My office in Moscow has IPsec tunnels and is fine, but we also see no outages other than the occasional last mile loss on one of the circuits (not at the same time). Maybe that’s because it’s a business line.
I've read that some people have used port 853 to mimic encrypted DNS or other ports less than 1024 to circumvent some WireGuard limits. I've yet to run into that.
Might want to check out https://yggdrasil-network.github.io for fun. I used to use it to connect to various networks.
Is it not obvious? Russia has long blocked many apps associated with the west, such as Facebook, Twitter etc. and promotes the use of russian-only webspace. Because the people are not stupid, many evaded this act of censorship with VPNs. It was a surprise VPN were permitted for such a long time as it is.
Maybe Russia thinks that Ukraine is using the mobile phone network to control drones in Moscow.
1.5 years into a "3-day operation" against a smaller poor country armed with hand me downs and some of the western peacetime production does not fit the narrative of 2nd best army in the world.
It's embarassing for the government that we there are even talks about them running out of tanks.
Locking down the internet supposedly helps against espionage and allows easier control of the news narrative. Authoritative regimes are always very concerned with that because the lack of open political discussion makes them seem very stable and united until the very last moment.
Additionally, Putin has a deeply seated mistrust against technology and the internet and technology.
Your impression was absolutely wrong. Before war, Microsoft and other big western companies along with police hunted companies which tried to use pirate software. So it was not a good idea to use pirate software for company in Russia, at least if you're big enough to be noticed. Ordinary people were kind of ignored, AFAIK.
Both Internet restrictions and surveillance also were present in Russia in the recent years. Officially to protect children, unofficially to suppress opposition as well.
Didn't they say somewhere that in response to the sanctions imposed early in the war they were going to go lenient on piracy? I wonder if that promise ever amounted to anything, or if it was just empty words.
There are enough software makers in Russia, so allowing piracy would just make their life harder. Like why would you want to buy КОМПАС-3D for some hefty price if you can pirate Autocad for free.
https://torrentfreak.com/rutracker-found-itself-unblocked-in...
https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2023/08/09/russian-cinemas-sc...
Nothing at all. It's a pointless exercise with which some cyber security apparatchik in Putin's regime hopes to earn kudos from his credulous betters.
In fact it will likely be detrimental once the filter forces communication of legit traffic (...) to propagate without VPN, which you know will happen the minute someone gets inconvenienced.
Russia. \o/
--- Chairman Mao
* You won't have the expertise to quickly build your own solutions when this happens you are cut off access to a certain technology. A browser is a beast to implement as we all know.
* You can't trust that e.g. Chromium as audited by American "experts" is really not phoning home if it detects the IP is from e.g Turkish defense corporation A's RD center.
* You need to have that software-skilled workforce anyway to ensure technological progress of your country.
I would also note that in your country the US agencies have no authority. However your own government can use that information to imprison you or otherwise exert its jurisdictional control. I think that’s generally what people worry about. It’s hard to imagine a reason the US government would care about you as a citizen of X country, whereas there are lots of governments who oppress their citizens for being themselves and for who they associate with.
That era of globalization is slowly passing away.
> I would also note that in your country the US agencies have no authority.
No it plenty does. Not well-known on the west side of the internet, but the US can and did easily order to our governments the individuals (which she saw to be influential in the directions she didn't want) to be imprisoned, tortured and executed. And this is just cost-effective side of the coin. Three letter agencies can make anyone disappear. I just searched for almost 25 mins for an article documenting such a case. I was able to find it several times in the past with increasing difficulty. It's not even on the webarchive now. I think the article is finally nuked by some agency.
> there are lots of governments who oppress their citizens for being themselves and for who they associate with.
Not everyone agrees with the idea that individual freedom extremism is good, or that everyone should be allowed to do or say anything as long as it doesn't adversely affect others. In fact in this side of the world we think that's a silly and naive standpoint.
Open the metin.txt for article. veri.json is metadata, 'baslik' means title. I hope my google account will not be burned over this.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmed_Omar_Abu_Ali
I agree, this is egregious. At least I’m allowed to say that and advocate strongly against such stuff without fear of reprisal. In many parts of the world I wouldn’t be allowed to criticize the government. (In fact I’m vacationing in one right now)
Edit: I think the fact that typing his name into a browser provided me not just Wikipedia but hundreds of websites advocating on his behalf, but you couldn’t find an article after 25 minutes of searching and fear you’ll be in some sort of trouble for having it in your Google drive exemplifies my point. An open internet isn’t just a tool for evil by the deranged. It’s how the good and the just know the truth.
