations for that? Perhaps it differs by city and region, but many modern cities with good sanitation systems are exceptionally clean - you're not getting frequently reinfected by others' gut flora unless there is a catastrophic problem with the sewer system. People with things like C. difficile infection can have chronic disease for years, and fecal transplants have only recently been recognized as a good treatment in those cases - point being you have to have an actual fecal transplant, you're not just going to "get reinfected with healthy microbiome from sharing germs with all the other humans".
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by quickthrower2 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @09:02PM
(#37083863)
If true, lockdowns would have had an effect on those without an appendix?
It would be interest to see how historically contact with X other people has changed over time. I don’t think you need a big city to mix with a lot of people. I imagine in older times there are fewer people but likely to be closer to each other - people sharing beds (not stupidly associating bed with sex) and tribes of families mingling close lower instead of nuclear family. By contrast the city apartment is the hermetic seal around a small number of people choosing to live together. But a modern concept: corporations, jobs and careers ensure people keep mixing up with people outside.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by kvgr on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:42AM
(#37086456)
Fully anecdotal, but I got my appendix removed at 19. After 2-3 years i started to have problems and found out that I can no longer process milk(protein), not allergy but intolerance and I started to have issues with "quality". I get bloated and my stomach hurts. Before that I had no issues and had perfect movement. So yeah I didn't "needed it" but quality of my life went down.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by MyneOutside on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:05AM
(#37088812)
Milk allergies are different from being lactose intolerant. I developed a mild allergy to dairy in my 30 or so - or so it was discovered then. With lactose intolerance, you can at least take a pill - not so much for an actual allergy. My one child has a much more severe dairy allergy and will get a very upset stomach even with a little dairy.
We both have our appendix.
Though to your point, whether you can develop a milk allergy later in life I am not sure.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by kkoncevicius on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:51AM
(#37086867)
In your case I would really doubt if apendix was the cause. As a teen I also loved milk, pancakes, pasta, etc, but around early 20s started to notice that they are bad for me. Now if I eat a lot of milk and glutamine I get digestive issues, skin rashes, etc. My apendix (afaik) is intact.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by echelon on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:02AM
(#37086236)
Yes. This is why T cell activity decreases as one ages. The thymus is where naive T cells are generated, and the output dramatically slows after adolescence.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by Brajeshwar on Thursday August 10, 2023 @09:11PM
(#37083915)
Recently, while on my usual documentaries watch, I learnt that the appendix may no longer be considered appendix.
From Wikipedia[1], “The appendix was once considered a vestigial organ, but this view has changed since the early 2000s. Research suggests that the appendix may serve an important purpose as a reservoir for beneficial gut bacteria.”
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by LinuxBender on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:27AM
(#37101154)
I've been doing this for some time but I replaced metformin requires RX with Berberine that is safer based on my research. less risk of lactic acidosis of the liver. I found that it's hard to find a sweet spot with DHEA. Too much leads to easy bruising.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by zingababba on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:52AM
(#37135469)
I actually prefer pregnenolone to DHEA, I've found it to be more forgiving. I agree wrt Berberine, the lactic acidosis issue turned me off metformin as well. I believe it's the reason Peter Attia stopped using it also.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by DantesKite on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:55PM
(#37082755)
There's an amino acid chain synthesized from the thymus of a cow that helped double my lymphocytes (they were low for months). Called Thymic Protein-A. Readily accessible. One of the few things that made a change. Nothing else really helped me out.
What I find interesting how the thymus becomes essentially a blog of fat as we get older and partially explains why infections tend to hit us harder as we age.
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by cma on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:59PM
(#37082790)
I can't remember what it was but there was a talk about some kind of tradeoff with thymus function and age that was supposed to explain its atrophy, something like pneumonia death vs auto immune or cancer or something?
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by jejones3141 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @08:55PM
(#37083789)
Sigh. Now I have to track down a copy of The Memluks' album Partida, so I can listen again to their classic "Joe's Thymus" (inspired, I'm sure, by the Readers' Digest "I am {Joe's, Jane's} [name of organ]" articles).
Re:Turns out lowly thymus may be saving your life
by charles_f on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:31AM
(#37085734)
Not claiming it's wrong, especially because it looks like this is an important organ re: immune response, but
> It is typically removed due to issues with the organ itself, such as thymus cancer
> The magnitude of death and cancer in patients who had undergone thymectomy was the biggest surprise for me
Isn't having had cancer the best predictor of having cancer in the future? And so if the main cause of Thymus removal is cancer, seeing cancer after its removal is not very statistically significant?
Even if we have legacy parts in out body, I'm fine just letting it fester in my body as long as it's not trying to kill me.
Feels very similar to thinking farming just needs 3 nutrients. Turns out better farming requires a lot more.
I am just a plain old bozo though so I could be talking out me ass
Yeah, kids don’t get tonsils removed anymore either. Just antibiotics.
Anyway, I offer my patients a choice. Most choose surgery. Those conscientious enough without insurance usually choose nonoperative management because it's much cheaper.
Are we to pretend all diets are the same?
Am I to pretend it is a religious mystery/miracle and no ones knows? Or genetics? Please, enlighten us...
Interestingly you present the possibility of a falsifiable hypothesis. Unfortunately due to the highly variable accuracy of diagnosis and propensity to treat (source: I was on The path to surgical training and now routinely diagnose appendicitis in my role as an emergency doctor) depending on health system capacity and availability to acute care the existing retrospective data doesn’t provide a satisfying result - what it does suggest is illuminating however; with a suggestion of a decrease in rate of incidence over the second half of the 20th century in industrialised countries, and a suggestion of increase in some developing countries. This would be more in keeping with an improvement in diagnostic capacity in both industrialised (less false positives) and developing (more false negatives) countries.
[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9945388/
Good practice in general but particularly so when you find a heisenbug that must be exterminated.
I recall when I woke up my throat didn't hurt (possibly due to painkillers), and when they brought ice cream and popsicles to sooth my pain I felt like a fraud. But the experience up to that point was traumatic to put it lightly, so you're damned right I was going to get all of the treats I could wrangle.
After I had my tonsils removed, even the thought of solid food was out of the question. It was just too painful.
You can have as much ice cream as you want. What they don't tell you is you won't want any. :P
I just get mad tonsil stones now. lol
Anyway, the relationship of tonsils and ice cream was established by Richard Scarry in "What do people do all day?" [0]
0. https://books.google.com/books?id=tuqKDQAAQBAJ&pg=PA45
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eosinophilia%E2%80%93myalgia_s...
Add circumcisions to the list.
This covers a paper that, while small in sample size, shows a reduction in age of 6 years. One of the major impacts of the drug cocktail is that it removes much of the fat that accumulates in the thymus as one ages.
We've known the thymus is saving our lives — it's where the t in t-Cells derives from for years. There are very old studies of removing it from older humans and statistically seeing a decline in health. Most doctors will not remove it without a decent cause in older patients (intractable infection, for example). In those cases it's not that removing the thymus was a good approach. It was just the least-bad approach the physician had on hand to help their patient.
Never forget that everything we do, medically, is a stall. I'm glad we have blood pressure pills and better health spans than our grandparents. Eat a healthy diet, run 3 times a week, manage stress and... die anyway. That's the deal we were given as living things.
Interestingly, a small portion of MG patients have an enlarged/tumorous thymus and end up getting it removed, though there aren't necessarily clear benefits. It's also a quite invasive procedure they wouldn't perform on older folks like my dad (he shows no signs of it anyway).
Overall I agree with you though—this article is not saying anything new. As a concerned son who's spent more than his fair share of time trying to understand what's going on here, I wish it did. I also wish there were some treatments for my dad that worked. For now, exercising, eating healthy, lowering stress, and a healthy dose of steroids are currently keeping him with us. If anyone has advice, I'm all ears.
As her symptoms increased—-speech delay, difficulty swallowing, eye misalignment, all stemming from fatigue-induced nerve conduction delays which can culminate in respiratory failure—-myasthenic crisis, they opted for thymectomy (open surgery). She was probably 50 and while the recovery was lengthy, it drastically improved her symptoms and the amount of activity she could do before arose symptoms appeared. No more prism glasses or multi-second speech delays, or weekly plasmapheresis visits. If she spent too much time being active or driving on a sunny day (squinting), she’d feel the ocular fatigue first and know she had to rest or take a prednisone. Now her eyes are failing for other reasons but the thymectomy bought her 25 years and counting.