Edit 2: by the way, thank you for the respectful discussion here, we don’t all have to agree on things but it’s wonderful to discuss with folks that aren’t part of the echo chamber.
I think people in many parts of the world would like to see the “others” oppressed - until tides change and they find themselves the “others.”
Once you allow someone to decide some thoughts are a crime because they agree with your views, it’s just a matter of time before that prison is open to your way of thinking.
On the CIA and extraordinary rendition and other things, yes I know it exists. My point isn’t that. My point is that your government does it a lot more and the likelihood of being snatched up by your government (wherever you are) is absurdly higher than the US breaking into your home and extracting you. That it happens is unacceptable but it’s also structurally rare to the point it’s news worthy.
I for one feel sorry for people who are imprisoned for no other reason for the people they love, the ideas they have, the way they view the world. I will welcome them to my side of the world with open arms and wish them peace, and mourn the loss of their home to people who feel they must hurt people for being alive.
The question is would you take that at the expense of blocking the big American corporations? That's probably really how the Chinese have developed their own to this degree. For example they weren't ubiquitous but Google was starting to make headway in China and Chinese in the late 00s when gmail hack/Google ban/GFW started. Baidu is not a quality service (though maybe because of government restrictions)
I'm also aware of an opposite opinion: if I'm to be spied by someone, it's better to be a three letter agency overseas, since it's much harder for them to harm me, than a three letter agency in my home country, which can just knock at my door.
And thanks for the comment. Indeed, I was thinking about countries like Russia, where US three-letter agencies don't have extradition power, as far as I know (thinking about Snowden). Countries like mentioned in that thread, indeed, have more complicated relationships with US.
If the Chinese government spies on you and finds some behavior it finds unacceptable your social credit tanks and you cant travel, send your children to a good school....
I would say that better goal would be for individuals to be digitally sovereign, and not countries. Individual digital sovereignty protects us from external and internal oppression.
They're still pretty lenient on piracy, which doesn't cancel out the government ever growing desire to control the news/media/social networks space
People use VPNs to get western news and information through other channels than state-controlled Russian media.
If Russia can block these other channels, then their own propaganda becomes the sole information citizens have access to.
Having said this, almost all of my Russian colleagues already talk like Russian TV and all of them use VPN this way or another..
It seems there is always a segment of the population that takes up nationalism/populism. You don't need a majority to enable authoritarianism, just enough to ease them into power, maintain the facade of support and help chill dissent.
Websites I need a VPN for most of the time are ones that just don't like Russian IPs, like my Western credit card company.
This sort of this is as likely to be emotional support censorship for Vlad’s benefit as anything else; hard to imagine it being very effective, certainly. Expect more and more ineffectual crackdowns on information as he deteriorates.
Why not? Sounds like the perfect scam, collect the $$$, funnel it to some offshore account. When Putin dies the chaos of succession ensures that nobody will be able to attempt to collect before I leave the country.
(Now curious whether "client became a dictator and is currently provoking people into murdering him" is sufficient basis for an insurer to get out of a policy...)
People won't be able to read anything contradicting government's point of view. It is important for stability in society that there is only correct and truthful information and no falseful foreign propaganda seeding distruct in government (e.g. by falsefully claiming that high-ranked officials own expensive villas in Europe that they cannot afford with their salary).
> only mobile networks are affected. I wonder why that is.
Because it is only testing stage now.
> Is this just the decisions of a handful of telcos
Why would telecoms spend money on censorship by themselves? It doesn't increase their profit.
> Wireguard for example is just UDP packets.
WireGuard packets are not obfuscated and can be easily detected. And even if it was obfuscated, everything that doesn't look like HTTPS can be blocked without causing much troubles.
You misspelled Putin.
This is easier, maybe, to follow where is going a wire than a wave.
Also, it's not just mobile operators. Major ISPs (with millions of customers) have some sort of DPI, or at the very least enforce the state's blacklist (which includes such "nefarious" websites such as FB, Linkedin, Medium, etc)
To make things weirder, the article claims that only mobile networks are affected. I wonder why that is. Is this just the decisions of a handful of telcos and it's being reported as a state-imposed restriction?
Edit: also in my opinion, "blocking at the protocol level" is a bit misleading since they can't actually see the packet contents. Wireguard for example is just UDP packets. They have to infer from other patterns that the traffic is Wireguard and drop packets that meet those criteria.