I’m glad your father survived his crisis. It sounds like you’re doing all of the conservative treatments (which is good; steroid noncompliance is a risk factor for crisis).
There are new medications that directly reduce or deactivate AChR antibodies. Non-invasive video-assisted thoracoscopic thymectomy is more viable today too (and thymectomy has been shown to decrease the frequency and severity of crises even where the thymus was considered normal). Plasmapheresis remains generally effective, if time consuming.
MG sucks. From one son to another, I hope you can get a few more good decades with your parent too.
> For the study, Kooshesh mined data from 1,146 adult patients who had undergone thymus removal, alongside demographically matched control patients who had undergone similar surgeries but kept their thymus
Sure, you can demographically match all you want, but I don't think this is a research question that can be answered with a retrospective analysis. The problem is that you haven't controlled for why surgeons decided to remove the thymus in some cases and not in others. Was the disease more severe in patients who got thymectomies? Was it differences in training between the surgeons? Was it just an arbitrary decision on the part of the surgeons? This is a critical confounder regardless of whether you've matched the demographics. You really need a randomized control study to answer this sort of question.
> Although the risk of autoimmune disease did not differ substantially between the groups in the overall primary cohort (relative risk, 1.1; 95% CI, 0.8 to 1.4), a difference was found when patients with preoperative infection, cancer, or autoimmune disease were excluded from the analysis (12.3% vs. 7.9%; relative risk, 1.5; 95% CI, 1.02 to 2.2)
What? What is this? Was this subgroup a preregistered, or did they just go fishing when their primary hypothesis didn't pan out?
I'd categorize this study as noteworthy, but not groundbreaking the way the press statement is selling it.
The best we're going to do is a careful case control study (and research in animal models). And the evidence is enough to imply strongly that we should expend a little more effort to avoid removing the thymus.
But that's exactly what we did with the appendix, multiple times [1, 2].
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26080338/
[2] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa2014320
If the standard of care is removing the appendix, and you have a strong reason to believe that something less may be superior, you may be able to conduct a randomized trial.
But any other combination of facts is going to be hard for an IRB to swallow.
Do you have any citations for that? Perhaps it differs by city and region, but many modern cities with good sanitation systems are exceptionally clean - you're not getting frequently reinfected by others' gut flora unless there is a catastrophic problem with the sewer system. People with things like C. difficile infection can have chronic disease for years, and fecal transplants have only recently been recognized as a good treatment in those cases - point being you have to have an actual fecal transplant, you're not just going to "get reinfected with healthy microbiome from sharing germs with all the other humans".
It would be interest to see how historically contact with X other people has changed over time. I don’t think you need a big city to mix with a lot of people. I imagine in older times there are fewer people but likely to be closer to each other - people sharing beds (not stupidly associating bed with sex) and tribes of families mingling close lower instead of nuclear family. By contrast the city apartment is the hermetic seal around a small number of people choosing to live together. But a modern concept: corporations, jobs and careers ensure people keep mixing up with people outside.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appendix_(anatomy)#/media/File...
We both have our appendix.
Though to your point, whether you can develop a milk allergy later in life I am not sure.
If so a confidence interval of 1.02 to 2.2 after arbitrarily excluding some data is not exactly ground breaking.
Not vestigial evolutionary speaking, but doesn't it get less and less functional over a person's lifespan and gets replaced with fat tissue?
From Wikipedia[1], “The appendix was once considered a vestigial organ, but this view has changed since the early 2000s. Research suggests that the appendix may serve an important purpose as a reservoir for beneficial gut bacteria.”
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appendix_(anatomy)
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25608928/
What I find interesting how the thymus becomes essentially a blog of fat as we get older and partially explains why infections tend to hit us harder as we age.
Edit:
Wikipedia on it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thymic_involution#Unknown_sele...
> It is typically removed due to issues with the organ itself, such as thymus cancer
> The magnitude of death and cancer in patients who had undergone thymectomy was the biggest surprise for me
Isn't having had cancer the best predictor of having cancer in the future? And so if the main cause of Thymus removal is cancer, seeing cancer after its removal is not very statistically significant?